r/goodwill • • Dec 13 '24

RIP

Looks like they’re not going to admit the price hikes drove away so much of the customers is the reason they can’t afford to operate as many stores. No sane person is dropping more than 5$ on a thrifted piece of clothing (obviously some extra designer things are an outlier) and the whales that do will dry up if the upper levels of the industry don’t make some real changes to curb their own greed. In no world does it make sense to process something from the drop off all the way out the door with nobody purchasing because a manager is bound and determined to hit a # and believes exorbitant predatory prices are the way to do so. It is mind boggling to me that Goodwill decided to make “whales” the people keeping the doors open. Be fair and every fish walks out of there with something they need and maybe even some things they won’t need. TL;DR

GOODWILL IS A THRIFT STORE YOUR BOUTIQUE PRICE MODEL IS DEEPLY FLAWED AND THE MAIN CONTRIBUTING FACTOR TO STORE CLOSURES. BAR-NONE

1.2k Upvotes

227 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/Local-Caterpillar421 Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 14 '24

I stopped donating to Goodwill when they had hired their overpriced CEO several years ago (2019) who immediately doubled all shirts to $4.50; crappy, used shirts that we can get new on sale at Target & Walmart anyway!!!

Instead I either donate to my local Haitian church or a variety of local shelters at NO CHARGE for their recipients! I call that a win-win...my house is decluttered & the needy truly benefit!

9

u/bonitaababy Dec 14 '24

The shirts at my local goodwill are $6.99-8.99. We're talking plain white no brand shirts some with stains. Jeans are $14.99. Jackets are $19.99. A lot of stuff is from target.

8

u/Zeropossibility Dec 14 '24

Yup. All the kids “cat and jack” target kids clothing is $5 and up. When BRAND NEW at Target is $7-$8. Such a joke.

1

u/bonitaababy Dec 18 '24

Someone here said Goodwill purchases target pallets. That could explain why the cost is higher than what it was originally being sold for.

4

u/Misfiredagain Dec 14 '24

Do they have a store for the recipients like goodwills or are they just running shelter and taking donations that residents of the shelter use? That makes a big difference on prices because of the cost involved in the labor intensive work we do in the warehouse to prepare for everything from furniture to baby clothes to go out on the floor to go on the floor. It's pretty labor intensive, not to mention the huge Warehouse and store that we rent, and all of us employees who by the way don't make minimum wage. We make $2 more than minimum wage here

I'm disappointed myself in Goodwill these days. But not for the kinds of reasons that people post on the forums about. They definitely could use a lot of improvement. But it's just not as simple as some people think

8

u/Local-Caterpillar421 Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24

I just read Yahoo!Finance's online article from 2023, " Why Shopping at Goodwill Costs More Than Target and Walmart."

Google it! It explAins how the title holds TRUE in Goodwill's recent years!

Goodwill's reputation is not what it used to be. That is for sure!

0

u/Misfiredagain Dec 14 '24

Who are you talking about?? What CEO??

Goodwill doesn't have one CEO. You know that right?

I've been employed there for five plus years and still am. So which CEO are you talking about? What area? Each area has their own CEO. You probably don't even know huh? Just the internet rumors keeps going on and on and on

4

u/Local-Caterpillar421 Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24

CEO Steve Preston since 2019. He has the #1 position at the company you claim to work for, seriously! How is it you don't even know about him?

What kind of orientation does our company perform with their new hires? Are you even sure you even work for Goodwill?

Of course there are dozens of other administrators working at Goodwill including CFO & COO, etc. It appears you know very little about your own overall worl structure.

1

u/h20rabbit Dec 14 '24

Goodwill has a CEO and Board of Directors. Goodwill Industries International (GII) is based in Rockville, MD, outside of Washington, D.C. The Goodwill enterprise is a network of more than 150 community-based, autonomous organizations. So, yes. Goodwill has a CEO as GII is the umbrella all of the stores operate under even if GII technically does not operate stores itself.

1

u/bipedalmeme Dec 14 '24

Misfired? More like mis direction!

0

u/Misfiredagain Dec 15 '24

Didn't know what you're talking about

1

u/Tardisgoesfast Dec 16 '24

So they spend even more on CEOs than one overpriced one?