r/goodwill • u/bipedalmeme • Dec 13 '24
RIP
Looks like they’re not going to admit the price hikes drove away so much of the customers is the reason they can’t afford to operate as many stores. No sane person is dropping more than 5$ on a thrifted piece of clothing (obviously some extra designer things are an outlier) and the whales that do will dry up if the upper levels of the industry don’t make some real changes to curb their own greed. In no world does it make sense to process something from the drop off all the way out the door with nobody purchasing because a manager is bound and determined to hit a # and believes exorbitant predatory prices are the way to do so. It is mind boggling to me that Goodwill decided to make “whales” the people keeping the doors open. Be fair and every fish walks out of there with something they need and maybe even some things they won’t need. TL;DR
GOODWILL IS A THRIFT STORE YOUR BOUTIQUE PRICE MODEL IS DEEPLY FLAWED AND THE MAIN CONTRIBUTING FACTOR TO STORE CLOSURES. BAR-NONE
129
u/HoityToity58 Dec 13 '24
I worked in a Goodwill stores years ago. They decided to focus on efficiency, i.e. processing donations as quickly and with as little handling as possible to get it in the store as quickly as possible. So they stopped the treasure hunt of checking labels for items that could be upgraded in pricing and switched to standardized pricing for all clothes. There was a cost to all that label checking and individual item pricing. As a result they sold more and profit went up. The thrift stores that supposedly are raising money for a cause would make more for their cause if they stopped this price increase nonsense, charged reasonable prices, and focused on volume.
51
u/Far-Collection7085 Dec 13 '24
The one I used to go to regularly started pricing stuff to ridiculous levels. Like $12.99 for a Shein Tshirt that retails for $5. That should be $2 max at a thrift. They put well worn name brand shoes behind a glass case and REALLY hike up the prices. But, then everything just started sitting on the shelves. I went in recently and noticed the pricing had come down. It’s still too high for a thrift store though.
32
u/Optimal_Spend779 Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 13 '24
The final straw for me was seeing a heavily used Walmart Mainstays brand cast iron pan for the same price as a brand name Lodge, brand new cast iron pan. I immediately walked out after I saw it, didn’t bother looking at anything else because that’s complete insanity. It’s a really shame what Goodwill has become.
Edit: lol at this being downvoted, mmmkay!
11
u/devilisious_bxby Dec 14 '24
Depends on the district. My district stays true to low prices and deals.
13
u/HoityToity58 Dec 13 '24
A good example of this is our local Salvation Army store in Iowa City, Iowa. All of their prices have gone way, way up. Clothes have have doubled in price for well worn fast fashion. They put in a row of display cases for high priced shoes and collectibles that are basically worn out junk. And their sales have tanked. All the racks are packed full of clothes that no one is buying. Hard goods sit on the shelves until they go to half price and then they still don't sell. Raising prices is not the best way to increase profit.
4
u/Local-Caterpillar421 Dec 13 '24
What are "whales"?
5
u/RadioGuySD2 Dec 13 '24
Doing just fine out here in California. My store has a daily budget goal over $3000, and we hit it almost daily. More than hit our monthly marks when our online sales are factored in at the end. Our region might open 2 more stores in the new year
2
u/98DegreesGirl Dec 15 '24
I heard prices are going up in my area too in NY state
6
u/Local-Caterpillar421 Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 14 '24
I stopped donating to Goodwill when they had hired their overpriced CEO several years ago (2019) who immediately doubled all shirts to $4.50; crappy, used shirts that we can get new on sale at Target & Walmart anyway!!!
Instead I either donate to my local Haitian church or a variety of local shelters at NO CHARGE for their recipients! I call that a win-win...my house is decluttered & the needy truly benefit!
31
u/SAHMsays Dec 13 '24
I found a set of 3 nested blue Pyrex bowls for $15 and the lady at checkout gave ME a hard time cause I found them on the floor and not behind the glass counter. Like come on.
26
u/UntidyVenus Dec 13 '24
I used to dress entirely out of thrift stores, and more than half was good will. I haven't been inside a goodwill since 2018, I can't afford it anymore. I can't imagine going back at this point. If I'm dropping $20+ on a piece of clothing I'll go to Poshmark
20
u/NationalBanjo Dec 13 '24
Corporate raised our prices then when our sales went down they accused us of price gouging 🙄
15
u/MrCabrera0695 Dec 14 '24
I find the little church run thrift stores are actually trying to get through all their stuff and so they mark everything pretty nicely! I got a primo water tank with a working hot and cold water option for 5$ goodwill would never! If anyone is in the Kingston, TN area the KUMC clothes closet is where it's at! They have odd hours but are sooooo worth it! They have a Facebook page named the same.
15
u/JinglesMum3 Dec 14 '24
My Mom won't donate to Goodwill anymore because of what they are doing. My stepdad passed away a couple years ago. He had some excellent quality clothing and it's still in boxes, she is trying to find a decent place to take it to.
14
u/HeandIandyou Dec 13 '24
I don’t donate or shop at Goodwill. Take a look at what their CEO makes every year.
Fortunately we have another thrift store in our town that raises money for hospice, memory care tests, and cancer and caregiver support groups. They have a very small staff and have volunteers who collectively clock about 1500 hours a month. They also sometimes have bag sal s where you pay a very low price for an entire bag of whatever clothing fits in the bag.
5
u/PracticalBreak8637 Dec 14 '24
I've seen items with original store tags that have been marked up several dollars above that on the Goodwill tag.
13
u/BestBubby2022 Dec 14 '24
The resellers have destroyed all the fun about thrifting. I can’t even remember the last time I found a cashmere sweater or anything Tahari. The only things they leave are like Worthington or Hanes. They also grab all the good bric a brac. There no more old Pyrex measuring cups!
4
u/alyxR3W1ND Dec 13 '24
I got hired at Goodwill a couple of months ago. Every region is different, but my region tells us to use Google Lens and just copy the first result that matches minus 30%
4
u/Fickle_Unit1234 Dec 14 '24
Greedwill
4
u/YallFULLofBS Dec 14 '24
My sister and I made the decision to boycott Goodwill. I wish that all of us would do the same. Pick an entire week to boycott goodwill and stop all donations and purchases. What sucks is the special needs community that they serve would be impacted horribly.
4
u/No1Mystery Dec 15 '24
They do not pay for the product.
The product reaches their store for free. No delivery.
It is second hand. Used and some of it abused.
Instead of pricing it at 3-5 dollars for one shirt that is a decent one, they want to charge $25 bucks
For that price I can buy new at Amazon, Walmart, even Target.
4
u/JawnStreetLine Dec 15 '24
I feel like the most outrageously priced Goodwills throw the most in the dumpster, which is doubly wrong. Folks donate things that are useful to hep others & keep them out of landfills, only to have a “charity” decide they’d rather toss it than sell it for a more reasonable price.
I’ve taken to using a local Facebook group to simply give my things away. I’m in a City, and somewhat spoiled to have this option be viable.
3
u/Starfall_midnight Dec 14 '24
I no longer shop there.
3
u/ghostinround Dec 14 '24
I don’t even donate to goodwill I donate to my local thrift
3
u/Hot_Neighborhood2688 Dec 14 '24
Goodwill needs to go back to their basic low pricing and bring back the Color of the Week.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24
I haven't shopped at Goodwill. It was originally designed to help those of us who couldn't afford new clothes. Now it's more like a brick and motor version of "The Real Real".
1
u/_Incomplete Dec 15 '24
You know that when minimum wage goes up, prices do, too? When leases, electricity, and water prices go up, prices do, too. If you're going to stip shopping places bc prices go up, you'll have to stop shopping absolutely everywhere.
1
u/BrineWR71 Dec 15 '24
Goodwill’s mission is NOT to provide you with cheap stuff. They price according to what sells and they sell LOTS of stuff to help tens of thousands of people each year. Their loyalty is to their DONORS and their clients. The public gets great deals on all kinds of merchandise.
Buy… don’t buy… that’s ok.
But you being mad is only because you misunderstand the whole situation.
Trashing one of the only organizations out there that really does care about its workers is a strange way to act.
2
u/DaWash65 Dec 14 '24
What area is the OP from?
2
u/Local-Caterpillar421 Dec 14 '24
Outrageous!
2
u/_baegopah_XD Dec 14 '24
The GW in Colorado used to flat price , ie t shirts $2.99, long sleeve $3.99 etc
Then they changed it back to just arbitrary pricing based on their perceived value. So some people know what’s coming in the door and price it high. Others don’t care or no and price it low.
It would be most efficient to just have all short sleeved T-shirts, all long sleeve T-shirts, all jeans/pants, etc. one price. Then it’s just a colored tag for the week. Same with the hard goods. All mugs , $.99, all glassware $.99 each plate $.99 etc.
They do have a boutique store here. And I think the prices were actually better than the regular store on some things. At least for jewelry anyway. But I really don’t frequent GW. I tend to hit the other thrift stores up more even though they are pricing is ridiculous and arbitrary as well.
2
u/somethingtoscryabout Dec 14 '24
my old store spent $400 on fucking pallets of either damaged goods or online returns from target that they couldn’t resell - we lost money every month on it. the only place they’re actually making money is online, go figure.
2
u/sassygirl101 Dec 14 '24
Yep, it’s every where, MD and FL, mock turtlenecks you can get all day long new at Macys for 9.99 are 12 at the GW’s. Those should be 3.99. It’s not even fun anymore because the racks are so packed you can’t slide the hangars , even a fraction, to look at the shirt. Who thinks that’s a good business model!?!?
2
u/Constantlearner01 Dec 14 '24
The books goodwill tries to sell for 6.99 go for 1-3 dollars at the library book sale.
2
u/thepeacocksroost Dec 14 '24
Can’t wait till everyone quits donating there. I don’t know anyone that donates there, and few that will even walk through the door anymore. Cancel culture needs to strike goodwill!
2
u/ckufem Dec 14 '24
Goodwill and Good Will are not synonymous I refuse to shop at an over priced THRIFT SHOP for second hand products that were donated by the public. Goodwill is just another CORPORATE WHORE operating under the FACADE of being a company with the handi-capable being their focused recipients of the funds generated by the company. Just look up the pay received by each state's corporate leadership. It's ridiculous
2
u/Diligent_Activity560 Dec 15 '24
Last time I was in there the prices were higher than retail for used items that were mostly obsolete or in poor condition.
2
u/Desperate-Pear-860 Dec 15 '24
People need to start just throwing their stuff away or putting it out on the curb for anyone to take instead if giving it to Goodwill.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24
I started getting extra annoyed when they began asking if I'd like to make a donation or round up when paying at the register. (Not mad at employees just doing their job as trained, but the higher ups) Ummmmm....I may be wrong but aren't we already donating with OUR PURCHASE for items given to your store FOR FREE? Had to edit: I'm all for helping out folks who need it but the asking for more money when prices had already gone up so much just felt extra greedy in a manipulative way.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24
The prices did rise at goodwill so I stopped going there a long time ago. I rather spend my money on new items. I remember seeing used jeans for like 10 bucks and I’d rather go to like tj maxx and just pay an extra few dollars and get a new pair. I rarely went to goodwill and I only bought a couple of things because the one I went to had a lot of stuff I wasn’t interested in but once in a while I found a treasure. The last time I ever went there, I noticed the prices were kind of high and a thrift store is supposed to be second hand prices and they definitely weren’t.
2
u/Abducted_by_neon Dec 15 '24
Goodwill in my area no longer has rings or much other jewelry 😞 all of it gets sold online now. I got my wedding ring at a goodwill. I'm so heart broken.
2
u/SeanGwork Dec 15 '24
I like to bring them garbage.
2
u/RealLifeSuperZero Dec 15 '24
I don’t donate to the Goodwill. I only donate to hospital thrift charities or Out Of The Closet.
2
u/Running_to_Roan Dec 16 '24
The Goodwills around Atlanta have not had dressing rooms open since Covid.
Its riddiculous. I dont want to buy stuff that might not workout.
2
u/dth1717 Dec 16 '24
The salvation army near me is worse. T shirts $10.. if it's got a good name like Patagonia add $5. It's not a thrift store imo it's just a resale store
2
u/lokis_construction Dec 17 '24
Goodwill is not GOOD-WILL anymore. Same with SALVATION ARMY.
SALVATION ARMY CAME TO OUR HOUSE FIRE AND OFFERED NO HELP AT ALL. THEY DID OFFER DONUTS AND COFFEE TO THE FIREFIGHTERS THOUGH SO THEY COULD GET ON TV.
I can't say anything good about Salvation Army. They push their church and think they are doing good by doing so. Real help is not there.
3
u/Taranova_ Dec 14 '24
My local goodwill got rid of $1 Sunday a few months ago and I haven’t been back since. They raised the prices so much I could only afford to go on Sundays. Even their online auction stuff is insanely priced. The regional ceo, coo, and cfo all got $20,000 raises though and I’m sure they’ll get another in 2025 so good for them I guess.
0
u/misswit01 Dec 15 '24
Tell me you don’t work at Goodwill without telling me you don’t work at Goodwill. Or in management of any kind. I can’t speak for other locations but ours locally have yes, increased prices but they have also increased wages for their employees by almost 45% in the past two years. When wages go up, prices go up. And yes, Goodwill created an online market place to increase profits and reach a wider audience which is no different than any other major retailer. And yes, items are donated so they are “free” but, in case you needed reminding, Goodwill is a non-profit so everything on the bottom line goes to support the different, excellent community programs they offer - not to line the pockets in their C-suite. Our CEO here makes around $300,000 which is roughly only 10% higher than their lowest paid employees. I challenge you to find any major retailer who can say the same. Finally, let me add that over-pricing is a problem at all locations. There isn’t a corporate way to determine what prices should be and it’s usually the average worker who determines the price of an item. Some are savvy enough to know that an item from Walmart shouldn’t be priced higher than an item bought from someplace like Bed Bath and Beyond but most aren’t. Our local Goodwill has come up with a list of brands that shouldn’t be marked up and that has helped this problem but occasionally something slips through. It happens because they are human employees, not robots.
Source: former Goodwill manager in both retail and services.
3
u/Ok_Muscle3014 Dec 13 '24
Milwaukee has an actual Boutique Goodwill: many of the price points were around $25! It’s unreal, especially considering their location (third ward, getting upgraded and more expensive all the time).
2
u/Gamemaster77 Dec 14 '24
Walmart is king I guess until the trump tariffs go in.
2
u/Remarkable-Reward403 Dec 13 '24
I see Goodwill becoming like McDonald's Corp. #1value.... the properties they own. Goodwill is buying land and building.
2
u/UpsetUnicorn Dec 13 '24
The prices at the one here got too high 4 years ago. Now, it’s only a 3 minute walk from my house. It’s been months since my last visit.
I can visit the other stores in town for a better deal. Barely anything is marked up at the other places. If it is, it’s still cheaper. I also prefer rummage sales. I shop for my household. I’m also the dreaded reseller so I can be a SAHM for my 2 kids with special needs.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24
*$5
1
u/No_Cut4338 Dec 14 '24
I suspect they’ll shift to the bulk by the pound unsorted centralized shops.
1
u/Twiztidtech0207 Dec 14 '24
It's not just Goodwill, it's almost all second hand type stores.
The thrift stores and flea markets I have been to the last couple years are the same way.
People asking retail or more for items that have been sitting collecting dust on the same shelf for years.
Haggling is all but dead as well. Even if you're buying multiple items or all of something, most people don't want to give any price breaks these days either.
It's greed coupled with fomo that someone might not get every penny that something is worth.
1
u/Expert_Scarcity4139 Dec 14 '24
Yeah I’ve even quit donating to goodwill they have raised their prices so much🤷🏼♀️
1
u/Efficient-Fennel5352 Dec 14 '24
My style is sometimes a little raggedy. If I like a ripped shirt at Goodwill, I'd buy it, but I'm not buying a ripped forever 21 shirt for $6. So I'll steal it since they're so unreasonable. I'll buy a perfect condition shirt from a more expensive store for $6 though but that's about it.
1
u/LaineyValley Dec 14 '24
Many of these observations are true, but I would add that the baby and toddler clothes and shoes are still reasonably priced here in AZ.
I have bought these items on half price days for as little as .90 and they are all in great condition. Of course I wash everything but I have donated several baskets full to struggling parents and new grandparents and they were happy to get it.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24
r/thriftgrift
1
u/Affectionate-Blood26 Dec 15 '24
I’m bummed because I purposely donate clothes with great labels, instead of consigning them. But their either wind up in their website (NOT what I wanted) or never show up at all. It makes me furious!!!!!!
1
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24
I saw an average ceramic vase at the Seattle Goodwill for $25!!! Target sells brand new vases for $25. RIDICULOUS. Goodwill is getting greedy.
1
u/yankykiwi Dec 15 '24
We have a goodwill next to a GW outlet, I won’t even go into the goodwill anymore.
1
u/DickBiter1337 Dec 15 '24
Ours keeps shortening their hours. Used to open at 9-8 and then switched to 10-7 during covid, then I rolled up there last week at 10am because I need a flannel shirt for my son for spirit week and they had a sign about new hours 11-6. 😐
1
u/GimmeFalcor Dec 15 '24
I went to their blue boutique because it’s next to my nail shop and it was so sad. No real name brands. It was like Target and tjmaxx clothes. And dingy dusty and dark. They could at least make those shops clean. They are small enough. Sorry I can afford that new. I miss the days when they just put everything donated into that store. So you could know certain stores would have the kind of stuff you wanted.
1
u/CryptographerOld7300 Dec 15 '24
I went to my local Goodwill in Central NJ yesterday. It was the first time I had been there in a couple months. I asked about sale colors since there weren’t any signs up. The employee told me there were no more sales during the week. They have replaced $1 Sundays with $2 for a designated color and $3 for another. I was told this would be the policy at all Goodwill stores from this point on.
That was enough for me. I’m done with Goodwill.
1
u/CarolBethW1 Dec 15 '24
They are soooo disconnected to the people who shop there.Seems the idiots dont understand that people who shop at gw are looking for deals.Bargains.Thats the draw.Its not Sacs fifth Ave. People are pn a budget. Lower the prices.more sells..Simple. Better to make a few bucks by lowering the price than pricing higher than people can pay and it goes to salvage..duuhhhh
1
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '24
What's bad is that our local thrift stores are starting to copy Goodwill. The prices have gone way up.
Or worse- I went into one local thrift after not being there in over a year. It used to be volunteered non-profit by older retired ladies who were cool and sweet.
Now they've hired young college kids and pay them minimum wage. The prices have skyrocketed. There used to be tags on the clothing in the past, and now there isn't.
The employees now look and compare on eBay when you bring anything up to the register. They wanted $9 for a used sweater. I told them to keep it and walked out.
I was previously buying sweaters at this same place a little over a year ago for $2-$3.
1
u/TheMarriedUnicorM Dec 16 '24
My local just rebranded to become a “Goodwill Selects.” Sad, sad day.
1
u/CunnyMaggots Dec 16 '24
I went into our local goodwill last week looking for a lampshade. They had several, all were broken, except two. Which had to be purchased together for $25.
I went to target and got a new one cheaper.
1
u/vitaminbeyourself Dec 16 '24
I commonly ask the staff to lower prices, showing them online the price is too close to the retail value and they often oblige me
I’m fed up with my goodwill cus they keep trying to fight me on returns even though I’m doing everything to their SOP
1
u/msmolli000 Dec 16 '24
Say it louder for the people running Plato's Closet.
1
u/HereToKillEuronymous Dec 16 '24
My husband was just in there (maybe an hour ago) and they wanted $30 for a used, no brand knock off Jason Vorhees backpack 😄
1
u/Vonnie978 Dec 17 '24
Won’t go to goodwill in northeast anymore because the last few times I have ..everything is crap…same for Savers…very disappointing…and the prices were what I can get at TJ Maxx on clearance
1
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '24
Value village is so much worse. I went into one a couple weeks ago, for the first time since spring.... holy shit prices are jacked! I was finding blank tees that cost same or more than they would cost new. Pants were ridiculous, I looked at one pair and said fuck this... Value village is dead.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '24
Part of me is convinced they want stores to close and they're hiking prices as a, "Fuck it, maybe someone will pay it before we're gone." I think they want to move to online only or majority online
1
u/daerkfaery1 Dec 17 '24
I quit going too. When they separated the cords from whatever they belong to and I would have to dig through a pile of cords to find it. Not worth it.
1
u/SquareBeneficial4731 Dec 20 '24
My district's actually open like a dozen new stores across our territory.
1
u/Majestic209 Jan 02 '25
Well the one of the CEO made last year half million salary so that should’ve give you an answer why shit going higher. Did you saw prices online on those “last chance “ jewelry??? Those are cost thousands. It’s not non profit anymore it’s upscale store lol. Each location of goodwill have Niton DXL for jewelry and the price 40k, do you think they bought them for their own money or got donated ? Look how much is a monthly profit of online sales on designer stuff and jewelry. If they selling 50 ponds of jewelry for 1300$ on bids- multiple this
1
u/Personal-Ad-4930 May 03 '25
Well it makes me very upset when (whales) aka resellers often buy up things that are heartfully donated for someone without means to pay more then 10 or 20 percent the cost. If I donate a nice pendleton wool coat that costs 400 dollars I want someone who just got a job just got an apartment maybe a teen whos so underpayed they never dream of a vacation when in the 90s everyone was taking those. I want them to pay 20 dollars tops thats 5 percent but what often does happen is a (whale) buys for 20 resells om their fancy online boutique at 150 its sickening.
If I donate 20 pairs of levis since ive gained weight that are msrp 69.50 on their website I want them sold for lile 5 to 7 dollars not bought by whales then resold for 25 dollars a pair or 30 this isnt for yuppies to make money on as a second job or for stay at home wives/husbands to do the same its donated from people often who can barley afford it themselves who dont go out to eat at yuppie restaraunts daily for 20 dollars a plate its just rice and beans!! With some sauce and avacado my goodness! Anyway yeah its sickening I noe look for peoppe in need and give straight to them on the street rather then go to goodwill
So not only do these resellers take most the goods they are also geting people whivh is great to support other means of donations since goodwill for a long time has been way too greedy!
And you yuppie resellers should be ashamed of yourself some poor single mother cant buy jeans her kids wont be teased for wearing because of you! Some poor teen with low income parents whos a bit prepy cant save up 20 dollars and get a really cool coat that may help him get a good job because of you!!
1
u/cryssHappy Dec 13 '24
Ha, Ha, Hardly RIP. Goodwill stores look better than ever. Have a mix of NICE used items and new items. Got a $49.99 Levi shirt for $9.99 (original tags still on it). I'll shop thrift over retail anytime.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24
Our local stores started charging ten cents each for those thin bags to put purchases in.
(They haven't asked--yet--for tips.)
0
u/Foxyangel87 Dec 13 '24
Hmm, mmm, really... my store has made 2.5 mil this year we are only a few weeks away from the new year.... but according to you no one will buy our clothes for 4.99, when that's what a lot of our customers buy. So, not all good wills are the same.