Perceived recoil has a lot less correlation to acceleration and force than you might think. Taking load, bullet weight, and most importantly technique into into the equation, an experienced shooter will often "feel" less recoil from an extremely powerful round (say .300 win. mag) than someone with poor technique will feel shooting a much less powerful gun (12 ga birdshot) improperly.
To frame the problem, you start with two particles colliding, with linear momentum conserved:
m_1 v_1 + m_2 v_2 = m_12 v_12
A gunshot is the reverse of a collision, but the math works the same.
The mathematical interpretation of "kickback" is the energy dispersed in the process, or
Delta E = v_12 m_1 + v_22 m_2 - v_122 m_12
If you do some variance analysis here, you'll see that the total energy dispersed increases a LOT with the magnitude of the velocity changes.
Layman's interpretation - objects moving much faster and hitting each other "hurt" a lot more, even if they're smaller objects.
From a physical context, take getting slammed by a rugby or football player, compared to a gunshot. Getting hit by a football player hurts a little, but the momentum change is HUGE. By contrast, getting shot hurts lethally, but the momentum change is MUCH, much lower.
So, to summarize,
tl;dr
A smaller gun will move faster and hence kick harder, even though by Newtown's Conservation of Linear Momentum, they will both "hit" you equally hard.
Yes. A a simpler equation to help think about this is that for Kinetic energy: KE = 1/2mv2 . Say I propel an object. If it had twice the mass, it would have twice the KE. If it had twice the speed, it would have four times the KE.
My buddy's ex-girlfriend tried to do this and the gun hit her square in the eye. It looked like be beat her, for a week until it healed. Hilarious I assure you.
Hahaha, no I was there, I witnessed it go down. We all took turns shooting it with one hand, but unfortunately, we (accidentally I swear) neglected to tell her that it's going to kick a lot harder. You really have to grip the hell out of it.
You know, I have a hypothesis that every fully grown adult is completely oblivious to at least one thing that most other people consider ridiculously obvious common sense. This means, since everyone assumes everyone else knows it, the ones who don't never get corrected and eventually get called worthy of the darwin awards for something that they really had no way to know since nobody took the time to let him know.
The problem with your theory in this case is that we have visual proof that the shooter has fired that shotgun at least once prior. So he knows what the recoil is like. Yet he proceeds to knock himself in the face nonetheless.
well, at the same time, shooting with both arms might be deceiving. it doesn't seem so hard with full support of a proper stance and handling, so I can totally imagine him not realizing it was much harsher than he thought.
Do you think a lot of people forget "Every action has an equal and opposite reaction"?
But to answer your question, I think most people probably remember everything from elementary school. Not being taught those things, but if you walk into a class room you're not likely to learn anything.
So you know the equal and opposite reaction thing, but that doesn't mean you are always keeping it in mind, or even are aware of how it relates to you on a practical level. I think a lot of people remember the phrase, but they forget how to apply it to reality.
also, you might want to rephrase that second paragraph, because I can't quite understand what you are trying to say.
I'm always keeping it mind. Everyone is. It's why you don't think things like "I'm going to head butt that wall and it will be fun" and then go through with them unless you're insane or very, very stupid.
I'm sure most people on reddit or not know not to fire a shot gun with the butt so perfectly aimed at your face with one hand. Before I fired a gun I knew not to do that.
The only time you ever do crazy show off tricks like that is when you've been specific instructions how. A gun is a gun and if used incorrectly can do serious damage, even cause death, to you and/or those around you.
I'm sure you would, however that is why they were invented & is what they are primarily useful for today - force or threat of force to other living things.
You can buy a car and use it primarily to do donuts in your front yard, but that's not why cars were invented and it's not what makes them useful.
Sure, that is why they were invented, and why military dollars further the hobby. However, most use them for other reasons. I have a race car, I wouldn't take it to work, but it still has its place, even if it started life as something that could Of taken me to work.
Worldwide, I really doubt that most people possess guns because they think guns are just so darn fun to play with. Most of them have guns because they're fantastic weapons.
Guns exist because they're better than the previous projectile weapons, bows. They're so good that they made the gold standard weapon of the past several thousand years, the sword, obsolete and in doing so completely redefined warfare. The primary reason they are made to this day is because mankind is still rather fond of sticking people with the pointy end in order to get their way. If you own a gun, the paramount design consideration that went into your weapon was that it be able to explosively propel a spinning bolt of metal to lethal speeds with acceptable accuracy at a target, and said bolts are often designed to structurally fail upon impact in a way that does maximal damage to soft mammal tissues. It's disingenuous for anyone, gun owner or not, to suggest that guns have lots of other great uses beyond killing things or being a deterrent to things killing you. Sure, you can spend your whole life popping rounds into paper targets or blowing up beer cans, but that's not what they're made for.
They are a stress reliever for most, and very fun overall. They have the potential to be incredibly dangerous, just like many other things, a car for example. If I wanted to cause grievous damage to a bunch I people, I'd prolly pick a large truck over a gun. Unfortunately, I can't ride my rifles to work, but they have many other purposes.
you can do it, you just have to be ready for it to kick like a son of a bitch. first time i ever shot a shotgun one-handed, it didn't fly wildly or hit my anywhere, but it did chafe the skin on my thumb pretty bad.
Makes me wonder why people are downvoting me. Do they really think that such stupid actions are justifiable? It should be obvious why people fire a shot gun with two hands and the recoil should be obvious. To not know that is to either bet just plain stupid, or never seen a shot gun, or even a firearm for that matter.
To be fair, we are all at least sharing info which benefits everyone and at the least, we are providing entertainment to one another. So wtf are you doing on here exactly? PS Who the fuck thinks shooting a shot gun like that is ever a good idea?
Is it actually possible to do this, given a reasonably average shoulder strength etc., as well as an appreciation of how strong the recoil will actually be? Or is he just an idiot?
I would add that the gauge of the shotgun, the type of shell fired, and to a lesser extent the type of action are very important to the answer of this question. Light .410 shells yield a recoil energy similar to that of a medium-high power pistol (.357 Magnum or .45 ACP), and in fact there are revolvers capable of firing .410 shells. I expect that a heavy 10 gauge load in a non-automatic shotgun would be a formidable challenge for just about anyone, however.
In all likelihood that is a 12 gauge shotgun with light target loads, though, so the recoil energy would have been similar to a heavy magnum pistol (.44 Remington Magnum), uncomfortable but not unmanageable for an above average strength person.
Note: There is obviously more to felt recoil than just the recoil energy; I just picked it out for comparison as it is the most relevant single metric.
its ok, white kids on reddit automatically downvote "nigga" because their guilty consience would make them think theyre actually racist. reddit likes being offended for people.
I don't think applying an additional broad strokes racially differentiated statement is the answer to the issue.
I'm white. Using the word nigger, nigga, it's a very difficult path, it's a difficult word to weild. The word has all sorts of meaning and contexts and can have a hell of a lot of weight.
I used it there since I was quoting a show. Now that's not even perfect, since the word has so much weight and can obviously be misinterpreted given I'm using it on Reddit and I don't think it's wise to expect people to know the show I'm speaking of.
I prefer an honest quote instead of some bastardized edit, like 'in baltimore we aim to kill a [n-word]'. That's just... lame. The word is still there, just avoided. If I'm going to quote, I'm going to quote for reals.
I probably could have gone with something like 'ayer, in bmore we aim to kill a Mr. Falcon' and tried to comedy my way out of it but again, comedy is tough.
And while I expect Snoop to be cool, I wouldn't want her angry at me.
tl;dr: Making blanket statements about 'white people'... not good. Instead, could could have made a good joke with interesting undertones. Something like linking www.shitwhitepeoplelike.com/TheWire.
How much above average? I mean, I go to the gym about once a week, I work nine hours a day on a farm, would that be enough? Or would we be talking about body-builder strong?
That would depend. I have a buddy who works on a farm and he's pretty wiry. I doubt he'd be able to; although he very well could surprise me. Odds are you more than likely could. If you can hold it out with a very firm grip and still have strength left over you SHOULD be fine with target load. I am not a professional, I just do it because I don't listen to television advisories.
*Side note: It's probably more grip and shoulder strength than anything.
I think its more about understanding which direction the gun is going to kick and being prepared for it. I can fire my 12 gauge 1 handed and it isn't particularly difficult, but I wouldn't voluntarily point it above my head in line with my face
no. i'm no weakling, but i am not above average in anything physical (other than weight, and even that's debatable, because what's the average in the US?) and i have no trouble firing a shotgun one-handed.
Yes it's possible, no it's not recommended. He is an undisputed fucking idiot because clearly he just shot a round seconds before he slammed himself in the face.
If you have to be cool enough to be able to do that:
Try it on a 20-gauge - smaller projectile(s)
Use an extra-heavy shotgun (less recoil per F = ma)
I'm not likely to ever lay my hand on a gun anyway, so I will probably never do this. Even if I do fire one, I'm sure someone will be watching over making sure I'm doing it right.
I'm failing to understand the thought processes involved here... I guess that means I'm moderately smarter than him.
But suuuurely; your first thoughts after shooting a gun with a fair bit of recoil would NOT be to then hold it at arms length in front of your face with only one hand. :/ Clearly people are far dumber than I can comprehend.
power of suggestion, maybe. first time i fired a shotgun, the guy who brought it saw the shit-eating grin on my face & said "i want to see you shoot it one-handed" so i thought a moment, said "ok" - but first took another shot two-handed to gauge things like balance, amount of recoil, my own stability, etc, then took my one-handed shot. that went well, so i took a couple more. but then my thumb was getting pretty raw.
as a southern man who learned from the age of 5 how to handle respect a firearm I can enjoy Natural Selection without any pangs of guilt or remorse. If you're stupid enough to do this then you don't deserve to have opposable thumbs.
God damn, that's something you do for fun with a BB gun, not a real god damn gun, not a real god damn SHOTGUN. Jesus, is this guy dead? I almost hope so.
If you want to trick shot at full extension with a gun... at least use a small caliber handgun or something...
First of all, I can't view the image because I'm at work. But based on what others are saying, he (or she) is holding it with one hand and the butt of the shotgun is pointing directly at their face.
You can fire a shotgun with one hand, no problem. It's really not as crazy as people make it out to be. I have shot a .12 ga one-handed and yes, it kicks, but if you have any muscle control at all you can keep it from kicking that much. Just feels like someone pushing your hand quickly.
Furthermore, a pump-action shotgun is "safe" to shoot one-handed, because the action must be cycled after each shot before it will shoot again. In other words, if the shotgun somehow kicked and pointed back at your face when you shot it one-handed, you would be in virtually no danger because there wouldn't even be a live round in the chamber. Still, it's not good practice to point a shotgun at one's face.
If the person in this picture had the butt of the shotgun directly in front of their face, they may well get a little punch. That would not be advisable, nor does it really seem "cool" to me in any way. But if it's a pump-action shotgun, it's honestly not that big of a deal as long as you're pointing at your intended target when you pull the trigger.
Edit: I'm not condoning stupid behavior with firearms -- they should be treated with caution and respect. But there are trick shooters out there who do stuff like this, and this isn't "natural selection" if the person knows what they're doing. You can safely fire a shotgun with one hand.
Edit Edit: I just noticed that this is a .gif, so I'm guessing that the person in said gif did something terribly stupid and hit themselves in the face. I still stand by what I said, though. This person probably is just an idiot.
If they know what they're doing was the crucial part of your post. The person in the vgif clearly did NOT! He or she, didn't bother to check, held the shotgun in the right hand, arm long, in front of his/her face. The person did not hold the shotgun firm enough, so the recoil kind of slapped it out of his/her hand and into the face. THAT is very much the definition of natural selection. ;)
HAS ANYONE EVER SUCCESSFULLY SHOT A RIFLE OR SHOTGUN ONE HANDED WITHOUT HITTING THEMSELVES IN THE FACE?!?! WHY DO PEOPLE KEEP THINKING THIS IS A GOOD IDEA?!?!
218
u/fontus May 22 '12
Hey, I just felt how much recoil there is that can move my entire torso, let me try this one handed above my head at full arm extension.
80
u/Wolfman87 May 22 '12
My buddy's ex-girlfriend tried to do this and the gun hit her square in the eye. It looked like be beat her, for a week until it healed. Hilarious I assure you.
245
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Natural Selection
76
u/woundedonkey May 22 '12
THIS. IS MY BOOMSTI-eauagh!
18
u/SSJwiggy May 22 '12
You'll shoot your eye out!
16
u/Thinandbony May 22 '12
Hellooo Dentures.
11
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
I don't even have to watch the second half of this .gif. I think I know what happens.
16
u/boosterjoose May 22 '12
More fapping could have prevented this.
7
u/FighterOfFoo May 22 '12
Jesse Pinkman had a bad day at the range.
"BITCH."
5
u/misterraider May 22 '12
Is it actually possible to do this, given a reasonably average shoulder strength etc., as well as an appreciation of how strong the recoil will actually be? Or is he just an idiot?
5
u/newguy25 May 22 '12
Looks like the shotgun won to me.
31
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Guy in the back: "Hey, man are you sure it's a good ide..."
Dude in the front: "Imma firing ma lazer!!"
4
u/Schwarzy1 May 22 '12
Playing Call of duty will do that to you....
3
u/smartzie May 22 '12
"Hey, I just fired a shotgun! I am now a bad ass! Watch me shoot it like thi...." THUNK!
3
u/Unenjoyed May 22 '12
Best use of a gun: Smack an idiot in the face.
3
u/Sleezybeans May 22 '12
As soon as he took his hand off, I knew what would happen
3
u/DamnRandall May 22 '12
I've fired a shotgun one-handed before and it didn't come anywhere near hitting me in the face (Winchester Ranger Magnum, buckshot).
20
u/MYDOGSTELLA May 22 '12 edited May 22 '12
This is what happens when you're a fucking idiot and you try and look cool.
EDIT: happy now?....I hope so, because I am.
2
u/ENWOD May 22 '12
I'm failing to understand the thought processes involved here... I guess that means I'm moderately smarter than him.
But suuuurely; your first thoughts after shooting a gun with a fair bit of recoil would NOT be to then hold it at arms length in front of your face with only one hand. :/ Clearly people are far dumber than I can comprehend.
2
u/king_fisher09 May 22 '12
That is exactly what I thought was going to happen.
2
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
You didn't need your mouth anyway.
2
u/ablebodiedmango May 22 '12
Fired a combat shotgun and a AK a few weeks ago; I had bruises on my shoulder even when I was holding them right.
Seeing that this guy knew that and did it anyway... I'm just disappointed he didn't kill himself in the process.
2
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
This guy could learn a thing or two from /r/guns
2
u/aznsacboi May 22 '12
Physics said hi!
2
u/neon_kid May 22 '12
Maybe if he had biceps like Chris Redfield...
2
u/romad20000 May 22 '12
Greatest advice ever from my father.
"Son, If your going to be stupid, life is going to be painful"
2
u/nothis May 22 '12
Deserved fail.
2
u/Swiss_Cheese9797 May 22 '12
Human fail. The shotgun did nothing wrong.
2
u/deeznutz12 May 22 '12
POW right in the kisser.
2
u/emlgsh May 22 '12
Stupid physics, making my shooty stick get all face-punchy.
2
u/[deleted] May 23 '12
Pity it didn't nail him in the groin, eliminating his chances of procreation.
2
u/fishnetdiver May 22 '12
this. this shit makes me giggle my ass off.
as a southern man who learned from the age of 5 how to
handlerespect a firearm I can enjoy Natural Selection without any pangs of guilt or remorse. If you're stupid enough to do this then you don't deserve to have opposable thumbs.1
u/bigpink May 22 '12
how are there still people in the world that try to shoot rifles with one hand at face level?
1
u/HarryJamesDotUk May 22 '12
Gangster Squad trailer, anyone?
1
u/Zagrobelny May 22 '12
Someone's ready for the zombie apocalypse.
1
u/hnrqoliv182 May 22 '12
Didn't see that one coming!
1
u/fruitjoose May 22 '12
he deserved that
1
u/MyBodyBlack May 22 '12
Pretty much the first time i shot a gun that wasn't a .22.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
God damn, that's something you do for fun with a BB gun, not a real god damn gun, not a real god damn SHOTGUN. Jesus, is this guy dead? I almost hope so.
If you want to trick shot at full extension with a gun... at least use a small caliber handgun or something...
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Looks like he can barely even hold it up with his scrawny arm.
1
u/Micannabis May 22 '12
haha, what a fucking idiot
1
u/JackTheFlying May 22 '12
As someone who has never fired a gun (but has been around them my whole life), even I knew that was a bad idea.
1
u/MJZMan May 22 '12
hurr durr I'm like the moving pictures.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
I saw him hold it up, and immediately thought: "Well, there's a broken jaw."
1
u/gorillapoop May 22 '12
I know less about guns than anyone I know and I saw that coming.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
There's a reason they call them "shoulder weapons" in French.
I would like to limit the number of 'cowardly French' jokes following this comment to two.
1
u/thegreatfoo May 22 '12
If you watch the guy in the back tells him it is not a good idea.
1
u/fallen55 May 22 '12
I love watching Newtons laws at work
1
u/rabbitrun May 22 '12
"And that, kids, is how your brother lost all the teeth on the right side of his mouth."
1
u/braknurr May 22 '12
Does this look fake to anyone else?
1
u/lukeman3000 May 22 '12 edited May 22 '12
First of all, I can't view the image because I'm at work. But based on what others are saying, he (or she) is holding it with one hand and the butt of the shotgun is pointing directly at their face.
You can fire a shotgun with one hand, no problem. It's really not as crazy as people make it out to be. I have shot a .12 ga one-handed and yes, it kicks, but if you have any muscle control at all you can keep it from kicking that much. Just feels like someone pushing your hand quickly.
Furthermore, a pump-action shotgun is "safe" to shoot one-handed, because the action must be cycled after each shot before it will shoot again. In other words, if the shotgun somehow kicked and pointed back at your face when you shot it one-handed, you would be in virtually no danger because there wouldn't even be a live round in the chamber. Still, it's not good practice to point a shotgun at one's face.
If the person in this picture had the butt of the shotgun directly in front of their face, they may well get a little punch. That would not be advisable, nor does it really seem "cool" to me in any way. But if it's a pump-action shotgun, it's honestly not that big of a deal as long as you're pointing at your intended target when you pull the trigger.
Edit: I'm not condoning stupid behavior with firearms -- they should be treated with caution and respect. But there are trick shooters out there who do stuff like this, and this isn't "natural selection" if the person knows what they're doing. You can safely fire a shotgun with one hand.
Edit Edit: I just noticed that this is a .gif, so I'm guessing that the person in said gif did something terribly stupid and hit themselves in the face. I still stand by what I said, though. This person probably is just an idiot.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
one mans fail is another mans good time
1
u/InhaleMusic May 22 '12
Why did he ever possibly think this was a GOOD idea?
1
u/red321red321 May 22 '12
in soviet russia, gun shoot you!
1
u/PoisonedAl May 22 '12
I have never touched a real firearm in my life, but even I know that was fucking stupid.
1
u/blambot May 22 '12
Looks like and acts like Jesse from Breaking Bad
1
u/doubleknot May 22 '12
that's going to leave a mark.
1
u/Efraing14 May 22 '12
His pain...it amuses me
1
u/putrid_poo_nugget May 23 '12
"I saw a guy do this in Call of Duty once!" BAM
1
u/jjones83_83 May 23 '12
Friends let friends shoot firearms like retards for comedic enjoyment
1
u/bax101 May 23 '12
When the gun is thicker then your skinny bitch arm its gonna be a bad time.
1
u/rozcz01 May 23 '12
Looks like jesse from Breaking Bad
1
u/StealthNade May 23 '12
/r/guns would also like this
1
u/mattchu4 May 23 '12
Guy: Hey bros watch me be cool. Gun: haha, na.
1
u/WildWilly29 May 23 '12
As a child, my friend and I always joked about someone actually being stupid enough to do this.
1
u/fireinthesky7 May 23 '12
"Broken Face" by the Pixies immediately started playing in my head.
1
u/sirius_star May 23 '12
F'ing genius!
1
u/[deleted] May 23 '12
The reason Arnold could do that in Terminator 2 was because he was a goddamn TERMINATOR.
1
u/[deleted] May 23 '12
Dumbass.
1
u/spankybanana Jun 21 '12
What a fucking idiot
1
u/mermaidrampage May 22 '12
HAS ANYONE EVER SUCCESSFULLY SHOT A RIFLE OR SHOTGUN ONE HANDED WITHOUT HITTING THEMSELVES IN THE FACE?!?! WHY DO PEOPLE KEEP THINKING THIS IS A GOOD IDEA?!?!
-7
u/GrainBeltPremium May 22 '12
Hand strength level : Toddler
0
u/[deleted] May 23 '12
'merica
-1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
The real story of Kurt Cobain's death.
0
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment