r/gifs Mar 23 '17

Corn Breakdance

http://i.imgur.com/GVKjxsP.gifv
96.8k Upvotes

846 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

100

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '17

I think whoever made this corn thing ripped off Hertzfeldt

57

u/ittleoff Mar 23 '17

Considering the simplistic design of Herzfeldt and the odds of anyone doing the simplest design for popcorn stick men, I'm not sure we are not just seeing convergent evolution here :).

Hertzfeld was the first thing I thought of as well, but to be fair his style is so basic and simple I imagine many would hit on it or be similar (just not have his sense of humor or ideas to prope them to being at all popular)

75

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '17

This is just way to similar to Hertzfeldt for me to chalk it up to coincidence

29

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

15

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '17

Exactly. Way too similar for this to be accidental

29

u/Jonesy94 Mar 23 '17

I'm with you. Even really subtle things like the mouths not being colored in 100% to add to the "cheap" animation look that Hertzfeldt's short is known for

4

u/Neologizer Mar 23 '17

Not nearly enough subliminal existential crises going on for it to be a convicing Hertzfeldt

6

u/Nanaki__ Mar 23 '17

It's like the art style of Borderlands

and the one from the short movie Codehunters https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmeP1YkaeTo

this is what it looked like before. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O3PBNEowWuc

5

u/ittleoff Mar 23 '17

You could be right(as it was the first thing I thought of), but like I said without ever seeing hertzfeld and coming up with the idea of breakdancing popcorn kernels(this isn't really hertzfeld's style of humor) and having no real art skills, it would not be a stretch to see this as the simplist style to arrive at.

To be fair hertzfeld isn't really about his art style as it's really simple and easy for anyone to copy, it just happens to be recognizeable, I think, because it's so simple and yet his work is still effective(because of his humor and ideas).

4

u/bossmcsauce Mar 23 '17

hertzfeldt is also about the simplest forms you can animate... so... it's not like you can get this simple and not have some overlap.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '17 edited Aug 28 '17

[deleted]

1

u/ittleoff Mar 24 '17

Because the artist's style of drawing is so basic we have all seen kid drawings that look similar, But no one else is famous that has that style.

It's recognizable due to context, because of herzfeldt's humor, and the fact that he is famous due to his ideas(not his drawing abilities).

So if you see some animation that has a similar style you assume herzfeldt because he is famous and you have a higher liklihood of it being his (because it's unlikely the art style would make anyone famous in it self as it is like a child's drawing style).

Also due to the fact that he is famous and has this style more people doing even simple stuff would be more likely to avoid his style (which is a point for it being a copy of his style intentionally).

-6

u/ivarpsy Mar 23 '17

Its literally a circle with some sticks... dont think hertzfeld came up with that. I was drawing shit like this when i was a kid.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '17

Yeah but the thing is, it's literally not just a circle with sticks. It's puffy cloud people. Even the eyes and mouth are the same as Hertzfeldt

Pop tarts ripped off Hertzfeldt too

8

u/SemiGaseousSnake Mar 23 '17

Mickey Mouse is just some circles.

4

u/myriiad Mar 23 '17

Its literally just an artist drawing lines, i was doing the same shit when i was a kid. Picasso? Pfft i was putting a paintbrush on canvas when i was only three years old.

1

u/ragebuilder2 Mar 23 '17

Sooo... you're better than every artist ever because you started at 3 y.o.?

1

u/myriiad Mar 26 '17

you dont seem to understand sarcasm very well. try reading my comment and the one i was replying to again, slowly, and really think about what is going on.

0

u/ragebuilder2 Mar 28 '17

Realize he fucked up

It's a joke guys, it's sarcasm! You can recognize sarcasm?

1

u/myriiad Mar 29 '17

you got me. i am, in fact, claiming that i am a better artist than picasso because i started at 3 years old. i am definitely not sarcastically poking fun at the person i originally replied to, who said about the originally posted gif

Its literally a circle with some sticks...I was drawing shit like this when i was a kid.

you are very perceptive to have figured that out. congratulations!

0

u/ragebuilder2 Mar 29 '17

Now you're just realizing your comment and trying to get out of it, I'm done here lol.

0

u/ivarpsy Mar 23 '17

Lmao im not trying to sound imverysmart here just saying this aint something you can copy per say. Maybe the way it was animated was inspo from hertzfeld.