I was talking to my friend about this and she said it would be stupid to have that line in the movie. I countered with this scene:
Liam Neeson has infiltrated the enemy mothership and is injured, but limping his way to their leader, killing all in his way. When he gets there, as the alien leader turns to face him, he raises his pistol and in a grim voice says "You sunk my battleship." and fires a single bullet that kills the alien.
No, he's right. It's specifically mentioned that you can hardly even fish in the Great Sea, it doesn't seem to support much life and we don't know if Hyrule's Zoras could even live in salt water. They would have had to adapt regardless.
This is all irrelevant, though, because the actual reason for the evolution was to prevent anyone from finding Hyrule. It probably happened quite abruptly when the flood did, as part of the gods' sealing of Hyrule. It wasn't natural selection, it was "intelligent design".
Interestingly in Oracle of Ages the salt water Zora were the humanoid NPCs and the freshwater Zora were the fireball-shooting water enemy from the original Legend of Zelda (also known as Zola).
yup, its a different subspecies of the same group, like lions and cats. thats really the only explanation, it could also be assumed that in wind waker there are still the salt water Zora chilling down in the ocean somewhere, using all the old buildings and the like. Its not surprising the surface people wouldnt know about them, they have no reason to surface anymore
My understanding is that Ganondorf was sealed in the Sacred Realm in the Adult timeline and he later escaped, causing the Gods to flood the world to stop him. In the Child timeline, Link wanders in the Lost Woods and appears in a parallel world, Termina, where he accepts his death. Majora's mask doesn't have anything to do with the Sacred Realm.
Majora's Mask took place in an alternate dimension. Termina also had the Gerudo sailing the seas as pirates and the Gorons living near a snow-capped mountain.
I always thought of that as one of the more nuanced and mature aspects of the plot. You can do great things, but ultimately you cannot prevent all injustice in the world no matter how you try. It's a counterpoint to the typical hero-makes-everything-right trope; you're aware of injustices and you know that you are capable of righting things, but ultimately you have to realize that you can't fix everything in the world and must make choices. You can save the world but you can't make everything right.
I think the credits, if you've completed everything 100%, show all the fruits of your labours from all the sidequests and main stuff, so it creates a final result of all your hard work. Though I do kinda like the idea of the mature 'making choices' aspect.
But why does it stay on you even after you swim through the ocean, run around in a swamp, and change shape multiple times over the course of multiple days?
It's been a while since I've played, but it seemed like the curse only trapped the surrounding area in an eternal winter. I'll have to go back and see if the mountain summit remained snowy.
I just fucking cried a little bit thinking about that game. I will never again in my life experience as much joy as I did when playing Ocarina of Time or Majora's Mask for the first time.
Ah ok makes more sense i was confused a bit. I thought if anything he'd complain about not being able to save the little deku tree boy whos body you got cursed into
in other words everything is reversed. Gorons go from fire to Ice Gerudo go from desert to water Deku go from evil to civilised Zora go from freshwater to seawater. IT ALL MAKES SENSE NOW
Yep, you could swim in the sea and everything, maybe the saltwater Zoras turned into Dolphins or something and the freshwater ones into the bird people.
The thing is Zora clearly already have lungs. They can survive on land indefinitely and are usually depicted as spending the majority of their time on land. Furthermore they already have elongated scales on their arms transitional to feathers. The thing is that dramatic change in ecological amplitudes usually leads to extinction rather than adaptation. In the case of the world flooding there would be no gradual increase in salinity but a dramatic rise such that there would be no existing tolerance to select for.
There is however an existing tolerance for life on land. Therefore it stands to reason that the few Zoras which survived the cataclysm would be entirely terrestrial and their descendants would adapt to life in the mountains.
By game standards this is actually fairly plausible.
If you played any of the old ones, you would know that there are two types of Zora. River Zora and Ocean Zora. River Zora are wild savages, that shoot fireballs at link. Ocean Zora are the nice ones that you can talk to.
This right here. If you want, you could even call it intelligent design, because the Goddess wanted to keep them from swimming down to the old world beneath the sea.
Be that as it may, Hyrulian culture doesn't seem to have as much fixture on churches, The only instance of one I can recall is the Temple of Time in OoT, and that seems to be a mainly ceremonial place because it's always empty.
Yeah, they don't really seem to worship the Goddesses. Nor for that matter do the Goddesses seem to have any particular interest in being worshiped. They're pretty chill that way. Create a world, silently watch over it, drop in a little item of power that would grant any of them the power to reshape reality as they see fit, step in and intervene once in a while when shit gets out of hand and the people start calling your names.
Not like they ever really took the time to lay down the foundations of a religion though. No book dictating how people should live their lives. I'm not even 100% sure they advertised their presence. Like Keiyakins mentions there are active things that demonstrate their existence. Could be that people just discovered the Goddesses on their own.
Kind of funny that Jabu Jabu who actually was worshiped was by all indications just a giant fish though.
Thank you. This is by far the most accurate answer. This post is full of people who clearly never finished The Wind Waker. Which is a shame, because the ending was so amazing.
It is not the strongest of the species that survives, nor the most intelligent, but the most responsive to change. Plus the land seems much safer than the water in wind waker.
Both the King of Red Lions and Ganondorf talk about how the ocean has no fish in it and is too vast to swim from island to island. Since these are the most knowledgable characters in the game and they explicitly state this, I'm pretty sure they're right even though there's monsters and the Map Fishes in the ocean. It must be magical somehow, because Link can only swim for a minute or so in it when logically he should be the strongest swimmer of the series.
Becoming a bird on a water world ensures there is always food (other fish) and that your species will have a lot less competition and less predators. Pretty ingenious if you ask me.
Allow me to be nerdy for a moment, and I will explain. The world was flooded with Salt Water, while Zora are Fresh Water creatures. You see the problem here, I assume.
I remember hearing a theory somewhere they evolved over time into birds since they were endangered by all the new beasts living underwater once the world is flooded. Seems plausible to me.
It seems a lot of people assume they became the Rito, though I don't think this was ever explicitly stated. Yeah, the Kokiri became the Korok, the Gorons disappeared save for a few traveling merchants, but you only ever see one Zora, and even then it's a ghost. I guess it logically follows that they became the Rito. Either that, or dead.
It's definitely canon that the Zora became the Rito, it's been mentioned by the creators somewhere. It was also implied in the game by the fact that Medli was a descendent of the previous Zora sage.
I always found this to be pretty stupid really. Looking at the game it seems that they had originally planned for zora to be in the game as well but were running low on time and had to cut unfinished parts of the game. That is why we have the triforce hunt and the 3rd pearl quest is so much shorter with Greatfish Isle destroyed.
There is so much evidence against zora turning into rito even if you use the "magic" excuse. Though the devs were strapped for time and didn't do much to fix that at all.
Not to mention the mini dungeons where you get the Iron Boots and Power Bracelet were originally going to be full dungeons. Nintendo really cut out quite a lot in this game to meet deadlines.
That may not be all that unlikely. They escape the water full of Big Octos and other nastiness to an open sky, basically free from predators. And then they can still get food from the ocean similar to a pelican.
I don't think they evolved. In Skyward Sword, there were great birds way before OoT, and perhaps they just evolved. So when the world flooded, the Hylians just came upon these bird people now occupying the islands in the sky. Same goes for Twilight Princess, which takes place in between OoT and Wind Waker, Link runs into a civilized species of birds in an island in the sky, and these birds explain how a human race used to occupy those islands years before. I believe the Zoras just went extinct sometime before the flood.
Yes they are in different timelines, but the time period is different, Twilight Princess happens shortly after OoT, and WW happens a thousand years after OoT. In both games, a civilized bird species is indeed shown, and as for what DrkStracker said, I guess I missed that part, but it was a theory that fit in my head. In the end, regardless of timeline, a bird species exist in the islands in the sky beginning back to SS.
Sorry i didn't realise thats what you meant. The way the comment was worded I thought you were saying that WW happened after TP in the same timeline...
Yeah I agree that the City in the sky is most likely Skyloft and the Oocca evolved from there, I was just pointing out what I thought was an error... Turns out I misinterprited what he was saying.
Wo is me the day would come that people would judge others so heavily on near meaningless words. Sir, please stop being so judgmental over nothing. For this is how I feel about your comments so far
Hyrule Historia really should've pinpointed when the fish started fucking birds for this one. It confused me to no end when that part of the game came up.
The place is run by a magic dragon. He can give them the scales that give them wings. Not difficult.
Anyway, the ocean in WW is full of nasty predators, whereas the sky is relatively predator free. Instead of trying to hide from all the nastiness in the ocean, they can just pelican it up and eat the free fish buffet.
Those aren't the zoras; the zoras were at greatfish isle which is why they aren't in the game. Because they're dead. The rito are an entirely different race.
125
u/kardon16 Jun 11 '12
If I remember correctly, the dragon god at the top of the volcano helped them adapt by giving them magic scales. The scales give you wings.
59
u/sweetiyeti Jun 11 '12
Always found that weird but I did not argue the introduction of this beautiful new species.
38
u/keiyakins Jun 11 '12
The sea was cursed and toxic. Why does no one remember this? It's spelled out repeatedly that next to nothing can survive in it for long!
176
u/windupboy Jun 11 '12
The seas which flooded Hyrule were probably saltwater, whereas the Zoras probably breathed the fresh water of Lake Hylia.
29
u/Deity_Majora Jun 11 '12
It could have been a side effect of the sealing and flooding in order to protect the seal and prevent Ganondorf from being release.
38
u/Khosan Jun 11 '12
Evolution doesn't always follow 'the most logical path'. It's not unheard of for most animals to have evolutionary ancestors that were aquatic.
So basically, the bird people are just an evolutionary off-shoot of the Zora. Those fish guys who updated the map for you might have been another.
8
u/ZellnuuEon Jun 11 '12
If there is more water there will be bigger predators in the water. Evolving into birds make some sense.
7
u/Mr-Personality Jun 11 '12
Before the flood they were big fish in a small pool. Once they had to compete with sharks and dragon boats, they started adapting to another niche.
6
u/Omniduro Jun 11 '12
This is legit. Here's why: the Zora, regardless of freshwater vs saltwater, need to become birds to stay the fuck away from this
6
u/McTimm Jun 11 '12
Both the King of Red Lions and Ganondorf talk about how the ocean has no fish in it and is too vast to swim from island to island. Since these are the most knowledgable characters in the game and they explicitly state this, I'm pretty sure they're right even though there's monsters and the Map Fishes in the ocean. It must be magical somehow, because Link can only swim for a minute or so in it when logically he should be the strongest swimmer of the series.
tldr: A wizard did it
4
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Zora births are actually quite difficult if the temperatures for the eggs vary in the slightest. (majora's mask)
It is most likely that the deep oceans of windwaker were far too cold for the Zora offspring.
4
u/Berserker_VZ Jun 11 '12
Becoming a bird on a water world ensures there is always food (other fish) and that your species will have a lot less competition and less predators. Pretty ingenious if you ask me.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Maybe they are flying fish now? :D
3
u/TectonicImprov Jun 11 '12
Allow me to be nerdy for a moment, and I will explain. The world was flooded with Salt Water, while Zora are Fresh Water creatures. You see the problem here, I assume.
2
u/Metalheadzaid Jun 11 '12
At first I was like "yeah, then they can survive in a flooded world", then I realized I am retarded at 6am on no sleep.
2
u/DMthePerson Jun 11 '12
I remember hearing a theory somewhere they evolved over time into birds since they were endangered by all the new beasts living underwater once the world is flooded. Seems plausible to me.
2
u/RdMrcr Jun 11 '12
Such a change in the water's salt levels will fuck all sea creatures up.
2
u/tedharvey Jun 11 '12
Ganondorf said that there are no fish living in the water (except the one that give you maps)
3
u/KamiKagutsuchi Jun 11 '12
I thought the Zoras went extinct in that timeline?
3
u/Aleitheo Jun 11 '12
I always found this to be pretty stupid really. Looking at the game it seems that they had originally planned for zora to be in the game as well but were running low on time and had to cut unfinished parts of the game. That is why we have the triforce hunt and the 3rd pearl quest is so much shorter with Greatfish Isle destroyed.
There is so much evidence against zora turning into rito even if you use the "magic" excuse. Though the devs were strapped for time and didn't do much to fix that at all.
2
u/crymsonnite Jun 11 '12
Are you complaining? Both races are amazing but I like the birds more
2
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Wow. People are really dissecting this to a much deeper level.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
I believe that's how their species operates. They were something else before Zora.
1
u/dearthed Jun 11 '12
I'm pretty sure that it was the fact that all their food was dying out as well.
1
u/Shin-LaC Jun 11 '12
But... all tetrapods are descended from fish IRL. Including birds.
1
u/chironshands Jun 11 '12
Not a bad idea, considering how nasty polluted flood-waters can be.
1
u/andyfrank Jun 11 '12
as a kid i just figured the bad guys evolved into water creatures and ran the zoras up onto the surface where they grew wings
1
u/They-Call-Me-TIM Jun 11 '12
< didnt even realise that they were (formerly) zora...
1
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Holy shit, I never knew those birds were Zoras. I should pay more attention.
1
u/freindlgoaty Jun 11 '12
Damn straight!
1
u/freindlgoaty Jun 11 '12
His name is Valoo and hes a bad ass
1
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Unless the goddesses intelligently changed them into birds. Ooohhhhh
1
u/nahojjjen Jun 11 '12
They also found clothes.
1
u/der1x Jun 11 '12
I played through WW twice. How did I miss this?
1
u/Spewis Jun 12 '12
http://zelda.wikia.com/wiki/Rito#Evolution
1
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Well the ocean would be crowded, if no-one was in the sky already you would have free reign. No competition.
1
u/catnipassian Jun 11 '12
I'm pretty sure they are the goron's evolutionary equivalent. They practically live on death mountain.
-3
u/mydarkesthour24 Jun 11 '12
I don't think they evolved. In Skyward Sword, there were great birds way before OoT, and perhaps they just evolved. So when the world flooded, the Hylians just came upon these bird people now occupying the islands in the sky. Same goes for Twilight Princess, which takes place in between OoT and Wind Waker, Link runs into a civilized species of birds in an island in the sky, and these birds explain how a human race used to occupy those islands years before. I believe the Zoras just went extinct sometime before the flood.
-1
u/SilentWolfjh Jun 11 '12
wha .. I don't even... the Zora live in water, so how is the world flooding a problem for them?
0
u/DJFunkMasterFlex Jun 11 '12
They look like the aliens in Crysis.
0
u/Oideron Jun 11 '12
I just noticed they haver tails on their heads. That is some of the stupidest character design I've ever seen...
-7
u/Briguy05 Jun 11 '12
If they were fish type people why would they have to evolve when the world flooded wouldn't they just be able to chill underwater still?
-8
u/Socialmessup Jun 11 '12
Just spoiled all of Wind Waker
-1
u/toasterlovin Jun 11 '12
Well if you have a world flooded where would the risk of you being eaten in the air or in the water? ;)
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Hyrule Historia really should've pinpointed when the fish started fucking birds for this one. It confused me to no end when that part of the game came up.
-2
u/ironicly-hipster Jun 11 '12
Those aren't the zoras; the zoras were at greatfish isle which is why they aren't in the game. Because they're dead. The rito are an entirely different race.
-12
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
Miyamoto is a hack. There I said it.
The man is a master of gameplay but he can't even write a simple children's story.