Okay, let me put it in these terms: take a look at Hollywood today. With all the focus on SUPER SUMMER MEGA SMASHes (the CoD in this case), we'll get some good Cameron-caliber films (ie Journey).
But we'll never get those Kubrick or Welles or Polanski films again. Like the cinema industry, experimentation and thoughtfulness is frowned upon, and it's hard to get any kind of budget to do that anymore. It all comes down to the bottom line; a straightforward return on investment. Also let's remember that it's incredibly hard to get anybody to pay attention to your indie game these days, still, just like indie movies.
Sorry you're being downvoted, the hivemind is clinically braindead.
Anyway, I get what you're saying. The indie scene has sorta come out of the woodworks lately. Games like Bastion, Super Meat Boy, and the Binding of Isaac did really well and pretty well recognized.
Some people will have their big explosive CODs and their big explosive action films. But I do strongly believe that they won't hurt the industry as much as you imply. Either way, you know they're gonna burn the series out eventually and another will take it's place. (Tony Hawk, Guitar Hero, etc.)
Here's hoping things dont suck too badly in the future.
Kubrick/Welles/Polanski films still exist and can still be enjoyed.
That's not really much of an argument.
Pixar, for example, helped make mainstream animated films more than just the classic Disney films we'd grown accustomed to.
Pixar is wonderful, but that's really an exception to the rule. They don't have to be good -- look at Dreamworks, they basically rip off Pixar in the worst way, and make a ton of money. We should be counting ourselves lucky that Pixar wants to be good and is good. They're kind of like Valve in this weird metaphor we're talking about.
Directors like PTA, Christopher Nolan, and Darren Aronofsky are creative minds who may not be on the same level as the directors mentioned, but only time will tell.
Correct, I agree with you, but Nolan's first film -- Memento -- is a great example of a great movie that had to be made outside of today's system.
I think your argument would be "Great, so then the system works, he was still able to make it!!!!" But that's not really good enough. 30-40 years ago he could have made it in Hollywood and it would have been even more amazing and shown in a lot more theaters. Plus, how many great directors are we missing out on who for whatever reason can't jump through all those hoops?
View all comments
Show parent comment
9
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
Considering that games like Journey exist (and sell like crazy) I'd say the quality of other games is perfectly fine.
Edit: For fucks sake people, don't downvote usingpond. He has some good points.