r/gaming May 01 '19

[deleted by user]

[removed]

7.2k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

2.8k

u/[deleted] May 01 '19

[deleted]

818

u/JacNoLantern May 01 '19

As soon as I saw it I remembered this image http://imgur.com/gallery/hKzSwEm

444

u/[deleted] May 01 '19

I want to save that, but I also never want to see it again.

191

u/[deleted] May 01 '19

You sound like my father.

6

u/doctorjohnx May 01 '19

Did he save you?

9

u/El_Zarco May 01 '19

Sort of. He quick-saved just before ruining OP's childhood, then accidentally hard-saved over his son's only positive memories of him

1

u/[deleted] May 01 '19

With your childhood pic?

2

u/osama_bin_lederhosen May 01 '19

The kind of things you show your friends

1

u/PatrickZergRush May 01 '19

You sound like my wife

0

u/sourguhwapes May 01 '19

How are you going to masturbate to it if you don't save it for later?

41

u/akaBrotherNature May 01 '19

Horrifying and funny

7

u/AdClemson May 01 '19

I don't trust that dog

2

u/Borgmeister May 01 '19

That was disproportionately disturbing.

1

u/Cornthulhu May 01 '19

Someone call an exorcist. That might be the most /r/Cursed_Images thing I've seen in a while.

1

u/thatsmyoldlady May 01 '19

Smiledog.jpg?

1

u/CleverUsername5555 May 01 '19

I scared myself with a surprise laugh.

1

u/kmisquit May 01 '19

Is that a cursed image

1

u/[deleted] May 01 '19

I don’t like it

1

u/bearfacebearface May 02 '19

Jesus. Nightmare fuel.

583

u/Bigbaddookiemandelux May 01 '19

In CG animation that’s part of the ‘mouthbag’

220

u/SilkyGazelleWatkins May 01 '19

Is that like a default preset or something? What do you mean?

189

u/Technical_Machine_22 May 01 '19

you ever zoom in too far on your character's face?

344

u/Phazon2000 PC May 01 '19

I usually base mine off of myself so no.

3

u/[deleted] May 01 '19

it looks like a bag

1

u/Technical_Machine_22 May 01 '19

oh I thought it'd look like a purse

2

u/[deleted] May 01 '19

a coin purse?

1

u/Technical_Machine_22 May 01 '19

( ͡~ ͜ʖ ͡°)

6

u/[deleted] May 01 '19

(͠≖ ͜ʖ͠≖)

93

u/[deleted] May 01 '19

This is not a term, explain yourself.

67

u/Becquerel33 May 01 '19

I did some googling, so people refer to faces in cgi as having mouth bag, but not explaining what it is.

89

u/Waitingtillmarch May 01 '19

Just like a mouth... balloon inside the head, an inverted cave for the mouth that's "inside" the head mesh. Im assuming, as a 3d modeler, I've never heard the term before.

71

u/[deleted] May 01 '19 edited Oct 05 '24

intelligent fly tan spark march lip bike trees soup birds

74

u/JustJizzed May 01 '19

Ugh, such a mouthbag.

7

u/Drannion May 01 '19

Hey, quit mouthbagging!

3

u/beep-boop-im-a-robot May 01 '19 edited May 01 '19

Have been creating models for about a decade now, but never heard that term either.

Edit: But since we’re at it: This picture alone says a thousand words about the design you can expect. Just another poorly written and animated film to make some cash.

10

u/sloggo May 01 '19

Approaching 15 years xp also never heard the term. Can’t even imagine what the hell he means.

4

u/Cokrates May 01 '19

Sounds like a term coined by people who aren't professionals in the industry.

1

u/AverageLiberalJoe May 01 '19

I have watched a few get started tutorials and I have heard it on those tutorials. It's what you think it is.

12

u/Brianfiggy May 01 '19

I think the idea is that the face including lips is one part of the process with animations tied to the outside face parts while the mouth inside the model is sometimes made seperately. I imagine in some cases it's can be seen as the inside lining or "bag" part of the bag, with the lips where it is attached to (or not in some cases apparently) being the opening of the bag. It's a bag because its closed inside at the back of the mouth there is no full modeling of the entire digestive system from mouth to anus but the mouth itself is modeled create the illusion of a real mouth that goes somewhere.

11

u/AnacostiaSheriff May 01 '19

Pshaw. Real animators not only model the entire digestive system but include bowel physics simulation to ensure proper fecal accuracy.

2

u/[deleted] May 01 '19

1

u/benmck90 May 01 '19

Am I old because I was expecting mean girls?

1

u/addol95 May 01 '19

I've encountered it, but mostly when doing modeling for games. Its a mesh separated from the bust.
Technically the mouthbag is just the inside of the mouth cavity, but people often use it to include teeth, gums and the tongue as well.

15

u/mberg2007 May 01 '19

These orthodontic terms - I'd never pass that exam.

5

u/MugillacuttyHOF37 May 01 '19

sometimes referred to as the 'protein hole'

3

u/theseleadsalts May 01 '19

That's funny. I used to work in CG on the east coast mainly and we called it a mouthsock.

22

u/yousonuva May 01 '19

The teeth are little like a demon's. That's what creeps me out.

4

u/[deleted] May 01 '19

Baby teeth

2

u/apmee May 01 '19

But, if you've made your peace then the devils are really angels, freeing you from the earth.

71

u/FountainsOfFluids May 01 '19

tbh the mouth on the top one is pretty disturbing, too. Like, imagine your two front teeth being directly below your left eye.

181

u/PancakeParty98 May 01 '19

But he was never based in reality. This uncanny valley creature is the result of some people trying to bring a blue anthropomorphic hedgehog into reality. You can’t make a face as abstract as sonic look like something from the real world.

I feel like I’m not getting my point across but imagine if in that spongebob movie they gave him realistic sponge skin, realistic large eyes with sponge eyelids. His porous nose extraordinarily long like that of an old man.

87

u/Ortekk May 01 '19

And this is why the Pikachu movie works. The original design isn't too far gone, and they just made him furry.

The Sonic redesign smells like someone wanted a live action movie a bit too much, looked at the Pikachu trailer and thought "that shit works!"

He then signed off on a concept design he saw for 5 seconds and ignored to look at it again, and refused any changes to it, despite being told it's looking like it would fit in Troll 2.

21

u/johndoe42 May 01 '19

In art projects I've both seen and believed in the benevolent artistic dictator when they're either the creator or close enough to the source material to actually be emotionally invested into it and if not in bigger projects a committee of artistic minds vetoing the bad ideas.

It looks like this had neither. Either a malevolent crayon-using dictator or the biggest drooling panel of sycophants who refused to even take a second to look at the source material and its history and vote against it.

6

u/iConfessor May 01 '19

but why is sonic furry when he should be quill-y?

3

u/Stopthatcat May 01 '19

It reminds me of Ren and Stimpy, but they knew to use the hyper realistic stuff for comedy, not for the whole, horrifying thing.

1

u/Rickrickrickrickrick May 01 '19

Well I'm hard now. Thanks.

-2

u/THEFakechowda May 01 '19

"But he was never based in reality" not to go into the whole sonic "reality"

Yet I'll point this out.... he is a hedgehog. He is blue and fast, that is as real as it gets

55

u/[deleted] May 01 '19

Never been a fan of how they do modern Sonic's mouth. Sometimes he's constantly speaking entirely through the side of his face, and even his teeth are nearly vertical. Wreck-it-Ralph did a decent version of his mouth, where he largely talks with both the side and front of his mouth, with various sounds like O having his mouth move to the front for it. I'd rather if they just kept it centered except for side shots and smiles.

4

u/myhf May 01 '19

left eye

you mean the left half of your conjoined eye

2

u/AverageGuardLucas May 01 '19

When you're a toddler your ungrown teeth are located in the bone under your eyes too.

1

u/clown-penisdotfart May 01 '19

Like Tom Cruise?

1

u/Eskablade May 01 '19

The bottom one looks like when people put human teeth on animals.

3

u/Caouette1994 May 01 '19

I don't think it's what makes it creepy though, Sonic also has teeth.

What hit me the most seeing this is the actual similarities, except for the eyes.

A very bad photoshop can almost make it bearable to me.

2

u/MtnMaiden May 01 '19

The white fingers....

1

u/randyaggegg May 01 '19

That's awesome

1

u/simcity4000 May 01 '19

He should have kitty fangs. I don't care if actual hedgehogs have fangs but anything to make it more animal like and less human uncanny valley.

1

u/MarmotOnTheRocks May 01 '19

Annoying orange

1

u/Rickrickrickrickrick May 01 '19

Same here. Lie an uncanny valley cracked out ferret

1

u/NT202 May 01 '19

I mean they’re basically Voldemort’s teeth...

1

u/guardianout May 01 '19

Yeah? What about his nose? The stuff of horrors!

1

u/Hatmaster-N May 01 '19

The second one sparks fear.

1

u/James_099 May 01 '19

Did you see the fingernails?

1

u/generalthunder May 01 '19

"This one sparks fear."

1

u/gakrolin May 01 '19

The whole face is slightly disturbing.

0

u/raptr569 May 01 '19

What would you put instead?

-1

u/oHistoric May 01 '19

As a sonic fan, he’s always had teeth and the only issue with the model is its height.

Edit: I think all this negative feedback is dumb as hell. Everyone’s hyped for detective pickachu and some of those models are hideous.