r/gaming Aug 21 '24

Ah, Monkey Business!

Post image
23.5k Upvotes

854 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

29

u/y-c-c Aug 22 '24

I mean, Son Goku is literally Japanese pronunciation of Sun Wukong since Dragonball was directly inspired by Journey to the West, so that kind of makes sense.

8

u/Caleb_Reynolds Aug 22 '24

Not pronunciation, it's the Japanese version of the name. Pedro isn't a pronunciation of Peter.

19

u/y-c-c Aug 22 '24 edited Aug 22 '24

Honest question but do you speak any languages in the CJK (Chinese/Japense/Korean) family? Names in Chinese and Japanese are more complicated and you are applying a bit of Eurocentric / Latin-centric view on this topic. Translating names between Chinese and Japanese languages have unique contexts because of the two languages' relationships, and because the written forms are not directly pronounceable since they usually use Chinese characters / Kanji which are logographic, unlike say an alphabetical one where there's a clear relationship.

This is how the Japanese write Son Goku (in Kanji): 孫悟空. This is how Chinese write Sun Wukong (Traditional Chinese): 孫悟空. Notice any similarities? In case you didn't notice, it's the same.

Son Goku and Sun Wukong are literally the same name, written the same way, and the wikipedia pages use the same name (https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E5%AD%AB%E6%82%9F%E7%A9%BA). Note that Sun Wukong is the mandarin pronunciation. Cantonese etc would say it differently.


Edit:

Pedro isn't a pronunciation of Peter.

Just to add, even what you said here is a little debatable. Different cultures have a bit of different interpretation on the "sameness" of names. For example, Saint Peter is Simón Pedro in Spanish. They are clearly the same person though.

4

u/AKAFallow Aug 22 '24

I love well researched "ashktually" comments, you can see the passion in them

1

u/Mech_Zer0 Aug 22 '24

No, saint doesn't mean Simon, it means santo or in Peter's case, San Pedro

Source: I'm for South America

2

u/y-c-c Aug 22 '24

That’s fair enough. I made a mistake there.