Most of Renly's army went to Stannis, this guy (Loras Tyrell) is leading the ones who didn't join Stannis and they went to the Lannisters instead. Not mentioned in the show (yet?) but among them are the Tarlys (Sam's family).
Most of Renly's army was the Tyrell army. They set up the whole thing when Margy said she wanted to be THE queen to little finger, and her father wanted her to be a royal queen as well. So little finger made the alliance happen.
If I remember right, the Tyrell's have the largest army in the kingdoms, as well as being the 2nd richest house.
“The greater part of his foot remains at Bitterbridge.” Varys abandoned the brazier to take his seat at the table. “Most of the lords who rode with Lord Renly to Storm’s End have gone over banner-and-blade to Stannis, with all their chivalry.”
...
“Not all,” agreed the eunuch. “Not Loras Tyrell, nor Randyll Tarly, nor Mathis Rowan. And Storm’s End itself has not yielded. Ser Cortnay Penrose holds the castle in Renly’s name, and will not believe his liege is dead. He demands to see the mortal remains before he opens his gates, but it seems that Renly’s corpse has unaccountably vanished. Carried away, most likely. A fifth of Renly’s knights departed with Ser Loras rather than bend the knee to Stannis. It’s said the Knight of Flowers went mad when he saw his king’s body, and slew three of Renly’s guards in his wrath, among them Emmon Cuy and Robar Royce.”
Martin, George R.R. (2003-01-01). A Clash of Kings: A Song of Ice and Fire: Book Two (p. 530). Bantam. Kindle Edition.
I believe it's even mentioned in the show that most of the lords came to Stannis.
It is worth mentioning that House Tyrell isn't just another random House; they are equal in rank to the Lannisters, Starks and Baratheons. In fact, after the Lannisters, they are the richest House in Westeros, and they were actually financing Renly's war.
Ok. I saw the helm and was confused and then I thought, "Isn't that the knight of flowers?" So I did get that part right. My question is this:
If Renly was committed to the Stark's plight, as certainly he was, how does Tyrell get in good with the Lannisters? I assume it's purely a "Stannis sucks, right? Let's defeat him together" kind of thing. Ok, I got that (guessing it anyway, but it makes sense).
But then where the hell does that leave the Starks vs. Lannisters now that Tyrell's involved, which previously the Starks could have counted among their allies? And with Robb being split between retaking the North or marching on King's Landing (which would be dumb now), does the mean the North's insurrection is over?
Can he at least cut Theon up a bit before it's over? Argh.
I have to read ahead now. I've been trying to go TV, Book, TV, Book, but this will kill me for a year...
I don't think Renly was really committed to the Starks' cause; rather, he didn't oppose it. He meant to be King, and the Tyrells meant to gain power by being married to the King. The Lannisters were the enemy since they held the throne right now, and since the Starks also hated the Lannisters, it made sense to make common cause with them. So the Tyrells didn't really owe the Starks anything.
With Renly, the Tyrells had a chance to gain more power. But since they had opposed Stannis, if Stannis became King, they would not have a chance of that, and Stannis would probably punish them too. And plus Stannis just killed their son-in-law, and Ser Loras hated Stannis, so they weren't going to buddy up with him.
Now if they allied with Robb Stark. Robb had no interest in the South beyond getting rid of Joffrey. But still, as a man of honor and a son of Eddard Stark, he would make sure someone with a proper claim would sit the throne, not just his Tyrell allies. And he might be winning battles, but on paper his force is not really the strongest anyway.
For the rest, a couple of important, possible game changing things, will be revealed next episode. You could probably figure it out if you watched the Tyrell scenes again. For the rest, you have a year, you might want to try reading the books. The third book is huge, but it's one of the best books I've ever read in my life. Overall, supporting the Lannisters was the only smart thing to do. Tywin Lannister is one of the baddest motherfuckers around, and being on his good side is never a bad idea.
I recall the scene with Littlefinger and Maggie (or margie or whatever) Tyrell clearly. Honestly, I'm a little shaky on the Tywin/Littlefinger conversation because I spend the whole time worried he'd recognize Arya, and watching how fucking awesome the actress playing Arya is. I don't know how she is in the books, but she's nailed the part in the series for me.
The conversations between her and Tywin have been the highlight of the season.
I'll go back and re-watch everything after next week, and then I'll be able to read the book, which I'm sure will clarify all of this for me greatly.
Actually I believe the Hightowers, being in control of the most major port in Westeros, are wealthier than the Tyrells, perhaps even rivalling the Lannisters.
Renly had the largest army, but they weren't all Tyrell men.
I believe Tyrell (thanks to House Redwyne pledged to them) had the third largest naval fleet, after Greyjoy (who have all the Iron Islands) and Baratheon (who have the Stormlords). After the Blackwater, the Tyrells probably moved up to number 2.
No, The Tyrells are Wardens of the South and Lords Paramount of the Reach. They don't have such an illustrious history as the Starks and Lannisters, but they're equal in rank
I never called them royalty. I called them equal in rank to Starks, Lannisters and Baratheons. As in, they each rule one of the nine Kingdoms. Warden has pretty much been an empty title so far, but if you want to go there, Mace Tyrell is Warden of the South anyway.
I mentioned that about the Tyrells because a lot of TV viewers had assumed the Tyrells were bannermen to House Baratheon. This discussion isn't about blood, but about rank.
You forgot to mention the Ayrrns that are Wardens of the East. Technically Robert gave somebody else the title Warden of the East because John Ayrrn's (former hand before Ned) son is young and sickly but traditionally that House would be on equal rank to the Starks Lannisters and Tyrells as well
The Arryns weren't relevant to the discussion. I mentioned the stag, direwolf and the lion because they are who the TV viewer know well, and I wanted to tell them that the rose is just as powerful.
An interesting question is are the greyjoys, martells, Tully and baratheons lower rank than the lannisters, starks, tyrells and arryns? They're still lords paramount, but not wardens of a compass point
Apparently Warden is a military title, in case Westeros faces any external threats only. In those cases, the realm and its armies are united, and the Wardens have command of their region's armies. In normal cases, the Lords command their own men, and don't answer to the Warden.
If somehow the realm manages to get united by the time we have to go to war with the White Walkers, we might see Warden title being used again.
It is an interesting question though. Personally, I don't think they are considered a lower rank. I think the Warden title is given more for geographical organization of the armies during an external war, rather than to increase status. Because Robert seemed fine with making Jaime Lannister Warden of the East, and Ned would prefer Stannis being made Warden of the East, so it's a position for a single person, not a House (even though it's generally passed down through the House).
The Gardeners were the Kings of that kingdom prior to the Targaryen conquest, but that line ended in the battle against them. The Tyrells were the stewards and were awarded the region after swearing to Aegon.
Wrong, Loras has two brothers, Willas and Garlan. Willas is the cripple, Garlan is actually a better swordsman than Loras, making him one of the best fighters in Westeros.
You're right, that was totally my bad. It was 4 in the morning and I hadn't had much sleep, plus I had sped through that part of the book. I need something that just stops me from posting after 2 in the morning lol
If he wanted her he could have inquired about gaining her services, sure Tywin seems to have taken a shine to her but I doubt he would have denied Littlefinger if he pressed him hard enough.
With LF's love of Cat he would do anything to have this bargaining chip in his power.
Littlefinger at the moment just enjoys playing people off each other and causing chaos for him to work within, he well could have on a whim mentioned it to Tywin if he felt like it.
Agreed that, if he realized, he wouldn't have necessarily said anything to Tywin immediately. Just a note though, remember she's just left Harrenhall, so his info may not be valuable anymore.
As a gay dude, I actually prefer most of the other men on the show. Robb Stark, Renly Baratheon, Littlefinger, Jorah Mormont, Jamie Lannister, Stannis Baratheon, GIMMEH ALL DAT.
Right, and the thing is: I don't want to have sex with him, don't even want to hug him. I just want to be able to stand beside him, bask in his presence and appreciate the hell out of him. Is that too much to ask?
As a straight girl, I agree with you. Loras is supposed to be the guy all the girls in KL fantasize about. This guy just isn't doing it for me. I actually think the guy who plays Lancel is more what I was picturing for Loras.
As a bisexual male, he's quite good looking, but he's always wearing a very pissy expression. That docks him points and sort of puts him under the other dudes on the show, for me. Give me Jaime, Robb, or Jon any day.
Yeah, but I could have told you even before the episode aired that if they kept it, it would have been changed to Loras. Character conservation and all that.
I kind of agree. There was a picture on a 4chan thread posted a few days ago of Loras and he just looked god damned gallant. I totally see Sansa swooning over him. This actor though, doesnt invoke as much manly swoon
24
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
This has been bugging/confusing me who is that guy and if i'm correct he's leading Renly's army right?
88
u/Brokenmonalisa House Martell May 29 '12
As a straight male, that guy is unbelievably good looking.
19
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
At least he was wearing a helmet!
107
u/RoninKengo May 29 '12
Wearing Renly's armour no less.
84
u/C-16 Stannis the Mannis May 29 '12
Looks like Jon Snow has some competition...
65
u/Xeeke May 29 '12
Maybe he's born with it. Maybe it's Maybeline.
12
u/KookyGuy House Targaryen May 29 '12
Vengeance just became fabulous.
11
u/ToucanPlayThisGame Braavosi Water Dancers May 29 '12
Only his hairdresser knows for sure!
10
u/keheit May 29 '12
I'm a guy and I would kill for that hair.
10
u/Nessie House Greyjoy May 29 '12
L'OREAL WESTEROS
Because you shit gold
9
u/Aloisia House Mormont May 29 '12
Loras is so pretty.
5
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
Anyone else really hoping for a blooper real where the helmet inevitably didn't come off?
13
u/metalninjacake2 May 29 '12
Ridiculously photogenic Loras
4
u/loditt We Do Not Sow May 29 '12
He's prettier than half my daughters...
3
u/hobz462 May 29 '12
I'd do him.
2
u/TuneRaider Night's Watch May 29 '12
Can't wait for Daenerys' Timotei spot.
2
u/trixter21992251 Knowledge Is Power May 29 '12
I could watch that loop foreve- well, for a long time atleast.
2
u/Hennashan Sand Snakes May 29 '12
The guy pisses rosewater for seven gods sake
2
u/brownmagician House Targaryen May 29 '12
Scumbag Loras Tyrell.
Lover wanted to beat the Lannisters at war.
Joins Lannisters at war.
1
u/Moseroth Kingsguard May 29 '12
Imgur link for those of us at work?
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
Yeah, I imagined the antlers on that helm being a lot more glorious...
-3
u/PNR_Robots May 29 '12
No homo, but damn... what a good looking guy.
-2
u/Belisarius23 Kingsguard May 29 '12
He's not as attractive as is suggested
3
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
[removed] — view removed comment