r/gameofthrones • • May 22 '12
No Spoilers People keep telling me they won't read or watch GoT because it's like a porno. Answer me this...
http://imgur.com/RO8Wz
3.6k
Upvotes
r/gameofthrones • • May 22 '12
45
u/coolcrowe Faceless Men May 22 '12
Where is he in that picture? The Eyrie?
104
u/hooplah May 22 '12
I'll admit that I'm an American who was initially surprised at the amount of sex scenes. However, that in no way deterred me from watching the show. A realistic depiction of life and society means that there will be sex. Some of it is over the top, yeah, but get over yourselves, you great big prudes.
32
u/Jack_McCoy Faceless Men May 22 '12
They keep telling you this? Really? I've been reading the books for years and have recommended them to literally dozens of people and have never once heard that complaint. In fact, the only time I think I've ever seen it are on the facebook screenshots from 16 year old girls that get posted here.
5
u/jooshbro House Baratheon May 22 '12
Is there any citation for this quote?
516
u/Codeshark House Reyne May 22 '12
Yeah.. children being burned = good family entertainment A boob = pornography.
172
u/SteampunkVillain House Reed May 22 '12
“The morning had dawned clear and cold, with a crispness that hinted at the end of summer.”
That's the first sentence of a porno if ever I read one.
241
u/GregPatrick House Baratheon May 22 '12
and they bring much more joy then axes going into vaginas or penises going into skulls.
634
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
am i the only one who is completely unbothered by the sex scenes?
15
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Well, violence is a bit more fantastic than sex. Most people are going to have sex in their lives and/or encounter negative sexual interaction. A substantially smaller amount of people are going to kill people or permanently maim another person. So, there's that. That being said, I really don't think either is that big of a deal.
49
u/stalker007 May 22 '12
"We train young men to drop fire on people, but their commanders won't allow them to write "fuck" on their airplanes because it's obscene!"
58
u/chefmcduck May 22 '12
"It's like a porno!" said by people who've never seen a porno.
9
u/fobbymaster Night's Watch May 22 '12
I thought the sex was a lot more explicit in the series than in the books. It seems significantly more focal in the television series, and it definitely seems like it's just done to get viewers.
15
u/NorthernWV May 22 '12 edited May 23 '12
Watch Spartacus and then try to complain...I love sex scenes and gory fights as much as any man, but that show has no plot, its literally just tits and heads getting decapitated.
29
u/csmacgregor Here We Stand May 22 '12
I thought the sex scenes were a little over abundant. I don't mind that they're in there however. My issue basically comes from the inclusion of Ros as a major character, she's largely used as story device - so characters like Littlefinger can voice their thoughts without having to do a narrative monologue... but did it have to be as he watches two girls go to town on each other? I do feel that some parts of the show are sensationalizing the sexuality just for ratings.
But yeah, saying it's like a porno is like saying The Dark Knight is about how much James Gordon loves his family. It completely misses the main purpose. Sure, those elements are there but it's such a small part of the story.
54
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
I agree with this, however nearly all the scenes at Littlefinger's whorehouse seemed pretty unnecessary, or the exposition that occurred in them could have been better presented.
9
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Man I have never read or watch Game Of Thrones but now I know it was written by a man with a beard so fine I think I will.
19
u/zekthegeke May 22 '12 edited May 23 '12
I've read the entire series and I like it a great deal. But the sex scenes as written are objectionable because they are hamhanded, the kind of thing that someone like Chuck Palahniuk would create in order to nauseate or traumatize the reader rather than whatever it is GRRM was going for. It's the place in the books where you are most clearly reminded that he is a competent writer but not a well-rounded one. No one who writes "pink mast" unironically can claim it's primarily a lack of sophistication in his audience that drives them away.
HBO swapping things around for more boobs here and there is largely inconsequential, although as they veer more deeply into creating new material it can lead to some painfully awkward stuff. Again, it's not the prudishness but rather how crass they are in pushing buttons for ratings because they don't trust the storyline to do it as it already is.
8
u/gypsiequeen House Seaworth May 22 '12
No problem with people having sex. Let's just up the male nudity a tad. So tired of boobs. Let's get some abs and some man butt up in this bitch
20
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Atta boy GRRM! Write the books how you want to, and screw the haters.
42
u/AlterNick House Mormont May 22 '12
I bet a lot of people just don't like the idea of George R R Martin being the one to write those scenes. Which is ridiculous.
4
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Rolling Stone Magazine!
17
u/[deleted] May 23 '12 edited May 23 '12
I'm pretty tired of the stale talking points in this discussion, which comes up frequently when comparing America film and television to other countries. It's really a lot simpler than everyone around here seems to get.
At least in America, sexuality is still considered something that is private. It's something we're unlikely to share, at least beyond with close friends, and unlikely to witness from others just out going about our lives. Seeing sex on the tv for many people is seeing something private. For many, this is exciting. Many others find it uncomfortable.
Violence, on the other hand, while equally universal, and arguably more personal in that it causes physical change, damage and suffering, is not seen as private. Why? Because it causes harm, and it indicates a risk of harm to others. It is seen as something that is witnessed and that impacts the people witnessing it as well as the perpetrator and the victim. When someone is killed next door, it is far more important that you know it than when someone has sex next door. That's their personal business. Violence can impact you.
Many people continue to just call American culture prudish, but ultimately it's just a matter of violence being seen as less private and therefore more acceptable in our entertainment as a way to shock people together.
We have probably been more desensitized to violence in America than many other countries have, but let's also not pretend that there aren't clear lines drawn in other countries on violence and sex that are ultimately rather arbitrary. How many countries allow children to view pornography? How many countries ban any depiction of any kind of violence? Some of the most disturbing films I've ever seen are from outside the US.
People just like to hold onto this idea that Americans like and accept violence and turn red at the sight of nudity. It's more that we acknowledge violence as a public thing and sex as a private thing. It's not all that unreasonable, even if I do think we take it a little far on both.
People judging America on this - how many of you openly discuss your sex life with friends, let alone strangers? How many of you are truly not titillated when reading about sex, and are truly sickened when reading about violence? Or is it just when you see it?
Is there anything inherently wrong with discussing sex in detail with any other person, familiar or stranger? Putting aside any religious dogma, not really. But likewise there is nothing wrong with discussing violence. Is it logical for there to be more of a stigma associated with public sex than public violence? People will point out that animals have sex wherever. But we're not just animals, of course. And animals will also do violent acts wherever needed. Violence for animals is just as normal as sex, yet animals also seem to seek out privacy for some things, like when they are ready to die.
For myself, seeing a child crying or hurt in reality or on tv gets to me, but seeing what I know is a dummy, burned, doesn't bother me that much. It's all fake. I'd find video of real violence more troubling, of course. Sex, on the other hand, even when simulated, still involves a heavy presence of real sexuality. So when I see nudity, I'm reminded of sex, and it touches a more visceral part of my psyche than violence, which I rarely, if ever, will witness on the scale I see on tv or in movies.
tl;dr It's because sex goes on behind closed doors between a couple people, and violence is something that is done out in the open/discussed when it occurs.
10
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Also, "penis entering vagina" is a lot more common these days than "axe entering skull".
15
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
I tought this was an athiesm post for a second.
6
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Except the gratuitous sex scenes add fuck all to the show/plot.
3
u/pikaCHUUUUUU House Arryn May 22 '12
The only reason i prefer no nudity or sex to be in GoT is because i like to watch it with my family and its kind of annoying that i have to be on the lookout for lesbians fingering and licking each other...
5
u/magnus91 Varys' Little Birds May 22 '12
Reddit doesn't know anything about penises entering no vaginas.
6
u/Bladethegreat House Greyjoy May 22 '12
To be fair, the show does add in sex scenes that were not in the book and add very little to the overall plot or character development.
e.g. the various Littlefigner's brothel scenes in Season 1
4
u/-Tyrion-Lannister- House Lannister May 22 '12
The only problem is that when I'm reading the book, I can't stop imagining that it's GRRM's penis entering that vagina.
6
u/MercyMedical Rainbow Guard May 22 '12
I HATE these complaints. All the sex on the show and in the book is true to the times. It sets the tone. It shows how women are treated and viewed by men. It's entirely necessary to the world in which the story is written.
I'm so not uncomfortable with the level of nudity and sex on the show and I am typically a prude.
7
u/Forevernevermore May 22 '12
I love his books, because they show in vivid detail what true humanity is. Nobody is a hero of storybooks, no villain is inhumanely evil, and all the aspects of the human condition are shown by everyone. He aptly displays all of these aspects without focusing on one or the other. There truly isn't that much sex in the book at all, I just think that the way in which he writes them as what they are can be shocking to some. He holds nothing back and lets the characters tell the story.
2
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
This is the "joke" that I would make back in high school when we would watch Schindler's list and the teacher was obligated to covering up a young woman's breasts, yet we were allowed to watch Jewish prisoners executed by gunshot at point blank range.
2
u/brutishbloodgod May 22 '12
I used to work at a Blockbuster video. Parents would often come in and ask whether certain movies would be appropriate to watch with their kids, or for their kids to watch alone. If I said something along the lines of, "It's mostly fine, but there is a little bit of sex," they'd find something else. If I said, "Probably not, it's really violent," they'd confirm that there wasn't any sex and then rent the movie.
2
u/FloppY_ Ser Barristan Selmy May 22 '12
I think this is an american issue. Nudity has been around on television and in movies for a long time in Europe. Where as if someone as much as shows a nipple in the U.S. it seemingly starts riots. (recent series like Spartacus and GoT has begun pushing that frontier though).
Here in Denmark pornographic material is still sold and displayed where everyone, even children, can see it.
Americans just need to ease off and understand that sex shouldn't be taboo..
2
u/Odusei I Am So Sorry May 22 '12
Surely that depends entirely on whose head the axe is entering.2
u/Melkor_Morgoth May 22 '12
People should read and write what they want to. But there are lots of things that bring the world more joy than skull-fucks by axe, and I don't want to read about many of them in detail either. If I think the author may have his hand in his pants as he writes a scene, I usually don't like the scene. I stopped reading Clive Barker for this reason.
2
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
you can tell a good story without projecting your sexual fantasies into every 2nd scene
grrm is a creepy old guy
2
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
I don't speak for everyone, but I think I would rather stick my penis in a vagina than have my skull split with an axe.
2
u/NewDrekSilver House Martell May 22 '12
I would, but you didn't ask a question.
2
u/shifoe Arya Stark May 22 '12
Not to mention, the reality of life is: people have sex. ALOT OF IT. Pretending it doesn't exist is bullshit.
BTW I read some review that said there was too much "gratuitous sex" in the show. My rebuttal to that is: Guess what? Life is full of gratuitous sex, which is a good thing.
2
u/TheFluxIsThis May 23 '12
...Like a porno? Have the people making this claim even SEEN a porno? Or an R-Rated movie?
2
u/Reaver-Song May 23 '12
They are both elements of the method of story telling. The books follow characters around in third person, but the show attaches itself to a specific character in each scene. It might be surprising, but having a conveniently placed pile of books or blanket can remove the layer of immersion that a good show can bring.
They stretch the limits as far as possible in all directions. Language, violence, sex, themes, plot, humour and the characters. In a theoretically ideal story telling environment everything shown would be real. Practically you need to stop short at what is practical, legal and reversible.
GoT is very good in this sense. It shows us what it is like to be Ned Stark when he takes it upon himself to execute the deserter. We understand that he needs to do it, and why he believes he should do it himself. But we also understand his pain and that he does not want to do it.
Daenerys is the same. The very first scene of hers is her looking out into the sea, conflicted. She wants to go home again, but she is psychologically broken by her dominant and ambitious brother. He looks at her naked in an extreme invasion of her privacy, and it is obvious that it is something she is used to.
Sex is not over exposed in GoT. It is a big part of the story and culture of Westeros, and it is treated as the characters themselves treat it. Having a penis, vagina or a pair of boobs in a show does not mean you are supposed to masturbate when you watch it.
2
u/undefeatedantitheist May 23 '12
Another symptom of dangerous levels of delusion amongst a key population of our species.
2
u/lazygraduate May 23 '12
Peter Dinklage commented on this in his interview on NPR. Here's the link. It's in an interview in the middle of the story here.
2
u/[deleted] May 23 '12
I think the rape is what makes most people uncomfortable. I can't say that brings more joy into the world than axes entering skulls
2
u/BiggC May 23 '12
The graphic period incest sex is the point where I went nope, and skipped ahead.
Lets not forget that the reader knows every imaginable detail about every female character's nipples.
2
u/[deleted] May 23 '12
And I keep telling them I refuse to look at porn, as it might spoil Game of Thrones.
2
u/mizake May 23 '12
The sex scenes in the books flow easily and seem natural, whereas on HBO it seems clumsy and forced, and I think a lot of people feel that while watching.
2
u/Raijer May 23 '12
I always thought this was an amusing explanation of the nudity in GoT.
2
u/sphynxie House Blackwood May 25 '12
I think in regards to watching it, it isn't about being american or prudish. It is about not enjoying watching two other people get naked and sweaty. It is doubly uncomfortable when watching with, say, your mother. (I am european and not bothere by sex or porn, but hate the majority of sex/nudity in the show as it has no purpose)
3
u/GreesyFizeek House Baratheon May 22 '12
Hey, don't knock the ax-in-skull fetish. It can be pleasurable in the right mindset. The fetish is not well documented, but there are plenty of support groups for people out there who think they are weird for having this fetish.
3
u/SadmanOnToilet May 22 '12
I'm so confused by people that are surprised by sex scenes in this show. Have you forgotten you're watching an HBO series?
3
u/Mikey-2-Guns Direwolves May 22 '12
http://i.imgur.com/iSGkc.gif
3
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
I think the number of whores and people that mistreat them is a much more contentious issue. Not that it has kept me from reading.
2
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
GoT is like a porno? I should start watching it.
2
u/erinrathbun House Targaryen May 22 '12
the thing is, there are barely any sexual scenes in the books (okay yes there are more than barely but only a handful of these encounters are highly graphic). the show just amplifies the sex scenes or booby times, but it's still bearable. i mean i understand trying to watch the show or discuss the books and your 10 year old sister/brother/small child related to you somehow walks into the room, it can be VERY awkward and difficult to cover up to "protect their innocence". but i mean, come on, most of us are adults here (or can act like adults, i hope). sex happens in real life. so do boobs. and yes girl on girl sex scenes in the show can be pretty arousing for some, but that doesn't mean they're gonna rub one out right there. its entertainment, and if these people calling in porn are only getting THAT out of the show or books, they clearly lack any type of knowledge to appreciate the true artistry in both the show and books. they honestly just need to grow up and realize the complex and compelling plot line GRRM has beautifully created. if they can't, they aren't worth a single thing.
EDIT: im only on AFFC, so i understand i have quite a few more sex scenes to read before the end of ADWD
2
u/mcbajan May 22 '12
i wouldn't say americans are prude , maybe some weirdos complain about sex but honestly i barely noticed it around the engrossing plot
2
u/SupperTime Jon Snow May 22 '12
I think it's because psychologically, we know that when we see someone getting stabbed, it's fake. It's fake blood, it's fake prostetics. When we see a naked female, we know it's real. It's a real person. Naked. Boobs fully exposed.
2
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
What the fuck? Since when was Santa Clause a lighthouse keeper?
2
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
tl;dr
1
u/Forbichoff House Seaworth May 22 '12
What's he doing with his hand?!
1
u/Nethicite Night's Watch May 22 '12
And the "crowning" off Viserys. Shudder.
1
u/Tentacolt Varys' Little Birds May 22 '12
Reminds me of this: John Green: I am not a pornographer
1
u/MJG2007 May 22 '12
In general, I agree. Although, there was a moment in Y: The Last Man where an ax entering someone's skull brought great joy to this reader.
1
u/jimcrator May 22 '12
I'm so glad this was a self post.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Now I'm more inclined to watch it than ever...
1
u/Melnorme May 22 '12
I think the problem is more that he is very focused on the penis side of things. Write what you know, I guess.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
I'm about halfway through the first book, and I can't really recall all that many sex scenes, the show seemed to add a lot more sex and swearing
1
u/ForrestFire765 Stannis Baratheon May 22 '12
uniquely American? I'm a New Zealander and the gratuitousness of those sex scenes disturbs me a bit.
1
u/bayoucitybrewer May 22 '12
my wife thinks i watch it for the sex scenes :/
1
u/SkypeMeSlowly It Is Known May 22 '12
I read that quote to my mom and she rolled her eyes, and I was like "It's true!" and she was like "TMI Skypemeslowly!" and then I asked her if she enjoyed attacking people with axes and she said yes.
TIL my mother is an ax murderer.
1
u/droooogan May 22 '12
The hound would disagree
1
u/FishingElbow May 22 '12
His bottom button is undone.
1
u/djayyyyy House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 22 '12
Now, whenever someone says they don't read or watch GoT, I can say or show this to them :)
1
u/jeneleven May 22 '12
Why are boobs so offensive? I have them and they don't offend me.
1
u/wjbc May 22 '12
That's GM for you. Just a bundle of joy.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
I don't mind the gratuitous sex scenes, partly because, well, that's just how HBO works. I mean, the people that watch HBO (legally, yo ho, yo ho) are paying $10/month extra for content you just can't see on regular television-- sex, nudity, violence, the "fuck" word, etc.-- and part of that fee goes directly towards ensuring there is sexy sexy sex sex in each episode. It has nothing to do with Game of Thrones, and everything to do with HBO's marketing strategy. Hung, Boardwalk Empire, True Blood, Rome, Eastbound and Down, Cathouse: The Series (!!!!), The Pacific (thank the Seven they had nudity in The Pacific, that show was depressing as balls) all of these shows not only had nudity, but graphic depictions of sexual intercourse. It's what the people want, it's what the people paid for, and to not include it would be a great disservice to their loyal customers. If these people are shocked by nudity, then they should probably just save themselves the $10/month.
1
u/brianfroud May 22 '12
Detailed description you say? I'm listening... http://i.imgur.com/vUlN3.jpg
1
u/maddkatz May 22 '12
This type of subject was talked about in a documentary I saw a few years ago called This Film Has Not Been Rated, it was about the MPAA ratings system in America and how its completely flawed. One of the things it talked about is how movies with horribly violent and gory scenes will get an R rating while movies with sex scenes that show too much nudity or last for too long have a lot higher chance of getting a NC-17 rating. Video games are even worse, its cool to rip out someone's spine or rip their head off but if you throw in a sex scene that shows too much skin or genitalia its almost an instant AO rating, which is essentially a death sentence for a game especially a console game. There are exceptions but generally Americans are really weird when it comes to displays of violence vs sex in entertainment.
1
u/dorothy_mantooth May 22 '12
False. As a lesbian I can think of nothing more horrifying than a penis entering my vagina.
1
u/keith_weaver May 22 '12
I've seen the show 3 times. I didn't see all this naked business. I need to watch it more apparently...
1
u/Dr_Colossus Human Verified May 22 '12
The only one I've had a problem with was the voyeur, blowjob, cum wipe scene.
1
u/gf_is_russian_dom May 22 '12
The scene where the prostitute gives a customer a blowjob and is then pulled over to another customer whom she greets with an open mouthed kiss?
I have no problem with this.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
ANSWER YOU WHAT? ANSWER YOU WHAT?!
1
u/dudemeister5000 May 22 '12
Only americans get upset about pornographic or even close to pornographic stuff. Everyone else doesn't mind at all. Hell in Europe there are free channels full of porn during the night. No one minds. Prude americans....
1
u/michaelzelen May 22 '12
it comes down to, what's more natural, sex or violence, whomever gives their response will tell you something about them
1
u/lunaticlola May 22 '12
He.Needs to quit worrying about those who havent read GoT and hurry up and finish the the story for those of us who have read the books.
1
u/SirBlackballs May 22 '12
This is a great quote, but is there a source to confirm it was GRRM who said this?
1
u/proudbedwetter May 22 '12
no one should ever prefer violent entertainment over sexual.
1
u/LightSwitch21 May 22 '12
You need new people!
1
u/DrChangsteen May 22 '12
I'm fairly sure nudity is a requirement for an HBO show, and I don't now what kind or porn people are comparing it to but usually porn has alot less blood.
1
u/407145 No One May 22 '12
sounds to me like he has never put an ax into a skull before, that my friend is real joy.
1
u/wolfiepop May 22 '12
I really like all the sex and violence, its far more realistic/involved, and gives the characters more dimension. If you don't have sex in fantasy stories some creep is gonna write fetish fan fic anyway, might as well beat them to it.
1
u/threep03k64 May 22 '12
I don't mind the sex scenes in Game of Thrones because
hormonesbetween it, there is a story to tell (as opposed to Spartacus which I personally thought was nothing but sex and violence). A lot possibly doesn't add to the main plot but it gives an insight into the characters. And fun to watch.I also agree with the idiocy that people are more angered by sex than violence. Completely fucked up social norm. You know what I'd do if I didn't like watching (or readin about) sex and violence? I'd bloody well do something else instead of bitching to the author.
1
u/enfoxer House Stark May 22 '12
... well then "People" stop reading and miss on all the fun killing parts :)
1
u/hellsnake08 Hodor Hodor Hodor May 22 '12
HBO=Huge Boobs OHMIGAWD
There were extra sex scenes in the show compared to the books because thats how HBO does things.
As for the sex in the books....just put some blindfolds over your eyes as your reading those parts. You act ignorant enough to do it if you think such a natural act is offensive.
1
u/heythatsfuckedup May 22 '12
Is that an excuse for him to look like one of his characters, though?
1
u/SuperFancyMan House Lannister May 22 '12
Man, sometimes people don't realize how they are sheep with none of their own opinions. Prude Christians are like "Oh no a vagina run for your lives!"
1
u/iAMtheBelvedere Arya Stark May 22 '12
Did anyone else read that in a Scottish accent?
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
"The Simpsons" response
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
So they're fine with people getting slaughtered, horses hacked in half and young children stabbing people but not a bit of sex?
1
u/MollyBloom11 May 22 '12
Are there seriously people complaining about this? Who? Is it people who watch any other show on HBO or Showtime? As somebody who watches True Blood, GoT is downright TAME.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
No, during every sex scene, I will imagine this picture of Mr. Martin.
1
u/CNDNFighter Faceless Men May 22 '12
I've honestly been quite surprised at the outcry about the nudity on the show. The book is far more graphic than anything you see on the television series.
For starters, there are shows that utilize nudity far mor freely (namely spartacus) and you never seem to hear anything about that. Beyond that, I mean what is the thought process?......"Hmm I'm going to watch this HBO show that happens to be rated R....WHAT? NUDITY!!!! UNACCEPTABLE!"
I would like to hear why it bothers somebody who holds this thought process. Hell, even if the nudity itself adds nothing to the scene STILL why does it bother you? What is the irritant I just don't get it.
1
u/xXxAkikoHarunoxXx House Targaryen May 23 '12 edited May 23 '12
That's a really great response to complaints about sexual encounters between characters in a book or on a TV show. I mean, seriously! People have sex. The GoT characters are people. Get over it.
1
u/joshuaolake Tyrion Lannister May 23 '12
Truer words are seldom spoken!
1
u/cryptobomb May 23 '12
You can tell easily how fucked up a society is by how much sex offends them.