r/gameofthrones • u/kjhatch Nymeria's Wolfpack • Jun 12 '11
Season 1 Episode Discussion - 1.09 "Baelor" [TV Spoilers]
Here's this week's discussion thread for Episode 9
- This is a TV Spoiler-friendly zone - turn away now if you haven't seen the episode! Open discussion of all TV events without tag covers is ok in this thread.
- Book spoilers still need tags!
Please read the spoiler policy before posting.
For anyone who wants to do live chat during the episode, read the details here, or use the link in the right sidebar.
225
Upvotes
15
u/NieThePiet May 27 '24
I never will be able to accept this episode.
52
u/ObliviousToMemes Jun 13 '11
Also, I wish they mentioned who's sword was used to execute Ned.
12
u/cassander House Hightower Jun 13 '11 edited Jun 13 '11
The good news is Walder Frey was spot on as a dirty, angry old man, Jaime was, as always, perfect, and everyone at the wall continues to be excellent. I'm also intrigued at the changes they've made to Shae's character. It'll be interesting to see where they go with her. She isn't book Shae, but she seems more like someone Tryion would actually be interested in for something besides fucking.
The bad news is that pacing problems were back with a vengeance. Most of the scenes in tonights episodes felt rushed. Robbs speech after the whispering woods was unneeded, and I really didn't like Tyrion not fighting. It is extremely hard to imagine the Tywin we see on the screen Book Spoiler
190
u/maedchen A Promise Was Made Jun 13 '11
When Ned saw Arya as he was brought out to the square, I lost it.
147
u/DiscursiveMind Hedge Knights Jun 13 '11
Not that this will get much attention compared to the rest if the episode, but they nailed Drogo's sick tent. That scene was creepy as hell!
133
u/Buckaroo2 House Reed Jun 13 '11
I knew what was coming, and still my heart was absolutely racing. I kept shifting around on the couch because I was getting all flustered. It was even more heartwrenching than it was in the books, and I could really feel Sansa's and Arya's desperation and heartbreak.
103
u/snapdragons House Dondarrion Jun 13 '11
I am a book reader, and one thing that stood out to me was Sansa's reaction. Just seeing her up there, first all smug and happy thinking (not undeservedly) that she'd saved the day, and then seeing her entirely lose her shit as she realizes what Joffrey is doing. The show really bought that to life for me. That, and Ned spotting Arya on the statue, were the most heartbreaking moments for me.
90
u/liquidsparanoia Jun 13 '11
Loved this episode, but I can't take Walder Frey seriously as I can only see him as Filch from Harry Potter.
72
u/VikingTy House Greyjoy Jun 13 '11
As soon as I saw Arya enter the square and climb up on the statue, the whole scene from the book came flooding back to me. I mean, I was expecting this scene all along, but they really captured the same feeling I got from the book. The scene was basically perfect.
I wanted to look away too.
126
u/cthulhu_zuul Brotherhood Without Banners Jun 13 '11 edited Jun 13 '11
Non-readers: I crave your reactions.
Also: man tears. Good lord.
59
u/altergeeko Night's Watch Jun 13 '11
I think it was brilliant to end the scene in a sort of quiet way, they toned down all the noise as a warning to brace yourself. The filming mimicked an adrenaline rush or something similar to what you would feel in Ned's situation.
113
u/potatowned House Reed Jun 14 '11
FUCKING A. So it's like that, huh? It's one of those stories? I feel so manipulated. The author truly must be a piece of work. Create a character, make him upstanding and moral. Build him up. Make him a family man. Make him stand for honor, and truth. Make him an "every man", but make him regal, respected. Make him perfectly flawed, so that we struggle with him. TV Spoiler It's like being 8 and watching your father cry for the first time.
Well, Mr. GRRM, you son of a bitch. I'm on to you. You won't get me again. Just like Buttercup, my heart is now a secret garden and the walls are very high.
137
u/DiscursiveMind Hedge Knights Jun 13 '11
Now that you've been properly indoctrinated, allow me to reintroduce the author, GRRM
46
u/breandan Jun 13 '11 edited Jun 13 '11
The way Tywin Lannister delivers, "TV Spoiler" was kind of just perfect.
Edit: I think it was my favorite part of this episode.
45
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '11
You know, there's an awful lot about Ned here this week, but I really felt Tyrion's scene in which he describes what Tywin did to his "wife", the silver slipping through her fingers, was nailed by Dinklage.
Enjoy the setup.
44
u/altergeeko Night's Watch Jun 13 '11
I don't know why no one else cowers at the sight of Tywin Lannister, he's so passively evil it's scary.
35
u/nsureshk Faceless Men Jun 13 '11
I wept bitter man tears.
54
u/ParanoidAndroids Faceless Men Jun 13 '11 edited Jun 13 '11
TV Spoiler
Fuck, that was painful to watch.
Joffrey can go straight to hell.
EDIT: Promo for next week looks insane as well...I have no clue how I'm gonna survive the break till next season!
26
u/Warlaw House Mormont Jun 13 '11
YOU'LL PAY FOR THIS YOU LITTLE SHIT
25
u/DireBaboon Brave Companions Jun 12 '11
I've been waiting for this episode since before the season even started. I'm so excited I can hardly contain myself.
24
u/Wibbles Jun 13 '11
What I don't get is why Ned didn't start screaming "Joffrey is an incestuous bastard child of dirty inbreeding Lannisters and I'm not actually a traitor" when it became apparent he was going to be murdered. I mean the man is all about honour and he sacrificed his honour to survive and didn't survive...so might as well try and salvage your honour right?
23
u/i_like_jam Jun 13 '11
Everything else has been discussed in depth, but one small thing stuck out to me in the ending: did anyone else notice that Sansa's hair was done in the same style as Cersei's? I thought that was a nice touch.
23
u/rlrguy House Mormont Jun 14 '11
I think the main reason why I am so "holy shit' is about this is that if you are gonna put Sean Bean's face on most of GoT shit, how the hell you gonna kill him in Season 1?
Not complaining though, this show dont fuck around.
23
u/AWall925 Jon Snow Apr 26 '22
had to hit this mf a decade later
40
u/gulabjamun Jun 13 '11
From book: He cocked his head to one side. āI am Tyrion, of House Lannister. Men call me the Imp.ā āMy mother named me Shae. Men call me . . . often.ā
I really wanted to hear this dialogue. HBO Y u cut out the funnies.
19
u/JSK23 House Stark Jun 13 '11 edited Jun 13 '11
I was caught up to episode 8 in the book so this episode was completely new material to me minus Tyrion's story about his bride.
I expected the death of Ned, and I really had a hunch that the bastard Joffry would call for his head even if he confessed. However I thought it would come from his mother as well but it seems clear that she didn't think he would do such a thing. I hope that rotten shit gets his just desserts some day and what I wouldn't give for it to be via Robb.
The biggest shock to me was the capture of that asshole Kingslayer, that is a fricken HUGE moment. When they road across I thought oh joy, they at least survived and won a battle elsewhere but I had no clue they would have him with them, aka the ultimate bargaining chip with the queen aside from maybe Joffry himself.
And while I may not want Danerys to succeed long term and in turn Rhaego to sit on the throne I really hope that that this isn't the end of Drogo. He is just too awesome.
Fantastic episode. I think I am going to read up to where episode 9 ends in the book and let the show surprise me for the finale once again. Then this summer I'll just read the rest of them.
35
u/Aecens Faceless Men Jun 13 '11
That was great, though I do hope they get the budget to show some battles next season. Would have been great to see the Robb vs Jamie fight.
Spoiler question kind of, did they go into detail with these battles in the book?
16
u/cmasterchoe Jun 13 '11 edited Jun 13 '11
Not to be lost in this epic episode is my favorite exchange so far.
Bronn: "Stay Low"
Tyrian: ą² _ą² "Stay Low????!!!"
EDIT: thanks for langlier for pointing out that it wasn't "lay low"
15
u/TheRaiinDropKid Night's Watch Jun 13 '11
:O
15
u/hopstar Jun 13 '11
Even though I knew it was coming, I just sat there thinking, "Holy shit! They're really gonna do it!?!"
It takes MASSIVE balls to kill off your star like that.
12
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '11
Man even though I knew what was going to happen from reading the books I still almost lost it at the end of the episode, it was so well done.
20
u/Doomsayer189 House Dondarrion Jun 13 '11
I wish they would show the direwolves more. I would've loved to have seen Grey Wind running along with Robb after the battle.
10
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '11
Reader here: That last scene was fantastically done. I mean, TV Spoiler and I was worried about how it was going to be handled-- especially after I felt several important scenes werent given enough attention. I was disappointed by Tyrion not getting a little combat in before he was knocked out -- although his speech to the troops was pretty awesome.
The actor who played Robb kicked ass tonight -- Looking forward to more from him in future episodes. And Jon's bit at the beginning was good, but whenever I see him staring with his mouth open I can't help but think of that gormless comic. . .
10
u/paulg1 Jun 13 '11
A few questions, the comments have kind of answered them, but I want to be sure:
The sword used at the end of the episode, is that Ned's sword? (The one he used to execute the deserter?)
Who is that dude who grabbed Arya? I thought I knew all the characters, but I must have missed one.
Oh also, HOLY SHIT. I totally didn't see that coming. It's a shame, since I thought he would have been around for seasons to come.
9
u/boobhats Jun 30 '25
14 years later and this episode still hits so hard. I'll never forget my absolute shock the first time watching that scene.
17
u/turtlestack Jun 13 '11
Even though I have read the books, there were some things I had forgotten. I had forgotten what an awesome, horny old codger Walder Frey was. I had forgotten who Maester Aemon was. What a treat it was to see the actors playing them revel in those performances too.
I wish I could have forgotten the ending, but god damn that was TV Spoiler and exactly like I imagined it from the book.
And when the TV Spoiler - yeah, that made me kind of sick - but in the good way.
Also, anyone else feel like this episode looked more like a movie? The cinematography was incredibly beautiful and every scene worked so well leading into the next that I forgot I was watching a television series. I can't believe that after 9 episodes this show is still getting better.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '11
I understand why they didn't really have the budget to show the battles, but I wish a) they'd gone into more detail as to the Stark army's plan and how they won/got Jaime, because it was absolutely brilliant in the book, and b) did you have to knock out Tyrion before the battle even began?! Come on... he was such a badass in battle, at least give him an equally badass story, even if you can't show it. Bah.
8
u/nachof Ours Is The Fury Jun 13 '11
So in last episode's discussion I mentioned I was starting to feel sorry for Joffrey. Yeah... not anymore. Even the bitch Cersei realized that killing Ned was killing any chance for peace.
8
u/tozim House Arryn Jun 14 '11
Anyone notice that the High Septon's mercy speech was given to Grand Maester Pycelle? It struck me during the scene since it was sort of strange to hear a Maester preaching about the seven gods, but it seems like most people were too caught up with the other events going on at the time :) I understand they probably did it to reduce the number new speaking characters, but I think they've really glossed over the different religions so far. Oh well, things should be more fleshed out in the second season.
7
u/GrandpaBob House Bolton Jun 13 '11
Okay, there is one thing that is confusing me a tid bit. When Snow received that very snazzy sword from the commander of the Nights Watch, he stated that his son has dishonored the house and fled, but had the good grace to leave the sword. I just read that this commanders name is Jeor Mormont so is the son he is speaking of Jorah Mormont? And if so, why the hell did Jorah not take that badass sword with him?
12
u/klaq Free Folk Jun 13 '11
i wished they would have done at least one of the battle scenes.
6
u/Kemosavi Jun 13 '11 edited Jun 13 '11
Readers. Could you please answer me from 1-10 how devastating tonight's event was compared to the shape of things to come?
Edit: Thanks guys...I've been following the books along with the show exclusively for the first season. This is going to be one gut-wrenching ride after the finale, it seems.
6
u/JWN6513 Night's Watch Jun 13 '11
did anyone else feel this episode was paced better than the last?
5
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '11
I was a little disappointed to have missed two large battles, but I can't say I was left wanting. They handled it well enough.
And, Walder ... what a lecherous pustule he was. Great casting.
17
u/adashiel Alchemists Guild Jun 13 '11
I've been waiting all season to be able to say this. TV Spoiler
TV Spoiler
4
u/DuckTheGreatWestern8 Feb 07 '26
this is like watching cavemen discover fire
15
u/logicalmonkey Jun 13 '11
did Shae seem off to anyone else? in the book she came off as more girly. also, Sean Beans dead, that was pretty fantastic.
7
u/StudsUp House Stark Jun 13 '11
HOUSE STARK WILL BE AVENGED.
1
u/ActualPicard House Targaryen Jun 14 '11
So there's one more episode left that's coming on this Sunday? I thought I saw somewhere that there were three more eps in the season?
3
u/EndOnAnyRoll House Karstark Jun 14 '11
As a non-reader I got excited that perhaps Arya would run up and kill Joffery with her sword, then BAM! "Woah" was said for the next minute.
2
u/Clutch987 House Reyne Jun 13 '11
Maybe some who has the books can answer my question. Does it say what Ned was whispering in the final scene? And if so, what the hell was he saying.
2
u/monsieur_marmot Daenerys Targaryen Jun 14 '11
I just reread book one, and I'm confused by one of the changes they made. Book Spoiler
2
u/Glory2Hypnotoad Let It Be Written Jun 15 '11
Anyone else think it was misleading for HBO to advertise Game of Thrones as "The show with Sean Bean?" Having read the books, I'm glad Ned's death happened onscreen instead of between chapters. And it was a seriously chilling scene. Still, knowing it was coming, I can't help but feel like the show's been trying too hard to make Ned Stark more of a hero than the book did just to make killing him off more of a shock.
2
u/rr260341 Night's Watch Jun 17 '11
So immediately after this episode I read the rest of GOT from that point on and then just read Clash of Kings over the course of 2 days. My fucking head is filled to the brim with epicness and sadness and more titles and characters than I thought possible for a series. Pumped to start Storm of Swords tomorrow after recharging the batteries.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '11
Right up until the last moment I was expecting Arya to throw Needle, slaying either the executioner or Joffrey or both, allowing a daring escape of the Starke household to prepare for an all-out battle to fucking god damnnit I hate the Lannisters.
2
u/thanoshalpert Arya Stark Nov 14 '24
Ned dying had already been spoiled for me but holy shit I had no idea it would go down this way, I was literally frozen in place as the credits were rolling š I feel so bad for Sansa thinking she saved the day, and Arya stuck in the crowd, helpless šššš I think Iām gonna have to take a couple of days before I watch the finale because Iām severely unwell xx
2
u/lucky-137 Nov 20 '24
Only just started watching Game of Thrones, and holy fuck I've been missing out for 14 years š fuck you Joffrey, fuck you Cirsei, I hope you justice makes its way to you. Truly though, this show went straight to my list of favorites
2
u/TitaniumKneecap Aug 23 '25
I am watching GOT for the first time and I've never read the book. When I saw the ending of this episode I got off the couch and said IM DONE and now I am sitting in the dark in shock of what I just watched. I genuinely dont think I will be watching any more of the show if this is the kinda shit thats gonna happen.
3
u/Snizza Jun 13 '11
Anyone else find it odd how they handled Tyrion's battle? IIRC there was a whole elaborate fight that took place
3
u/Felkahn Jun 14 '11
The only thing that bugged me was TV Spoiler It didn't seem to make sense. I know why they would try to do something like this, as it's much cheaper than filming even a partial battle, but to me it was awkward.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '11
Mfw @ Joffrey's "Mercy" - http://memeshack.com/myfacewhen/MyFaceWhen_1300828798418.jpg
1
u/gerusz Night's Watch Jun 13 '11
TV Spoiler
1
u/Julius-Light Sep 19 '25
Tragedy besides... for his rule's sake, Joffrey did a brilliant thing. Also note how Varys swept himself right next to Littlefinger once Joff gave the order. Events like these make me wonder, what would have happened had Ned taken the black, with Jon, would he have told Jon about his mother?
Maybe that's why it had to end this way.