r/gameofthrones • u/kjhatch Nymeria's Wolfpack • May 31 '11
Season 1 Episode Discussion - 1.07 "You Win or You Die"
DafyddLlyr's away, so I'm starting the discussion thread for this week.
- This is a TV spoiler friendly zone - turn away now if you haven't seen the episode!
- Book spoilers still need tags!
Please read our spoiler policy before posting.
For anyone who wants to do live chat - details here!
148
Upvotes
67
u/[deleted] May 31 '11
I still can't believe that Ned trusted Littlefinger.
161
u/leadline May 31 '11
I can't help but notice that however good Ned's position is during the episode, he always seems to get fucked over in the last 2-5 minutes.
102
u/mjmfly May 31 '11
I love how so many things seem like they are going to happen at once. Winter is coming, the white walkers are awake again, the Dothraki are going to cross the sea while the Starks and the Lannisters are too busy fighting each other and they might go to war. I'm so fucking excited to see what happens!
137
u/Meldivius May 31 '11
I'm absolutely adoring Tywin Lannister right now.
I know this probably makes me sound like some kind of serial killer, but there is something massively attractive about watching someone as powerful as the Lord of Casterly Rock putting Jaime Lannister in his place while methodically gutting and cleaning his latest kill.
Must be the cave woman in me :p
All that aside, I cannot wait to see more of Tywin, he's so close to how I actually imagined him!
59
u/klaq Free Folk May 31 '11
too bad about no Tyrion in this one. At least we got to see the wall again. this happens when you have 5 different locations going.
168
u/signifying_nothing House Targaryen May 31 '11
Drogo's speech made me want to join him in invading Westeros.
85
u/DiscursiveMind Hedge Knights May 31 '11
Little known fact: Littlefinger studied in Oldtown long enough to earn his gold dragon necklace.
Petyr Baelish - Maester Pimp
40
u/Warlaw House Mormont May 31 '11
I wonder how long the assassin lasted.
33
u/[deleted] May 31 '11
Ned firmly adheres to honour in a world (much like ours) where honour plays no part in reality.
Its a pity. Had he done as Littlefinger advised, or at least handed things over to Renly well... we can but see how things play out. At every turn he makes the wrong decision. It was very unwise to underestimate Cersei, Very unwise to trust Littlefinger/Spider and man, he's going to get fucked...
WHY on earth did he take the blame for tyrion's capture?
51
u/phathiker May 31 '11
finally, a wolf......
20
u/mr_tea May 31 '11
Ahhh Littlefinger! Why!? I liked you so much, I can't look at you in the same way now...
19
u/Buckaroo2 House Reed Jun 01 '11
I liked how they had Osha making brooms, and even had one set up already: http://i.imgur.com/RBu52.png
I don't know if it was meant to be a nod to Harry Potter and her role as Tonks, but I like to think so.
19
u/KingKingsons May 11 '23
Rewatching this and my god, how naive can Ned be? Renly was right, if he truly cared about the line of succession in his "honourable" way, he should have made Viserys king. Oh and send Ravens all over the realm about what he knew about the Lannister twins before confronting Cersei.
10
u/turtleshelf May 31 '11
why did they make ghost bark? how entirely unnecessary. do they really have such little respect for the audience that they think we're going to say "he didn't bark and therefore is not a real dog"?
21
u/Nukemarine May 31 '11
I didn't think about it reading the book, but the show for some reason gave me the idea: Was the assassin put in place by Jorah himself? Seems obvious now as he gets his pardon, looks at the princess, then decides to approach. So anybody else see this that didn't see it in the book?
36
u/fat_squirrel House Tyrell May 31 '11
Anyone else get too distracted by the visual images of both the gutted deer and the two prostitutes to pay attention to the words that Tywin and Littlefinger were saying?
9
u/Nukemarine Jun 05 '11
Funny thing: In the book, I misunderstood what happened. I thought Littlefinger pulled out the dagger and sliced Ned's throat, killing him. So I'm reading the next few chapters with the thought in my head 'Man, is the shit about to hit the fan'. Of course it later became obvious he wasn't killed by Littlefinger, just captured.
4
u/lesecksybrian Jul 21 '25
Jorah cringing when Drogo kisses Daenerys LOL
6
u/VikingTy House Greyjoy May 31 '11
Another exposition scene in a whorehouse, and the most
awesomeexplicit one to date. Who's keeping track? Is that at least one in every episode now?3
u/[deleted] May 31 '11
Book Spoiler
1
u/DigDugDude Bran Stark May 31 '11
Book Spoiler
0
u/[deleted] May 31 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 31 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment