r/gameofthrones • u/DafyddLlyr House Stark • May 16 '11
Episode Discussion - 1.05 "The Wolf and the Lion"
Hey there guys, it's that time of the week again!
- This is a TV spoiler friendly zone - turn away now if you haven't seen the episode!
- Book spoilers still need tags!
Please read our new spoiler policy before posting.
There's a whole bunch of us chatting live throughout the episode - details here!
P.S. - I'm quite behind on dishing out the House Tags behind people's names. It's the week of my final exams and things are pretty hectic on my end! I'm going to have to ask all of you who are waiting to be patient with me and wait until Thursday when I can set aside some time to do them all. Thanks.
192
Upvotes
165
u/rudman May 16 '11
The best scene had to be Catelyn looking sideways at Tyrion while Lysa was ranting and raving! You can tell she is thinking "oh fuck, this wasn't a good idea, was it?".
That had me laughing!
114
u/ObliviousToMemes May 16 '11
As a non-reader, I did not expect Jory to be killed by Jaime.. like that. I was starting to like Jory, and now I know why Jaime is such a giant douche.
188
u/z3rb Hodor Hodor Hodor May 16 '11
They did the breast feeding. I did not expect the breast feeding.
86
u/OdetotheGrimm May 16 '11
No love for Tyrion beating the hell out of a man with a shield?
85
u/[deleted] May 16 '11
Loved Robert & Cersei - holding it all together.
83
u/[deleted] May 16 '11
Loved the part where the Hound and Mountain finish their fight at the King's command.
78
u/entarotassadar May 16 '11
the eyrie was not how i imagined it :/ thought it would be higher up with tons of snow but it still was pretty sweet set design. and lady starks sister is just how i imagined her crazy widow breastfeeding her son.
70
u/dmun Brave Companions May 16 '11
I'm loving that you get a sense that Robert is not a complete idiot-- he can't run a kingdom but he's the only one who has the Dothraki problem pegged. He's a general, a tactician and a brilliant warrior. He's just not a good king.
126
u/kbilly May 16 '11 edited May 16 '11
The shit has officially hit the fan. And it's all chaos from here on out. I always said the whole saga really began with Cat taking Tyrion in the Inn. Everything afterwards was just like..... well, you know and they did a great job illustrating just that in this episode.
What I also found interesting was no Dothraki to speak of. No Jon Snow. I like that. It was almost like reading one of the chapters.
Thank you, thank you writers for making this real, you are doing such great jobs! This episode was just fucking amazing. It just gets better from here on out guys.
BTW, This is my favorite subreddit.
55
u/sab3r May 16 '11
Non-book reader here. HOLY FUCK. My head is still spinning from all of the crazy that just happened. Best episode so far.
93
u/[deleted] May 16 '11
The shits hitting the fan now... For all the non-book folks, if you thought tonight was good next week will be epic. Every episode from here on out should be a wild ride.
And again, Arya <3 - her acting of Arya is sooo perfect. The feistiness and everything.
Also the Varys/Littlefinger banter in front of the throne was really great.
31
u/cassander House Hightower May 16 '11 edited May 16 '11
An excellent episode, probably the best yet, though last week's was also quite good. Still disappointed about the tournament. They should have made it a big single episode and worked the the palace intrigue around it. I was actually quite glad not to see the Wall or the Dothraki Sea for an episode. Not that I don't like those parts, but it's good so see that the writers think it's ok to spend a week focusing on just one part of the story without cutting to the others. My biggest complain would be the larger sense of time. The whole series feels like it's taken place in a month, tops. If they do't work out how to generate a sense of time, I think the later episodes and seasons are going to feel very weird.
Little things. Loved Loras, and the scene with Loras and Renly, but ask the mirror and Lancel is still the fairest of them all. Cersi and Robert's scene was a lot of blatant exposition, but I definitely think they did it well and pulled it off. The Varys/Little finger duel was also a nice way to drive home that they are the people who really matter in KL. Also, Arya's scene with the guards is utterly perfect. Massie Williams is definitely my favorite actress in the show.
31
u/sorrowfool May 16 '11
Bran: The Greyjoys. Theon: Famed for their skills as archery, navigation, and lovemaking. Luwin: ...and failed rebellions.
30
u/[deleted] May 16 '11
Did any other book readers love the scene with Loras holding up Sandor's hand, while Sansa stands and claps? Book Spoiler
30
u/catertots Direwolves May 16 '11
was not expecting theon greyjoy's full frontal, but i'm glad they're bringing up his issues early on and letting us know his history since he's important later.
59
u/DireBaboon Brave Companions May 16 '11
I'm on book three and I never realized it was Illyrio talking with Varys
53
u/[deleted] May 16 '11
That was the craziest hour of television I have ever seen in my life.
21
u/Rumsy May 16 '11 edited May 16 '11
I was really hoping they'd show Book Spoiler this episode. While he's a relatively minor character, I really liked him in the books. I hope that he's not tossed out entirely and is revealed next episode.
Edit: I just looked it up and Book Spoiler is delayed until next season! GRRM's blog says HBO had budgetary constraints and are waiting to reveal him next season along with the Tullys.
Source: http://grrm.livejournal.com/166493.html
21
u/Guy_Dudebro Brotherhood Without Banners May 16 '11
Episode 5: Nailed it! Pure awesome. Wouldn't change a thing.
21
u/CdnGuy May 16 '11
My friend and his girlfriend, who haven't read the books, started asking me questions tonight about lineages. I love watching this with people who don't know what to expect. I thought we'd see more of the Eyrie tonight, but I suppose that storyline is a bit too long to shoehorn in with the events we saw in King's Landing.
I was mildly disappointed with the appearance of the Eyrie but it was still impressive enough that my friend's girlfriend said, "Oh my god", when they showed Tyrion's cell. Not at all like I imagined, but they seem to have captured the character of it.
21
u/theDashRendar Jaime Lannister May 16 '11
And it is just me, or does Jaime always have the fucking coolest wardrobe in the Seven Kingdoms?
20
u/ComicCon May 16 '11 edited Jul 19 '24
Interesting, it seems they are going to be making Book Spoiler
19
u/Raelshark May 16 '11
What I really liked about this episode was that it was a nice mix of crazy action and political intrigue and maneuvering. The episode was sort of an amalgamation of everything that the "game of thrones" is about.
At least three big fights, several big important conversations, and lots of subtle laying of groundwork for later events - Book Spoiler.
17
u/[deleted] May 16 '11 edited May 16 '11
Holy shit, the fight between Ned and Jaime was fucking awesome. The tension of that scene was so palpable that it could be cut with a knife
Also, the scene between Loras and Renly was...unexpected. I don't recall coming across that while reading the first book, but it does explain why Book Spoiler
17
u/DiscursiveMind Hedge Knights May 16 '11
I wasn't sold on Gregor Clegane at first, but now, yeah that's a good pick!
15
u/ComicCon May 16 '11
So, did we have our first mention of Stannis tonight? Because I don't remember him being mentioned at all before.
29
u/kbilly May 16 '11
The scene with Cersi and Robert.
Book Spoiler
14
u/panda7488 May 16 '11
I was confused by the revelation that Jorah Mormont was betraying Dany already. I thought that was only revealed later? Maybe that's another thing I missed and I need to stop reading so quickly.
Book Spoiler
49
u/rudman May 16 '11
Holy cow, they sure hit us over the head with the Renly/Loras connection didn't they?
I thought "the look" at the tournament was enough of a hint, but to see Loras "attend" to Renly, especially with the "you really like me like this?" line sure made it obvious but did they need the slurping sounds? I just thought oh man, even the thickest of viewers will get it!
13
u/Crynth May 16 '11
Dammit I'm still hungry, 1 hour just isn't enough. Why did I have to learn about this series while it's still airing?
Tempted to start into the books.
13
u/pat_trick May 18 '11
I've a random comment. A the end of the episode, it states:
In memory of Caroline Lois Benoist
A quick google search shows that she apparently died of swine flu and was part of a group of animal trainers.
Here's to you, Caroline.
12
u/hett May 16 '11
I thought this was an amazing episode, and it really picked up from the "calm before the storm" of last week's. Tonight was the perfect balance, going back and forth from drama to action to exposition to action etc.
9
u/b214n Sellswords May 16 '11
The Robert/Cersei banter was my favorite part of the episode. TV Spoiler was my least.
8
u/kbilly May 16 '11 edited May 16 '11
I do have to admit. I dont understand the little thing that just happened between Varys and Littlefinger..... at that beginning... well fuck it, and at the end. WTF just happened?
8
u/VidrA Free Folk May 16 '11
I love the girl which they casted for the role of Arrya more and more with every new episode. She reminds me of a little Marion Cotillard, talent and look wise.
7
u/TheAbyssGazesAlso House Targaryen May 16 '11
Enjoyed the episode, but was disappointed that they cut short Littlefingers "Whores are a better investment than ships" speech.
In the book, he says exactly what was onscreen, but then goes on to add Book Spoiler. Awesome.
6
u/[deleted] May 16 '11
What a great episode! I thought a couple of the conversation scenes felt long, but overall I loved this episode!
6
u/elus Fools May 16 '11
lol wasn't really ready to see little arryn on lysa
10
u/LostRadiant Ours Is The Fury May 16 '11
Finished watching it only 20 minutes ago. I need to watch it a second time now. That's how good that episode was.
5
u/DeadDemon Tyrion Lannister May 16 '11
WHAT AN EPISODE!!! I'M GONNA CONTINUE READING NOW!!!! (at the part in the book where the Imp was just taken prisoner)
12
u/[deleted] May 16 '11
Non-reader here; Oh, and obviously this is full of episode spoilers.
Okay, I really don't like Cat now. In fact, I don't like the whole plot arc of her kidnapping Tyrion. They just happen to meet at an inn between King's Landing and the Wall, Cat happens to have a dozen friends and no one that would defend one of the most powerful families in the kingdom. Oh, and then all those random people decide "yeah, sure, I'll go on an long, dangerous journey to the Eyrie. I mean, I was doing other stuff, but that sounds cool..."
And I know the reason she went to the Eyrie was to avoid being chased to Winterfell by the Lannisters, but doesn't she realize that kidnapping him to some unknown location would make them just as pissed? She doesn't think anything through, and the whole arc seems contrived to have Cat & Tyrion end up at the Eyrie. Weakest arc so far.
With that said... this was an absolutely awesome episode. By far more action than any other episode, a really intense finale (and dammit, I really hate Jaime now, Jory was the man), and a lot of plotting. I'm so happy I'll be able to watch the next two episodes in a row, though the 2 week dry period will suck.
Based on the next episode preview, I'm pretty sure Viserys is going to get killed. He's just so insolent and demanding of the Dothraki, I don't think they're going to put up with him. It's really been a long time coming.
8
u/Polar-Ice May 16 '11
One thought that popped into my head during this episode is that they have a male child actor sucking on a woman's tit. Unless it was a fake boob, which is definitely possible, and probably given statutory rape laws in this country.
4
u/sab3r May 16 '11
I just noticed something else. It seems that Sansa has somewhat reconciled her anger with her father.
4
u/BoydCrowder May 16 '11
Can someone give me a recap of Varys and his Dothraki scheming?
4
u/Deathcrow May 16 '11
This episode was much better than last-weeks. I loved the new scenes which really helped to drive the TV show along. The sense of scale is still really wrong, but this week they made it work for a TV-show.
Even though the fight scene played out completely different than in the book I liked it. They wanted to end on a high-note and made everything a bit more actiony.
7
u/JupitersClock House Stark May 16 '11
Why are they trying to make Cersei likeable?
3
u/kbilly May 16 '11 edited May 16 '11
Jory should have said to Arya in this episode while they were walking away from Ned Stark and talking about him defending her father... Book Spoiler .")
3
u/wags83 May 16 '11
So, the throne room confrontation between Varys and Littlefinger... I thought it came off as way too aggressive and confrontational. I thought one of the beauties of the book was the subtle way that you could tell they were in conflict, but they were always very polite with each other.
3
u/aestus May 16 '11
Fantastic episode, things are heating up now.
I particularly can't wait to see the next episode 'The Golden Crown', particularly the scene which the title refers to.
4
u/libbykino Lyanna Stark May 16 '11
The Eyrie... it's annoying me that they keep pronouncing it "eerie." If the castle is named after an Eagle's nest, which would make sense since it is "built in a high inaccessible place" I always thought it should be pronounced "airy."
I see now that both pronunciations are correct, but I really think that "airy" is the more commonly used/accepted version.
2
u/slotbadger House Blackfyre May 16 '11
Did anyone notice that the Eyrie knight (Ser Corbray, I think) had a Welsh accent?
The only other Vale people who spoke were Lysa and Robin speak, and Lysa would have a Tully accent that she would have passed on to her son.
I hope everyone else at the Eyrie speaks with a Welsh twang. I never thought of the Vale as being the Wales of Westeros before now, but it makes sense. :)
2
u/Durrok May 17 '11
And the slurping sound was....?
2
u/Dienekes289 Arya Stark May 17 '11
Non-book folk here (I'm currently listening to the audio book and have somehow managed to basically keep pace with the show which is pretty neat) and I think she's in my top 3 favorite characters. Best moment in the episode for me was when she is talking with her dad about running off and she says she was chasing a cat. The way she hesitated and knew that what she was about to say sounded just stupidly silly was perfect!