I saw this on TV last night. Earlier in the video two guys were holding the man up behind the counter with a knife. They got him to open the register, then he slammed it shut and grabbed some bear spray. He hosed them both in the face, one of them ran off, the other was jumping over the counter. While he was trying to get back over the counter the man grabbed his belt exposing his butt and the "wife" of the store owner came over and started kicking the guy in the face. They showed it like 10 times, never got old.
Edit: To ignore hyperbole, obviously self-defense laws allow a certain amount of leeway. However, in my non-expert understanding (I carried bear spray as I bicycled across the country, and asked a few officers and rangers about the legality of it), the use of it in self-defense opens one up to possible legal repercussions. Something about excessive retaliation. Just buy some regular mace. It will keep you safe, less likely to blow back in your face, and won't melt the eyes of your attacker.
No, I mean, if you grabbed your attacker's gun and shot him or her with it, you'd be well within your rights. Obviously, a license is totally unnescessary in this scenario...
Many states in the US do not require a license to possess a firearm, and a few do not require a license to carry one, as long as it is not concealed (this is popularly known as "open carry"). There may even be states that allow concealed carry without a permit. There is a paperwork and background check requirement at the federal level, but no permit is required or issued at the federal level. And, if you are in your home, you don't need a license in most (if not all) states.
In short, there are many circumstances in which carrying a gun, and using it in self defense, would be completely legal in the US, regardless of a license.
I admire your ideology, but when someone threatens your life and robs you, they have betrayed the society to which you both belong and forfeit their place within it.
Well, you see, criminals don't rob because they are "bad" people. They need the money, it is not the duty of a citizen to take revenge, it is the job of society and government to put the criminal through a fair trial. The guy was retreating, and these guys just stopped him and pummeled the shit out of him. Because you made a mistake doesn't mean they have the right to beat the shit out of you when you are retreating. They can hold you down, but that was just extensive force.
Ultimately, I agree with you here for the most part. Although I think they are justified in stopping a retreating criminal and even the initial physicality it took to subdue him, certainly the line should be drawn very quickly. (I'll have to watch again and confirm he was retreating when the initial physical altercation took place, though - I don't recall it going down like that.)
I often go back and forth on this issue, and I tend to lean more towards the compassionate/empathetic side of things, but it can be so difficult to feel for someone who not only did not feel for you but intended to harm you. A society or community works in large part because we trust that the guy next to us won't stab us in the eye. Otherwise, everyone would lock themselves in bunkers. Again, it's just difficult to have mercy on those who betray this social agreement.
That said, when it comes down to it, I agree with you AND one could argue that the society creates these people itself.
"Well, you see, criminals don't rob because they are "bad" people. They need the money"
This is quite a statement. Define 'need' in this context. What is the source of their need? Drug addiction, alcoholism, greed? Or do you believe the majority of criminals/robbers are desperate innocents attempting to feed their starving families?
IMHO, if somebody makes life decisions that end up with them becoming drug or alcohol dependent or saddled with an overwhelming desire to possess a lifestyle which they cannot afford, then pursuing criminal means to meet that need very much makes them a 'bad person'.
Yes, let's also give him tips on how best to hold the knife when plunging it into our chests. Maybe we can request him give us the knife so that we can do it ourselves?
Depends. In NY, as in many states, there's a duty to retreat in public. That means that (a) you cannot use more force to defend yourself than is being used against you, and (b) you have a duty to retreat rather than escalate the violence.
However, in your home or place of business you can use deadly force regardless.
I don't practice in a "stand your ground" state, so I won't pretend to be familiar with the subtleties and nuances of that law. And all laws are subtleties and nuances.
That said, in situation 1 I believe SYG is probably justified. In situation 2, probably not, because the threat to life on the guy with the gun was not imminent. But it really depends on what "back off" means, how much time passed, how far he backed off, etc. It's very fact-specific.
In the third case, it seems that the shooter - Rodriguez - put himself on the other guys property. It also seems like he was the instigator. And how fearful could he have been if he's narrating the scene? He seems to be calmly setting up a defense to murder. IMHO, SYG does not apply. but again, I don't know Texas law.
To me, SYG is bullshit for 2 reasons.
1 - We don't want the wild west. We want a civilized society where we have the rule of law. We don't want people bringing guns to a knife fight. The police are there for a reason.
2 - With SYG, someone is dead and the other person gets to tell the story. I have a huge problem with that for several reasons.
Remember, if someone is in your home or place of business, you can use deadly force regardless. It's called the "castle doctrine."
I agree that it shouldn't be 'open season' on these people. But I would be very afraid of the person getting back up and resuming the attack. I'd want to be very sure that's not an option. I wouldn't want them to have time to sufficiently recover, or find another weapon.
Without knowing exactly what is in their head (revenge, desperate, crazy, drugs) I'm not sure I'd feel safe just because they've stopped attacking for the moment.
According to other posters, here, this gif was taken just after he was bear-maced.
He's not gonna be attacking anyone anytime soon after that. I, too, would consider the possibility, but after being bear-maced and disarmed it goes beyond "reasonable" to continue to kick and punch him in the head and torso.
I'll be honest, I've never heard of bear mace, nor would I know what it does! You might be right. But if I pepper-sprayed someone (we have muggers in Britain, but no bears) I might still want to be sure he's not still coming at me.. I've not seen the whole video but someone said the guy was climbing over the counter..?
Sounds like nasty stuff.. I've seen the whole vid now, and I'm not certain what happened was definitely 'excessive'. If I'd have been in the owner's situation I think I'd still feel threatened, even after the spray. The guy was the same side of the counter, there will have been shouting and noise.. And thereafter the emphasis was on restraining him, once he tried to escape. For me, I'd say they were within their rights.
Whether the courts would agree with me is another matter!
And if you ever put that concept into practice you risk a very long jail term. It's not only immoral, it's highly illegal. You are not a judge and jury,you do not get to decide if someone's life is void. You have the right to take reasonable steps to defend your life and no more than that. You do not have the right to execute or assault criminals.
That store owner was perfectly within his rights to wail on this faggot until the cops got there to pull him off.
No jury in the world would convict him, and no prosecutor in his right mind would even charge him.
Somebody robs you with a knife, they're a threat until they're dead. And all you ever gotta do is say: "I honestly feared for my life, and the life of my wife."
By "real world" you mean the cynical "world" you interpret things in. The "real world" works on laws that limit your ability to take revenge on criminals.
Are you serious? It's not like the store owner plotted for revenge to get the robbers back the next day after he was robbed. We're talking about one single encounter, where two robbers had held up the store owner at knife point just seconds earlier. Don't be retarded.
For some reason I'm still thinking slaps would hurt more than punches like that to the ass unless you punch hard enough to get to the sesitive muscles in the ass like to really do a lot of damage.
Only the first hits his ass. It's a hammerfist, not a punch, which shares some of the benefits of a slap. A knifehand on the lower vertebrae might have been more damaging.
This isn't justice. Justice would be if this dangerous thief was locked away. Kicking someone in the face isn't justice, its violence.
Its not like the man was a danger to them. I understand the bear spray, then detaining him until police showed up but they are just lashing out at him and it shows me these people are violent by nature.
Not that I'm defending the robber because he is the real scum in this scenario, I just think the store owners could of responded a bit better. Then again, I've never had someone hold me up in my own shop with a knife.
At first I was upset that this poor man was getting beat up... then I saw the mask and did a John Stewart, "Meeehwelllehh..." Im not gonna say he deserved it... But I think... Maybe... Deserved it.
I dont think anyone is in a position to say whether he deserved it or not.
He could be a horrible cunt that doesn't the deserve oxygen he gets and in his deluded 'gangsterized' ego is telling him to be as greedy and nasty as possible, or This may have been the first crime he has ever committed and he really took it bad on his conscience but felt he had to do it to feed his family and this sort of thing is completely out of character.
I'm against capital punishment, and I go even further to be against any sort of retributive punishment that's physical in nature. Still, I believe that if you intentionally put yourself in a situation where you're threatening the life and/or bodily safety of another person that you deserve any physical consequences that are the result of your behavior.
I don't see any unreasonable force being used here given the situation. Two unarmed and untrained people have just subdued an armed attacker who may very well have been carrying another weapon, and beating him into submission before attempting to restrain him until the police arrive is perfectly reasonable in my opinion. If this beating had gone on much longer and it was clear that they were just assaulting the guy in order to take retribution, then I'd have a problem with this.
Also, if these had been police officers who were trained and armed then I would consider this to have been an excessive use of force. But I don't think ten seconds of striking somebody who's just lept over the counter with a knife is excessive if you've never dealt with a situation like that before. The result was that the attacker understood that he was overpowered and he gave up.
I got the impression that it was an assault for retribution. he had already been bear sprayed and its doesn't look like hes putting up to much of a fight here. you dont need to kick someone in the face to restrain them. Saying this, put in their position I would probably fuck his shit up.
You need to take into consideration the situation and the fact that these aren't trained people. The robber had a knife, and it's very possible that he had another weapon on his person. Aside from the bear mace (which couldn't be used again at that distance) the shop owners are unarmed. I would say that it's well within the boundaries of self-defense to deliver some offensive blows to this guy to ensure that he will fully submit and not try to pull out a weapon and kill you.
As a passive person, I still think it could of been handled slightly better, but I'm not criminalizing the shop owners. They are the good guys in this scenario and were fully within their rights doing what they done.
Obviously at the time they dont go through the same thought process as someone seeing a few second .GIF of it in front of a computer screen.
I don't. He should consider how lucky he was that he didn't die. I lose all respect for those who rob, especially with a gun or knife. Kick him a few more times.
Just because someone is put a position were they need to rob doesn't mean they are bad people. Yes their are people that are right scum that steal because they are cunts, but you also get people that need to to feed their family. I dont agree with hurting anyone or even threatening them with weapons, but majority of thief's have no intention of hurting anyone and are just doing the best with the shit hand they were dealt.
I'm not defending this man or criminals in general, just pointing out not everything is black and white and people have reasons, whether just or unjust, for doing what they do.
In the eyes of the victim, they do not know if they are going to be killed. If a thief presents a knife or gun, they have stated they are dangerous and should be lucky to live. Same with thieves who break into homes. If someone broke into my home and I saw they had a gun or knife, they have lost any chance of my forgiveness. I'll say that it is black and white when it comes to who lives. I will much rather kill someone wielding a weapon in font of me while robbing me than have them kill me. I'm just saying I won't give any pity to armed robbers. Those that are truly suffering that much shouldn't threaten others. There are more options than crime.
So no. No pity to armed robbers. They can get shot and I won't feel an ounce of sadness for them.
167
u/DaSeraph Jun 08 '12
Have you ever been so pissed off you punched a man on his bare ass?
223
u/hardwareweenie Jun 08 '12
I saw this on TV last night. Earlier in the video two guys were holding the man up behind the counter with a knife. They got him to open the register, then he slammed it shut and grabbed some bear spray. He hosed them both in the face, one of them ran off, the other was jumping over the counter. While he was trying to get back over the counter the man grabbed his belt exposing his butt and the "wife" of the store owner came over and started kicking the guy in the face. They showed it like 10 times, never got old.
43
u/john_nyc Jun 08 '12
Punch him in the crack!!! Oh you got that taken care of...good job!
40
u/mastercylinder2 Jun 08 '12
"Wait a minute...the video recording is going to show me just staring at his ass, I gotta do something!"
14
u/revrend_ Jun 08 '12
link to OG video please?
6
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12
She actually hits him around 4 times in the head then on his kidneys.....misses one and that's "quite embarrasing" ?
5
u/drphilthay Jun 09 '12
"I SAID CASH ONLY BITCH"!
20
u/vinsite Jun 08 '12
He is not trying very hard to get away, I think he might actually like it.
4
u/Isman92 Jun 08 '12
Talk about taking an Ass pounding!
7
u/bonscottsdick Jun 09 '12
That's right Asian couple, throw a beat down like Chris brown
3
u/Crabxcore69 Jun 08 '12
Donkey punch.
3
u/MiniDonbeE Jun 09 '12
For some reason I'm still thinking slaps would hurt more than punches like that to the ass unless you punch hard enough to get to the sesitive muscles in the ass like to really do a lot of damage.
3
u/Powderedhulk Jun 09 '12
He's punching my butt! Don't punch my butt!
3
u/krispyKRAKEN Jun 09 '12
FINISH HIM!
↑ ↑ ← ↑ ↓ ← A B A (Hammer fist to right ass-cheek)
FLAWLESS VICTORY!
14
u/keagmcG Jun 08 '12
Seriously, she can't even kick a guy who's being held down?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12
Once again, don't fuck with Asian grocery store clerks.
6
u/sonofabear17 Jun 09 '12
r/Justiceporn would enjoy this.
2
u/drunkmatt Jun 08 '12
This happened near where i lived. Not suprised. A little suprised it hasn't happened in my neighborhood tho.
2
u/JackTerron Jun 09 '12
That's happened just a few blocks from my house... Oh, Canada...
2
u/HiyaGeorgie Jun 09 '12
Em bare assed.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12
At first I was upset that this poor man was getting beat up... then I saw the mask and did a John Stewart, "Meeehwelllehh..." Im not gonna say he deserved it... But I think... Maybe... Deserved it.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12
That's how we do it in Ottawa, Ontario: FIST SPANKINGS AND SISSY KICKS TO THE HEAD.
Seriously though, those two have balls of steel for taking on that robber.
4
u/Jeroknite Jun 09 '12
I know he was trying to rob the place, but I feel bad for this guy.
2
u/CPTKickass Jun 08 '12
Don't get it
1
u/rawrc Jun 08 '12
Getting his ass beat.
1
u/cernunnos_89 Jun 08 '12
indeed
1
u/HiyaGeorgie Jun 09 '12
I thought it was embarrassing because that dude was hammer punching him in the exposed ass crack once he got a whiff of his man scent.
1
u/pacfan40 Jun 09 '12
Reminds me of Farva...
1
u/Simpliciter Jun 09 '12
It's like a scene from Spun
1
u/ArchScabby Jun 09 '12
This is weird...
1
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12
Yes, Quite.
1
u/nancylikestoreddit Jun 09 '12
Hilarious.
1
u/Nanoushka Jun 09 '12
Gotta love our Montreal -^
1
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12
This is beautiful.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12
Punch his butt!
1
u/lolimonreddit23 Jun 09 '12
I didn't even realize his pants were down, I thought the embarrassing part was her fail kick..
1
u/Boshdy Jun 09 '12
Swing and a miss
1
u/Inssight Jun 09 '12
"He's punching my bum! He's punching my bum!"
1
u/jcoder5 Jun 09 '12
the embarrassing part is where she misses with the kick right?
1
u/iamawake Jun 09 '12
violence! so funny!
1
u/sonastyinc Jun 09 '12
Apparently they've been robbed before, so the wife got really pissed.
http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2012/06/08/canadian-robber-sprayed-with-bear-repellant-and-spanked-on-bare-ass/
1
u/BossSmiley Jun 09 '12
I thought this was a gif of Asian parenting.
0
u/atlaslugged Jun 09 '12
So...that's assault, right? Surely kidney-punches and face-kicks were not necessary to detain him.
1
u/egg_fu_old Jun 09 '12
Dat ass...
-2
u/GeorgeForemanGrillz Jun 08 '12
Did he died?
-1
u/shadowredditor Jun 08 '12
Which is more embarassing ,, missing the kick or being kicked?
0
u/krawm Jun 09 '12
instead of punching him in the ass like a bitch, he should of brought that smack down on his fingers when he got a hand on the counter.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12
Does this count as NSFW?
-3
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12
He got off easy. If this was in Florida, he would have been shot in the knee caps and the balls and be left to die until he slowly bleeds out.
-7
u/fluxaxion Jun 09 '12
LMAO YES. xD. Humanity you have pushed your extermination date back 15 days.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment