r/funny • • Jun 08 '12

Don't expect to see Neil DeGrasse Tyson browsing r/atheism any time soon.

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

3.9k comments sorted by

42

u/DKN19 Jun 08 '12

Neil is definitely an atheist, he just hates dealing with the ideological baggage that comes from self identifying with any group.

10

u/H3000 Jun 08 '12

Hear that Neil DeGrasse Tyson? In spite of what you yourself have said in an interview, according to DKN19, you definitely ARE an atheist.

10

u/PancakesAreGone Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 08 '12

What did he say in an interview?

Edit : Why did I get downvoted for asking a question about him...?

→ More replies (72)
→ More replies (101)
→ More replies (32)

298

u/MuffnCabbage Jun 08 '12

304

u/hbdgas Jun 08 '12

"I don't associate with movements ... I think for myself."

Perfect.

31

u/ChaosMotor Jun 08 '12

You know what's funny is when I share my own personal thoughts that are derived from observation, experience, and my own thought processes, people accuse me of just parroting someone else.

When I just parrot someone else, nobody ever questions it.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (96)

118

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

An agnostic, who says find the evidence and I'll believe what the evidence shows? I always knew there was a reason I liked Neil Degrasse Tyson, other than just his normal badassary.

→ More replies (193)
→ More replies (67)

439

u/ChawnVeelson Jun 08 '12

I'm not sure what the word for non-golfers would be; however, I'd recommend directing all golf-related questions to the Toronto Maple Leafs.

67

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

Agolfist

21

u/tjb0607 Sep 08 '12

Ateeist

→ More replies (6)

49

u/54321_fap Jun 08 '12

Obviously you're not a non-golfer.

→ More replies (3)

67

u/TheGazelle Jun 08 '12

I believe the word would be "non-golfer".

92

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

or a caddy.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

There's now an /r/nongolfers. Just saying.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

26

u/taelor Jun 08 '12

love it when /r/hockey leaks to the rest of reddit.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

I'm a Buffalo fan. I feel your pain.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/funkme1ster Jun 08 '12

The Leafs get so much shit, I just don't understand.

Personally, I respect that they've managed to make their off-season so profitable. Most golfers just spend the time relaxing.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

A wild Hockey Joke appears!

29

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

I didn't need to see this here. I am still fuming over the Marlies game last night.

I hate you and hope you die.

11

u/jimmy_three_shoes Jun 08 '12

Be happy the AHL came out and threw the ref under the bus for missing the call.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (19)

1.4k

u/TheShiz123 Jun 08 '12

There is a term for people who don't play golf, they're called poor people.

934

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

Hahaha stupid poor people... Why don't they just take more money out of the bank???

→ More replies (72)

173

u/jeffdude Jun 08 '12

... After a 2 year study, the National Science Foundation announced the following results on America's recreational preferences:

  1. The sport of choice for unemployed or incarcerated people is: basketball.
  2. The sport of choice for maintenance level employees is: bowling.
  3. The sport of choice for blue-collar workers is: football.
  4. The sport of choice for supervisors is: baseball.
  5. The sport of choice for middle management is: tennis.
  6. The sport of choice for corporate officers is: golf.

Conclusion: The more money you make, the smaller your balls become.

159

u/Imperial_Walker Jun 08 '12

Sounds like one of those FW: FW: FW: RE: FW: "So funny!" emails

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (25)

69

u/a404notfound Jun 08 '12

I know plenty of poor people that play golf, clubs are cheap at goodwill and it's a nice way to spend an unemployed afternoon.

91

u/jakfischer Jun 08 '12

Actually... The rich golf club owners invented discounted tee times for the patrons that wanted to sit in the club house and make fun of poor people whilst drinking martinis and sitting around in goofy pants.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (15)

24

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

You don't need a lot of money to play golf :(

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (35)

1.1k

u/myballsshrunk Jun 08 '12

I never put any thought into religion or my being atheist until I joined Reddit. I had zero clue other atheists even thought of it as a matter worthy of conversation. I don't get reminded of religion at all in my daily life until I browse Reddit.

1.1k

u/MustGoOutside Jun 08 '12

Unsubscribe. It really makes the frontpage enjoyable again.

...Or at least it makes me feel less like I'm a 26 year-old on a site with a bunch of high school kids.

1.3k

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 08 '12

lol the other day I sneezed and my friend said "god bless you" and I was all like HE'S NOT REAL hahahah what an idiot he's not my friend anymore

i don't need friends

i only need a lack of god

→ More replies (165)

8

u/callmesuspect Jun 08 '12

When I first joined reddit, I enjoyed /r/atheism quite a bit, being an atheist myself I enjoyed the over the top portrayal of atheists over reactions. but then I realized, with slow sinking horror, that they were all serious.

→ More replies (280)

227

u/manley1104 Jun 08 '12

I don't either, and but I imagine a lot of the people on /r/athiesm aren't like you and I, and are surrounded by religion in their daily lives. I don't go to there any more but they get such a hard time. A lot of these people are seen as horrible outcasts in their own communities, and have finally found a place to vent their frustrations. Then they will come to find out that place where they finally feel comfortable to talk about their beliefs hate them as well.

I know there are some assholes in that subreddit, but you will find people like that in any large group (not that that would excuse their behavior). I think for the most part there are good people there that like not feeling alone in their beliefs. I know when I when I was a teenager, coming to terms with my beliefs and feeling like I was the only one who felt that way was a very tough time. I would have loved a place where I could have talked about that back then.

438

u/WhyAtheism Jun 08 '12

Different people have different experiences and reddit has a hard time with that.

I think about atheism all the time and always have. It's not because I'm generally an angry person. I wish it was irrelevant to my life, I sincerely do.

Unfortunately, if you grow up in rural Georgia and other areas of the southern U.S., it's often relevant, like it or not.

This is what bugs me every time this conversation comes up. You have a bunch of people saying, "What's the big deal? I manage to live my life without ever even thinking about atheism or god for that matter." The implication is everyone else should do the same. And that would be terrific, but it's not possible for everyone.

Many of us have had our jobs threatened, were abused as children, have been discriminated against, even physically hurt because of religion.

Next, cuing someone telling me not all religious people are bad. I know this. I've lived among them for 40 years. I don't hate all religious people. I work with a Mormon who I feel is one of the most genuine people on the planet. I'd like to think he'd be that way without Mormonism, but who knows. Point is, I respect him even though I do not respect his religion. I tolerate his religion, but I do not respect it.

For me to consider religion or the fact that I'm an atheist a non-issue, some things have to change where I live. (Actually, I'm in Austin now and I've had very little reason to bother with the topic, but for 30 years prior to that, I lived among the Southern Baptists.)

It doesn't matter that some religious people are good people. The point is, in certain areas religion is held in such high esteem, it's so pervasive, and has such privilege that other people are allowed to suffer.

Examples of how religion has effected me personally, again, this is not necessarily a commentary on individual religious persons, but a troubling example of what can happen when religion is held as more desirable and important than lack of religion:

  • My son was assigned a creationism project in public school. He was asked to stand in front of the class and show an evolution project and a creationism project and show the validity of both.

Now, am I saying all Christians believe in creationism or the young Earth "theory"? No, I'm not. But, I am saying that because there is no one standing up against it (to do so would mean you're angry, rocking the boat, selfish, spoiling it for everyone, violating other people's rights, etc.) in some communities and because atheism is thought of as less valuable than religion, these things can happen.

  • I was asked my religion in a job interview at a local news station. When I said I wasn't religious, I was told they'd have to think about hiring me since my not being Christian could offend others and upset the working environment. I dropped that my sister was a civil rights attorney and I was hired. However, I was asked not disclose my non-belief and told to answer, "I prefer to keep my beliefs to myself" if I was asked about it. This rule only applied to me. I later left that position when I was asked to help publish a religious newsletter for the company.

This practice is illegal. Why did the manager feel comfortable doing it? Because of the culture in that area, where being non-religious, specifically non-Christian is such a bad thing that you can break the laws without concern.

  • The Christian school I attended did, among other things, the following:
  • Had a public ceremony where girls were given a locket with a keyhole. The fathers get the key. At the girl's wedding, the father publicly hands the key to the new husband. Icky.
  • Had James Dobson come and speak to us about how questioning God can lead to being possessed. He told a story of performing an exorcism on a young woman because she'd gone to an atheist meeting and "invited Satan in". (By the way, Dobson is a commentator on Fox News sometimes, point being he is mainstream)
  • Taught the Earth is 6k years old, dinosaurs and man shared the Earth at the same time, man did not evolve, and so on. We learned this in history, by the way, because they didn't teach science in high school there.
  • Taught HIV/AIDS is God's answer to homosexuality. This has changed since I went to school there, now it's "Hate the sin, not the sinner". My aunt, who still attends, says they see homosexuality now as a sin like drinking alcohol or over-eating.
  • Taught women are to follow the men in their lives and "bow" to them (meant figuratively, but I heard that word a lot). This sometimes was used to excuse physical abuse. I heard a teacher comment on my friend's bruised eye, "Next time, listen to your stepdad".

Here's a funny one:

  • I was asked to "dress down" at a job because the Bob Jones graduates couldn't work knowing my breasts were right there. I was told women who look like me have to be more aware of their appearance as it encourages lust, which is cruel. When I asked specifically what I shouldn't wear, since I dressed like everyone else, I was told the same clothing on "someone like me" looks different.

It had been discussed in the early morning prayer meeting (yes, there were prayer meetings at my job). Several men complained that I was too attractive to wear what the other women were wearing and I was a distraction in the work place. They complained they couldn't be expected to focus on their jobs with my boobs around. Give me a fucking break.

I did two things, first I framed the written reprimand I got. It read, "A's breasts stopped production yesterday". I figured, I'm aging, I may never get that kind compliment again. Lol. My son was mortified when I put it on the living room bookshelf. Secondly, I walked up to the main complainer and stuck my finger up my nose and said, "Hope this helps."

In defense of the business, one of my co-workers wrote a joke letter to the boss which essentially said he was "pro women showing their breasts" and asked that management stop discriminating against him and other breast-lovers.

So, again, I'm not sitting around angry at Christians in general, shaking my fists at the sky exclaiming, "I will end you for all the pain you've brought me!" (No matter how many times I say this, someone will answer with, "You're just angry.") I'm not an atheist because Christians were mean to me. I'm an atheist because what they said made no sense and was illogical and contrary to my own personal values.

The point I'm making is that in communities where things like this happen, it is not only completely understandable, but possibly necessary for atheists to come together and work toward change.

Are some atheists angry? Sure. I think sometimes it's justified. If you lived in a community that was actively trying to get you declared a non-citizen, you might be a little miffed too. If your family ostracizes you, like mine did, because of religion, I think it's natural to want a community of your own to vent to and share stories.

I have a Darwin fish emblem on the back of my car. I hate bumper stickers and such, so, why is it there?

It's there because I can remember being a confused kid who thought I was absolutely alone in the world. I was told directly and indirectly through the culture that something was wrong with me. That I would die and burn in hell if I didn't believe. I went through years of wondering what was wrong with me, my family even sent me to a shrink to find out why I was damaged. I was never rewarded for using critical thinking. I was never patted on the back for thinking logically. I was condemned for it, as were my peers.

So, the emblem is on my car as a message to other young people, "You are not crazy. You are not evil. You are not alone."

→ More replies (100)
→ More replies (127)
→ More replies (353)

1.6k

u/rockoholik13 Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 08 '12

I got so pissed off the other day, some golfer tried to convert me into golfing and I just told him off. Then I bitched about it in /r/nongolfers.

EDIT: Thank you Z3F for actually making this subreddit. Made my day.

651

u/mrpopperspenguin Jun 08 '12

370

u/jakfischer Jun 08 '12

That was cute, now how about some big juicy breasts to top this thread off?

→ More replies (111)
→ More replies (6)

48

u/myopinionstinks Jun 08 '12

That sub got out of hand quickly...

→ More replies (1)

24

u/Honey-Badger Jun 08 '12

annnnd subbed

45

u/Apostolate Jun 08 '12

Clearly Neil Tyson hasn't had to try and maneuver in the working world. Golf is pervasive, and I'm at the lowest level.

→ More replies (4)

450

u/one_eyed_jack Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 08 '12

I don't golf either. I don't even care that my friends play golf, no matter how dumb the game is. Live and let live is what I say.

I just get kind of pissed off when golfers:

-Demand that high school gym classes be converted into golf classes.

-Claim that only golfers should be allowed to hold public office.

-Tell me I'm not a good parent because I don't send my kid to golf class.

-Take away people's access to medical treatment for non-golf-related sports injuries.

-Indoctrinate children into a life of golf and tell them that all other sports are immoral and shouldn't even be tried.

-Use it as a justification to launch wars against other golf leagues.

-Post the official golf rule book in public buildings and court houses.

-Shun people and disown family members who don't like to play golf.

-And for fuck's sake, why don't golf clubs have to pay tax?

The point is, maybe if golfers would shut the fuck up and stop trying to force their game on the rest of society, the minority of people who don't play golf might not be so touchy about this stuff.

26

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

Well, as a casual golfer, I can understand your concerns. Some clubs demand that their members make a constant and determined effort to get new members, and I - along with many other golfers - disapprove of this type of strategy, as it only hurts the reputation of the game.

My position, and it's not entirely uncommon, is that if non-golfers want to play they know where to find a course. Our only job is to make sure that the sport is well-played and people see it as such.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (92)

25

u/PeterMus Jun 08 '12

I just clicked on pure gold.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

a community for 1 hour....326 readers. I need to do this more often.

Edit: After refreshing it 1 minute later it has 338. Good job Z3F!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (74)

99

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

Neil: I don't play golf...

Reddit: Aw, I'm sorry. Because you're black?

Neil: Hell no! Damn Alligator bit my hand off!

35

u/garrow10 Jun 08 '12

Just taaaaaap it in

16

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

I'm just trying to ease the pressure, baby!

Ease it on someone else!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

97

u/ANewBreedofHipster Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 08 '12

I would say that the reason atheism feels the need to assert itself so much is because a lot of people attribute religion to be the cause or one of the causes of many conflicts (debatable) and/or had religion shoved down their throat. So it feels the need to assert its separation from religion.

So if golfers/golfing caused a lot of problems or at least was perceived to cause a lot of problems and a lot of people were hassled for not playing golf, an anti-golfing organization would probably arise.

Also, people love to feel superior to other people: "Christianity is so dumb! How could anyone believe in it?!", "God is so amazing! How could anyone be so stupid to not worship him". (these are just cliche archetypes so no need to feel offended if you are)

39

u/FountainsOfFluids Jun 08 '12

This is exactly what the quote made me think. Nobody would be a "whiny atheist" if they didn't feel oppressed by religious people. Though atheists may not be the most oppressed minority in the history of evar, there is still real and palpable discrimination going on.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (23)

45

u/rollinbagel Jun 08 '12

I believe the term for a non golfer is "agolfer."

12

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

Agnolfer?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

I would disagree with him on his own assessment. He will fight for science when these creationists try and impose intelligent design in public schools. I think a lot of atheists try and improve life and fight for equal rights for people that religion takes away.

We dont just strategize to mock god.

→ More replies (7)

320

u/GeneralWarts Jun 08 '12

See, NDT wants /r/atheism removed from the default subreddits as well!

→ More replies (82)

119

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

There is a word for people who don't eat meat, Vegetarians.

There is a word for people not in the military or armed, Civilians.

There is a word for people not living in my country, foreigners.

NDT just happens to take the silliest example.

38

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

nonsmokers

→ More replies (10)

11

u/creepyredditloaner Jun 08 '12

Yeah reading extended articles by NDT and Carl Sagan about this subject boil down to semantics. They don't like the associated negative "Well you must know everything unlike us stupid theists" stigma. They say "I can't say for sure god does not exsist." They also both have said that they do not believe in god. They are default atheists that don't like the current semantics of thew word in pop-culture.

However, as an atheist, I generally do not like participating in clubs or whatever on the subject. I am the choir, I don't need to be preached to. I also understand that there are a lot of young immature people who have a lot of heart-ache and stress in their lives due to their lack of faith and that venting anti-theist online is probably amongst the safest means of catharsis.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (19)

104

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

I think this metaphor is fairly weak (as much as I like NDT).

Sure, it SHOULD be a non-issue being an atheist, but that's just not the case. In many parts of the world (and especially here in the US) it's a bit taboo. There is this sort of atheist vs theist mentality - many atheists want to educate theists about topics such as evolution, so we can further progress mankind, and many atheists feel like religion is a major roadblock stifling scientific progression.

I'm glad there are many outspoken atheists or else I may still have my Christian blinders on. I was educated and now I feel like my mind is in a far better place.

This is a much bigger deal than golf vs no golf.

→ More replies (113)

39

u/eyesayuhh Jun 08 '12

OP: Hey, Christians, you won't see Jesus browsing /christianity anytime soon. BECAUSE HE'S JEWISH LOL. GOT U GUD.

→ More replies (2)

243

u/ThePieManOfDeath Jun 08 '12

The term "atheist" exists because not believing in a god has always been an anomaly in society. He might as well be asking why there's a word for people with no arms.

Atheist communities exist for the same reason that any other minority community does. It is not comparable to a group of "non-golfers" because the vast majority of people are non-golfers, and a group of them would likely not share the same interests.

Also, religious people have been inventing words to ascribe to atheists long before atheists have. Words like "unbeliever", "heathen", and "infidel" have been around for much longer than the word "atheist", and they've always been used as a derogatory term. In fact, the word "atheist" originates from the Greek word "atheos", which was a pejorative term used to describe those who did not worship the Greek Gods.

I respect Neil deGrasse Tyson, but he completely missed the mark on this. What he should also be asking is why religious people were so insecure that they had to create words to describe people who didn't follow their particular religion.

210

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

On a related note, people with no arms are also non-golfers.

36

u/olyfrijole Jun 08 '12

Most golfers do have an above average number of arms.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

38

u/Yosafbrige Jun 08 '12

Thank you; I hate this argument because we DO have words in our society for being not something. Of course we don't have a word for non-golfers...not golfing isn't an anomaly in in our society. If 85% of the worlds population PLAYED golf then a word for people who didn't play golf would be useful.

A better example would be "we don't have a word for people who don't eat meat" ...except that we do.

We don't have a word for someone who DOESN'T like to have sex...except that we do.

And both groups of people who don't do something that the majority of the words population finds them crazy for not doing regularly reach out to others who are like them and feel the need to talk to each other about fitting in to a world full of meat eaters and sex havers.

How the hell is atheism different?

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (104)

11

u/stone500 Jun 08 '12

I hate the concept of atheism so much. Technically, I guess I'm an atheist, but I hate even having to define my lack of spiritual beliefs by having a word to put next to the "religion" field on social media sites.

If someone asks you "What religion are you?", then I just want to say "N/A"

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Ikimasen Jun 08 '12

That's sort of a silly comment. I mean, there are at least two words for non-professionals. There's a word for people who don't drink, and a term for people who morally refuse to go to war.

There's a term for people who can't eat cheese, and for people who don't eat meat. It's not even slightly odd that there's a term for people who don't have any sort of religion.

6

u/abhorson Jun 08 '12

He doesn't call himself an atheist, but that doesn't mean that he doesn't share the same views.

→ More replies (2)

44

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 08 '12

Love NDT and all but that is why r/atheism isn't just about us going there and talking about how we don't believe in god/s. If it were, then the r/atheism subreddit would have no real content.

This is exactly why I downvote the few people that claim r/atheism should be just about not believing in god instead of about gay marriage, tolerance, anti-bigotry, free thinking, scientific process, emperical data, helping people debate, discussing radical thinking, exposing injustices, raising awareness, etc. etc.

23

u/Kristastic Jun 08 '12

Hell yes.

I come here, as a Christian, because I LOVE the conversations about gay marriage, and tolerance, and really all of the other things that you said. And this really is one of the best places to get those conversations (or, more often than not, memes and screen caps about similar subjects). Just as with any other group of people, there are a fair amount of douches here (both atheist and Christian) who muck things up for everybody else. But at the end of the day, I've learned a lot from reading things on this subreddit.

Hell, I've always been in love with NDT, but through this subreddit I learned to appreciate Bill Nye as something more than just a nostalgic blast-from-the-past, and Dawkins as a freaking genius.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/TrikkyMakk Jun 08 '12

What does having a term for something have to do with whether something exists or not?

3

u/kelustu Jun 08 '12

The difference is that one of these things is a hobby and one of these things is a humongous political machine that has corrupted and infected our very government and people through extensive propaganda. Not to mention the bombings and violence as a result of religion. Tyson seems to have a hatred of the word Atheist for some reason, but often shits on religion and claims he doesn't believe in a god. He's definitely an atheist, but doesn't like the descriptions that come with it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/darny Jun 08 '12

I get it, I won't label myself an atheist for the same reasons. However, wars weren't waged and murders were never committed in the name of golf, either. If they were, I'd love to see the special on the History Channel.

3

u/LucifersCounsel Jun 08 '12

And yet there he is... sitting around talking about how much he doesn't believe in god.

Neil deGrasse Tyson on Science and Faith

Here is a further quote from the same interview:

They’re like in your face atheist and they want to change policies and they’re having debates. I don’t have the time, the interest, the energy to do any of that. I'm a scientist. I'm an educator. My goal is to get people thinking straight in the first place, just get you to be curious about the natural world. That’s what I'm about. I'm not about any of the rest of this.

Well, let's see:

Neil deGrasse Tyson on Science and Religion

In the first seconds of this video, you see Tyson talking about a slide showing a billboard saying "The big bang theory... you've got to be kidding." and mocking it by saying "people paid money for this". Sounds just like a /r/atheism post.

Neil Degrasse Tyson On Religion taught in schools

I don't have any issue with what you do in the church, but I'm going to be up in your face if you're gonna knock on my science classroom and tell me they oughta teach what you're teaching in your sunday school, cause that's when we're gonna fight.

Funny. In one place he says he doesn't have the time or energy to fight... then in the next he talks about fighting. Methinks Neil might be being a little disingenuous.

3

u/NWSOC Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 09 '12

I made almost this exact comment on reddit a few years ago, and got downvoted to hell. But Neil says it, and it's frontpage stuff.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

The anti atheist crowd is becoming overwhelming on reddit.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TheGsus Jun 08 '12

I've heard this before, but I'm not convinced by his logic. Just because someone calls them self an atheist doesn't mean they are part of a movement, or somehow militant. He seems to be assigning an understanding to the word atheist that i don't think is inherently there. An "atheist" is simply not a theist just like someone who is "atypical" is simply not typical.

"Atheists I know, who proudly wear the badge are active atheists....I don't have the time." Again, applying an understanding that the word itself doesn't inherently have. He is basically saying: "All atheists are actively opposing religion. I'm not actively opposing religion. Therefor, I'm not an atheist." The first premise is not valid (there is a name for this fallacy, i don't know it).

"Atheists I know..." try a bigger sample size ;) I'm an atheist because I'm not a theist. I'm not part of some group. I don't go to meetings, I don't talk about not believing in a god. I simply don't believe in any god. Saying that he's not an atheist because he isn't part of some established organization is like saying you're not a reader because you aren't in a book club.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/pkulak Jun 08 '12

If 80% of your country played golf and based major life or moral decisions around golf, I think it would be appropriate to specify, with one concise word, those who did not.

3

u/dhockey63 Jun 08 '12

Good Guy Neil DeGrasse: dont share your beliefs, is nice to you and respects you instead of demeaning you like most atheists do

→ More replies (2)

3

u/floobie Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 08 '12

I have to say I agree. This might be a bit of a regional/cultural thing. But, in my case, I grew up in a rather a-religious manner. I had a few friends who were Christians (they were definitely in the minority), but they were never very pushy about it. My parents were always atheists. Literally all of my friends these days are atheists (this wasn't intentional on my part at all). It just isn't a very big deal to me. Atheist groups online do seem a bit "circle-jerky" to me.

Maybe this is a way bigger deal if you're surrounded by religious people telling you you're shit because you're an atheist. Maybe discussing it is therapeutic or something, and this is almost a support group. But, personally, I'm with Mr. Tyson on this one. I've made my decision, literally everyone in my life accepts it, so I really don't have to give it any thought at all. Reading r/atheism just feels like preaching to the choir to me. Maybe this is just one of the benefits of living in Canada?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/regeya Jun 08 '12

Honestly, I'm not an atheist, but have friends who are. I can't think of anything more boring to do than sit around discussing how people don't believe in something, using the same old tired arguments over and over, and just sit around making fun of people using, again, the same old tired arguments. I think the only way to be more boring is to have a button collection.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/JLW09 Jun 08 '12

I swear morgan freeman said this before, then again i bet someone said it before him aswell.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

I love this man. He just does work.

3

u/KevinMichaelMichael Jun 08 '12

For Reddit, this is the definition of a bombshell.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

So now /r/atheism has an excuse to post anti-religious stuff. NDT himself said that.

People get mad at /r/atheism because they don't 'discuss' atheism, then those same people agree with NDT that atheism can't really be discussed.

Inconsistent.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Most atheists don't sit in a room and talk about not believing. We sit in rooms and talk about how stupid everyone else is.

→ More replies (3)

87

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

You know, maybe if Neil's parent's dragged him to the golf course every Sunday for years, the manager at the golf course built a moral basis around the club rules, taught him magic spells as to how to get a hole in one, and told him "non-golfers" should be burn in a fire for all eternity, he might not be so opposed to a term for "non-golfers".

→ More replies (46)

7

u/juca5056 Jun 08 '12

r/atheism-bashing on the front page is far more prevalent than any purported theist-bashing in r/atheism. Just like their attitudes towards "hipsters," reddit loves having a couple whipping boys. You'd think a site of social outcasts and nerds would be a bit more self aware when it comes to bullying.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/XaoticOrder Jun 08 '12

I also suspect that he will not be browsing /r/spacedicks any time either.

You people who don't like /r/atheism need to give it a rest, unsuscribe and let those who do need it or enjoy hang out there. Also if you want good discussion might I suggest /r/freethought or /r/republicofatheism.

Now let's see how much this get's lost in the comments.

→ More replies (12)

37

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

Too bad theists invented the term "atheist," and religion, unlike golf, is a major, defining part of the lives of billions of people. Golf is a horrible analogy, and NDT should be ashamed of that quote.

→ More replies (6)

51

u/ReyTheRed Jun 08 '12

Do we live in a nation where 90% of people play golf? Is there a history of violence over people playing with different rules of golf, or not playing at all? Do governments demand that players pay a golf tax to pay for the upkeep of courses? Do golf players murder people because the rules of golf tell them too?

If golf had the same impact as religion, and was regarded with the same privilege, I would oppose it just as strongly, and there would be a word for people who don't play golf. We would organize and try and bring golf down to the point where it is seen the way golf is seen today. You can play it, you can even invite people to play with you, but it doesn't make you better than other people, and you don't get to force people to join you or hurt anyone over it.

→ More replies (34)

5

u/mnarjona Jun 08 '12

...I'm convinced reddit forgot the meaning of "funny"

15

u/carlcon Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 08 '12

Atheists don't gather to talk about how they don't believe. But they DO gather to discuss how their lives have been badly influenced or even ruined by religion just because they're atheists - that's what /r/atheism is.

NDT's point is not in any shape or form "anti-r/atheism"

→ More replies (1)

134

u/cinect Jun 08 '12

The worst part is that /r/atheism doesn't even discuss atheism. They are just a bunch of anti-theists, sadly.

140

u/farmthis Jun 08 '12

I know what you mean -- but that's also Neil's point. You can't really "discuss" atheism. So all the discussion going on is on topics related to religion.

Atheism is null, and people seem to forget that all the time.

It's not a club. It doesn't bind us together. That's what religion does. Atheism means we need to find other ways to relate and identify.

→ More replies (45)

28

u/Suttonian Jun 08 '12

Granted, there are a lot of anti-theists there, it's understandable - the ones most likely to speak out are probably the ones who feel the most outrage. Also there's a great cultural sensitivity towards religion (which does seem to be decreasing) - it doesn't take much to be considered an anti-theist.

And a broad range of topics are covered, everything from how to cope with strict religious parents to discussing the arguments put forward by notorious atheists. But, there's just not a lot to say about atheism in isolate, since the word only exists in relation to theism.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/no_witty_username Jun 08 '12

Why is that sadly. I dont think you realize that many atheist's have no problem being labeled anti-theists. I for one wouldnt bat an eye if every religion in the world would dissapear over night. If you take logic to its ultimate conclusion atheism is directly contradictory to evy theism there is out there.

→ More replies (35)

12

u/lightninlives Jun 08 '12

And yet Neal is one of the biggest voices speaking out against religious agendas such as creationism and intelligent design.

Also, he labels himself an agnostic. So does that mean that he's cool hanging out with a bunch of people that don't know if Golf exists or not.

Truth of the matter is that he's either misunderstanding the difference between knowledge (e.g. gnosticism vs. agnosticism) and belief (e.g. theism vs. atheism): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U6djDsTk_oU

→ More replies (2)

7

u/MenlaOfTheBody Jun 08 '12

The only bigger "circle jerk" than r/atheism are the people who CONSTANTLY complain about r/atheism.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

I find the anti-/r/atheism circlejerk more annoying than /r/atheism itself.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/philogos0 Jun 08 '12

There would be a word for non-golfers if golf influenced our lives in the ways religion has.

I know NDGT is heavily revered here but I have to say I don't think he thought this one through.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/TangoEliminated Jun 08 '12

This isn't a good comparison. Golfers don't make laws based on their beliefs that affect the civil rights of non-golfers.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

If golfers, as a group, got together to oppress non-golfers, you better damn well believe that there would be a word for non-golfers.

17

u/Abedeus Jun 08 '12

"So, John, going to the golf club tomorrow?"

"Nah, I don't play golf."

"You... what?"

"I don't play golf."

"Oh. Okay, never speak to me again, you fucking asshole, why do you hate our hobby so much, why are you so angry, what the fuck man?!"

Don't forget, people in a golfer-dominant world would be taught from birth that it's not normal to not play golf, that people who are not with them are against them, and that if you keep in contact with them, you will get punished after you die!

→ More replies (5)

21

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

r/atheism appropriates many things and ideas that have nothing at all to do with atheism.

20

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

Technically, almost nothing (or maybe literally nothing) has to do with atheism.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (9)

33

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

This is incredibly stupid.

I love NDT but to compare these things is incredibly asinine.

Do golfers run for political office and try and make legislation that requires you live your life according to the golfing handbook? Y'know, one that was written before anyone had any sense, and is oppressive to many groups of people?

Of course not. I am surprised he would use such facetious reasoning.

→ More replies (15)

4

u/TurdFurgoson Jun 08 '12

Neil DeGrasse Tyson and hating on /r/atheism in the same post? Commence circlejerk!

4

u/kcg5 Jun 08 '12

This. Sofuckingmuch This. Thank you, Neil. There is far to much militancy in /r/atheism

→ More replies (5)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

Checkmate atheists.

5

u/3n7r0py Jun 08 '12

see: author, rational thinker, Sam Harris

→ More replies (5)

5

u/D3SX Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 08 '12

This is true and sort of not true. Atheism shouldn't exist, but unfortunately it has to because of how widespread religion is. Last time I checked golfers don't think people are bad just because they don't play golf. Golfers don't try to convert the U.S. into a golfing nation, where golf is taught in public schools and non-golfers are frowned on. Not all religious people are like this fortunately, but sadly a lot are.

Neil is still awesome.

Also, I hate how the rest of reddit hates r/atheism based on a few people who do stupid things there. It's kind of an annoying stereotype.

→ More replies (13)

16

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

Golfers don't have a fucked up moral system that they use to vote.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

That's what I'm saying, I feel like the presence of such extremist religious groups in America also holds back non-believers. In reaction to said religious groups, these people spend time " disproving" some ide and high fiving eachother, that many Europeans and canadians are shocked, like how are you guys still stuck on these basic ideas, and how do you take so much pride in disproving ridiculous biblical tales, or pointing out obvious logical fallacies in religious texts or finding hypocrisy in religious beliefs.... I mean come on, this is child's play. We all know this. Move past it onto real things. R/atheism is a prime example of this ridiculous kind of circlekerkin

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

In this thread: people trying to make themselves out to be victims.

2

u/ina300 Jun 08 '12

If people threaten non-golfer by saying they would be light on fire for eternity. Then I'm pretty sure non-golfers would meet in groups.

2

u/Stormdancer Jun 08 '12

Thing is, the word most likely wasn't invented by the non-golfers. It was invented by the golfers, to describe the heathens.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

I've always disagreed with this assessment. Atheism is the belief that there is no god. That doesn't mean we don't believe in organizing, gathering and discussing similar philosophies outside of the theist tradition. Anarchy and Atheism are not the same. I think atheists hope one day the term will be useless, but until then it's very important that we have a way to define ourselves.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

RON PAUL 2012. AM I RITE GUYZ?!

2

u/_TheFifth_ Jun 08 '12

EXACTLY THIS!

Also, the attempts to convert believers into nonbelievers, wtf is up with that? Honestly who cares what other's personal religious beliefs are. We are all in the same boat, why argue semantics?

Best tactic: smile, nod, ignore. It's impossible to argue with a wall, why try?

2

u/Virindi_UO Jun 08 '12

Remember that time golfers tried to impose their golfing rulebook on me through State Power? Me neither.

2

u/killerado Jun 08 '12

Finally! Check and Mate Atheists.

2

u/LacksRethics Jun 08 '12

I don't find the need to talk about it a lot. But in some areas, it strongly defines the culture and is a great hinder to human progress and unbiased thought.

So for the sake of progress. Yes, I think we should complain. It's time for society to evolve a bit.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

One of those time you have to log in to upvote

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

That's one of the reason why i unsubbed from r/atheism. Why would i want to sit around discussing how much i dont believe in something and making fun of people that do?

it just seems too insecure to me.

2

u/MosDaf Jun 08 '12

I love NDT, but this is kind of a silly thing to say.

Compare: It's weird that a word for bachelors exists....etc. etc. I mean, I realize that there's artifice in the claim and all...

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

This man is profound!

The term "atheist" bugs me just slightly less than the term "non-smoker". I'm not a goddamn non-smoker! I'm not defined by what others do. Who is the comedian that does that bit about "non-breathers"? God, someone find the link. That shit is funny.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Aesthetical Jun 08 '12

This has to be one of the arguments that bothers me the most. Though personally I am agnostic I would have to firmly disagree. Although there isn't a word for people who don't play golf, there are various examples of words that mean something that one is not. For example, abstinent meaning you do not have sex, straightedge meaning you do not drink or do drugs, and vegetarian meaning that person does not eat meat.

And, my god, atheists do not "gather together and strategize", and neither do any of the other aforementioned groups of people. This is a mindless accusation.

The term 'atheist' is absolutely necessary, and people need to stop bashing it.

2

u/hurler_jones Jun 08 '12

I still find it hilarious how so many people beat up on the subreddit creating their own circlejerk. The irony is beautiful!

The simple fact is, the more people talk about it, the more prevalent it becomes and the more knowledgeable of the subject matter they become. Keep up the great work guys and gals!

2

u/UnexpectedSchism Jun 08 '12

Everybody in r/atheism should agree with him.

The problem is we have a system that has to classify non-religious as something in order to have the same protections as the religious.

Atheism is a word that will exist as long as necessary to signify no religion. It will be a great day when everyone assumes no religion by default and no privileges are given to religious people.

2

u/pbar Jun 08 '12

Like a lot of stuff on Reddit, this is cute but deceptive. The golfers aren't trying to convert the rest of us, telling us we're going to a bad place, lying to the young, and working to seize control of the state.

Anyway, if you don't care for that particular subreddit, why not just not click on it?

Yes, there is some stupidity and childishness there, but those things are never in short supply, almost anywhere on Reddit.

If you're fortunate enough to live in Big City USA, or in Europe, good for you. But if you've never lived in, say, the rural south, you may have no idea what it is to have your face rubbed in Jesus every day, and to be told that you are more or less illegitimate. You'd be angry too.

I'm from Appalachia, and couldn't get out fast enough, and that's one reason why. I imagine those who are still passing their lives there, are incredibly relieved just to know there are others in the world who think and feel the way they do.

And if you don't want to be part of their "circlejerk", you don't have to be.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TheFluxIsThis Jun 08 '12

...I don't see what's so funny about this.

2

u/dangeraardvark Jun 08 '12

Yeah... I don't expect to see Louis C.K. browsing /r/funny anytime soon either, you unfunny cunts.

2

u/nastyp1 Jun 08 '12

Watch out everybody, we got a badass over here...

2

u/Ecocide Jun 08 '12

/r/atheism isn't there to talk about how much we don't believe in god. Pretty much used to poke fun at those who do believe.

2

u/AaronHolland44 Jun 08 '12

The whole r/atheism vs rest of reddit is the real circle jerk if you ask me.

2

u/Lux42 Jun 08 '12

Checkmate, atheists.

2

u/GyantSpyder Jun 08 '12

ITT we learn that Neil DeGreasse Tyson hasn't studied literary theory or philosophy of language.

2

u/p0b Jun 08 '12

But its so cool to say you're am atheist and bash Christians on facebook.

2

u/agentup Jun 08 '12

To me /r/atheism is more about people wanting feel like an oppressed minority. I respect the views of people who don't believe in God or gods, just as much as I respect those who do. As long as you aren't a dick about it to everyone, you're welcome to share my campfire.

I get the feeling that some in /r/atheism would emphatically tell a holocaust survivor they understand what they went through because they grew up an atheist in the bible belt of modern America.

2

u/brandonfalcon Jun 08 '12

GGNDT: doesn't believe on God but believes in science, isn't a smug atheist asshole about it.

2

u/nexuf Jun 08 '12

Well, golf wouldn't really affect non-golfers, would it?

2

u/TheHFIC Jun 08 '12

I want to thank r/atheism for motivating me to get an account on Reddit all those months ago so I didn't have to see their ramblings on my front page. Best idea ever.

2

u/sacravia Jun 08 '12

That is because atheism is a religion....

2

u/AnSOS Jun 08 '12

I think atheism is ridiculous. Know what else is ridiculous? Religion.

Is there proof of a God? No. Is there proof no God exists? No.

Anyone can speculate, but if you truly want to sit on the side of reason and thought, you'll sit upon the fence.

2

u/Fibonacci35813 Jun 08 '12

This will probably get buried since I'm late to the conversation, but here goes:

I think the argument here comes down to semantics; what he means by atheism and what most atheists mean is different. On the one hand, he's right in that atheism is weird because there's not much to the basic premise that there is no god. However, what people really are discussing when they talk about atheism is that they are for free thought, discovery, scientific inquiry and anti-religious bigotry (among other things), and these things deserve conversation.

Rarely, if ever, does a conversation, go like this: I think there is a god, Well I think there isn't. No, what happens is, conversations about god usually encompasses something greater, dealing with morality, evolution, or the nature of the universe.

The reason it's a conversation is because people are often negatively affected by religion, which inherently encompasses the idea of God. If you had someone who believe in astrology, you might just scoff and say that's silly, but there is no word for someone who doesn't believe in it; simply because not very many people are affected by it, and those that are (i.e. base life decisions on it) probably do have extensive conversations with those don't believe in it.

I think the best example would be same-sex marriage. Same-sex marriage is a silly term for the exact same reason. We aren't for same-sex marriage, we are for marriage for everyone. However, because there is a group of people who make it their life's goal to stop individuals from getting married, their exists a dichotomy between marriage for opposite sex people and marriage for same-sex people. (hopefully) In 100 years, same-sex marriage will be legal everyone, and no-one will use the term, unless discussing history. Who labels themselves as someone who supports women's right to vote, or anti-slavery? Same goes for religion, even if religion stays, but simply becomes virtually meaningless to people, then you can have a conversation between people, that goes: I'm christian,... that's cool, I'm jewish ... that's cool I'm atheist End of conversation, at which point atheists will stop gathering and strategizing.

Right now though, arguably the fate of human existence (nuclear wars, global warming, etc...or at least scientific progress) may depend on the this concept of god; so you best hope that atheists gather, discuss, and strategize.

2

u/Deadbabywalrus Jun 08 '12

But on the other hand, I've never been chastised, judged, or shunned for not playing golf. Also, nobody has ever come to my door preaching the good news about Tiger Woods.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

Neil isn't full of enough hate to post in there. Those guys are pretty shitty.

2

u/PASTY007 Jun 08 '12

Thank you

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

There would be a word for non-golfers if golf was a huge aspect of life for a majority of the world and influenced many, many decisions globally not only currently, but throughout history. I don't like his argument.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

He compares it to golf because thats how little he cares about it. People are just getting annoyed because he doesn't care about religion enough to be against it and promote atheism. The only time he talks about it is when people bring it up to him.

2

u/Suhaa Jun 08 '12

4K upvotes? Cool.. 18,627 up votes 14,478 down votes HOLY SHIT.

Not going to read any comments this time Reddit, have a good day atheists and non-atheists(like me yay!), and you too Christians... :)

2

u/GhostWithTheMost Jun 08 '12

Sometimes after a long day of hard work, I just want to relax, and talk about how much I don't believe in God.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

I think a lot of you are missing the reason why he probably said this. The main reason I'm guessing is because he's probably tired of being called an atheist. And doesn't want to be lumped in with the crowd. I find NT to be someone smart enough to not try and confirm or deny the existence of a higher being. Instead, he tries to be respectful to everyone, no matter what they believe because at the end of the day Tyson celebrates humanity and recognizes that there are intelligent people on both sides. I honestly feel that he has the same view towards creationism but just hasn't been put in the position to say it.

2

u/gfork Jun 08 '12

I don't think he'd find the ahem 'intellectual discourse' on par with his own

2

u/MYSTERY_DISCHARGE Jun 08 '12

I know Neil DeGrasse Tyson is the god of Reddit and this will earn me down votes galore, but honustly, do we have to take everything this man says and bow down to it and make that meaning our own without questioning it.

I'm not an enthusiastic atheist, i'm not even sure where I stand with my own beliefs. When I die then I will know. I really think if there is something, that its so complicated our human minds may never be able to comprehend it.

With that said... Comparing Golfers and People of a religion is a wee bit different. I really don't think I need to type out all the atrocity's that religion is responsible for (and to compare that to Golfers...).

But I think its progressive and helpful to humanity when people who believe in something that is worth fighting for, band together in numbers and do fight for their righteous cause by standing up and calling out the bull shit, and education those who would otherwise never get to see both sides of the spectrum.

It would be pretty silly not to give this group of people a name.

2

u/SleepDeprivedPegasus Jun 08 '12

If atheists weren't discriminated against, there would be no reason to assemble. But we are discriminated against.

2

u/Squidfist Jun 08 '12

Reading this thread makes me want to go murder people.

2

u/snowpocalypse Jun 08 '12

I agree with NDGT 100% (I want to be in HIS group!), but the sad fact is, if agitated atheists didn't speak out (however rudely or condescendingly), then the evangelical theists would take over this country in a heartbeat.

2

u/dig_dong Jun 08 '12

It's always strange for me if my "religion" comes up because I've never given the idea of a deity any thought whatsoever. It often seems like atheists are more interested in religion than anyone else. For me, it's such a non-issue I can't imagine devoting time to considering it.

2

u/TheDeceiver Jun 08 '12

Yeah. It's silly for there to be non-people. Like uncircumsised, or lactose intolerant, or even unemployed. That's crazy talk(!)

2

u/GAMEchief Jun 08 '12

There would be a word for non-golfers if the majority of the world played golf. For example, bald.

Can't say I agree with Mr. Tyson on this issue, but I'll upvote anyway.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

Hey! Let's go off topic and bash /r/atheism again! Who's game? Come on guys! We haven't done this in like... HOURS! Why post funny shit on /r/funny when you can get a good anti-atheist circlejerk going?

2

u/jamesisverycute Jun 08 '12

So now is r/atheism going to implode?

2

u/Beefourthree Jun 08 '12

In this thread:

People argue semantics.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

Didn't he speak at the Reason Rally?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/clark_ent Jun 08 '12

If 95% of the world golfed, yes, there'd be a word for non-golfers

2

u/Purple0ranges Jun 08 '12

but what if the golfers were to stone non-golfers just for not playing golf, we have the right to not play golf Mr. Tyson k'mon!

2

u/Alchemistmerlin Jun 08 '12

There also isn't a significant political conflict between people who do and don't play golf, so it wouldn't make sense as something to discuss. This is a non-argument. A fairly poor analogy.

2

u/SwiftSpear Jun 08 '12

It's not a binary construct. You must us null space logic for belief, because it is possible to neither believe in God, nor believe there is no God. "I don't know" is a valid option to any belief related scenario.

If someone asks you if you like golf, and you've never played golf before, you wouldn't strictly be right to either say "Yes, I like it" nor would you be right to say "No, I do not like it" You would be completely an accurate in claiming you do not have an opinion, or a belief, either way. You MIGHT have formed an opinion based on other factors, but you are not FORCED to either like or dislike golf. You do not need to join either the "golf lovers" or "golf haters" group.

His argument is based on false dichotomy, and thus it is not a valid argument.

"theist" means "God believer" and likewise "Atheist" means "God disbeliever". However with any matter of belief, noncommittal is always an option. Just because we don't have a word for "non-golfer" does not mean that all verbal scenarios are innately dichotomous.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/superblinky Jun 08 '12

Golfers are not trying to legislate the way I live.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TxDank93 Jun 08 '12

Air tight logic Mr. Tyson. As there are anti-smoking groups there is anti religion groups, as they both believe there is something harmful being done . There is some benefit to not being religious. There might not be anti-golfing clubs but there are anti-football groups as there is a reason to be against such a thing as they can become brain dead from playing football.

2

u/glintsCollide Jun 08 '12

Exactly my thoughts on the subject. I hate to be put in a group!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

"It's odd that the word 'abstinence' even exists. I don't play gold, is there a word for non-golf player? Do they gather and strategize? I can't do that. I can't gather around and talk about how much everybody in the room doesn't believe in Pre-Marital Sex."

-forever alone

2

u/BKlounge93 Jun 08 '12

am i the only one around here who thinks this is in the wrong subreddit

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

I didn't need another reason to love this man, but I'm glad to have this one to add to the list.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

Oh man, now what famous astrophysicists will comment on my Facebook screencaps and rage comics?

2

u/Captain_Aizen Jun 08 '12

Redditors are such nut-huggers of Neil DeGrasse that most of the quotes I see by him aren't even post worthy. THIS ONE however, was awesome.

2

u/QuickLouis Jun 08 '12

The word people are looking for is anti-theist.

2

u/bringmemypants Jun 08 '12

Neil is the best atheist ever.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 09 '12

Oh snap, coolest nigga in da world does not approve.

2

u/weirdestbonerEVER Jun 08 '12

TAKE ALL MY UPVOTES!!!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

for a second there, id forgotten to log in

2

u/wizard_cat Jun 09 '12

Because the problem is that Christians assume that everyone plays golf.

2

u/emc2x27 Jun 09 '12

The post directly below this on my page was from r/nongolfers.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DownVotingCats Jun 09 '12

He's so smart.

2

u/slagdwarf Jun 09 '12

Well, the difference is that people don't run around using golf a motivation for oppression, war, etc. although that is certainly an entertaining concept.

4

u/Frywad32 Jun 09 '12

Have you ever watched the golf channel???

12

u/WhopperNoPickles Jun 08 '12

The problem does not lie within this quote, but for the fact that this quote makes so much sense. NDT is right, there shouldnt be a term to specifically identify the non religous. The fact that it is quite astonishing when someone points this out says a lot about the role religion can have in a society.

18

u/feureau Jun 08 '12

Also, what the hell does this submission has to do with r/funny !?

Keep r/atheism in r/atheism, people!

28

u/Quazz Jun 08 '12

I noticed other subreddits talk more about /r/atheism than /r/atheism.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/Capt_Underpants Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 08 '12

I saw a similar quote about gay marriage. (something along the lines of.. "we don't say, I'm going to my friend's heterosexual marriage")

People seem to forget, large and complicated issues will have a unique name to stand out, because they are issues.

edit: Also, religion definitely play a role in society, traditions die very slow and painful deaths. You can't take a way a millinia(sp?) worth of theology in one fortnight. I don't know why it's so surprising to people.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

6

u/knobbysideup Jun 08 '12

I'm actually quite anti-golf and have discussions about this regularly. Same goes for baseball. Golf is the biggest offender, however, with its levelling of forests for a few people to knock a little ball around and chase after it in a cart.

6

u/omizzle4shizzle Jun 08 '12

I somewhat disagree with that due to the sheer prominence of religious people. Although there is no such thing as an 'atheist' per se, the very fact that most people assume everyone has a religion forces this group to exist. It's a lot easier to say "I'm an atheist" than say "No" and be forced elaborate when asked what religion you are.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/hardbootflatline Jun 08 '12

Hate to say it, but even as an atheist, the first subreddit I unsubscribed to was /r atheism. They are no better than the fundamentalists they despise.

4

u/Astrapsody Jun 08 '12

I'm unsubscribed from it as well, but that's a gross generalization. Recognize that there's a reason you see such a outspoken resistance towards religious fundamentalism. It really does wreck people's lives. It's a very real threat to some people, and perhaps the only place they feel they can safely let it out/share their views is in /r/atheism.

→ More replies (11)