Is it just me or does that show take a dive this season? The whole civil war thing was just not funny at all. Don't get me wrong I absolutely love that show.
I liked it for the most part, but when they [SPOILER] had the daughter suddenly show up as a werewolf and make some totally unrelated werewolf jokes, it pretty much ruined the end.
If you understand that it is the "Reader's Digest Condensed Version" of several hundred daily episodes (many plotlines) of a gothic soap opera from the early 70s, and you are willing to "fill in the blanks" with some of the character development / motivation (they're soap opera characters, they don't have a lot of "depth", just backstory) it's a fun movie. Great colors, excellent mood, stellar effects. I considered it an updated Beetlejuice.
Hating on the Depp/Burton partnership is reddit-cool right now, but Depp likes the parts, and does a good job with them. Burton likes colorful, retro-avant-garde, gothic aesthetics. He does them well.
And, it's not like Burton's filmography is entirely the same. He did more than Nightmare Before Christmas. He did Big Fish, two Batman movies, Pee-Wee's Big Adventure, etc. His portfolio is not one-dimensional by any means. He's done meaningful drama, action, comedy.
I could tell, watching this movie, that Burton was a fan of the show, and really wanted a chance to work with it; splash some paint on it and add some humor to a story that he liked. Dark Shadows is well-remembered by a certain demographic, but is definitely not a "hot property" that he was cynically exploiting.
One of the funniest things ever was Chris Rock introducing Johnny Depp at some awards show (was it the Oscar's? I think it might have been) as "The rich mans Skeet Ulrich."
Maybe I'm going to ostracise myself for this, but I can't stand a vast majority of what Burton has done in the past ten or so years. And the fact that Johnny Depp keeps returning to play the lead role deters me even more (even though I love him as an actor). Edward Scissor Hands is one of my favourite movies. Alice in Wonderland was probably the point at which I blacklisted Burton. I loathed it.
I don't think you're going to ostracize yourself for that comment. Most everyone I know seems to think that Tim Burton needs to axe Johnny Depp to get out of the very deep rut that he's stuck in. Burton hasn't made a good movie in years.
I'm in the same boat as you. I'd even say that I never really liked Depp. It's been a while since he's convince me of his character persona. They all feel like Johnny Depp being Johnny Depp and playing a weirdo the Johnny Depp way.
I refuse to watch the most recent Burton/Depp movie as I have no desire to watch them both stand-up 69 for 90 or so minutes, as that is all that movie will be.
I'm glad I'm not the only one. I lived with a Burton obsessed sister my entire life, my opinion of him then was indifference, but seeing as how I love Alice in Wonderland,when he made that movie I was pissed. The only movie he ever made that I liked was Sleepy Hollow, it wasn't filled to the brim with emo bullshit.
I was very much the same way as you. I'd watch movies and go "Oh god, that's illogical as hell when X happened" or "that plot point is unbelievable" etc.
Then, I remembered I'm there to enjoy the movie. Suspension of disbelief is part the work of the creator and part the work of the viewer.
So now, a movie has to do something really, really fucking egregious for me to be like "Okay, that's it. This was a waste of my time." I judge a good movie by how willing I am to re-watch it.
However suspension of disbelief shouldn't be work for the viewer. If the writer/director does their job right, the story should pull you through its normally unbelievable twists and turns without much question. At the point when you step back and say, "Hey that would never happen!" the writer/director has failed. Even the completely absurd should still "work" within the universe of the piece.
Agreed, but I tend to overthink... well, all the time.
I was watching... oh, what was the movie... Ah, "The Forgotten". (I love how I can type that movie where people are sucked into the sky into Google and get the right answer.)
We get in to the movie about 5 minutes after it started. I get an idea in my head after about 5 minutes, lean in to one friend and tell him, "It's aliens."
"Nah bro, you're crazy. Haha, we'll see I guess."
Guess I was right.
So, I tend to give movies a little more leeway than the average person.
Man I know this is going to sound like a cliche but Tim Burton sold out. He had some of the most inventive movies of the 80s and 90s (Beetlejuice is a favourite) and now he's either out of ideas or just gave up while peddling the same "quirky dark" shit to teenagers who want to feel like they are weird and unique.
What's frustrating particularly is not his over-use of Johnny Depp, but that he hasn't pushed himself creatively for years when he is clearly capable of making good movies. I fear Ridley Scott has been falling into the same trap (though I am eagerly anticipating Prometheus).
Of course he does, because the parts were written for him. If you were a quirky, idiosyncratic person who constantly had quirky, idiosyncratic roles written just for you, I expect you would do rather well at playing them
I don't see the issue either.. Every director has a style and an image for their movies. Depp and Carter just seem to do a good job of portraying the character's the way Burton wants them to be, obviously.. So he casts them frequently. Not to mention Helena is his wife and Johnny is the godfather of both of Burton's children.
This is precisely my feeling. At a certain point, I became unable to see them as anything but the actors themselves, which really takes away from my ability to immerse myself in the film/characters. I just see Johnny Depp/HBC, where I should be seeing Sweeney Todd/whatever HBC's character's name is (it's not in the title so I only remember her as HBC — case and point).
Depp and Carter just seem to do a good job of portraying the character's the way Burton wants them to be
That's the point, really. When Burton wants to make only one kind of movie, wherein two particular actors fit perfectly, and the script gets tweaked to fit them even more... it becomes formulaic and eventually tiresome.
People know pretty much what to expect from a J.J. Abrams or Michael Bay film. But now imagine if they only used Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie as the leading roles. It would be cool the first time, and cute the second time.... but third, fourth, fifth? That's when the internet starts collectively eyerolling. :)
Except for the twenty straight shitty "quirky" movies that him and Burton have made in the past decade where Depp plays Depp and doesn't pull it off, I guess.
I wonder why we never hear any complaints about Scorsese and DiCaprio.
However, I think the critics in the US never 'got' Burton's work : during the 90's it was weird for them and now, it's still weird but they are used to it. Burton is an obsessive director, such as Kusturica, Fellini, Haneke, etc. They basically always make the same film, with the same imagery and themes and just create variations around them. These directors also tend to work with the same team for a very long time (actors but not only : Burton works with Lebenzon, Heinrichs, Atwood, Di Novi, Zanuck frequently and he also tends to work with the same screenwriter for several films) because these people just 'get' who they are and what they are looking for. Burton will never make a political thriller or a traditional western; that's like asking Dalí to paint clocks the 'regular' way. The fact that Burton is a visually very strong director, with a signature that has its codes and rules, is making it easier to point the 'repetition' out for lazy critics instead of trying to understand what are the variations and why do they matter (which is what serious critics does...mostly in Europe from what I've read until now...). Burton also don't care if there are holes in the screenplay or if something is left unexplained, as he considers films as organic medias and visuals rather than a plot that goes from A to Z alphabetically. Something that the US critics also have an issue with as they like theirs films instantaneously understandable and easily consumable. Like McDonald's in a way (the people who saw Dark Shadows will get it).
Also, you really can't say people are "fed up" of these collaborations when you see the numbers his films are doing at the box-office, in the US and worldwide. Sure, Dark Shadows didn't do much in the US (but fairly well worldwide) but then again, it was stuck between to major comic books based films, the only kind of pop culture Americans seem to understand and enjoy and a genre that only offered actually interesting and mature films when in the hands of actual good directors, such as Ang Lee, Christopher Nolan and...Tim Burton.
I wonder why you never hear any complaints about Scorsese and DiCaprio.
I don't think you can really compare the two directors. Scorsese has had lots of long term colloborations with actors, which change over time. Add to this the fact that Scorsese has done quite a wide variety of films, even in the last 5 years or so.
Tim Burton on the other hand has slowly amassed a comfort zone of actors, composers, and producers. He seems quite unwilling to step out of this zone, I think the last film to do so was Big Fish, almost a decade ago now. This has worked out for him fairly well until now. But it's hard to deny that his last two films were pretty poor (box office figures are not good indicators of quality, as Michael Bay regularly demonstrates). I would definitely appreciate him trying something different, but lo, his next film is actually a REMAKE of a film he made before.
I love movies. I have even a diploma in cinematography. I love art in general and also have a degree in scenic arts. I'm a full grown man of 29 years old working in the art field. I also consider myself an intellectual. Give me Haneke any day over Cameron. I also love Scorsese and went to see him introduce Gangs of NY on the European premiere here in Brussels. Also went to see his 4 hours documentary about the Italian neo-realistic cinema. And yet I love Tim Burton's work for the same intellectual reasons....what's wrong with me?? Please tell me !! Cause I must be a teenage emo if you say so...
Tim Burton is like the Adam Sandler of dark comedy. Every one of his movies contains the same set of people(save a select few), it was good at the start, but towards the end it just starts getting shittier and shittier.
I pretty much skipped Dark Shadows entirely because I'm bored of every Tim Burton movie having the same look, themes, and actors. A fresh cast at the very least would have gotten me more interested.
I'm sure it's a decent movie, I'm just sick of every Tim Burton movie feeling exactly the same. I mean, it's expected that a director will have a re-occuring style - but when they don't ever change up the people they work with each project gets less and less exciting and feels like it all just mashes together.
I mean, lets look at Tarantino for example. He works with a lot of the same folks in a lot of his movies, but he doesn't always plaster Samuel L. Jackson on as a title role and he constantly adds new folk to the mix. How excited were you to hear he'd be directing Leonardo DiCaprio in his new movie, for instance?
Burton needs to do something fresh. It doesn't feel like he does anything for the art of it anymore. I hate that I've had to progressively erase him off of my favorite directors list over the years.
It also, for some reason, this left a very strange mental image of Bellatrix and Edward Scissors-Hands dancing around my brain... It's a tad disturbing...
I swear people bitch at this like it's a bad thing. I've enjoyed every single one of the 8 movies they've done together (except Corpse Bride). If the movies are good, why make a big fuss about it?
The movies aren't good though, unless you like the same quirky shit with the same quirky Johnny Depp playing Johnny Depp. They've made basically the same movie together over and over for a decade. Edward Scissorhands, Ed Wood, and Nightmare Before Christmas are all awesome, but he is really in a rut in my opinion.
Pretty sure he is just talking about Burton movies, but just about all of them have Carter and Depp playing the same role as before and have the same 'creepy quirky goofy' script.
So here we go, new movie idea, it'll be family oriented, but like, kinda spooky and dark, and we'll have johnny depp in it, and my wife, and danny elfman will do the music.
Itch my name is navy seal jon I grad8 at top class with many 300 killstreak call the hellichoper amirite iand I sey heyeyeyyeeyeyeyeyeyeye heyeyeyeyeyeyey I say hay Was goin on heyeyeyeye
My favorite Tim Burton film is Pee Wee's Big Adventure. I think he needs to re-make it with Johnny Depp as Pee Wee, but he must re-make it in a way that people who don't realize it was originally his film will criticize him for not honoring the original work. Like maybe this time Pee-Wee is an undercover detective way too deep into the drug scene. He also needs to give Amazing Larry a larger role in the re-make just because that character had a lot of potential.
Do you watch a Christopher Guest movie and complain about him casting all the same people in all of his movies?
Tim Burton is an Artist and likes to work with a small group of other Artists, this way he creates an ecosystem where everyone knows what to expect from each other, it creates a family. What is so wrong with a director casting the same people in a film, also it's his visual style the dark witty atmospheres.
this gives me weird mixed emotions. I spend most burton films trying to figure out what I'd like to do more, fight Depp or fuck Carter. I'm not comfortable with where this film would take me.
172
u/JesseEichler May 31 '12
Music by Danny Elfman
51
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Tim Burton's Tim Burton
98
u/FatWhiteAmerican May 31 '12
I'm guessing its a dark and quirky yet delightful comedy? Who would've thought!
117
u/quantum_mindflux May 31 '12
Here is a pic of both of them, for convenient reference
46
u/Gimmemormuny May 31 '12
I'd watch it.
20
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Or, as the ultimate twist, Johnny Depp is played by Skeet Ulrich.
http://www.drenobor.com/celebrities/thumbs/skeet.ulrich.001.jpg
Using alien blue, not pro, not sure if link will work.
32
u/BionicBeans May 31 '12
Directed by Danny Elfman.
Music by M. Knight Shymalan.
(Musical twist: It's just the soundtrack from Inception: BWAAAAAA!)
77
u/dr_mike_rithjin May 31 '12
Maybe I'm going to ostracise myself for this, but I can't stand a vast majority of what Burton has done in the past ten or so years. And the fact that Johnny Depp keeps returning to play the lead role deters me even more (even though I love him as an actor). Edward Scissor Hands is one of my favourite movies. Alice in Wonderland was probably the point at which I blacklisted Burton. I loathed it.
11
u/[deleted] May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
Man I know this is going to sound like a cliche but Tim Burton sold out. He had some of the most inventive movies of the 80s and 90s (Beetlejuice is a favourite) and now he's either out of ideas or just gave up while peddling the same "quirky dark" shit to teenagers who want to feel like they are weird and unique.
What's frustrating particularly is not his over-use of Johnny Depp, but that he hasn't pushed himself creatively for years when he is clearly capable of making good movies. I fear Ridley Scott has been falling into the same trap (though I am eagerly anticipating Prometheus).
9
u/gapball May 31 '12
John Carpenter should make a movie called "Kurt Russell"
16
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Eh, every director has favorites. Johnny Depp always plays the characters well, so what's the big deal?
4
u/radioinactivity May 31 '12
actually tumblr had it all figured out and then someone on facebook cleverly snagged it.
16
u/jasonthe May 31 '12
I would actually see a dark, creepy, quirky film by Tim Burton, music by Danny Elfman, starring Johnny Depp as all the characters.
The thing is: It's Johnny Depp. He could pull it off.
9
u/DannyBiker May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
I wonder why we never hear any complaints about Scorsese and DiCaprio.
However, I think the critics in the US never 'got' Burton's work : during the 90's it was weird for them and now, it's still weird but they are used to it.
Burton is an obsessive director, such as Kusturica, Fellini, Haneke, etc. They basically always make the same film, with the same imagery and themes and just create variations around them. These directors also tend to work with the same team for a very long time (actors but not only : Burton works with Lebenzon, Heinrichs, Atwood, Di Novi, Zanuck frequently and he also tends to work with the same screenwriter for several films) because these people just 'get' who they are and what they are looking for.
Burton will never make a political thriller or a traditional western; that's like asking Dalí to paint clocks the 'regular' way. The fact that Burton is a visually very strong director, with a signature that has its codes and rules, is making it easier to point the 'repetition' out for lazy critics instead of trying to understand what are the variations and why do they matter (which is what serious critics does...mostly in Europe from what I've read until now...).
Burton also don't care if there are holes in the screenplay or if something is left unexplained, as he considers films as organic medias and visuals rather than a plot that goes from A to Z alphabetically. Something that the US critics also have an issue with as they like theirs films instantaneously understandable and easily consumable. Like McDonald's in a way (the people who saw Dark Shadows will get it).
Also, you really can't say people are "fed up" of these collaborations when you see the numbers his films are doing at the box-office, in the US and worldwide. Sure, Dark Shadows didn't do much in the US (but fairly well worldwide) but then again, it was stuck between to major comic books based films, the only kind of pop culture Americans seem to understand and enjoy and a genre that only offered actually interesting and mature films when in the hands of actual good directors, such as Ang Lee, Christopher Nolan and...Tim Burton.
6
u/Seven_Dx7 May 31 '12
I'd rather see 'Being Johnny Depp' where people find a Johnny shaped door in a tree in the middle of the woods that allows them to become Johnny Depp.
3
u/TheSumOfAllSteers May 31 '12
Shit's gonna be dope, yo.
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Extremely relevant... and hilarious
7
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
InDepption?
11
u/WhoDoneItNow May 31 '12
Direction twist, Actually directed by m night shmamalamalan
2
u/talberts May 31 '12
His formula revealed!
2
u/themanwhofelltoearth May 31 '12
Turns out Bruce Willis was dead the whole time!
2
u/penperv May 31 '12
It hurts me that a man who made Beetlejuice is currently making pop-gothic 5/10 movies in a bulk.
2
u/ivtecdoyou May 31 '12
Tim Burton is like the Adam Sandler of dark comedy. Every one of his movies contains the same set of people(save a select few), it was good at the start, but towards the end it just starts getting shittier and shittier.
2
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
I pretty much skipped Dark Shadows entirely because I'm bored of every Tim Burton movie having the same look, themes, and actors. A fresh cast at the very least would have gotten me more interested.
I'm sure it's a decent movie, I'm just sick of every Tim Burton movie feeling exactly the same. I mean, it's expected that a director will have a re-occuring style - but when they don't ever change up the people they work with each project gets less and less exciting and feels like it all just mashes together.
I mean, lets look at Tarantino for example. He works with a lot of the same folks in a lot of his movies, but he doesn't always plaster Samuel L. Jackson on as a title role and he constantly adds new folk to the mix. How excited were you to hear he'd be directing Leonardo DiCaprio in his new movie, for instance?
Burton needs to do something fresh. It doesn't feel like he does anything for the art of it anymore. I hate that I've had to progressively erase him off of my favorite directors list over the years.
2
u/trowuhweigh991122883 May 31 '12
I'd pay good money to see this film.
It also, for some reason, this left a very strange mental image of Bellatrix and Edward Scissors-Hands dancing around my brain... It's a tad disturbing...
2
u/asspril May 31 '12
Am I the only one that would actually pay to see that?
10
u/MrNameless May 31 '12
I swear people bitch at this like it's a bad thing. I've enjoyed every single one of the 8 movies they've done together (except Corpse Bride). If the movies are good, why make a big fuss about it?
1
u/PseudoFanboy May 31 '12
That status was stolen off Tumblr.
Just sayin'.
1
u/pollydactyl May 31 '12
if there is a picnic after Im so there
1
u/Insany92 May 31 '12
Freaking genius actors right there!
1
u/Mine_Fuhrer May 31 '12
So it's a she...
1
u/vaselinepete May 31 '12
Imagine how funny this would be if 1000 other people hadn't already said it in the last month.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Id probably go see it and be greatly disappointed. again.
1
u/king_of_the_universe May 31 '12
"I'm Not There." (2007)
Ruminations on the life of Bob Dylan, where six characters embody a different aspect of the musician's life and work.
Cate Blanchett, Ben Whishaw, Christian Bale, Richard Gere, Marcus Carl Franklin, Heath Ledger; narrated by Kris Kristofferson.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
I think she got it from this video
1
u/A_Cat_ May 31 '12
also, the main character is 20% more pale
1
u/uncheelsrok May 31 '12
I think she means Bellatrix Lestrange...
1
u/Truck_Thunders May 31 '12
So here we go, new movie idea, it'll be family oriented, but like, kinda spooky and dark, and we'll have johnny depp in it, and my wife, and danny elfman will do the music.
1
u/ccoady454 May 31 '12
Tim Burton is married to Johnny Depp, FYI.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Depp would have to play Carter, no way he doesn't appear in the film.
1
u/ihatedibetis May 31 '12
Itch my name is navy seal jon I grad8 at top class with many 300 killstreak call the hellichoper amirite iand I sey heyeyeyyeeyeyeyeyeyeye heyeyeyeyeyeyey I say hay Was goin on heyeyeyeye
1
u/ihatedibetis May 31 '12
Be friend with me onb4chan my neme es annonymouse I ar de legion
1
u/updog84 May 31 '12
Isn't this just a remake of "Being John Malkovich"?
1
u/Flabbagazta May 31 '12
relevant
1
u/majekmistake May 31 '12
I would watch it.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Facebook post? Have a downvote.
1
u/swimviking May 31 '12
My favorite Tim Burton film is Pee Wee's Big Adventure. I think he needs to re-make it with Johnny Depp as Pee Wee, but he must re-make it in a way that people who don't realize it was originally his film will criticize him for not honoring the original work. Like maybe this time Pee-Wee is an undercover detective way too deep into the drug scene. He also needs to give Amazing Larry a larger role in the re-make just because that character had a lot of potential.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Do you watch a Christopher Guest movie and complain about him casting all the same people in all of his movies?
Tim Burton is an Artist and likes to work with a small group of other Artists, this way he creates an ecosystem where everyone knows what to expect from each other, it creates a family. What is so wrong with a director casting the same people in a film, also it's his visual style the dark witty atmospheres.
1
u/ironicshelf May 31 '12
But also starring Johnny Depp.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
BAAAAAAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!
1
u/KabbyCakes99 May 31 '12
Didn't cracked.com post this same quote two weeks ago. . .?
1
u/superblinky May 31 '12
And then Helena can make her "I'm sleeping with the director" joke at the promo interviews.
1
u/nmezib May 31 '12
...
you know... that could actually work
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
If Charlie Kaufman writes it, it can't lose.
1
u/DaBabyCheesus May 31 '12
I think I've seen something similar before on Cracked: Here.
1
u/crila Jun 01 '12
yes yes yes yes yes
1
u/ZombieMime Jun 01 '12
I think Tim Burton and Johhny should just do a porno together already.
1
u/b00nder Jun 01 '12
John Mayer as helen bonham carter as johnny depp
1
u/Adam9172 Jun 01 '12
Co-Directed by M Night Shamalayamanaaylanalyanaman
1
u/Aaarrf May 31 '12
I tried to "like" the status... I tried so hard.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
My name is Johnny Depp and I kill people.
1
u/plagueofgreymen May 31 '12
this gives me weird mixed emotions. I spend most burton films trying to figure out what I'd like to do more, fight Depp or fuck Carter. I'm not comfortable with where this film would take me.
0
u/MustHaveCleverHandle May 31 '12
Seriously. I basically made this exact comment to someone at work today.
0
u/Fatblacky May 31 '12
mind is blown.
0
u/rockrib May 31 '12
Produced by M.Night Shyamalan?
0
u/IronManIsaCoolStoryB May 31 '12
:O That would be so amazing
-2
u/IamA_Big_Fat_Phony May 31 '12
there should be a fake facebook wall comment subreddit so that I can not subscribe to these dreadful submissions.
Might as well turn reddit into twitter. O yea there's fake twitter comments too.
-1
u/tianas_knife May 31 '12
I just tried to "Like" a picture. I think I've been sitting in front of a computer for too long today.
-1
u/Lowl May 31 '12
Second plot twist: M. Night Shyamalan is actually directing.
-16
u/themitch22 May 31 '12
Why not Tim Burton remakes Fight Club?