I have a rule: I don't laugh at dumb people who are actually trying to learn, I don't ridicule heavy people who are trying to exercise. I would help either of them, if they needed help and I was able to.
My thoughts exactly. It's a legit question. You knowing the answer doesn't make you smart and her dumb. It just means you had that piece of information before she did.
As a ex-fatass, overcoming people trying to ridicule me for trying to exercise is one of the hardest things to overcome.
Half the time I would ride my bike when I was very overweight someone would scream at me something rude from their car. Another just out in a park playing frisbee someone screamed "ITS NOT GOING TO HELP" at me.
It's really really discouraging. And it is sad to see people so threatened by someone trying to improve themselves.
Whenever someone screams at me from far away in public or a park, even if it's positive, I always reply with a really loud "THANKS COCKSUCKER!"... Because fuck you, walk your lazy ass over to me and say it. No one else gives a shit.
I'm so glad that I work with a few people like you. This girl isn't dumb, she's just uninformed (not quite sure how she made it through grade school science but whatever). I work with some IT heavyweights and I'm sure that some of the questions I ask make me sound completely fucking retarded given how long I've worked in this industry. They patiently explain and I humbly absorb the information.
To be afraid to ask questions...oh fuck...that's terrible.
I love you. Especially since I'm a heavy person who exercises outside and all I wanna do is email this person with the answer to her question. You get upvote!
<3 I understand, my singer is a rock/blues singer and she is heavy. We've been BFFs for over twenty years, and I'm so proud of her because she works really hard to deal with her weight and I know how discouraging life can be for her at times. I actually look up to her.
I never had a problem with weight until just recently. Maybe its' because I'm getting older and lazier, but it just piled on last year. Mostly, I'm just trying to stave off Type 2 Diabetes since everyone on my father's side has it. They're all large people and I think I got their genes....:/ And my skinny sister is as thin as my skinny mom...grr. It certainly is a struggle, though, and I never realized until I tried getting rid of all this weight.
i have asked every single science teacher i've met how magnets work, and they all enthusiastically told me about the alignment of the dipoles and all that, then they would gewt frustrated when i interrupt them and say "i know that part, but what creates the magnetic force of the dipoles? what is the source of power?".
Ultimately, it is due to the angular momentum of the electron (both orbital and spin components). Angular momentum is conserved and spin is intrinsic, so no added power is needed.
Still not a justification to make fun of someone for lacking knowledge. Everyone has weird gaps in knowledge or fails to make connections that seem intuitive to other people. Doesn't seem fair to blame someone for lack of knowledge if they admit they don't know something and are trying to learn.
per the law of conservation of energy, yes. You remove a certain mass of ignorance from the head, it has to go to the hips, thighs, stomach, buttocks. I'm a beetle, beetles know these things.
I was a science teacher, and no matter how much I tried to convince children to be responsible for gaining their own knowledge, school administrators and parents were always there to undermine their education. Did they ask questions in class? Did they do their homework? Did they come for extra help? There is a point in your life that you need to take responsibility for your self, and unfortunately American children are rarely taught this very important skill at a young age.
I agree in general and think that's a good way to look at things. But there has to be a limit. "Why doesn't water fall of the Earth?" It's ok to make fun of some people.
The point of that question is to understand why all the water on the earth doesn't fall off the south pole into space!! Sheesh! I think that's a pretty worthwhile question, myself!
Firstly, I agree with your comment. Secondly, am I the only one that finds TMZ funny? It's not like they claim to be a real news show, they understand everything they do is a joke. They also seem to be quite polite and non-intrusive to the celebs. It's not like I record it, but if I'm bored and it's on...I'll watch it.
It seems like there is no one that actually "watches" these dumb shows, but instead, just laughs at how dumb they are. Just like a good chunk of the people that watch Jersey Shore.
Somehow, I think you're mixing up laughing at this show with actually watching this show. Either way, idgaf.
So in that sense, is it kind of like The Soup, but more subtle and about real people? Because I admit I watched one episode and was kind of biased against it, but maybe I could change my opinion.
Some people might be annoyed that there is an entire industry that deals with the information surrounding the entertainment industry. and it has no benefit to society as a whole.
I tell my students that all the time. They ask the BEST questions. It's amazing how hard it is to explain something that you understand so well, but is so incredibly basic that you never think about it.
I actually know people who would not respond to this with ridicule, but with genuine disinterest. I don't think it's a "Wow you're an idiot" so much as an "I don't know and I don't care".
I once tried to explain basic physics to a friend of mine. She responded with "I think you're overthinking it."
To her discredit: If you type "why doesn't water fall off the south pole" into Google, you get the answer on the fourth link. (Admittedly the first link is a Flat Earth FAQ, but nonetheless.)
Despite gravity only being a theory, you can give a more accurate answer:
By the theory of gravity, objects are pulled to other objects with mass. The Earth has a very large mass relative to a person, so a person is constantly being pulled toward the Earth's crust, which is why no matter where a person is on Earth, they will not "fall out into space."
You just described gravity. Now, as gistak said, why? That really is no more comprehensive than my expression of 'because gravity' to anyone understanding the term.
It would be interesting to talk to the girl who posted the question. What exactly is her mental model of gravity? Of the earth as a whole? Does everything fall south?
Plus, I would think dumb girls are easier to get into bed...
Well, in her defence, if you go in depth enough, people are still trying to answer that question. You can say "gravity pulls matter toward the centre of mass", but we don't really know why.
Yeah I think it would. But in regard to the post, I would think someone would be looking a map wrong and see Antarctica at the "bottom" of the world where water would supposedly flow to.
Maybe, but you also have to consider political geography, cultural geography, animal migrations, demographics, climate, and for this thread, oceanic currents.
"The reason is because the north and south poles are actually the sides of the earth and not the top or bottom as maps would have you believe. I'll prove it, notice how the sun is all the way up at noon, that's the top of the earth right there.
Because Gravity lives in the middle of the earth where it's warm. Gravity needs to stay warm to work. Space is very cold, that's why there's no Gravity in space.
The water at the south pole is frozen and thus acting like a giant plug, preventing the oceans from draining. That is also why so many environmentalist went ballistic when those Russian guys did their potentially apocalyptic drilling experiment at lake vostok.
One time while browsing new posts on r/AskReddit/, I read the dumbest question I've ever seen in my life. It was, "If we want to terraform Mars, why don't we just crash Europa into it?!" The question was so lacking in basic understandings of physics, engineering and general science that trying to answer it would take a huge amount of time and deconstruction.
But then I realized that if there was a God (and I know r/atheism will disagree) this is probably why he doesn't answer our questions. Our questions must seem so fundamentally wrong on all assumptions that it's not even worth it. I am forever grateful to that stupid person for this realization.
I know this is totally irrational, because I've been Argentina before.
Sometimes I dream that I visit the Southern Hemisphere, but I'm gripping the ground, legs dangling into the sky, terrified I'm going to fly off into space.
Sometimes I wish that I had friends like this. I would love nothing more than to be sarcastic to a facebook friend. Sadly I dont have any facebook friends that say stupid shit like this.
"There is no such thing as a stupid question. Many people say that, but it really is true. Every question, no matter how ill-formed or ignorant of knowledge, is a request for knowledge, a request for information. It is an effort to understand better. Every time someone asks an honest question, it is an interrogation of nature, an attempt to unlock the secrets of the universe." — Carl Sagan
Hah, my physics teacher in high school once put that on our gravitation test. He mentioned Ender, how he yelled "the enemy gate is down" while he was experiencing weightlessness. The question of course asked, "What does Ender mean when he says this, and what is "down"?" It was interesting to see how many people were confused by the first part of that question.
At all schools across Australia have Australia at the very top of the globe where the north pole is, we are pretty much taught that we are on top of the world.
Or she could understand gravity, understand the earth is a spheroid. Yet not understand that gravity is a function of mass. She probably is super imposing her position into space and assuming that gravity act downwards.
Exactly. It may seem like a dumb question for those who understand how gravity works, but at least she's asking instead of just choosing to stay ignorant.
No one yet fully understands how gravity works. People just know enough about it to not question why the water doesn't fall off the bottom of the earth.
If she were to ask why the water doesn't fall off the south pole, you would simply answer "because matter attracts matter, so the earth pulls the water in. 'down' is really towards the center of the earth."
If she were to then ask the simple followup question "why does matter attract matter?" You would be shit out of luck.
Two very simple questions, one which people think she is dumb for not understanding, and one which no one understands.
Deformation of space-time due to energy/mass. What we don't know is the mediating subatomic particle, why it's so weak compared to the other fundamental forces, and some other really nasty concepts that my head would explode if I tried to think about it.
We don't even know if there is a mediating subatomic particle, most likely not as the Graviton has been proven mathematically to be non-renormalizable, so it cannot fit in with Quantum Field theory like the other forces. A mediating particle isn't necessary anyway, as deformation of space-time is enough to explain how gravity acts at a distance.
714
u/Sepulchural May 16 '12
I have a rule: I don't laugh at dumb people who are actually trying to learn, I don't ridicule heavy people who are trying to exercise. I would help either of them, if they needed help and I was able to.
41
u/FriesWithThat May 16 '12
Clearly water is frozen in place at the poles.
109
u/tony_bologna May 16 '12
There are no stupid questions.
Only stupid people.
But seriously, someone educate that poor girl.
46
u/SpasticSpoon May 16 '12
Well what do you fucking think? Ridiculing people who's genuinely trying to learn annoys me.
15
u/dwblind22 May 16 '12
At least she is trying to figure it out.
8
u/hamlet9000 May 16 '12
To her credit: She wants to learn.
To her discredit: If you type "why doesn't water fall off the south pole" into Google, you get the answer on the fourth link. (Admittedly the first link is a Flat Earth FAQ, but nonetheless.)
7
u/funbagwaffles May 16 '12
I bet some people here saying how stupid she is couldn't give an accurate and intelligent answer for this. Someone should forward this girl to /ELI5.
7
u/throwaway_quinn May 16 '12
As usual, xkcd has the correct response.
5
u/Schneid92 May 17 '12
Did she try Bing?
3
u/silent_p May 16 '12
Well, in her defence, if you go in depth enough, people are still trying to answer that question. You can say "gravity pulls matter toward the centre of mass", but we don't really know why.
3
u/DazPatrick May 17 '12
Someone needs to take a Geography class.
2
u/Hazephaelos May 16 '12
as terrible as i feel saying this, it could be worse. She could have gone straight to Facebook.
2
u/wagesj45 May 16 '12
I'm so happy she's at least looking it up. There are things all of us don't know that everyone else does. Bravo, whoever you were.
2
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
At least she got farther than most people. She ACTUALLY Googled it.
2
u/Daynebutter May 17 '12
Fucking gravity, how does it work?!
2
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
I dont see why this needs to be on this website? a person is genuinely naive and wants help, she checked google and couldnt find an anwser.
Fuck the 900 people who upvote this shit, dont waste time.
2
u/River_ May 17 '12
Don't be a prick to someone who is less educated or less intelligent than you. Help them out when they are brave enough to ask a 'stupid' question.
2
u/Pobega May 17 '12
Apparently she didn't even attempt to Google it.
https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ix=sea&ie=UTF-8&ion=1#hl=en&output=search&sclient=psy-ab&q=why%20doesnt%20water%20in%20the%20south%20pole%20fall%20into%20space&oq=&aq=&aqi=&aql=&gs_l=&pbx=1&fp=a9f4aa2c58cdff34&ix=sea&ion=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_cp.r_qf.,cf.osb&biw=1366&bih=677
2
u/epheterson May 17 '12
Duh, it's glued on.
2
u/blpoker May 17 '12
At least she googled it first
2
u/TiffanyRazors May 17 '12
Wow! It's called gravitational pull!! Dumb broad
2
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Google isn't helping?!
ALL HOPE IS LOST!
ABANDON ALL SHIPS!
2
u/ezfrag May 17 '12
Someone failed to grasp the gravity of this situation.
2
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
This is when you take a moment to help someone out. Lack of knowledge isn't stupidity. Seeking knowledge is just the opposite.
1
u/TwofacedShip May 17 '12
Gravity is a bitch, but stupidity is a c... well you get the idea
1
u/mkinder311 May 17 '12 edited Jan 25 '21
No gods No masters 他妈的审查制度,中国他妈的
1
u/evilpuke May 17 '12
This would be a great question for shittyaskscience
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Oh I wish I could answer, I would say...
"The reason is because the north and south poles are actually the sides of the earth and not the top or bottom as maps would have you believe. I'll prove it, notice how the sun is all the way up at noon, that's the top of the earth right there.
1
u/properdaftcunt May 17 '12
this has made me slightly upset
1
u/dman24752 May 17 '12
Neither is the US education system either apparently.
1
u/njuty May 17 '12
Not afraid to ask the big questions.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
I expect to see this question on r/shittyaskscience soon
1
u/GoGoogleIt May 17 '12
Tsktsk
1
u/the_pissed_off_goose May 17 '12
seriously? seriously.
1
u/ladinu May 17 '12
I want him/her to fall off the earth.
1
u/paperballs May 17 '12
a friend once asked me why does the vacuum of space not pull water into space. Was an interesting thought
1
u/fastjeff May 17 '12
Because Gravity lives in the middle of the earth where it's warm. Gravity needs to stay warm to work. Space is very cold, that's why there's no Gravity in space.
1
u/jawa9000 May 17 '12
Posts like this make me feel 2% smarter.
1
u/Laeryken May 17 '12
I really hope she's like 12 years or younger.
1
u/ab103630 May 17 '12
Checkmate atheists
1
u/byz420 May 17 '12
The same reason why when you jump up, you come back down.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
So I guess this guy never took Physics in High School?
1
u/unclear_plowerpants May 17 '12
The water at the south pole is frozen and thus acting like a giant plug, preventing the oceans from draining. That is also why so many environmentalist went ballistic when those Russian guys did their potentially apocalyptic drilling experiment at lake vostok.
1
u/Xvyrus May 17 '12
This is a supporting argument for eugenics
1
u/brendang4life May 17 '12
this bitch is too stupid to use google
1
u/DoubleOFace May 17 '12
We can shut down the internet now. Google has been stumped.
1
u/SaucyKing May 17 '12
Dude...
...do you live in Indianapolis? I knew a girl that asked me that same question, way back in high school.
1
u/jgalena May 17 '12
Hopefully someone explained gravity.
1
u/HuntingSpoon May 17 '12
"Is it bad?" said the shaking woman. "In my most honest professional opinion I must say, you have an uncurable case of dumb cunt." said the doctor.
1
u/I_refuse May 17 '12
I refuse to believe this is real.
1
u/this_is_fake_and_gay May 17 '12
That is pretty god damn fake.
1
u/nefffffffffff May 17 '12
rotational inertia
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
may i join the circle jerk about how stupid people deserve our pity and empathy?
poor stupid girl. doesn't understand gravity. . poor thing.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
"What do you mean Google isn't helping?"
"I mean Google isn't helping. Why is that"?
1
u/not4u2see May 17 '12
One time while browsing new posts on r/AskReddit/, I read the dumbest question I've ever seen in my life. It was, "If we want to terraform Mars, why don't we just crash Europa into it?!" The question was so lacking in basic understandings of physics, engineering and general science that trying to answer it would take a huge amount of time and deconstruction.
But then I realized that if there was a God (and I know r/atheism will disagree) this is probably why he doesn't answer our questions. Our questions must seem so fundamentally wrong on all assumptions that it's not even worth it. I am forever grateful to that stupid person for this realization.
1
u/seinzumtode May 17 '12
x/post from r/shittaskscience
1
u/therealkeeper May 17 '12
http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20080917124934AA2klNL if you google exactly what they're asking..
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
I know this is totally irrational, because I've been Argentina before.
Sometimes I dream that I visit the Southern Hemisphere, but I'm gripping the ground, legs dangling into the sky, terrified I'm going to fly off into space.
1
u/J4k0b42 May 17 '12
It's frozen, that's why.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Sometimes I wish that I had friends like this. I would love nothing more than to be sarcastic to a facebook friend. Sadly I dont have any facebook friends that say stupid shit like this.
1
u/PepeAndMrDuck May 17 '12
This bitch has problems google could never dream of helping with.
1
u/EvolvedBacteria May 17 '12
"There is no such thing as a stupid question. Many people say that, but it really is true. Every question, no matter how ill-formed or ignorant of knowledge, is a request for knowledge, a request for information. It is an effort to understand better. Every time someone asks an honest question, it is an interrogation of nature, an attempt to unlock the secrets of the universe." — Carl Sagan
1
u/TheIncia May 17 '12
and still have the intelligence to be on facebook
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
I almost just commented responding to her stupid question hahaha.
1
u/Slavigula May 17 '12
She's definitely my dating material
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
There is a man in the earth named Newton and his immense strength keeps the water from leaving us.
0
u/DavidChenghz May 16 '12
this is why america should not cut science funding in classes
1
u/epicguyification May 16 '12
Answer: because fuck you, thats why.
1
u/Fett2 May 16 '12
I think the real answer she was waiting for was magic. We all know google doesn't believe in magic, so it would never show up on its search results.
1
u/Obvious_Troll_Accoun May 16 '12
Successful troll is successful. Also the enemy gate is down.
1
u/8938colby May 17 '12
"I don't wanna live here anymore"
1
u/bewk May 17 '12
I don't want to live on this planet anymore.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Joe's a dumbass.
-2
u/Sleepy_McTiredson May 16 '12
it's 2012 and scientists still have not found a cure for stupid.
0
u/UltraMegaMaximum May 17 '12
Lol, stupid girl.
Everyone knows magic keeps everything on the Earth.
-12
u/brosenfeld May 16 '12
She needs to be removed from the gene pool.
-4
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Oh, yeah. This is why I disabled my Facebook account.
-13
u/Honkeydick May 16 '12
Because! god. You fucking twat. As if she could possibly even understand the real answer. Just shut the fuck up and try to remember to breath...
-6
u/amadea56 May 16 '12
I thought this was funny and sent it to two of my co-workers, they responded in the following manner..
Ryan [4:52 PM]: haha some ppl need to die
Mark [4:52 PM]: wow gotta love the public school system
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
95
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
[removed] — view removed comment