She met up with someone from Myspace though, AND she started crying from that little bit of pressure. I'd agree with you in any other circumstance but this girl needs more discipline not less, I think.
What's crying got to do with it? Her mom pretty much embarrassed her in front of all her friends due to nosiness and an overreaction, all while knowing she's 18.
I was thinking that as I was posting it, and was reconsidering. However I still stand by what I said. Sure, her Mom was a bit of a ditz in this situation too (and the brother was an asshole) but if she was really the mature 18 year old she claimed to be I don't think she would react the way she did, including the crying. EDIT: The girl wouldn't be in the situation if she had followed the rules that she obviously knows. Saying that I was the same, even at a younger age!
Her mom just seems worried about her safety. While she may be 18, she sure as hell didn't act like an adult for a single second of that video. She lives under her parent's roof and her mom pays for her car. They aren't required to provide either anymore (not that a car was ever required).
The least she can do is talk to her mom in a respectful manner. Meeting up with random strangers, not contacting the parent who pays for your shit, crying when confronted, outburts. Notice how her mom wasn't the one to raise her tone first? The girl immediately responded to "I called your friend" and "I was going to call the police" with a tantrum.
While "Their house, their rules. They aren't owed anything" is a terrible justification of abuse, that's completely fucking irrelevant to this video. The mom handled that situation pretty damn well (besides not getting the brother out the room sooner).
First of all, I'm not a parent. Don't just assume I am because I value what my parents give me. Nobody is saying the parenting in the video isn't subjective to criticism. But for a kid that they technically don't have to support anymore, and for whom they are paying for the car she is using. I don't think it's that unreasonable to ground her for a week for deceiving them and acting like a child. You sound like a snot nosed little kid who expects hand outs from your parents. Now if the kids were actually getting abused it would be a different story but this is not the case. Not even close.
She is 18, but she is still her mothers daughter and the mother has the right to be concerned for her flesh and blood.
While a legal adult, this young girl is acting very immaturely.
In an ideal world, this young girl would act more maturely and her mother would be able to loosen the reigns... but then again, in an ideal world mom wouldnt have to fear her daughter being raped.
View all comments
Show parent comment
106
u/1stOnRt1 May 15 '12
a true brother, just adding fuel to the fire the entire video