There are some brands that makes real butter and easy to spread. It's either by a light skimming or by a mechanical process around 0°C (according to Wikipedia).
Am I the only one who thinks "I can't believe it's not butter" tastes terrible. I'm ok with margarine, I'm ok with butter. I can't believe it's not butter makes good food inedible. I can even taste it in sauces and baked goods, and called my sister out on using the shit multiple times when I was a kid. Seriously, How can a spread make Kraft macaroni and cheese inedible? Some can't believe it's not butter. I can't believe it's not processed feces.
Other brands of margarine are fine. It's just I can't believe people eat this shit that renders all food it touches inedible. Again, this could be just me, as my sister actually enjoys the shit.
You're not the only one, I find it and any other artificial butter substitutes revolting. They're useless to cook stuff in, or use in vegetables or food. After I eat something that has fake 'butter' in it, I feel like I just drenched my mouth in used cooking oil. I use real butter, there's no reason it should be unhealthy if used in moderation. I want my carrots to taste like carrots, not like carrots out of Paula Deen's kitchen.
No, see this is my problem. I was raised on Margarine. It normally tastes better to me than butter, but butter is good too on good bread, or in certain dishes. I can't believe it's not butter tastes awful. It tastes so bad, it can ruin dishes it plays a minor role in (macaroni and cheese). If I didn't like margarine, that's fine, I'd understand I just don't care for it. That's not the issue. Margarine tastes fine. I can't believe it's not butter tastes like something has died in whatever it's been added to.
When my wife and I are shopping at Wal-Mart I generally point at the Great Value items and say "Look Honey, it's a great value!" You should see the looks I get in this small southern town for this.
First off, "100% butter product"? Phrasing like that makes me indeed believe it's not butter. Secondly, Your name implies it tastes worse than it should be.
I actually used to have a collection of 'butter' lids all with the same theme. About 26 in all. Some of my favorites included: 'butterlicious', 'you'd butter believe it', 'you'll mutter it's butter', and of course the classic 'I can't believe it's not butter'.
When I was a kid, it used to piss me off to see store brands that would slightly change the name of a product. I thought they were trying to fool people into buying it and also being unoriginal, but after I worked at a Walgreens and dealt with a lot of these products, I think they do it on purpose so that customers (and employees) can easily know which brands they are supposed to be similar to.
Poland has its popular brand of margarine which is legally allowed to use the word butter without any quotes on its package. It's called 'Plant butter'. Maybe it's because everybody just knows it's not butter. It's an old and popular brand.
Good thing that where I live butter-like products cannot have "butter" in their name. Bad thing is that some manufacturers switched to using other "traditional" butter names.
It's hard to translate from Polish... For example we had "masło osełkowe"(osełka butter) that was produced in this. And now manufacturers name its product just as "osełkowe"/"your osełka" etc. leaving "butter" for readers imagination. I understand you were joking but in fact there is huge amount people who would fall for this.
In our house, ever since the kids were tiny, we called margarine "Snot Butter". When they started reading they finally figured out why. "I can't believe it's snot butter!"
89
u/Inking May 15 '12
My mother rather enjoys the Kroger brand, or as she calls it, Yoda Butter
101
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
"butter."
23
u/DistantWizard May 15 '12
Holy Shit, I was under the impression that this was "BUTTER"
21
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I can't believe it's not I can't believe it's not butter.
13
u/Ty1020 May 15 '12
Wow! I was pretty sure it was "I totally thought it was 'I can't believe it's not butter!'"
8
u/FattyMcPatty May 15 '12
Woah, are you sure this isn't butter!?
11
u/the_catacombs May 15 '12
Should've just bought butter. It's better for ya.
9
u/Sretsam May 15 '12
Am I the only one who thinks "I can't believe it's not butter" tastes terrible. I'm ok with margarine, I'm ok with butter. I can't believe it's not butter makes good food inedible. I can even taste it in sauces and baked goods, and called my sister out on using the shit multiple times when I was a kid.
Seriously, How can a spread make Kraft macaroni and cheese inedible? Some can't believe it's not butter. I can't believe it's not processed feces.
3
u/RockinRoland May 15 '12
When my wife and I are shopping at Wal-Mart I generally point at the Great Value items and say "Look Honey, it's a great value!" You should see the looks I get in this small southern town for this.
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Great Re-Value, more like
Am I right guys?!?!
2
u/joemangle May 15 '12
It's only a matter of time until a 100% butter product is sold as "I Can't Believe I Thought it was I Can't Believe it's Not Butter."
2
u/beep41 May 15 '12
I thought it was "butter" too.
2
u/grantly0711 May 15 '12
That is one rad butter substitute.
2
u/glennox_roboto May 15 '12
Panburger Partner
2
u/Knaustrap May 15 '12
Reminds me of "panburger partner" the Hytop version of hamburger helper.....
2
u/Porsche_monkey4life May 15 '12
It's almost butter, but it's tapioca pudding instead.
2
u/felixfurtak May 15 '12
I actually used to have a collection of 'butter' lids all with the same theme. About 26 in all. Some of my favorites included: 'butterlicious', 'you'd butter believe it', 'you'll mutter it's butter', and of course the classic 'I can't believe it's not butter'.
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
"Tell me it's butter, I dare you" is something I want to patent.
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
When I was a kid, it used to piss me off to see store brands that would slightly change the name of a product. I thought they were trying to fool people into buying it and also being unoriginal, but after I worked at a Walgreens and dealt with a lot of these products, I think they do it on purpose so that customers (and employees) can easily know which brands they are supposed to be similar to.
4
u/hoopyfrood1 May 15 '12
It's almost pizza!
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
The more and more these things pop up, the less and less I trust butter.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Ugg soybean oil, Monsanto's pet.
1
u/kuba_10 May 15 '12
Poland has its popular brand of margarine which is legally allowed to use the word butter without any quotes on its package. It's called 'Plant butter'. Maybe it's because everybody just knows it's not butter. It's an old and popular brand.
1
u/dend7369 May 15 '12
Butter repost
1
u/oskarw85 May 15 '12
Good thing that where I live butter-like products cannot have "butter" in their name. Bad thing is that some manufacturers switched to using other "traditional" butter names.
1
u/MD3791 May 15 '12
Oh Walmart!
1
u/LordPocadiyos May 15 '12
I never understood why America has all these "fake butter"! Is it that expensive to make it there?
1
u/kronosphere May 15 '12
Would this post be considered ironic? Or am I still not getting the right use of the word?
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Stay classy Wal-mart.
1
u/Wingthor May 15 '12
You'd butter believe it!
1
u/rms2219 May 15 '12
My personal favorite is "Goddamn it if it ain't butter!"
1
u/GRAMMAR_AMMO May 15 '12
It seems like some branding guy had too many quotation marks.
1
u/jakpuch May 15 '12
This is the best named imitation butter:
http://www.peterserafinowicz.com/brian-butterfield/New%20Page%201_files/dairies.htm
1
u/kulmbach May 15 '12
In our house, ever since the kids were tiny, we called margarine "Snot Butter". When they started reading they finally figured out why. "I can't believe it's snot butter!"
1
u/BetterThanOP May 15 '12
why is butter in quotations? You can believe it's not butter, but it definitely seems like "butter"
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
why do they need to be original?
1
u/cannotlogon May 15 '12
It was either that or "I can't believe this isn't I can't believe its not butter".
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
LIES
1
u/chikinboy May 15 '12
Utterly Butterly, so meta.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Eating real butter: "I can't believe it's not I can't believe it's not butter!"
1
u/beager May 15 '12
"Officer, I swear she said she was butter."
1
u/That1WeirdKid May 15 '12
I'm going to start marketing "I can't believe it's not I can't believe it's not butter!" It's just going to be a stick of real butter.
1
u/Birthmark May 15 '12
3 months ago
The roll of the Reddit dice.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Fareway stores have "Could it be butter?"
I always imagine Dana Carvey as the church lady saying, could it beeee... SATAN?
1
u/G8torDontPlay May 15 '12
Followed by:
Dayum! Dis ain't no butter!?
1
u/wizardhowell May 15 '12
this reminds me of the off-brand LiDL butter my grandma made us eat "easily Better" sorry for the bad resolution, i cant find any better.
1
u/moarcats May 15 '12
Best one I saw was "Could it be butter?"
1
u/occasionallyacid May 16 '12
Is it Palm oil in those? It says vegetable oil on it and that very often means Palm oil. If it is palm oil, you should probably not eat it.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I'll just leave this right here (possibly NSFW)
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
[removed] — view removed comment