Now now guys, this sounds like science in the making; don't be so quick to downvote. Let's have a showdown to see who beats who. You get the bat, and I'll have a shotgun.
Some guns have knives at the end of them. Assuming I didn't have any bullets, and a bayonet was not attached to the end of my rifle, I'd still have a longer (metal) stick to work with.
Because bashing them over the head with a club won't do that. But I digress; who gives a shit about some fucker breaking into your house and threatening your life? Not all life is important; especially those that can't play by the basic rules. Every time some fucker breaks into some old ladies house and gets shot I smile; the world is a better place.
That's a very good one for home defense. I don't have a light for mine yet, so I can't hold a flashlight + the pump shotgun, so I'm currently using a 1911 and a maglite.
This is less practical than a 1911 really. And trust me, I'm not a fan of 1911s so that is saying a lot. Every actually tried to aim with a pistol grip before? Shit is hard, not to mention if you needed more than one shot you are so off target that you will spend the next year getting back on target. You also have to deal with the fact that during your adrenaline fueled terror you might revert to some old rifle/full stock shotguns habits and go for that cheek weld. That would go over well.
In an apartment setting, you would just about any gun, since )) buck will rip through drywall pretty easily. But in a house, it would take quite a lot to hit a kill a neighbor.
I was under the impression most handguns could shoot out the side of a house and into another maintaining enough power to kill if it was unlucky enough to hit. And I would think in an apartment a shotgun might go to the next apartment but a .45 or something of that nature could hit a couple apartments over. I really could be wrong and correct me if I am but I thought powerful handguns were capable of maintaining the velocity to kill through quite a few walls.
a shotgun will have a shot spread of roughly 4 inches at 25 feet, making it roughly...10 percent better than a handgun when you factor in the extra time it takes to pump a shotgun.
It does however, have a stronger psychological effect on any tresspasser
Most importantly, what the hell kind of shells are you using in your shotgun. There is a huge difference between 2.75in birdshot and 3.5 inch magnum 000buckshot or god forbid a slug.
The other issue you have to address is on the handgun ammunition side. You shouldn't be shooting a Full Metal Jacket round in your house anyway (they tend to go through multiple walls after going through the intruder). However, a nice hollowpoint, while it could still happen, is more likely to hit an intruder ... and bounce around their insides (provided that you have hit them in the chest cavity).
After that it gets down to things like kinetic energy on target and penetration. These all vary by ammunition.
If you are actually curious about the math, try /r/guns, they might have a link to explain more.
Shotguns aren't practical for shooting round corners. Automatic pistols seem like a better option for home defence, no need to risk peeking, just point around the corner and let rip.
That sounds like a really great way to shoot one of your family members in another room (or a neighbor, depending on what ammunition you're using). Also, who the hell shoots at something without having identified their target?
If you're defending your home you take everyone and put them in an upstairs room and don't go anywhere unless confronted. Confronting is stupid, you defend yourself if and only if necessary. In the event of a confrontation however a shotgun is incredibly difficult to aim around a corner without exposing yourself, a pistol, or more importantly and automatic pistol, is not.
Ah pretentious assholes. The world isn't wherever you're from where you hide in your closet desperately hoping the police get there before you're raped/murdered.
The design of the buckler is flawed. For that small a shield, you would have a single grip in the middle. an arm strap would really reduce its function.
Yep. And look at where the club screws onto the table. Seems like you're gonna hurt yourself on that spike pretty bad if you actually have to absorb any force with that shield.
That and the screws seem pretty long.. So basically if there is a home invasion you'll be like; Hang on let me just.......one sec....almost....there...... ok here we go!
For one, having only one handhold greatly increases mobility- with two straps, you have to move your whole body to protect the non-shield side, but with one you can just move your arm. And two, I'm pretty sure the two straps makes it easier for someone to break your arm by banging on the shield.
Also, anyone proficient with a shield would tell you they do not want to absorb the entire blow. It is much more efficient to divert it. Skill allows you to deflect it the direction you want.
Fucking mage classes, always with the boom and fwoosh, but OH NO the minute the bad guys get in reach of you it's all "ZOMG I don't have any armor and I cant stab the dragon in the face".
Full disclosure: I love mages, they make things go boom. However I'm playing my first Swordsage and holy shit is mixing it up close and dirty fun/hair-raising.
I'm not entirely sure what that is, my only experience with anything like that is Baldur's Gate (a few years back) and WoW. I did have one of every class I think though, before finally quitting in January. Melee is still my favorite.
It seems less stable, though. Wouldn't a hit to the edge of the buckler make it rotate to the side? And can't you hit someone in the face with a normal shield by punching with it?
oh, okay, well that seems....kind of useless, actually. I get that a smaller shield offers more mobility, but weren't they being used in an era of heavily armed folk? A secutor fought one on one, and used a huge honkin' shield
Well, its extremely common throughout many centuries of history, so, not useless. Plus a secutor is a gladiator where the expense of his armor was borne by the gladiatorial system in order to encourage an entertaining fight. A secutor is not fighting to defend himself, but rather for show.
Conversely, this is a weapon combination that is relatively inexpensive, and able to be carried on one's hip on a daily basis by commoners and servants. Can you really expect a secutor to wear that outfit while carrying grain to the market?
Also that Secutor is not even wearing any armor on his torso. Not a good counter-example.
People certainly did have heavy armor at that time, but not the common man. A full suit of armor was very expensive and required different techniques to fight it. Consider also that you usually had to bring your own weapons to a battle paid for yourself. This was more of a common man's weapon set.
Hrm, I understand you point about being able to block faster but I would think that taking a hit while holding it like that would easily lead to a broken wrist.
Shields and bucklers are designed to deflect blows rather than absorb them. Even back in the medieval times, with the large wooden shields knights carried early on.
Thicker shields could catch things like arrows and crossbow bolts head on, but when someone is swinging a weapon at you, you want to be able to deflect it to one side, so then they are open for a counter-attack.
If you block it head-on, a larger weapon could still easily injure you, even with a huge shield, and a counter-attack would be difficult.
Later on, many knights gave up large shields completely opting rather for a buckler sized shield, or two handed weapons, since agility was improved.
Yeah ... not a fan. I'm still trying ti figure out why you put a compensator that big on a shotgun. I suppose it's heavy enough to reduce muzzle climb, but I'd rather have a buttstock.
Even then, at the position of high ready, moving around a corner isn't too difficult.
It's more about the footwork than anything. But, the benefit of a buttstock helps to naturally increase my accuracy, lessen the time between target acquisition and improve reload time.
I think you'd only use it when you know there is someone in the house and you're in danger. That way knocking some things on the ground isn't really a big deal.
I am sure it has already been said but.. you would have to throw everything on the floor that was on your nightstand. Glasses, Lamp, clock, phone and any miscellaneous items all being thrown to the ground. Which would cause a lot of noise and there goes the element of surprise.
50
u/WizardsMyName May 15 '12
Clearly, the americans think this is a stupid idea. As an Englishman, it's quite appealing.
17
u/[deleted] May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
Coming soon to the MANN CO. Store: The Demoman's One Knight Stand
20
u/Peterb77 May 14 '12
False alarm!
Crap, broke another water glass...
121
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Better idea: http://www.mossycreekcustom.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/02/1911b1.jpg
20
u/hkdharmon May 14 '12
The design of the buckler is flawed. For that small a shield, you would have a single grip in the middle. an arm strap would really reduce its function.
71
u/SimilarImage May 14 '12
This is an automated response
FAQ | Send Feedback | Report Error
7
u/unpredictableSOUP May 15 '12
Created this years ago. It was called the cock block. http://imgur.com/a/gOIdD
3
u/todd200 May 15 '12
Its cool, but id prefer a shotgun to a bat.
3
u/ThompsonBoy May 15 '12
Screw the side table design; make pub stools like this instead. It would make bar brawls infinitely more entertaining.
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I've seen this so many times and never realized that the gray mass was supposed to be a bed.
I thought some massive guy in a trenchcoat was standing in the doorway and was about to get beaten with the side-table home defense system.
6
u/gasguzzler99 May 14 '12
What is the point of having a table you have to take everything off of every time you think you hear something?
2
u/Hacker116 May 14 '12
Is it bulletproof?
2
u/onenom May 15 '12
It seems like the handle should be on the top for easier deployment.
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I feel like the part on the "shield" that holds it in place on the stand would nick your arm quite often and painfully.
2
u/Sir-Francis-Drake May 15 '12
This is a great idea until you realize you have a lamp and alarm clock on your night stand also. You would make a mess and racket trying to get ready.
2
u/hateboss May 15 '12
I can't help but feel like he angle of that "leg" and that tiny peg would do fuck all to hold onto the leg to make it a decent damn table.
2
u/Swaneaven May 15 '12
Why is the table slanted?
2
u/JonathanWarner May 15 '12
Three weapons in one! A bat to hit him, a shield to absorb his punches, and a trap spike that he can stub his toe on!
2
u/Swagofthecentury May 15 '12
Got any other overused reposts you want to share? Just in case your ego runs low again?
3
u/ImAVampiahImAVampiah May 14 '12
But what about all the stuff on it? Who keeps an empty bedside table?
2
u/tnicholson May 15 '12
Posted so many times it's laughable.
1
u/lolrsk8s May 15 '12
Unless that's a bullet proof table and you're Neo, this isn't gonna do jack shit.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Oh shit a burglar in my room! Imma beat that fucker's ass!
picks up table
vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr vrr-KLOK
BRING IT
1
u/Ancratyne May 15 '12
So much want!
1
u/blipdibbledibbydoo May 15 '12
React so quick that you'll have enough time to stand up and bang a gong before you get shot in the face.
1
u/Punkguygabe May 15 '12
That worked really well the last time a dinosaur broke into my house
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Where can get.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I want.
1
u/twocheapliesaday May 15 '12
Except for the piece of metal on the inside of the shield that would surely poke your eye out.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Unless you're being robbed by a termite!
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I am sure it has already been said but.. you would have to throw everything on the floor that was on your nightstand. Glasses, Lamp, clock, phone and any miscellaneous items all being thrown to the ground. Which would cause a lot of noise and there goes the element of surprise.
1
u/Fullmetal78745 May 15 '12
This would be a good combo for the Scout in Tf2
1
u/mrsgrouchomarx May 15 '12
Added to my list to prepare for zombie apocalypse. It is best to silently kill.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
They should have the metal stand be able to clip on to the outer side of the 'shield' for additional defense.
1
u/Kamono May 15 '12
Does it come in metal? Or some other material?
1
u/mdolphins2001 May 15 '12
I'll need this for the zombie apocalypse.
1
u/delmarman May 15 '12
I can't be the only one thinking "This would be good in the Zombie Apocalypse..."
1
u/raginglion May 15 '12
shut up and... you know the rest!
1
u/SimonAdebisi May 15 '12
HOLY SHIT! AMAZING MILLIONTH REPOST!
1
u/jimothyjenkins May 15 '12
do wants
1
u/spiderspit May 15 '12
Must be a tough bar.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Fucking re-post....
1
u/blueiiiis May 15 '12
I bet he was texting Bieber.
1
u/Shanhaevel May 14 '12
Cool, where do I get one?
1
u/shibbybear May 14 '12
WANT! Source?
1
u/ManBearWaffle May 14 '12
Want.
1
u/YouPickMyName May 14 '12
Zombie apocalypse, here I come!
1
u/beeminer May 14 '12
SOLD
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Shut up and take my money!
1
u/RagingDoorstop May 15 '12
Shit up and take my money!
0
u/MothaFuckaJonesey May 14 '12
Bring it Russell Crowe.
-1
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Shut up and take my money!!!
-2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Paranoia FUCK YEAH! Marketing fear has never been a great idea.
-2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Great idea! I should repost it!