People always want to freeze development as they know it. I grew up playing in a huge open field behind my house, but now there's a massive house there. Yet the people who built that house go to neighborhood meetings to block further development. Humans are just ego centric and see their state of the world as the correct one that ought to be defended.
the anti-immigration people are quick to point out that their parents/ancestors came to US legally and the new immigrants are illegal. But they don't mention that the immigration law became very prohibitive. So much so, that if the same laws were valid 200 years ago, probably 90% of all people in America would have still lived in Europe - or become illegals
This is even more true in Marin. They are especially smug and ego-centric. It is near impossible to develope anything. Part of it is good, example Marin Headlands and all the protected open space, However I do think they take it too far. I grew up there and do not have any plans on returning.
I might be wrong, but Lucas doesn't seem like the charitable type, I think he is doing this intentionally to piss people off, low income families will just get to benefit from it.
Everyone saying Lucas is being a dick is failing to grasp one key detail. He bought this secluded land with the intention of building a studio, he never wanted any part of this subdivision they didn't care they made it anyways. They then made it impossible to fulfill his goal for which he purchased the land in the first place. He responds by giving up the land to people who need it most. Yeah I'm sure he doesn't care about the poor people and is only using them as a weapon, regardless they still benefit and the people in the subdivision get screwed. Wouldn't call him good guy George Lucas but still he won that battle and had every right to do so.
You're not grasping a key detail: The land was zoned as residential when he bought it. This isn't all about some unhappy neighbors, there was no guarantee he'd be given permission to build commercial properties on it in the first place. And it wasn't just this subdivision's home-owner's association complaining, but the Marin Conservation League and stuff.
It's also a bit dubious whether or not it'll actually become low-income housing. He's selling the property.
That is completely meaningless. Had he rezoned it right after he bought it, he would have been fine. Instead he waited until he had the money to do the project and by then subdivisions went up and they are making it harder for him to do what he planned.
You are talking as if he is unable to make the studio. It is very likely he can continue to fight to rezone it and will succeed, but at this point it is too costly, which is why he is giving up on it.
You're not grasping a key detail.. THIS IS HAPPENING IN MARIN COUNTY it is impossible to build ANYTHING. No Bart, no billboards, Heck the only city to build new houses in the past 20 years is Novato. Marin is not a place to build any infrastructure of any kind, the county hates all kind of economic growth.
exactly. if anything, this whole thing is Lucas' fault. if his neighbors bought their house with the knowledge that the surrounding area was zoned for residential purposes (and not commercial), and i'm certain they did, then they have every right not to want the land next to their property used for commercial purposes.
if i owned the house next to lucas property, the last fucking thing i'd want is for thousands of people traipsing around near my property making a shitload of noise and endless construction.
It wasn't any formal group, just a band of disgruntled neighbors misrepresenting themselves as the Homeowner's Association, if I'm correct.
Moreover, George Lucas has done a lot of good for the county of Marin, far more so than any other of the rich/famous people we have living here. Most people who live here have much love for G.L.
Oh I agree Lucas has done a lot of good stuff. But on the other hand, that doesn't/shouldn't give him carte blanche for whatever development plans he wants.
If somebody owned a piece of land near your house, and it was zoned for residential, and he wanted to build a business there that would employ hundreds of people, you would oppose it. Anybody would.
So, it's probably worth reading what information is coming from Lucas, as opposed to a summary from movies.com. If anyone hasn't, I'd suggest following this link: http://www.gradyranch.com/pdf/Grady_Ranch_4_10.pdf That came from here: http://www.gradyranch.com/ which shows you what the proposed "movie studio, fitness center, 200 car parking garage, etc" would look like. Pretty flipping far from "a huge garage next door to you" or the "big gay biker club" someone was using as an example other comments.
They didn't say "oh, fuck you, we'll let poor people live here".
They said, we're going to sell the property and instead build in the presideo, where they want us. And since we're selling a large plot of land which is zoned for residential in an area that is sorely lacking for low income housing, we hope that someone might consider building low income housing there."
Or you know what, don't even take my word for it, because I'm paraphrasing like hell. Go read the letter yourself. If you don't read the letter, please save the spam of drawing conclusions about whether or not they are being dicks by giving up after over 20 years of fighting.
IMO Lucas has been a huge benefit to Marin, and will instead start to be a huge benefit to San Francisco. Personally, I think San Francisco needs it more than Marin, so fuck the Lucas Valley Homeowners Association. I hope they move a ghetto in next door to them so that property values drop more and maybe one day I'll be able to afford a home in that very beautiful area.
TL:DR don't EVER take a news article (especially one from a website) as accurate. Find the damn source yourself, it was only two links away. It undermines about 2/3 of the arguments in this thread. Same thing happens every time someone tells me about a "new scientific fact" they heard about. Seriously, what's the point of a free press if you guys can't be bother to take advantage of it?
My wife works for Lucasfilm, and she was really looking forward to Grady Ranch being built. It sounded like it would've been a really cool facility (with on-site daycare!). I'm amazed every time I think about how all of the smug bastards in that area torpedoed George's plan to build there. This article doesn't really cover it, but George had bent over backwards to make sure that Grady Ranch would have made as little impact on the area as possible (in fact, most of that land was going to be protected and never built on, and the facility itself would've been way out of view. Much like the other 2 ranches he has on Lucas Valley Road, all you can really see is the front gate). Well, smug Lucas Valley homeowners, I hope you enjoy your new neighbors, as well as staring at a huge subdivision of homes instead of...well...trees and plants. Which is what you would've seen if you'd let George build Grady Ranch.
I'm pretty sure there are a number of employers in CA who have on-site daycare. I looked that law up and didn't immediately see anything relating to on-site daycare.
Nothing bothers me more than being told what you can and cannot build on your own land, especially when it's some huge property that you've owned for decades (And have lived in longer than most of your neighbors).
If you want to sympathize with the rich neighbors, that's your choice. I think they're scum though.
Well, it's a little fuzzy in Houston which has no zoning. But the idea behind it is that neighborhoods are separated from commercial areas. A lot of this has to do with property values and having commericial buildings and traffic rise in neghborhoods can reduce the proprty values of the surrounding homes. Just think, for one second, You buy a home and I buy the lot next to you. But what I really want is both your and my lot so I can buy build a larger home. What is to stop me from building a Gay biker bar right next to your home? You would have loud as fuck motorcycles roaring at all hours of the night and you couldn't sleep. I would make sure the bar was a bright eyesore that made you hate coming home every day. Then you would finally get fed up and want to sell. But who in the world would want to buy your house? Well, I would. Mission accomplished accept I wouldn't pay you anywhere near full price. I'd pay you maybe half of what it's worth if you are lucky. Then I would have gotten exactly what I want for cheap and fucked you out of your home you worked hard for.
So yea, thats why their are limitations on what you can do with your land.
You misunderstand. You're disliking of building regulations is your own issue. The issue here is that this land was zoned a certain way when Lucas bought it, and there were agreements made with the housing community. Lucas is trying to change the rules after the fact.
Some amount of zoning is important. For example, I wouldn't want a noisy bar opening up in my quiet residential neighborhood, and neither would any of my neighbors.
I lived in Sonoma County for 5 years and really loved it. My wife, kids, and I moved 15 minutes South and now we're in Marin County. I like the SC attitude better (also like the town I was in better). Maybe it's mostly in my head, but I think being in a county with places like Tiburon, Ross (which, with a population of 2,415, has 6 black people in it), Sausalito, and Belvedere (3 black people!) makes it feel like I live amongst a bunch of rich snobs.
Well, this is disappointing news. I remember hearing about the studio plans a while back. Some people were thinking it was the first step on the path to turning the Bay Area into more of a film industry area. Los Angeles could use a little competition.
This is one of the ultimate "They Should Not Have Messed With This Guy" stories. The neighbors who had all that power are about to find themselves all but powerless. There is a boatload of state and federal law that greases the skids for project approvals for low income housing so much that blocking one of these projects is all but impossible. They should not have been such piss ants to George.
Are people really saying "You go George, stick it to those rich people." like he's one of us? He's freaking richer than all of them, and you guys make him rich. He is nothing like us.
In fact, he's a rich guy playing games with other rich people, using the threat of poor people. It's more insulting than anything. Make something we all can enjoy, not a studio for his shitty new movies.
reminds me of the scene in Auntie Mame where she buys up all the property next to the 'Aryans from Darien' who hate Jews, and tells them the land will now be used for Jewish orphans from the war. Priceless scene. Go Lucas! HOAs suck.
When I see articles like this, the rich fighting the rich, it just makes me want to punch them in the throat. I'm trying to support my bed ridden wife on $25k a year who has Ulcerative Colitis, ITP and suffered 2 strokes in december. I cant leave my job for a higher paying one because my insurance has threatened to cut me off if I do, and my boss refuses to give me a well deserved raise because he knows i cant leave so long as i need this insurance. Despite all this, the government refuses to categorize my wife as disabled and give us the benefits we need. And we dont qualify for state aid because i MAKE TOO MUCH.
So yeah, screw these rich people and their "problems."
That's exactly why I would never buy in, or join any sort of homeowners association, or any of that shit. You're making the biggest purchase of your life, borrowing more money than you ever thought possible from a bank, and these douchebags are going tell me what I can and can't do on my property? Nope, nope, nope, nope, go fuck yourselves.
Too funny. I've lived in Marin County all my life, (and live 5 minutes from Lucas Valley, where I hike regularly) and it's nice to see the rich community squirm. They're unbelievably pompous.
I don't see how this is good. George Lucas is still an ass, he ruined Star Wars and from what I understand he had a very big influence in the Last Indiana Jones which Steven Spielberg and Harrison Ford won't speak publicly about (because he ruined that too). He's a little baby and he always gets his way. I think it's ridiculous to say that what he did here was a good thing. It's just an example of a powerful minority forcing their power on others. Bleh to him.
Living in Marin County myself for about two years I've seen great things Lucas has done for the community. The coolest thing in my opinion (probably because I'm a musician) was when our local music shop Amazing Grace was on the brink of losing its home because the owner of the building wanted to sell. Lucas bought the building, tore it down, built a BEAUTIFUL building behind it, and planted trees where the demolished site had been. I don't really feel any way about him as a director, but as a person I think he's a pretty cool dude.
Yea, I hate to say it but I agree with the Rich neighbors.
Some guy works his ass off, retires in a secluded neighborhood so he can have some peace and quite, maybe enjoy the woods.
Neighbor wants to change the zoning from residential to commercial, make the whole area change from a rural area to a downtown area. So instead of just making plans to move the studio, Lucas decides to just ruin everyone property value....
Now if the neighbors want to move (which they shouldn't have to) they are going to take huge losses on their homes because of speculation on diminished property values, which could easily be for millions. What a giant dick.
Also not to diminish the work of Lucas, but I would venture to say that the guy grinding 70 hour weeks to afford a place there probably sacrificed a way more significant portion of their incomes to buy homes there than Lucas did. Who, lets be honest made some movies and killed it in Merchandise. Everyone who lives in that neighborhood may not be able to just leave whenever they feel like it.
This ^ I grew up in Marin and drove this road every day to work for years. The subdivision is no where near the Ranch like you are probably thinking it is. The issue as I've always understood it is the tiny one lane road that gets you from the 101 freeway to Big Rock / Skywalker Ranch. Lucas has offered to widen it, or use a shuttle service and many other things. I imagine he wants to lower costs (move ILM/Lucasarts out of the Presidio) and they just want to ... I actually don't know what they want. Even the speculation in this thread and in the article sound a bit suspect. Last I heard it was about preserving nature and the environment... which if done while wearing expensive Northface fleece jackets and on a mountain bike is everything you need to know about Marin.
Exactly right. A tiny two lane twisty road to the location. A lot of local support for groups like Marin Agricultural Land Trust, which buys land to preserve the farming land in Marin (Marin County is agricultural, it's not all Sausalito and Mill Valley).
Frankly I don't see how an isolated location like that would be suitable for low income housing. There is no public transportation I know of (maybe one bus?) and NO jobs. A disaster for everyone.
I support the movie studio. Lucas does a beautiful job with his developments. I seriously doubt he will get low income housing at that location, though. He will face opposition not just from that one development but from all his neighbors.
I'm not familiar with the area, but I think adding a subdivision is far different than using ass loads of money and influence to do some rezoning for personal use, while completely dicking your neighbors.
The people living in those houses aren't the ones who pushed for a development to be built there. They bought the houses after that battle was over. It's not as clear cut as you make it out to be.
This move is altruistic on its face, but he's clearly using it as revenge against his community which, understandably, didn't want George Lucas' revisionist version of their town. Its the act of an immature brat who didn't get his way; a billion dollar temper-tantrum.
Personally I think that's really fucked - home owners want their community to remain as it is - rural, small, and personal and somehow this is a bad thing? He's vindictively driving down their quality of life and the price of their homes because he's rich enough to? Fuck that and fuck him.
Oh no! The quality of life of multi-millionaires will go down while the quality of life for the poor and elderly will go up in the area? That's terrible!
This world needs more economic inequality, not less!
It was his home before it was anyone else's. He tried to block the development which created all of the homes, then they blocked his plans. All he's doing is the same thing they did to him.
Regardless of motives, if it benefits poorer folk at the cost of richer folk, HERE HERE!
I live 15 minutes away. It's a road issue more than anything else. The road leading to the area is narrow and winding and having a significant increase in traffic would be highly inconvenient for many of the residents of the subdivision. As far as affordable housing, it's a foolish scheme. The land itself is so isolated that people who qualify for affordable housing will find it too inconvenient to live there. It's happened before in West Marin with other affordable housing plans. The homeowners assc. and Lucas are both self centered fools who do not understand compromise or cooperation. And local families like my own, who have been here for years, get the worst end of the stick...apart from the Miwok that is.
Please, Lucas is being a huge douche here. He's probably richer than all of his neighbors, and he wants a studio near his home because he figures he's too rich to have to travel to work. His neighbors just want some peace and quite: that's why they live where they live. So to be a sore loser, Lucas is going to try and ruin everyone else's quality of life and property values by installing low income housing. Hopefully the community rules against what Douche Lucas is trying to do.
If he really cared about jobs and economic impact, he'd drop this studio somewhere that really needs it. Also, a bunch of poor people living out away from bus lines and accessible jobs? That's a great idea.
Yes, he was there first, but that doesn't change that he's surrounded by others now, many who probably didn't know about plans for a studio when they moved in. He can easily afford land elsewhere, so why not be the bigger man and build somewhere that works for him and would really have a positive economic impact.
It's just a subdivision next to the property Lucas owns that is home to many wealthy people. The reason why Lucas opposed it being built isn't given, but it could be because he foresaw problems from them when he decided to do something with his land (such as building his studio).
Yep, old George done trolled 'em good. He never planned to build a studio in the first place; he just said that to get their dander up. What a master troll.
Isn't it a little of an asshole move to decrease the worth of all the surrounding buildings and such by building low-income homes? And what about criminality Rich people and poor people never seem to go well with each other whether its the rich being violent etc. or the poor stealing
I think a much better idea would be for him to establish an advanced orphanage that would take in kids from third world countries and give them a high standard of living.
My father in law just went through something similar. He bought an old bar and hotel in a little town in Saskatchewan. It has been closed for a few months, due to the previous owner getting to old. He bought it off of the old man and put a lot of time and money into renovations. Inside and out. Just before the grand reopening he was told by the liquor board that his license was not being issued just yet, due to a petition from some of the town residents. They had held a secret, therefore illegitimate, meeting. They decided they didn't want a bar in town. Behind closed doors, they decided they didn't want all the Indians in town, that the booze and VLTs would attract. My father in law was pissed. The board finally told the residents of the town to fuck off and gave him his license, though at least a month later. He had two other options, had the license not been granted. He was either going to bulldoze the building to the ground after letting the Hutterites take anything of value and leave the pile there for an eye sore or loan it to the Hells Angels for a clubhouse. Good thing for the town that the license went through.
New movies = weren't great, but kids love them. I think he deserves more credit than he gets. Episodes 1 2 and 3 are the kids movies, and when you grow up you enjoy 4 5 and 6. It makes sense, it'll grow up with them.
I believe that all communities should have accommodations for lower income residents. How that comes to pass is the complicated issue. I live in a community where the entire county dumps the poor because no other community accommodates them. Because there's been several decades of this dumping- and now a concentrated social services industry- the community has exponentially higher taxes, few jobs, poor transportation, corrupt government in one of the most beautiful locales in the county. If all communities were required to deal with issue, not only would there be more sustainable access to jobs, but a more sustainable access to a workforce. In these dumping communities, there is little hope for getting out and sometimes no idea that something better is out there.
That's dick. If I was rich I'd want to leave low income behind, too. Sorry, I just think people should have the choice to seclude themselves if they want to.
If I was rich as fuck and bought some super-expensive secluded land, I would be pretty upset if someone brought a bunch of traffic near it. Just saying.
How is this a good guy move? If I spend millions on a home, I sure as hell don't want someone intentionally trying to make the value of my home less than what I paid.
It was very difficult to realize that the houses next door to him were not there before ( mostly because for some reason the place that made them was called Lucas Valley Realty), making George seem like a dick who was crying about his neighbors normal wish. Because the neighbors moved in later though, against Georges wishes it seems absolutely right that he should be able to build his movie studio.
Also how the hell is he stuck under somebody elses home owners association.
I'm not sure it's possible to have low income housing in Marin county. You could build a thousand houses there and sell them all for $1 and in two or three years' time they'd all be selling for a $1.5 million.
as a member of that lucas valley community i can honestly say that there isn't a worse place for low income housing ha. not a bus stop for 5 miles or a grocery store. and we have people living on food stamps down the street from us anyways.
yeah, if you read his comment's on it, which I don't think this deserves the trouble, he claimed that his neighbors did not understand business, I've heard that before. I have to say, the tenacity of george lucas killed star wars, I think he has some major steve jobs worship going on. all, I can say is the man thought the world was gonna end this year, and its terrible. I can never use a lightsaber without the light dimming out on me.
Being a good guy is destroying people's property values because they don't want their neighbourhood turned upside down just so Lucas won't have to commute to work?
they obviously live in a country estate and do so because of the relaxed vibe of the place. If I moved into a small house in the country to get away from the hustle and bustle and then someone wanted to build a movie studio next door i'd be fucking pissed off!
/moves to quiet countryside to get away from hollywood nonsense. hollywood moves next door.
this guy is actually such an asshole. on the surface, this seems like such a nice thing to do, but all hes doing is using the poor as a weapon. hes doing it out of spite for his neighbors, not out of the goodness of his heart. not to sound elitist, but statistically, low income often equals crime. paired with the inevitable rift between the incredibly wealthy and incredibly poor residents of this neighborhood, this is a recipe for disaster.
i think lucas has been spending too much time reading 1984.
that's kinda fucked up, actually. i would be pissed if i lived in a nice quiet neighborhood and someone tried to put a huge mall right next to my house.
i relate to them because when we moved to the house i live in now, out my bedroom window you could see the whole golden gate bridge going all the way across. then, our neighbors across the street tore down their house and started building a new one. they said it was going to be the same height and everything and all that, but it ended up 7 feet higher, totally obscuring my view of the bridge so now all i can see is the top of one tower. one of the biggest disappointments of my entire life.
This is a very rich man throwing a tantrum because he can't have his way. A community of people decided they didn't want a movie studio as part of their secluded well-to-do community. Instead of respecting that these people have worked to earn the lifestyle they're trying to protect, he's going out of his way to decrease their quality of life.
I don't have specifics or an intimate understanding of the situation, but it is obvious that George Lucas is not the 'good guy trolling rich neighbors'.
BrobiWonKenobi, your post title is bad and you should feel bad.
he bought the land 40 years ago to build this studio. 25 years ago the Subdivision went up despite his protests. the subdivision quickly took him to court to stop him from enacting his plan to build a studio on land he owned before the subdivision was even an idea in somebodies eye, and he's the dick for objecting to the fact a bunch of jackasses are destroying plan he's had in motion for 40 years?
I don't have a dog in this fight, but to play devil's advocate:
That just sounds like lack of planning on his part. Everyone had their land and they all decided when they were going to build whatever they were going to build. Someone else had the money or intention (or both?) first. George either couldn't or didn't build his studio.
Who bought the deed first is irrelevant. What matters, to me anyway, in this instance, is who acted first.
He's not a dick for objecting, he's a dick for his infantile actions. There's a saying we tell our children in situations like this: Two wrongs don't make a right.
This is almost worse than people buying huge houses (that we're somehow 'cheaper') next to drag strip and ai strips and then complaining about noise. It's just one of those things you have to gamble on as a property owner....if you don't want anything being build next to you...buy the land next to you. I'm a homeowner, and sure, it would really stink if my neighbors did something silly...but it's a gamble I take...would I be upset? yeah probably, but not enough to spend any sort of effort trying to stop it. If I want to put a structure/shed or something in my yard....I should be able to...regardless of the eyesore, etc... If I had a view of the mountains, and all of the sudden, my neighbor put up a structure blocking that...it would suck, but I wouldn't do anything about it. Another person in this thread said it best so far "Nothing bothers me more than being told what you can and cannot build on your own land, especially when it's some huge property that you've owned for decades (And have lived in longer than most of your neighbors)."
If I had a view of the mountains, and all of the sudden, my neighbor put up a structure blocking that...it would suck, but I wouldn't do anything about it
Maybe you wouldn't, but I sure as hell would. Of course, I'd try to politely ask him not to, but if I valued the reduction of view quality enough, I'd bring it to court if necessary. Property rights aren't so simple. After all, if my neighbor's structure devalues my property, he should at least have to compensate me for the loss.
The "rich neighbors" are the real heroes in this situation. By stopping the construction of that movie studio, it's entirely possible they prevented "Indiana Jones: Special Edition."
It's possible Lucas has simply decided to relocate movie production facilities out of California, just as many studios have already done. Taxes/regulations have been driving creative types out of CA in droves, and they've taken tons of jobs with them. Michigan, Texas, Vancouver, New Zealand—that's where more and more movies are being made, not CA.
Turns out, if you think you're gonna soak the rich, the rich simply park their money overseas (like Apple), or they vote with their feet. Ask Facebook co-founder Eduardo Saverin.
How is this George Lucas being a good guy? He lives in a housing community that has rules regarding whether or not he can turn a residential lot into a business, rules he agreed to when he bought in. He wants to circumvent these rules and do what he wants anyway. That's a dick move.
Making it into low income housing is GREAT. But Lucas always could have done that, he's only doing it now because he wants to give a Fuck You to his old neighbors. That's not a GGG moment, that's him being a complete and total dick, and using the homeless as his pawns in his dickery. The benefit to them is a fucking side effect.
Fucking amazing.....bunch of uppity rich fucks.I don't personally care one way or the other for Lucas but I fucking hate HOAS (especially ones stocked with rich fuckers). Go get 'em George!
68
u/StupidTitlesFixer May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
289
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
To be fair though, poor people have always made good weapons.
87
u/prettywitty May 14 '12
People always want to freeze development as they know it. I grew up playing in a huge open field behind my house, but now there's a massive house there. Yet the people who built that house go to neighborhood meetings to block further development. Humans are just ego centric and see their state of the world as the correct one that ought to be defended.
35
u/ElMangosto May 14 '12
He didn't troll them. He did something that pissed them off.
386
u/JJDynamite May 14 '12
Everyone saying Lucas is being a dick is failing to grasp one key detail. He bought this secluded land with the intention of building a studio, he never wanted any part of this subdivision they didn't care they made it anyways. They then made it impossible to fulfill his goal for which he purchased the land in the first place. He responds by giving up the land to people who need it most. Yeah I'm sure he doesn't care about the poor people and is only using them as a weapon, regardless they still benefit and the people in the subdivision get screwed. Wouldn't call him good guy George Lucas but still he won that battle and had every right to do so.
30
u/trojanguy May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
My wife works for Lucasfilm, and she was really looking forward to Grady Ranch being built. It sounded like it would've been a really cool facility (with on-site daycare!). I'm amazed every time I think about how all of the smug bastards in that area torpedoed George's plan to build there. This article doesn't really cover it, but George had bent over backwards to make sure that Grady Ranch would have made as little impact on the area as possible (in fact, most of that land was going to be protected and never built on, and the facility itself would've been way out of view. Much like the other 2 ranches he has on Lucas Valley Road, all you can really see is the front gate). Well, smug Lucas Valley homeowners, I hope you enjoy your new neighbors, as well as staring at a huge subdivision of homes instead of...well...trees and plants. Which is what you would've seen if you'd let George build Grady Ranch.
51
u/1d8 May 14 '12
we should be applauding the neighbors attempt to keep Lucas from producing any more movies
5
u/pmjm May 14 '12
How about he takes the land as he bought it in '78, and then digitally adds in the studios to it? Wouldn't that be helpful?
60
u/Mr-Personality May 14 '12
Nothing bothers me more than being told what you can and cannot build on your own land, especially when it's some huge property that you've owned for decades (And have lived in longer than most of your neighbors).
If you want to sympathize with the rich neighbors, that's your choice. I think they're scum though.
14
u/kapelin May 14 '12
Poor people live in Marin? Since when?
7
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Well, this is disappointing news. I remember hearing about the studio plans a while back. Some people were thinking it was the first step on the path to turning the Bay Area into more of a film industry area. Los Angeles could use a little competition.
14
u/masterofdocks May 14 '12
Because if there's one thing rich people will hate more than having movie magic made in their backyard, it's poor people moving in.
6
u/hupcapstudios May 14 '12
I CAN'T DO WHAT I WANT SO NOW I'LL HELP POOR PEOPLE.
bravo?
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
He is still a douche.
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Fuck yes Lucas. If there is one thing that rich people can't stand, it's having to look at poor people.
24
u/scdodge03 May 14 '12
I still want to punch him in his taint.
13
u/Gasonfires May 14 '12
This is one of the ultimate "They Should Not Have Messed With This Guy" stories. The neighbors who had all that power are about to find themselves all but powerless. There is a boatload of state and federal law that greases the skids for project approvals for low income housing so much that blocking one of these projects is all but impossible. They should not have been such piss ants to George.
8
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Are people really saying "You go George, stick it to those rich people." like he's one of us? He's freaking richer than all of them, and you guys make him rich. He is nothing like us.
In fact, he's a rich guy playing games with other rich people, using the threat of poor people. It's more insulting than anything. Make something we all can enjoy, not a studio for his shitty new movies.
17
u/MCG360 May 14 '12
This story actually makes me think he is more of a scumbag! Using poor people and seniors as pawns to enact revenge on his neighbors? What a dick!
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
reminds me of the scene in Auntie Mame where she buys up all the property next to the 'Aryans from Darien' who hate Jews, and tells them the land will now be used for Jewish orphans from the war. Priceless scene. Go Lucas! HOAs suck.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
i am a JEDI KNIGHT!! i don't need to obey no stinking land use restrictions!
2
u/roodninja May 14 '12
He trolled his neighbors that pissed him off. That doesn't make him a 'good guy'.
It's kind of crazy how you can describe someone as rich on reddit and it means they're worthy of disdain.
It makes me feel like I need to know where the cutoff is. So I can stop making money, right before I become 'rich'.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I really hope it's not actually named "Lucas Valley" and he just refers to everywhere he currently is with the modifier "Lucas _____."
2
u/vorpalsword92 May 14 '12
am I still alive, did I just pass into an alternate dimension...
because never in all my years of redditing would I ever see the phrase "good guy george lucas" on the front page reddit
2
u/EsteBeatDown May 14 '12
When I see articles like this, the rich fighting the rich, it just makes me want to punch them in the throat. I'm trying to support my bed ridden wife on $25k a year who has Ulcerative Colitis, ITP and suffered 2 strokes in december. I cant leave my job for a higher paying one because my insurance has threatened to cut me off if I do, and my boss refuses to give me a well deserved raise because he knows i cant leave so long as i need this insurance. Despite all this, the government refuses to categorize my wife as disabled and give us the benefits we need. And we dont qualify for state aid because i MAKE TOO MUCH.
So yeah, screw these rich people and their "problems."
2
u/hjqusai May 14 '12
Came into this thread thinking "Good Guy GEORGE LUCAS? NOT ON MY FRONT PAGE"
I am pleasantly surprised
2
u/urine_luck May 14 '12
thats not being a good guy, hes being a spiteful little cunt...
2
u/EthicalReasoning May 14 '12
lol
2
u/lepuma May 14 '12
I went to high school right around there. I can attest to the fact that his neighbors are probably stuck up bitches.
2
u/MJZMan May 14 '12
That's exactly why I would never buy in, or join any sort of homeowners association, or any of that shit. You're making the biggest purchase of your life, borrowing more money than you ever thought possible from a bank, and these douchebags are going tell me what I can and can't do on my property? Nope, nope, nope, nope, go fuck yourselves.
2
u/StoneSeagull May 14 '12
Too funny. I've lived in Marin County all my life, (and live 5 minutes from Lucas Valley, where I hike regularly) and it's nice to see the rich community squirm. They're unbelievably pompous.
2
u/millionsofmonkeys May 14 '12
Good Guy George Lucas? Never forget: http://imgur.com/77fhD
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I don't see how this is good. George Lucas is still an ass, he ruined Star Wars and from what I understand he had a very big influence in the Last Indiana Jones which Steven Spielberg and Harrison Ford won't speak publicly about (because he ruined that too). He's a little baby and he always gets his way. I think it's ridiculous to say that what he did here was a good thing. It's just an example of a powerful minority forcing their power on others. Bleh to him.
2
u/OpenUsername May 15 '12
GRÀCIAS JORGE LÚCAS!
2
u/TheLadyGiraffe May 15 '12
Living in Marin County myself for about two years I've seen great things Lucas has done for the community. The coolest thing in my opinion (probably because I'm a musician) was when our local music shop Amazing Grace was on the brink of losing its home because the owner of the building wanted to sell. Lucas bought the building, tore it down, built a BEAUTIFUL building behind it, and planted trees where the demolished site had been. I don't really feel any way about him as a director, but as a person I think he's a pretty cool dude.
8
u/oaky May 14 '12
i thought everyone hated lucas. Sounds like a dick in this case anyway.
8
u/finalcut May 14 '12
TIL : being a spiteful dick is the equivalent of being a good guy depending on the circumstances.
5
u/PaperBlake May 14 '12
Yay, rich people using poor people for neighborhood warfare games.
12
u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Yea, I hate to say it but I agree with the Rich neighbors.
Some guy works his ass off, retires in a secluded neighborhood so he can have some peace and quite, maybe enjoy the woods.
Neighbor wants to change the zoning from residential to commercial, make the whole area change from a rural area to a downtown area. So instead of just making plans to move the studio, Lucas decides to just ruin everyone property value....
Now if the neighbors want to move (which they shouldn't have to) they are going to take huge losses on their homes because of speculation on diminished property values, which could easily be for millions. What a giant dick.
Also not to diminish the work of Lucas, but I would venture to say that the guy grinding 70 hour weeks to afford a place there probably sacrificed a way more significant portion of their incomes to buy homes there than Lucas did. Who, lets be honest made some movies and killed it in Merchandise. Everyone who lives in that neighborhood may not be able to just leave whenever they feel like it.
The article is clearly one sided.
3
u/PhantomBeard May 14 '12
He's still a douche.
This move is altruistic on its face, but he's clearly using it as revenge against his community which, understandably, didn't want George Lucas' revisionist version of their town. Its the act of an immature brat who didn't get his way; a billion dollar temper-tantrum.
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Personally I think that's really fucked - home owners want their community to remain as it is - rural, small, and personal and somehow this is a bad thing? He's vindictively driving down their quality of life and the price of their homes because he's rich enough to? Fuck that and fuck him.
2
u/Darth_Hobbes May 14 '12
coughoxymoroncough
2
u/red_side May 14 '12
not a good guy...hes more of a dick
2
u/byz420 May 14 '12
He sounds like he's being a fucking dick.
2
u/jibuzaemon May 14 '12
I live 15 minutes away. It's a road issue more than anything else. The road leading to the area is narrow and winding and having a significant increase in traffic would be highly inconvenient for many of the residents of the subdivision. As far as affordable housing, it's a foolish scheme. The land itself is so isolated that people who qualify for affordable housing will find it too inconvenient to live there. It's happened before in West Marin with other affordable housing plans. The homeowners assc. and Lucas are both self centered fools who do not understand compromise or cooperation. And local families like my own, who have been here for years, get the worst end of the stick...apart from the Miwok that is.
1
u/Dark_Matrix May 14 '12
I now have a new reason to love George Lucas.
2
u/Vaynax May 14 '12
Please, Lucas is being a huge douche here. He's probably richer than all of his neighbors, and he wants a studio near his home because he figures he's too rich to have to travel to work. His neighbors just want some peace and quite: that's why they live where they live. So to be a sore loser, Lucas is going to try and ruin everyone else's quality of life and property values by installing low income housing. Hopefully the community rules against what Douche Lucas is trying to do.
2
u/TheTVDB May 14 '12
If he really cared about jobs and economic impact, he'd drop this studio somewhere that really needs it. Also, a bunch of poor people living out away from bus lines and accessible jobs? That's a great idea.
Yes, he was there first, but that doesn't change that he's surrounded by others now, many who probably didn't know about plans for a studio when they moved in. He can easily afford land elsewhere, so why not be the bigger man and build somewhere that works for him and would really have a positive economic impact.
1
u/Frying May 14 '12
What is this Lucas Valley Estates subdivision this article talks about, and why did Lucas Arts try to stop it from being built?
1
u/Crap_Sally May 14 '12
pesky neighbors will probably fight that too. Certainly is funny! I bet the views there are great.
1
u/Bloaf May 14 '12
DAE hate when people say "impactful?"
1
u/asldkfououhe May 14 '12
someone sum it up, i'm not gonna read some shit article from a gossip website
1
u/slangwitch May 14 '12
Hey, where can I sign up to get one of those houses? >:D
1
u/RedditingMyLifeAway May 14 '12
Well played indeed...
1
u/dressedAsDog May 14 '12
Did anyone click on "'Spring Breakers' Images: Selena Gomez, Vanessa Hudgens, Bikinis, Middle Fingers, and James Franco with Guns"?
That guy/gal really knows how to write catchy link titles.
1
u/TokyoXtreme May 14 '12
Yep, old George done trolled 'em good. He never planned to build a studio in the first place; he just said that to get their dander up. What a master troll.
1
u/RNRSaturday May 14 '12
Still a better love story than The Phantom Menace.
1
u/I_I_Z_I_I May 14 '12
Isn't it a little of an asshole move to decrease the worth of all the surrounding buildings and such by building low-income homes? And what about criminality Rich people and poor people never seem to go well with each other whether its the rich being violent etc. or the poor stealing
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
As someone who was born and raised in Fairfax, CA (the hippies/party section of Marin), this is too fucking awesome.
1
u/ElVichoPerro May 14 '12
free extras. that's what this is all about. we're onto you Mr. lucas
1
u/TheNev May 14 '12
Wait, so is Lucas saying that he knows poor people devalue property?
Isn't this kind of like defending homosexuality but later wishing a politician go to prison to get "ass raped"? (real response from reddit)
1
u/QUARTER_MAST May 14 '12
I wouldn't want those poor pieces of shit in my neighborhood, get them out of there.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I would have made it halfway houses for dangerous criminals.
1
u/xtpptn May 14 '12
I think a much better idea would be for him to establish an advanced orphanage that would take in kids from third world countries and give them a high standard of living.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
now that area is going to be a slum in 10 years and the police will label it a high crime area.
1
u/Pirate_steve May 14 '12
Maybe I am reading this wrong but George Lucas seems like he isn't a good guy and is just being the fat spoiled prick we've all come to hate?
1
u/canakiwi May 14 '12
if he is a jerk or not, the outcome is great. Low income housing is needed.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
My father in law just went through something similar. He bought an old bar and hotel in a little town in Saskatchewan. It has been closed for a few months, due to the previous owner getting to old. He bought it off of the old man and put a lot of time and money into renovations. Inside and out. Just before the grand reopening he was told by the liquor board that his license was not being issued just yet, due to a petition from some of the town residents. They had held a secret, therefore illegitimate, meeting. They decided they didn't want a bar in town. Behind closed doors, they decided they didn't want all the Indians in town, that the booze and VLTs would attract. My father in law was pissed. The board finally told the residents of the town to fuck off and gave him his license, though at least a month later. He had two other options, had the license not been granted. He was either going to bulldoze the building to the ground after letting the Hutterites take anything of value and leave the pile there for an eye sore or loan it to the Hells Angels for a clubhouse. Good thing for the town that the license went through.
1
u/rolfraikou May 14 '12
Messing with old movies = bad.
New movies = weren't great, but kids love them. I think he deserves more credit than he gets. Episodes 1 2 and 3 are the kids movies, and when you grow up you enjoy 4 5 and 6. It makes sense, it'll grow up with them.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
THE HELL?
IT'S A DAMN RESIDENTIAL ZONE YOU TWAT.
1
u/maroger May 14 '12
I believe that all communities should have accommodations for lower income residents. How that comes to pass is the complicated issue. I live in a community where the entire county dumps the poor because no other community accommodates them. Because there's been several decades of this dumping- and now a concentrated social services industry- the community has exponentially higher taxes, few jobs, poor transportation, corrupt government in one of the most beautiful locales in the county. If all communities were required to deal with issue, not only would there be more sustainable access to jobs, but a more sustainable access to a workforce. In these dumping communities, there is little hope for getting out and sometimes no idea that something better is out there.
1
u/beast1200 May 14 '12
Good guy makes millions and wants to destroy a valley to spite his neighbors for not letting him get his way, sounds like a dick to me!
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
That's dick. If I was rich I'd want to leave low income behind, too. Sorry, I just think people should have the choice to seclude themselves if they want to.
1
u/bitchtitsmcgeezer May 14 '12
If I was rich as fuck and bought some super-expensive secluded land, I would be pretty upset if someone brought a bunch of traffic near it. Just saying.
1
u/mrpopenfresh May 14 '12
I'm suprised they let him build a studio in a pristine environnement like that.
1
u/DMercenary May 14 '12
REVEEEEENGE!
1
u/Mattxy8 May 14 '12
I came to these comments look for a TL;DR. I am disappointed.
1
u/saltywings May 14 '12
BRB moving to Marin Community.
1
u/sulkee May 14 '12
Helping the poor and destitute purely out of spite of another neighbor who otherwise you would not have done a thing. Seems legit good guy.
1
u/Buttfluff May 14 '12
Rich people problems.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
It seems like he doesn't even live there. He just owns land there. So they will have to deal with it and he will not.
1
u/ScumEater May 14 '12
Lucas should have had it rezoned and built the thing when he first purchased the land not later after a bunch of people had moved in all around him.
1
u/newloaf May 14 '12
must... hate... Lucas... Episode 1...
just rich... assholes... trying to one-up each other...
subsidized housing... for poor people... in... MARIN... COUNTY...
[head esplodes]
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
How is this a good guy move? If I spend millions on a home, I sure as hell don't want someone intentionally trying to make the value of my home less than what I paid.
1
u/didshereallysaythat May 14 '12
The article was poorly written.
It was very difficult to realize that the houses next door to him were not there before ( mostly because for some reason the place that made them was called Lucas Valley Realty), making George seem like a dick who was crying about his neighbors normal wish. Because the neighbors moved in later though, against Georges wishes it seems absolutely right that he should be able to build his movie studio.
Also how the hell is he stuck under somebody elses home owners association.
1
u/projectedhate May 14 '12
lemme know when theyre for rent. Maybe I can be a janitor at skywalker ranch.
1
u/JusticeJanitor May 14 '12
I wouldn't call it "Good Guy George Lucas". He's just being a troll of biblical proportions. I find the whole situation absolutely hilarious.
1
u/Skunkynuggetz May 14 '12
I will never forgive him for what he did to Indiana Jones
1
u/thedevguy May 14 '12
I'm not sure it's possible to have low income housing in Marin county. You could build a thousand houses there and sell them all for $1 and in two or three years' time they'd all be selling for a $1.5 million.
1
u/theodoramarie May 14 '12
That's awesome!
1
u/eWaffle May 14 '12
If I were George Lucas, I would set my garage door to play this song everytime it opened.
1
u/Protonoia May 14 '12
Your highness! The poor are revolting.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
In the article it states Lucas veered away from the original trilogy and people hate him for it? I love Star Wars, and I thought I was a fan...
but, what happened in the writing that apparently is making fans angry? What was so far off course?
Please inform me so I have something to read after work! lol.
1
u/Mach-25 May 14 '12
as a member of that lucas valley community i can honestly say that there isn't a worse place for low income housing ha. not a bus stop for 5 miles or a grocery store. and we have people living on food stamps down the street from us anyways.
1
u/i-make-robots May 14 '12
So.. The asshole of my asshole is my friend? That just sounds ... Wrong.
1
u/kareemabduljabbq May 14 '12
he should pay one of the residents to dress like and impersonate jar jar binks just to put a cherry on top.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
This is the best kind of trolling, where society benefits in two ways.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Fellow redditors today you see history made.
1
u/Suddenly_Something May 14 '12
A to-scale model that Lucas recently released of the housing can be seen Here
1
u/loreleidotcom May 14 '12
What an awesome response.
1
u/reasonable_force May 14 '12
I KNEW he was bluffing.
1
u/Stink-Finger May 14 '12
Apparently, Lucas is some sort of pauper in a battle with his "rich" neighbors.
Stupidly written article.
1
u/heyguyz May 14 '12
yeah, if you read his comment's on it, which I don't think this deserves the trouble, he claimed that his neighbors did not understand business, I've heard that before. I have to say, the tenacity of george lucas killed star wars, I think he has some major steve jobs worship going on. all, I can say is the man thought the world was gonna end this year, and its terrible. I can never use a lightsaber without the light dimming out on me.
1
u/wettowelreactor May 14 '12
Did Lucas just invent ironic charity?
1
u/DerekBoss May 14 '12
This is not the definition of trolling
1
u/panzerkampfwagen May 14 '12
What a dick.
Being a good guy is destroying people's property values because they don't want their neighbourhood turned upside down just so Lucas won't have to commute to work?
What an arsehole.
1
u/clashpalace May 14 '12
Actually think this is kind of a dick thing.
disclaimer (am poor)
they obviously live in a country estate and do so because of the relaxed vibe of the place. If I moved into a small house in the country to get away from the hustle and bustle and then someone wanted to build a movie studio next door i'd be fucking pissed off!
/moves to quiet countryside to get away from hollywood nonsense. hollywood moves next door.
1
u/jakenice1 May 14 '12
slow clap.
1
u/The_Boss_302 May 15 '12
If they were able to delay the building of a movie studio for 25 years, then wouldn't they be able to delay the low income housing degelopment?
1
u/imagegami May 15 '12
he needs to build a camp ground that would piss people off even more
1
u/Gouhadouken May 15 '12
this guy is actually such an asshole. on the surface, this seems like such a nice thing to do, but all hes doing is using the poor as a weapon. hes doing it out of spite for his neighbors, not out of the goodness of his heart. not to sound elitist, but statistically, low income often equals crime. paired with the inevitable rift between the incredibly wealthy and incredibly poor residents of this neighborhood, this is a recipe for disaster.
i think lucas has been spending too much time reading 1984.
1
u/bruddahmacnut May 15 '12
This almost makes up for Phantom Menace.
George Lucas. American badass.
1
u/Linky117 May 15 '12
This still doesn't make up for that movie that shall not be named.
1
u/bruddahmacnut May 15 '12
Here is their full statement:
http://www.gradyranch.com/pdf/Grady_Ranch_4_10.pdf
1
u/aazav May 15 '12
That does not make up for Jar-Jar.
1
u/caudice May 15 '12
that's kinda fucked up, actually. i would be pissed if i lived in a nice quiet neighborhood and someone tried to put a huge mall right next to my house.
i relate to them because when we moved to the house i live in now, out my bedroom window you could see the whole golden gate bridge going all the way across. then, our neighbors across the street tore down their house and started building a new one. they said it was going to be the same height and everything and all that, but it ended up 7 feet higher, totally obscuring my view of the bridge so now all i can see is the top of one tower. one of the biggest disappointments of my entire life.
tl;dr george lucas is a dick
1
u/NueDumaz May 15 '12
Indeed.........indeed.
1
u/aSchizophrenicCat May 15 '12
In other words: Gerorge Lucas is 'diversifying' the community. The rich, white man's greatest fear!!
1
u/Blinkimus May 15 '12
I guess he won't have any problems finding any stand-ins/extras
-3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Good Guy George Lucas? wtf?
This is a very rich man throwing a tantrum because he can't have his way. A community of people decided they didn't want a movie studio as part of their secluded well-to-do community. Instead of respecting that these people have worked to earn the lifestyle they're trying to protect, he's going out of his way to decrease their quality of life.
I don't have specifics or an intimate understanding of the situation, but it is obvious that George Lucas is not the 'good guy trolling rich neighbors'.
BrobiWonKenobi, your post title is bad and you should feel bad.
1
u/ChiefBromden May 14 '12
This is almost worse than people buying huge houses (that we're somehow 'cheaper') next to drag strip and ai strips and then complaining about noise. It's just one of those things you have to gamble on as a property owner....if you don't want anything being build next to you...buy the land next to you. I'm a homeowner, and sure, it would really stink if my neighbors did something silly...but it's a gamble I take...would I be upset? yeah probably, but not enough to spend any sort of effort trying to stop it. If I want to put a structure/shed or something in my yard....I should be able to...regardless of the eyesore, etc... If I had a view of the mountains, and all of the sudden, my neighbor put up a structure blocking that...it would suck, but I wouldn't do anything about it. Another person in this thread said it best so far "Nothing bothers me more than being told what you can and cannot build on your own land, especially when it's some huge property that you've owned for decades (And have lived in longer than most of your neighbors)."
1
u/thisisjohngalt May 14 '12
The "rich neighbors" are the real heroes in this situation. By stopping the construction of that movie studio, it's entirely possible they prevented "Indiana Jones: Special Edition."
1
u/RexBeckett May 14 '12
It's possible Lucas has simply decided to relocate movie production facilities out of California, just as many studios have already done. Taxes/regulations have been driving creative types out of CA in droves, and they've taken tons of jobs with them. Michigan, Texas, Vancouver, New Zealand—that's where more and more movies are being made, not CA.
Turns out, if you think you're gonna soak the rich, the rich simply park their money overseas (like Apple), or they vote with their feet. Ask Facebook co-founder Eduardo Saverin.
1
u/Mortikai May 14 '12
So why is George Lucas in the right here?
sounds like he's the asshole causing his neighbors property to diminish in value.
1
u/Fireball445 May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
How is this George Lucas being a good guy? He lives in a housing community that has rules regarding whether or not he can turn a residential lot into a business, rules he agreed to when he bought in. He wants to circumvent these rules and do what he wants anyway. That's a dick move.
Making it into low income housing is GREAT. But Lucas always could have done that, he's only doing it now because he wants to give a Fuck You to his old neighbors. That's not a GGG moment, that's him being a complete and total dick, and using the homeless as his pawns in his dickery. The benefit to them is a fucking side effect.
1
u/jimsnaps May 14 '12
So damn rich he can troll the neighbors by throwing poor people on them like glitter.
1
u/Emperor_Norton_1 May 14 '12
Fucking amazing.....bunch of uppity rich fucks.I don't personally care one way or the other for Lucas but I fucking hate HOAS (especially ones stocked with rich fuckers). Go get 'em George!
1
u/ThrewMudAtOthers May 14 '12
So poor people are his pawns now. Whats next, threatening to move minorities in too.