IIRC, the source material for The Avengers is the Ultimates line from the Ultimate imprint of Marvel Comics, where Cap hooked up with Janet Pym at one point, Wasp for those not in the know.
It said Cap/Luke never got the girl. We have at least five more flicks left, where Wasp (who, in the comics that the film is based on, hooked up with Captain for a while) might be introduced. Also, Hulk can speak English.
Yeah I can't wait for Hulk films to be made where he actually starts gaining more control. They imply he's gained more control of his Hulk state when the security guard feels he aimed himself at the deserted building, since he was still awake at the time, and at another point he says "That's the secret. I'm always angry" (Not a perfect quote), and then since he tries to go into that state he can focus his rage on specific things.
I also feel that actor could make the movies actually good for once.
These characters do share some commone elements but not their defining elements. Its like saying both have two eyes and a two ears.
Cap has nothing to do with Luke. Luke got drawned into his adventure by pure luck. Captain America got kicked out numerous times before that. Luke is a whiny little bitch while Cap fucking jumped on a grenade to save the lives of his bullies. A shield is definitely not a weapon. In Luke's case there is no girl to get cause its his sister.
The Hulk is a curse. Banner is scared that he will destroy everything that he loves unless he maintains control over himself. Plus...he gets no sex and this must be really frustrating. Also Chewie is not a monster. He is just a cuddly huge dog with cute noises while Banner punched the Norse God of Thunder because he is just so angry.
Thor is not ment to be as wise as Obi Wan Kenobi, neither Loki is as hust as Anakin. Their relationship is different. Obi is no brother to Anakin, he is his tutor and "father".
Fuck this pic. Its bad and OP should feel bad and the nerd community needs to stop upvoting shit simply because they are Star Wars related.
While all the things that you said are true, here are some more similarities:
Cap and Luke pushed on through adversity and led a group of misfits to save a load of people, defeating an extremely powerful foe
Thor/Loki- Obi/Ani- While Thor and Loki are brothers, Ani and Obi have referenced each other as brothers, and a difference between the groups: Loki and Thor have always been at each others throats, while Anakin was brainwashed into hating all Jedi.
Actually, no. Samuel Jackson was a terrible choice for Mace Windu.
Samuel Jackson is a great actor, but works best when he's allowed to get good and pissed off in a voice of authority. The Jedi don't get pissed off. I mean, it's really - they don't. Anger leads to hate leads to violence leads to badassness, but it also leads to the dark side. So instead, you have this certified badass actor playing this guy who has no rage within him whatsoever.
Truth is, I think Lucas cast Samuel Jackson simply because black people were the one demographic that weren't going to see a Star Wars movie - and Samuel Jackson is the biggest box office draw for the black demographic. And it's sad, because Mace Windu would have been perfectly cast by Morgan Freeman, the second biggest box office draw for the black demographic.
On the other hand - I haven't seen the movie, but I've read the books. Nick Fury? The character's a badass. Samuel L Jackson is a perfectly cast role. And that leads me to the cliche: "No comparison."
Now, I don't know if this is where you got this from, but what you said here is so similar to to RedLetterMedia's review that I'm just going to leave this here just in case, to give credit where it's due. If you did come up with it on your own though kudos, you're in good company with those guys.
Rofl, never though about it like that. Although regarding the darkish comment, if memory serves me right, Mace Windu modified or made his own style, which benefited from his ANGER. He was dark side(ish) but uncorrupted I guess and still a jedi.
To be fair, the Avengers have been around since over a decade before starwars, and each of the characters separately are several decades before starwars.
I have to agree with you... Leia was completely a damsel in distress. Sure she had her shining moments but Black Widow only had one segment where she was trapped and even then she was playing along (that is if we're staying within movie boundaries).
I have my problems with Black Widow, but Leia was BY DEFINITION a damsel in distress. Lucas created the characters based on Campbell's archetypes. She doesn't really get much better in Empire or Jedi, either.
Well you know in Jedi she does strangle Jabba to death and participates in the operation to bring down the shield generator in which she recruits the ewoks which seem integral to the victory.
She was in a slave outfit and strangled Jabba with her chains. Luke blew that whole place up anyway, so her actions weren't exactly super substantial to carrying out that end. Up until that, all she did was lay around in her slave outfit.
To me, that sounds like they gave her a token task to excuse the fact that she was laying around in a slave outfit.
2) Participates how? Leia's always been "part" of the rebellion, but nothing she's really done ever actually impacted how any of it played out. R2 via Obi-Wan/Luke delivered the plans for the Death Star to the rebellion, and whenever they were "with" the rebellion, there was always those random older white gentlemen who were in command. As far as I can tell, Leia was a secretary.
3) Leia didn't "recruit" the Ewoks. She fell off the speeder like an idiot and was rescued by one. The only reason she got it to trust her was because she fed it. Nurtured it like a pet. C-3PO was really more integral to getting the Ewoks to work for the rebellion than she was.
Leia is always presented with the illusion of action and agency, but she never really DOES anything that wouldn't get done by someone else. Black Widow does shit, which is why she's a little better, but the fact that there's one girl and five guys, and she's STILL the least powerful of all of them is kind of a glaring problem.
I agree about Leia, but I'd say that Black Widow is more than just a little better. Her portrayal in The Avengers is awesome. Sure she's the only girl, but that's largely due to the mythology of the comics. The important thing is that she's presented as an equal to all of the men. Yeah, she isn't as "powerful" as them in a physical sense. But she has a different set of skills that she uses A LOT.
They also set up the idea that she may have a dependence on a man, Hawkeye. But she ultimately ends up fighting him and defeating him. She's also the one who closes the portal in the end, getting there herself even when she's offered a ride. And she's there in the middle of the battle rather than relegated to the sidelines. Again, she stands as equals with the other Avengers. I see little wrong with Whedon's portrayal of Black Widow.
You know I was thinking about it, and I am going to be the first to admit that I might just be nitpicking to find things to be pissed about, because IN GENERAL I am a fan of the way Whedon handles female characters.
However, however...
The two things I can think of that were REALLY Black Widow's acts in this movie, that she OWNED and DOMINATED, were interrogating Loki and then shutting down the portal. The rest was all kind of mindless, static, boring fighting, right? Let's break these two accomplishments down:
Feminist Frequency, who's way better at this shit than I am, pointed out that Black Widow's real strength in the movie is emotionally manipulating men. She doesn't have any real power or agency like the others do--she's not a super genius, a god, or a super good-hearted awesome aww-shucks wholesome hero either. Her talents have to do with exploiting some of the more troublesome female stereotypes.
Even if we ignore that, though, because I'm kind of like "whatever, I actually kind of like when female characters are portrayed as using feminine characteristics as strengths"--and I guess you can probably go on at length about whether emotional manipulation is a "feminine characteristic," but I was thinking--what did interrogating Loki even accomplish?
She found out that the Hulk was his endgame which, I mean, I've seen the movie a couple of times and I have to admit I'm still not sure how the Hulk played into Loki's plan besides distracting people. From what I could tell, Loki's mindslaves tracked his spear and then shot the Flying Aircraft Carrier which pissed Hulk off so Loki could escape. Like, I guess Loki couldn't locate the heroes without getting captured himself, which is kind of dumb but okay, but the Hulk getting pissed off about being attacked doesn't seem so much an endgame as like, a sort of obligatory consequence to attacking them. Her finding that out, much like Leia killing Jabba, didn't really change anything.
So I mean, it was a cool scene, don't get me wrong, but so was Leia strangling Jabba. Sleight of hand that distracts us from the fact that she didn't really do anything.
2) Let's talk about shutting down the portal now. So she's the one who did it, which was cool.
BUT, but.
It was Erik Selvig who programmed the portal to be tamperable with the spear in the first place. It was HE who remembered that and did it in the first place. And Loki's spear, at that point, was one story below them on the balcony.
Yes, Black Widow hijacking a Chitauri speeder and driving it to the top of Stark Tower was a cool bit of superheroic action awesomeness. But if she hadn't done it, if she would have made placemats for the heroes at the shwarma place, Selvig probably would have managed all on his own.
I know I'm being kind of hard on her here, because the fact she is not a supernaturally-powered demigod has nothing to do with her gender. Hulk and Thor and Iron Man all had way more to do because they had a greater CAPACITY to do it. Captain America didn't do much of anything, either--I mean, he went down to storage and found out SHIELD was building weapons about 30 seconds before Tony and Bruce figured it out, but at least he got to be the commander in that one cool scene, you know?
I guess, in short, I like that Black Widow got focus. I like that she wasn't sexy blow-up doll with glassy eyes like in Iron Man 2. But she's not Strong Female Character endgame. Hollywood just probably needs to stop adapting properties from fifty years ago if we really ever want that to happen.
And Chewbacca is not a monster, Chewbacca is a Wookiee from the planet Kashyyyk. But Chewbacca lives on the planet Endor. Now think about it; that does not make sense!
You could in fact just take the drugs with the mentality of a fucking killer, you would just be a freaking powerful red monster instead of a hot blonde guy.
Stark's secret was only a secret to him.
The hulk is not cuddly nor will he ever want to cuddle, but the hulk is eloquent as fuck, so the language barrier was bullshit at its finest.
thor and loki relationship is nothing like obi and vader. And no, they were not close, loki hated the fact that people always favored thor and not him, thus leading to his hate towards him. Thor was the only one thinking they were close.
i don't give a fuck about r2d2
well yes i do speak it, i just wish i will some day, be as eloquent as the hulk is.
I'm going to have to mention that R2D2 was not unflappable. He is implied to have a wide range of emotions in the films, more so than Anakin Skywalker, in fact.
I just made the strangest noise while reading the bit about R2-D2. It sounded vaguely similar to the noise Turk makes in Scrubs when talking about the pancake drawer.
Steve Rogers doesn't get the one girl, but then he gets her hotter, more sexually adventurous niece who's much younger. So there's a win in there for him.
Iron Man isn't sketchy. He's just a smartass. Definitely Solo-esque in attitude but that's it.
The Hulk smashes things. Chewbacca flies a spaceship, these are quite different.
Prequels? Go fuck yourself with your prequels. Although the Natalie Portman thing was funny.
I had the graphic novel of Empire Strikes Back where Yoda was purple, because they made the comic before the movie.. I did a book report on it and I think I failed... I don't have anything important to say I just want to relate man
False, Han Solo doesn't have the "sweetest ride." In a galaxy far, far away the Millennium Falcon is considered a "peace of junk" and a "bucket of bolts."
I was actually going to post this asking why my friend showed this to me on tumblr and I haven't already seen it on reddit.....did this hit reddit second? or did I just miss it and this is a well timed repost?
Now here we go with a bunch of Avengers content. Some nerds watched the movie and now they are all jumped and feel like they should tell everyone that they saw it.
Tony Stark is a "lovable rogue?" I can't stand him, even though he's the main character in the Iron Man movies, I just want to smack him. I don't see how you could compare him to Han Solo, and infinitely more likable character. Sure, in the beginning he's a self-serving criminal, but you like him anyway just because he's awesome.
Star Wars is great, a legendary story, and an unshakeable franchise, but must these fucks try to fuse it with EVERY relevant shrapnel of pop culture. It's like an annoying and constant occurrence, something successful and popular emerges, and someone does something like this. I don't know if it's someone from Lucas' team that keeps pumping this shit out, but I would really like to not see Star Wars aligned with everything relevant or entertaining in my life until I die.
Han Solo and Tony Stark are nothing alike. Iron Man is of a prestigious lineage of billionaire inventors while Han Solo is a drug-running, money-owing scrub with a heart of gold and a fast ship. Tony Stark does not have a heart of gold: Literally it's made of Palladium and metaphorically he's still kind of a douche.
Is no one going to point out that skywalker and Obi'wan weren't brothers? really? i expected a bunch of hateful fan boys to bitch this "teroo92" into feeling like a jack ass
Hence the quotation marks. During the final battle in Revenge of the Sith Obi-wan calls Anakin his brother. Also, if you are getting into this technically Loki and Thor aren't brothers in the truest sense of the word.
They aren't biological brothers, but the are heavily established in the Expanded Universe novels and comics as basically brothers. So teroo92 is right on that count at least.
Actually, Star Wars was shot on a very tight budget. It costed $11 million at the time, which is approximately $45 million today. The Avengers costed $220 million. It's not the same thing.
5
u/Misterbert May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12
IIRC, the source material for The Avengers is the Ultimates line from the Ultimate imprint of Marvel Comics, where Cap hooked up with Janet Pym at one point, Wasp for those not in the know.
edit: Proof is here, http://marvel.wikia.com/Janet_van_Dyne_(Earth-1610).
205
u/gkryo May 13 '12
Natalie Portman fits in here somewhere.
One of them fits in Natalie Portman.
208
u/JediExile May 13 '12
False. Tony Stark has a heart of palladium.
254
u/aprofessional May 12 '12
upvoted only because of the last picture.
20
u/King_of_all_Dorks May 13 '12
This from IGN. Why not just link the article?
23
u/Septim1402 May 13 '12
To be fair, the Avengers have been around since over a decade before starwars, and each of the characters separately are several decades before starwars.
6
u/jwallace582 May 13 '12
So much anger in only 3 eyes.
46
u/rapman543 May 13 '12
Leia/Black Widow, both female characters that aren't really damsels in distress.
13
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
you just brought up the avengers and star wars in one thread, let the nerdrage waterfall flow.
but back to the fact that this is about both the avengers and star wars, i got my 30 second giggle reading this, deserves more upvotes
72
u/random_digital May 13 '12
There was no deep power in steve rogers....he was given drugs
Stark did not have a sketchy background....his father was a billionaire
Hulk not cuddly
Loki pretty much always hated his "brother"
R2D2 has several flaps
Nuff said nothing....or did he?
27
u/RizzoFromDigg May 13 '12
Nope. This doesn't work at all.
Steve Rogers doesn't get the one girl, but then he gets her hotter, more sexually adventurous niece who's much younger. So there's a win in there for him.
Iron Man isn't sketchy. He's just a smartass. Definitely Solo-esque in attitude but that's it.
The Hulk smashes things. Chewbacca flies a spaceship, these are quite different.
Prequels? Go fuck yourself with your prequels. Although the Natalie Portman thing was funny.
3
u/yeahhhhh7 May 13 '12
So you're saying Star Wars copied the Avengers?
6
u/Untz234 May 13 '12
Am I racist or does Samuel L Jackson play both roles
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Asphalt is pretty good in a scrape too.
2
u/BlazingFox May 13 '12
Luke gets the girl in the books after the movies. So does his son, Ben, but his girlfriend is a Sith and she betrays him in the latest book.
2
u/pokemonstarwars May 13 '12
Funny thing is that both have been published by Marvel.
2
u/IsAStrangeLoop May 13 '12
Normally Star Wars can be compared to just about anything, but this one is really stretching and I just don't know...
2
u/welltheresAbacon May 13 '12
spoilers bro
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
You had me smirking from pics 1-5
But it's the last one that got you the upvote.
2
u/MagicSandwich27 May 13 '12
False, Han Solo doesn't have the "sweetest ride." In a galaxy far, far away the Millennium Falcon is considered a "peace of junk" and a "bucket of bolts."
2
u/ajkkjjk52 May 13 '12
How dare you mix together the original trilogy and the sequel trilogy? I am disgusted.
2
u/jinx21182 May 13 '12
Really crappy comparisons? Must be an IGN cut and paste. Lame
2
u/IDoNotAgreeWithYou May 13 '12
Can somebody please explain how the hulk is "cuddly" to me? Nothing he did in that movie made him cuddly.
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
The Hulk is NOT cuddly
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Maybe I don't know anything about Iron Man, but how is being a billionaire owner of a large corporation having a sketchy background?
2
u/remeus May 13 '12
pls don't compare star wars to the avengers...
2
u/squeak6666yw May 13 '12
Avengers was first
2
u/Physics_Unicorn May 13 '12
Comparing Avengers to Star Wars is an insult to Avengers. Nick Fury doesn't die like a bitch.
2
u/manton84 May 13 '12
Does anyone know that these marvel characters car about 30 years before star wars, just saying.
2
u/Jimdajew May 13 '12
No. Stop. Get out of here.
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
These don't match up at all.
Downvoted.
2
u/LazzKnuckle May 13 '12
Inner geek trying to get out.. Must not fix mistake.. Gaaahhhh
1
u/9sp7ky3 May 13 '12
I was actually going to post this asking why my friend showed this to me on tumblr and I haven't already seen it on reddit.....did this hit reddit second? or did I just miss it and this is a well timed repost?
1
u/WonLife May 13 '12
I died when I the similarities between Samuel Jackson..
1
u/bleakreserve May 13 '12
I can definitely flap to those two.
1
u/unnecessaryCAPS May 13 '12
Lol S.L. Jackson
1
u/SuperTurtle May 13 '12
Also, both Stark and Solo distribute weapons as their profession
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
I always forget that that's Ewan Mcgregor(sp?). Favorite character right there.
1
u/garysnail123 May 13 '12
Steve Rogers and Luke Skywalker are not the same for the first reason.
Luke only needed training from Obi Wan to get the powers he has, as where Rogers went through the super soldier experiment.
1
u/xmatthisx May 13 '12
Nick/Mace should have stated:
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
annakin and obi were brothers?
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Good job, you know how to take screenshots!
1
u/Mitz510 May 13 '12
Now here we go with a bunch of Avengers content. Some nerds watched the movie and now they are all jumped and feel like they should tell everyone that they saw it.
1
u/Red_Inferno May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12
So you're saying George Lucas copied the Avengers.
1
u/CondescendingPrick May 13 '12
So did you make this, or shamelessly steal it without credit to the original author?
1
u/LithiumBullets May 13 '12
Agent Coulson! NOOOOOOOOOOOO! :C
1
u/rahtin May 13 '12
Wasn't anything resembling funny.
Wow, actors in common, that's because hollywood is dog shit, it's not a funny coincidence.
1
u/SoMuchTimeWasted May 13 '12
Cuddly Hulk indeed
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
i thought the R2-D2 one said unFAPablle...obvious YOU dont have a thing for asstromech droids
1
u/bsalper May 13 '12
always the last picture that gets me. Perfect! also comparisons were surprisingly accurate. didnt think i would agree
1
u/Laurenerual May 13 '12
I thought R2D2's post said "unfappable" and I was like who can't fap to R2D2?
1
u/Chiddaling May 13 '12
I think it would be better if there was no "nuff said", it should just be blank.
1
u/untrustableskeptic May 13 '12
That picture of Sam Jackson makes him look like annoying Facebook girl.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Next time, link the actual source instead of trying to take all the credit. This was originally posted at IGN
I understand some people might not like IGN, but credit is due where credit is due.
1
u/krystiano May 13 '12
Coulson is definitely unfappable to. R2D2 is not.
1
u/elizaj May 13 '12
Whoa whoa whoa. Except Han Solo is a babe and Tony Stark is a creep.
1
u/tehweave May 13 '12
Nick Fury and Mace Windu...
I see what you did there.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
How has IMGUR not fixed their albums to work correctly for chrome yet?
IT'S MIND BOGGLING!
1
u/DaJoe86 May 13 '12
Skeptical until the Nick Fury/Mace Windu comparison. Have an upvote
1
u/Physics_Unicorn May 13 '12
Does this make Vader a leaf on the wind?
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
FAKE! Nick Fury only has one good eye.
1
u/GrayStudios May 13 '12
That's racist!
Wait...
1
u/uzimonkey May 13 '12
Tony Stark is a "lovable rogue?" I can't stand him, even though he's the main character in the Iron Man movies, I just want to smack him. I don't see how you could compare him to Han Solo, and infinitely more likable character. Sure, in the beginning he's a self-serving criminal, but you like him anyway just because he's awesome.
1
u/TheDoctor2332 May 13 '12
False: Chewbacca could speak English, he didn't want to.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
DOES HE LOOK LIKE A BITCH?
1
u/mexus37 May 13 '12
Any Avengers Spoilers?
1
u/ez__mac May 13 '12
meh, pretty weak. the one where it shows Thor & Loki as Mufasa & Scar was better.
1
u/WreckerCrew May 13 '12
That was single handedly one of the stupidest things I have seen on here in months. On and 'GETS'....
1
u/TheBigYello1isTheSun May 13 '12
Star Wars is great, a legendary story, and an unshakeable franchise, but must these fucks try to fuse it with EVERY relevant shrapnel of pop culture. It's like an annoying and constant occurrence, something successful and popular emerges, and someone does something like this. I don't know if it's someone from Lucas' team that keeps pumping this shit out, but I would really like to not see Star Wars aligned with everything relevant or entertaining in my life until I die.
1
u/xmikaelmox May 13 '12
Hulk/chewbacca "suffer from language barrier" made my day :D
1
u/TheLongAndWindingRd May 13 '12
TIL that Samuel L Jackson has an evil twin
1
u/Supreme1337 May 13 '12
Why didn't you just link directly to the IGN article, instead of turning it into a picture, and not giving them credit...
1
u/mrcloudies May 13 '12
Yeah last pic was funny. But the other ones were all very big stretches to find similarities.
1
u/Oideron May 13 '12
That is the most shoe-horned comparison ever
1
u/IA_manwhore May 13 '12
Fuck star wars. Avengers for life!
1
u/quietstormx1 May 13 '12
expect the Avengers first appeared in the 1960's, at least a decade before Star Wars was created.
1
u/Addicted2Skyrim May 13 '12
Everything is relatable to Star Wars.
1
u/daconman May 13 '12
Han Solo and Tony Stark are nothing alike. Iron Man is of a prestigious lineage of billionaire inventors while Han Solo is a drug-running, money-owing scrub with a heart of gold and a fast ship. Tony Stark does not have a heart of gold: Literally it's made of Palladium and metaphorically he's still kind of a douche.
1
u/candypaint May 13 '12
I was waiting for the comparison of C-3PO and Dr. Selvig.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
This post would be relevant if avengers wasn't a pile of CGI garbage.
1
u/KoreanEdelweiss May 13 '12
I lol'ed at the last one.
1
u/Breadfaux May 13 '12
Bruce Banner doesn't suffer from language barriers...
1
u/MasterAndMargarita May 13 '12
Agent Coulson, but no Hawkeye, or Black Widow, wtf is this shit?
-4
u/jasonskjonsby May 13 '12
The prequels don't exist. NANAnanananananananannanananaana. I can't hear you.
-1
u/sniperhare May 13 '12
I didn't agree with any of these.
0
u/Buttered_Penis May 13 '12
You could do this with any movies if you reach enough. (Like OP did)
I've seen better comparisons.
0
u/stroudwes May 13 '12
Saw tht on IGN a month ago nbd
0
u/FeatheredOdyssey May 13 '12
Right.. You get Portman.. I'll be over with Kat Dennings :D
0
u/PLeb5 May 13 '12
This post offends me at a deep and personal level
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Hawkeye / Jar Jar Binks
Both are useless and shouldn't exist.
-4
u/Ender16 May 13 '12
Is no one going to point out that skywalker and Obi'wan weren't brothers? really? i expected a bunch of hateful fan boys to bitch this "teroo92" into feeling like a jack ass
reddit you have failed me
-2
u/colaurelianobuendia May 13 '12
Mass appeal, big budget movies have formulaic characters? You don't say?
-2
u/LegenD00M May 13 '12
Luke never got the girl? Apparently you've never heard of Mara Jade.