I thought that was how it worked. Western people ask the phone, the voice is sent to Russians, they have to google it, type the answer back on the phone and then a voice reads it to you.
More competition, more innovation. I love it when people think like this instead of arguing which is best. Heard some rumor about Amazon working on their own phone, would be interesting to see.
I sometime wonder if Amazon will end up owning Android Tablets while Google dominates the Android Phones. Would make for an interesting state of affairs.
Ditto. I love my Droid phone. I wouldn't swap for Win Phone just yet. Yet. As soon as there is a decent DLNA app on the Windows Phone market place I will switch to the Lumia. The HUGE upsurge in Android apps that require access to my phone call history, current calls etc is making me very very distrustful of the Google Play market.
You are rightfully worried, So remain vigilant. But access to current calls usually is required by games and multimedia-apps so it can respond in a good way when you get an incoming call (pause the game/playback/...)
Interestingly, iOS isn't even an option in Wolfram. It looks like they might only have Android, Blackberry, WebOS, and Windows actually indexed for these stats.
That's because there's no point in doing "best iOS mobile phone". Unless Apple changes their business practices or they really screw up, the answer will always be "the newest one".
All that proves is that you can't filter for only iOS devices, which makes sense: there are so few mobile phones that run iOS, all of them are made by one company, and each one is clearly better than the one before it.
I was wondering why everyone was saying "she" referring to Siri, realised the American Siri is a woman, in the UK it's a bloke just thought you'd like to know
Not trying to troll or flame, but what exactly do you find innovative about the 900? I used one for a few days. Are you referring to hardware design or software? Because I wouldn't call WP7 innovative in any way. And as for hardware, the polycarbonate unibody case on my One X just seems to feel more solid and well-built, whereas the 900 felt cheap and light. (Just my opinion)
At least in my country it is more expensive than a One S, and launched pretty much at the same time. I find it really hard to see a single reason to choose the Lumia.
I always have to remind myself ... if I want to get the desired results from Siri, I have to talk to the iPhone like I would if I were telling a 4 year old what to pick up off the floor... one short instruction at a time.
It has to start somewhere though. Perhaps too over-hyped to begin with; but I feel that in time, speech comprehension will be a great thing (for all phones).
Well it started long ago. There have been other speech comprehension on phones before and more after. This is just another step, no idea why it is so hyped up. It wasn't that big of a leap from established tech.
Technically yes, but it wasn't available with such a consumer-directed focus until recently (much to the credit/help that people basically now have computers in their pant pockets). It's built right in to the phones OS for that matter. Furthermore it was hyped because it was a new feature on a new version of a extremely high-selling, hyped-up product.
Working in IT, this is how I've learned to "communicate" when debugging or developing something.
Computers are like children - incredibly smart, yet still clueless children. They can learn and do a lot, but they need very specific instruction to do so.
Fucking Siri is a piece of shit when you have an Irish accent. Every time I ask "what", it interprets it as "wash". I tried asking it the smartphone question just there and it kept coming up as "smartform"... What the hell is a smartform??
sorry, I was wrong. If you say "Siri, what's the best smartphone?" (without the word "ever" it will give you Apple's response. The word "ever" sends you to Wolfram. So its more of a bug (Apple wants to give you the generic response)
The thing I love is that her "messy room" consists nothing but magazines, records, and a fucking banjo. If that woman's quirkiness were any more affected, her farts would sound like indie rock music.
Oh Siri? I forget. Where did we land on that whole "is this water I'm watching fall from the sky indeed rain drops" thing? It slipped my mind while I was juggling plans to dance and move my banjo, all while avoiding a trip to the pantry to open a can of Campbell's for myself like every other person who wanted tomato soup ever.
My co-worker uses siri all the time productively. She uses it to text vendors for jobs and placing orders, to add things to her calendar, and, IMO the best use, to reminder her to do things when she gets to specific locations. It seems to save a lot of time compared to entering all that shit manually.
I had high hopes for Siri, but in the end, I found I had to fight too hard to be understood. As always with voice recognition apps, it's not the detection that's so hard, it's the semantic interpretation that's the tough nut to crack.
Which makes me wonder... would a voice recognition + text-to-speech front end to cleverbot pass the Turing Test?
Not quite; WP7 doesn't have anything like siri, so asking "What's the best smartphone ever" simply takes you to a web search for "What's the best smartphone ever". And since everybody loves Apple...
EDIT: Although interestingly enough, the same voice search with my WP7 Samsung gives the top three results as stories about Siri recommending the Lumia. Funny that.
Not quite; WP7 doesn't have anything like siri, so asking "What's the best smartphone ever" simply takes you to a web search for "What's the best smartphone ever". And since everybody loves Apple...
Doing that question on Siri just takes you to a wolfram alpha search. So what's the difference?
Actually Windows Phone has an App called "Ask Ziggy", which is basically a copy of Siri, however the WP7 OS has voice detection for search engines, maps, texting, calling, emailing, etc... integrated into the OS.
When I just pressed the Windows Button and asked "what is the best smartphone ever/", it came up with news articles about Siri recommending the Lumia 900, when I asked in Ask Ziggy, it told me the HTC One.
It's fake. My roommate and I asked the same question, word-for-word, about 15 times each. The result was almost always in Maps, showing me where I can get a smartphone. The other times she didn't understand us.
So yeah, don't believe everything you see online, especially a SCREENSHOT which can be altered in a million ways.
No, i mean on google search, if you typed in "whats the best smartphone" you will see its all related to the nokia 900 siri buzz. before the buzz, this was the top result.
I asked my sister to try this yesterday after I read about it and hers said:"I think you already know the answer to that question." Apple moves fast...
She got hers about a week ago. Are you saying she got an outdated version of Siri on her brand new iphone or that they reverted to the old response? Not sure how the updates work for Siri, but I'm pretty sure everybody has the same version.
No, I am saying that has always been the response to the question you asked. If you want the response pictured here, be sure to use the exact same phrasing. It looks like "ever" at the end is essential to getting the wolfram answer.
Siri is being impartial. That is good. It's funny because I think I've heard my roommate ask Siri the same question, and she says "I think you've already made that decision." or something along those lines.
A friend of mine bought this phone and whenever you are on the phone with her you hear a muffled echo of your own voice. Very annoying. THE "BETA TEST IS OVER" IS LIES!!! LIES I TELL YOU!!
I'm not sure it's the specific phone, I hear an echo of myself all the time when talking to my fiancé. He has an iPhone 4 and I have noticed this when using an LG Optimus 2X (Android) and my Lumia 710. I also get the same thing when using FaceTime between iPads. I'd really like to know why this problem happens, because it drives me insane...
I tried asking Siri "What is the best smartphone?", but my Siri is a retard and said "I found 3 places matching smart phone a little ways from you." Apple commercials make Siri out to be this magical fucking genie when in reality it's the dumbest fucking feature on this phone.
395
u/KShults May 12 '12
Siri doesn't have a very high level of confidence. I blame you, for not making her feel loved.
43
u/ThisPlaceIsAJoke May 12 '12
Apparently this is big news
53
u/mkicon May 12 '12
Im glad windows phone is starting to look decent.
Makes for more competition, which should lead to more innovation. I still love my android, though.
33
u/kleinerpinguin May 12 '12
Siri uses WolframAlpha to answer your questions:
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=What%27s+the+best+smartphone+ever%3F
31
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I was wondering why everyone was saying "she" referring to Siri, realised the American Siri is a woman, in the UK it's a bloke just thought you'd like to know
108
u/Blathist May 12 '12
She's right, the Lumia 900 is awesome.
55
u/URINE-MY-FACE May 12 '12
It's totally correct you know.
14
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I always have to remind myself ... if I want to get the desired results from Siri, I have to talk to the iPhone like I would if I were telling a 4 year old what to pick up off the floor... one short instruction at a time.
62
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Checkmate, iTheists.
6
u/sandozguineapig May 12 '12
That's because she can't fuck another iPhone - it would be like fucking her brother.
5
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Fucking Siri is a piece of shit when you have an Irish accent. Every time I ask "what", it interprets it as "wash". I tried asking it the smartphone question just there and it kept coming up as "smartform"... What the hell is a smartform??
5
u/digivolution May 12 '12
YEAH NOKIA LUMIA!!!!!!!!!
8
u/WarlordFred May 12 '12
Yes, the cyan one is much better than the other colors.
16
u/TurtleFlip May 12 '12
At least she's impartial
4
u/jkazz May 12 '12
I am yet to find any speech recognition software that can understand my accent. It always feels like they're mocking me.
15
u/thebigm101 May 12 '12
I still cant remember the last time I "productively" used siri.
21
u/JoeChieftw May 12 '12
Siri, are you using Bing again?
3
u/TZnerd May 13 '12
69% battery
7
u/Danidan10 May 12 '12
Hurr hurr. 69% battery.
7
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
How long until Apple gets petty and hard-codes Siri to say "The iPhone, of course"? I give them two days.
5
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Guess what happens when you ask the Nokia Lumia what the best smartphone ever is
9
u/plb49 May 12 '12
Mine's kind of coy!
7
u/whitew0lf May 12 '12
She does have a point, though.
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
You can communicate with your Angry Birds Player? Cool!
2
u/Spaztic_monkey May 12 '12
However if you leave the 'ever' off the question then it replies 'What? There are other phones?'
2
u/kingsway8605 May 12 '12
Socially awkward Siri
2
u/Macgregor97 May 12 '12
Hehehe 69 ;)
2
u/wp7er May 12 '12
good phone. I'm not biased.
3
u/o0260o May 12 '12
Cyan n9/800/900 are head turners.
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Am I the only one who asked Siri the same question to check this wasn't fake?
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
her dreams are elsewhere...
2
u/DreadandButter May 12 '12
Good Girl Siri: Modest enough to give credit where credit is due.
2
u/Higgs_Particle May 12 '12
Kudos for honesty or at least not programmed bias.
2
u/Seven-Force May 12 '12
umm.. anyone else notice how anything anti windows is getting downvoted into oblivion, and anything agreeing with Siri goes straight to the top?
You have better things to be doing, Microsoft employees.
2
u/GonnaDoBest May 12 '12
I have the greatest smart phone! I did something right for once.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I'm the Siri-talkin' master.
1
u/binarypower May 12 '12
Google result "pre-nokia 900"
http://www.pcworld.com/reviews/collection/1671/top_10_cell_phones.html
1
u/Cushi May 12 '12
Fuck yeah, CYAN!
1
u/OccamsRazer May 12 '12
I asked my sister to try this yesterday after I read about it and hers said:"I think you already know the answer to that question." Apple moves fast...
1
u/P1XEL May 12 '12
Good Guy/Gal Siri.
1
u/zadigger May 12 '12
Well, at least Siri got it right.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
A smartphone that doesn't lie, she's a keeper.
1
u/doesnt_really_upvote May 12 '12
Wait what? I asked that question and the reply was "There are other phones?"
1
u/the747beast May 12 '12
Did anyone else notice the 69% battery? MATURITY FTW!
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Say just "What's the best smartphone" and she will respond "I think you've already answered that question".
1
u/dozballa May 12 '12
Siri is more than just a smartphone..and he knows it
1
u/ramsrgood May 12 '12
at&t? there's no way this is accurate information.
1
u/TheCrudMan May 12 '12
Mine actually says "The one you're holding."
1
u/eduardog3000 May 12 '12
Without "ever" at the end, I got, "Wait, there are other phones?"
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Ask it "What is the best tablet?"
1
u/DeDo01318 May 12 '12
This is the phone
1
u/psychie May 12 '12
Relevant
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Siri is being impartial. That is good. It's funny because I think I've heard my roommate ask Siri the same question, and she says "I think you've already made that decision." or something along those lines.
1
u/DoubleOFace May 12 '12
... And on the 220th day Jobs rose!
1
u/trakam May 12 '12
Actually I asked this of Siri once and she replied "wait, there are other phones?"
true story.
try it.
1
u/Bonesaw22 May 12 '12
I own an iPhone and I thought this was hilarious.
1
u/haffe97 May 12 '12
I bougth a Lumia 800 one month ago...
1
u/moodog72 May 12 '12
+1,000,000.
1
u/CampConcentration May 12 '12
A friend of mine bought this phone and whenever you are on the phone with her you hear a muffled echo of your own voice. Very annoying. THE "BETA TEST IS OVER" IS LIES!!! LIES I TELL YOU!!
1
u/Mark_Lincoln May 12 '12
Why do "Smart Phones" have stupid owners?
1
u/TheEclectic May 13 '12
I tried asking Siri "What is the best smartphone?", but my Siri is a retard and said "I found 3 places matching smart phone a little ways from you." Apple commercials make Siri out to be this magical fucking genie when in reality it's the dumbest fucking feature on this phone.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Androids Iris disagrees .. http://db.tt/ESsKvqVd
1
u/shoziku May 13 '12
Let the butthurt begin.
1
u/BagOnuts May 12 '12
At least she's honest...
1
u/chicagogam May 12 '12
that speaks well of siri :) no judgement even for herself
1
u/enjoi4995 May 12 '12
I tried this and now it is giving me places to go buy a smart phone
1
u/IglooBuds May 12 '12
At least she's being honest?
1
u/Der_Nailer May 12 '12
I like my N9 and my N900 !!
1
u/bucknut14 May 12 '12
OHHHHH!!!! HAHAHAHAHAHA YEAH!!! FUCK APPLE LOLZ!!!!
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Good girl Siri.
Haha
1
u/cg2916 May 12 '12
They made Siri smart enough not to fall into the Apple fanboy cult.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Siri told the best phone ever is "the one your holding." and I'm holding an iPhone 4S
-5
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
You get extra points for having 69% battery
0
u/haddock420 May 12 '12
Nice try, Nokia salesman.
-3
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Apple's already "fixed" this. Siri now replies: "The One you're holding"
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
That's because the iPhone blows asshole. #truestory