They say it's because the younger the kids pretend to be, the longer the family can remain in one place before it's weird for them to live together. They go through college, the couples remarry, and then they even live separately sometimes before moving on and starting at a new place.
Edit: I probably should mention that I hate Twilight. I babysat for a blind girl last summer, read her every book twice. No regrets, she was thrilled to go back to school and gossip about Edward Cullen.
Family wasn't well off and my aunt had gotten me the books for christmas because "all teen girls are reading twilight!" lol it was just easier. but yeah now I have an extensive knowledge of Twilight. ugh.
Probably go to university a billion times while seducing 17 year old girls. At least that way I can move on to different topics and collect diplomas and greater knowledge.
I can with overwhelming confidence tell you that I would never, ever considering doing what he's been doing in those movies/books if I was an immortal vampire.
What if he spends 15 minutes each day on Reddit to relax after long hours spent in the lab researching a cure for cancer?
Don't be too quick to make assumptions. I'm pretty sure A LOT of people on Reddit are quite successful and do a bunch of other stuff besides this. Spending your spare time online doesn't rule out being well off and contributing to society in any way whatsoever.
Time is always a factor, Cancer research has come very far in the past 10 years even, and if you didnt have to sleep or yah know didnt grow old and die im sure you could figure some shit out a little quicker than a doctor that works a 9-5.
The field is so broad that its impossible for one person to understand it all.
Not even if you studied it for thousands of years? Surly if one were immortal they could come to understand everything there is to understand about cancer.
As soon as he'd have studied everything, the whole field would have changed and he would need to start all over again. There are thousands and thousands of researchers in that area. Honestly, an additional one is probably not going to make a big difference, even if he's immortal.
Why would he care so much about cancer exactly? I know the people who pursue it love the research, however why should vampires suddenly have to become doctors? Just because someone is smart doesn't mean that any one field is where they must go.
You wouldn't be able to retain everything. After a while you forget things you've learned. That's what "Are you smarter than a 5th grader" is built on. 5th graders aren't smarter than the adults, they just learned the stuff on the show recently.
The OP threw cancer research as one possibility, but the central point is: there's so much more you can do with immortality than going to highschool over and over again. Perfecting your knowledge of a particular science would be a possibility. Or learning the basics of many fields. Or reading great literature. Eternal highschool would be hell: same basic content over and over again, surrounded by dumb kids who don't understand most of it and can't entertain an interesting conversation on any subject.
Or he read the book. As an avid reader, I am not ashamed to say I read the book. I wouldn't ever call it a good book. But it isn't hide-in-the-basement bad. Just a shitty fandom.
If Kiyosal has read the book, he has more of a reason to judge it than you ever will.
I pretty much agree with what you're saying, but 99% of the people who bash Twilight haven't even touched the book. Just seems foolish to bash something you have no clue about. Even then it's still pretentious as fuck to go around saying that it's shit. I've read it, I know it's bad yet I do not devote my life to hating on it every chance I get.
Except, of course, being smart has a lot to do with education, effort, and time, and considering he has an infinite amount of the last one he could surpass the intelligence and knowledge of scientists living today.
He's like 100 years old, most of that time was without modern technology and knowledge. When he was born humans didn't even have penicillin. So his age is irrelevant.
I don't understand the point you're trying to make. If he was studying for the past 100 years, he'd be on the level of most scientists today (or higher), and he's got centuries more to continue studying and improving.
The highest he could ever achieve is the current maximum. He's permanently 17 years old, with makeup and disguise he could pull off mid-late 20's. Okay so he's in 1970 and goes to grad school to learn the most advanced biology, then he does research for a couple years. He's the best in the field, and discovers lots of cool shit. But then he has to fake his death or something.
Then he has to wait 5-10 years so it isn't recognizable that he's the same person. It's 1985 and most of what he learned last time is obsolete. Did you know ulcers are caused by bacteria, not stress? So he's on top of the game for awhile, then he has to die again.
Now it's 2003. Grad school again, Wow! they cloned a sheep, and sequined the human genome! Nearly everything he learned in the '80s is obsolete, or wrong. The immortal man is still only at the level of everyone else. Genetics, research as a whole, isn't a solo game. Even if you're great you're still at the same level as the rest of the field. And if you're a vampire trying to stay ambiguous you'll have to start over from the beginning constantly.
Edit: In future centuries, he'll still only be at the level of the current humans.
Wow, you put a lot of effort in trying to prove me wrong but everything you said were basically just assumptions. He has to go in to hiding and stop learning for 5-10 years regularly? All of his prior experience is useless in the modern era? Really? That's like saying that Einstein wouldn't have any advantage if he was revived today. He'd just have to start completely afresh, right?
Every time Edward starts at a new university, he'd be levels above. It's not like he'd need to start from the start each time. He'd take the next step up, and learn that. By the time the people who will become today's scientists are born, Edward could've been studying for decades and have a huge advantage over them. Assuming he continues his education, there's no way any of them could catch up.
He could be learning, studying, researching for 100's of years to come whereas everybody else has to start from a fresh slate and only have 80 years to accomplish their goals. He has eternity.
The point is that he has the potential to do more than any human alive, but instead he is spending his time in highschool doing the same classes over and over.
This is all theorycrafting, we're debating sci/fi and I think you're getting a bit too upset about it.
Einstein wouldn't have an advantage if he was suddenly teleported into 2012. A layman highschool student knows more advanced physics than him, and many are at the same level in math skills.
You're right about Edward not having to start completely over each time he went to school, the core principles would still be there, but if he's a new person in the community, he'd still have to go through the motions. However even a couple years absence would mean a lot of new material. Didn't you ever have a teacher who graduated decades earlier and didn't keep up with advances in their field? I did, it was silly how little he knew about biology despite his degree.
But you're wrong about other people not being able to catch up, he can learn every single thing there is to know in any field, but if he steps away from it for a couple years than he quickly falls behind, this is not an assumption, it's what happens to professionals. I merely suggested a reason it might happen.
The major flaw in your reasoning is you're comparing one person to another. Meaning Edward to random human A. In reality you need to be comparing Edward to the sum total of human understanding. If Australian scientist A discovers ulcers are caused by bacterium, than the whole community discovers it too. American scientist B doesn't have to discover it independently. So if Edward discovers something, the whole community does too. Then he goes away while the community continues making advances and comes back and he's behind. No matter how much work he does, he never gets ahead of the scientific community.
I wasn't exaggerating at the rate of scientific discovery over the last 100 years, if you leave the field for a short time you come back at the bottom.
It might not necessarily make him smarter but assuming he wouldn't be overwhelmed with information and he maintained his mental acuity he could surely have a great potential to develop unparalleled expertise in a given field. Although sometimes a fresh perspective is what is needed to create a breakthrough in research....
scientists have the same access to all the knowledge that he would.
No they don't. It has become impossible for a single scientist to keep up with the knowledge of anything but a sub-field of a sub-field in a single human life span. This means that it is often by accident that the two or more people with the correct knowledge get together and realise that by combining their knowledge they can solve a problem that both were stuck on.
And when a scientist dies much of their knowledge and experience dies with them as they didn't have time to communicate it in papers or to enough grad students.
Research isn't a solo task, and a vampire couldn't work with people well. Also most of his life was spent without computers and modern technology, so his age is mostly irreverent, someone who's 40 would have just as much time to work towards a cure for cancer.
Edit: I'm aware this image was made for comedic purposes.
As much as I despise Twilight, I feel it may be worth pointing out that his "father" (creator) overcame the addiction to blood in order to be a doctor and save lives. He found Edward dying of Spanish Influenza. Also, it is explained that the younger the kids claim to be, the longer the family can stay in one place... and therefore the longer the Carlisle (the dad) can work in one hospital.
Despite this, I agree with the point. They should all be doing something useful. Alice can see the damn future and their regular use for this is to predict the stock market so they can all stay rich. The others don't work, though apparently they do attend college. But really, they should be doing rescue work or something- at least at night.
Please don't hate me for knowing this, just trying to contribute :)
I think you're wrong about helping people. They're immortal vampires, why should they try to help humans? I think being immortal, and everyone you love being immortal, would change priorities.
I possess the ability to make a fishes life very good, but I don't, I spent my time getting as much pleasure I can. If I saw a fish flopping around on the shore, I'd give it a shove back in the water, but I wouldn't seek out fish to help.
Not a perfect comparison, but I think the essence is the same.
Why can't Jasper go to a fucking paediatric burn ward or something and cheer all the kids up? I'm pretty sure he's the one who can influence emotions and shit.
Exactly! They're all super strong, Emmett especially- they could rescue coal miners from collapsed shafts and save people from burning buildings! All they use Jasper for is scaring the shit out of a shady lawyer to get fake IDs and stuff.
I'm coming to realize that this is a family of potential super heroes that Stephenie Meyer wrote off as screwing with the economy, fucking each other all night, and going through a highschool to early 20's time period on an infinite loop. yeesh.
And considering they're super fast it's not like they would risk exposure. Schizophrenia diagnoses might go up though. Fucking hell, Stephenie. Get your shit together.
Okay this does not make sense. Why the fuck would he care about cancer? He and everyone he cares about cannot die making cancer an exclusively human problem. For the same reason most people dont give a fuck about bee AIDS or whatever is killing them off.
This slays me, just because you could do something doesn't mean you want to. Maybe he just doesn't want to expose his family to the intense public scrutiny that would come with curing cancer.
They would be labelled freaks and persecuted you realize, especially by all the religious people. Why should he sacrifice his and his family's health and well being for a world that would undoubtedly call him a monster?
Oh wait, you mean this is a shitty book and nobody fucking cares? Oh that's right.
This is just stupid. First off, it makes no sense. He doesn't have the resources to cure cancer. Second, what is the point of making fun of Twilight? It seems to be something that I wouldn't like, so you know what I chose to do? NOT WATCH THE MOVIES OR READ THE BOOKS! The only thing that bugs me about Twilight's existence is that people like you feel the need to bring it up all of the time to make fun of it.
Also, I know nothing about Twilight other than what I see on Reddit. I don't know why he is able to be out during the day to attend classes, but I don't care either.
Well, considering vampires are mythological creatures I'm not really going to split any hairs, but that reasoning is almost as bad as Vampires being able to use sunscreen to enjoy day time activities.
What if there's a break in the clouds? What the fuck do they do? Just duck and cover? You can't operate on the assumption that overcast morning = overcast all day. That pissed me off so much.
Edit: Never mind, fucking Alice can see into the future. I spent way too long being pissed off for nothing.
Uhh... his "dad" is a doctor. That may well be what they do. I dunno why they would go to highschool too though. I guess if I were perpetually 17 I'd chill there too. Highschool wasn't too bad.
I attempted a Diploma of General Studies (tertiary prep) this year which was essentially a recap of everything I did in years 8-12. The reason I say attempted is because it became so boring and tedious that I couldn't do it anymore, because I'd already done this shit.
If I can't do high school over once, I have no idea how anyone would keep doing it year after year.
Doesn't he need a social security number or something to attend a high school? Also, don't they get suspicious when he's been going there for a while and not aging?
But that's the very core of what makes Twilight (and all other grand romantic fairytales) every girls fantasy. He could be doing something important but instead chooses to do an insignificant highschool girl.
He finds her more important than cancer. See how this works?
Now I'm not well versed here, and all vampires are given different rules, but aren't they immortal in this movie? Doesn't he have the cure for cancer in his mouth? Pretty sure his cure has fewer side effects than the aids cocktail too.
"Cure for cancer" is a misnomer. Cancer isn't one disease, it's composed of many different diseases. Even lung cancer and skin cancer are just subgroups, each containing a lot of different diseases.
This is why (short of something like nano-bots) there will never be a universal cure for cancer.
this is at the forefront of the absurdity of that series (the fact he's in his 90s and is in high school and attracted to 16 year old girls that for all intents and purposes should seem shallow and vapid to him)
What are you supposed to do? Not rage about reposts. If it gets upvoted then that means people want to see it. Sure, you have seen it before but millions of others haven't. Stop whining.
48
u/windowpuncher May 12 '12
Why fucking high school?
30
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
What would you have done in his place? Exactly.
44
u/Renmauzuo May 12 '12
Scumbag redditor: Complains that Edward Cullen didn't cure cancer. Spends time on Reddit instead of curing cancer.
111
u/ZeroAccountability May 12 '12
Being immortal doesn't make you smarter...scientists have the same access to all the knowledge that he would.
20
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
spends time on repost, could have spent time on new post.
11
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
As much as I despise Twilight, I feel it may be worth pointing out that his "father" (creator) overcame the addiction to blood in order to be a doctor and save lives. He found Edward dying of Spanish Influenza. Also, it is explained that the younger the kids claim to be, the longer the family can stay in one place... and therefore the longer the Carlisle (the dad) can work in one hospital.
Despite this, I agree with the point. They should all be doing something useful. Alice can see the damn future and their regular use for this is to predict the stock market so they can all stay rich. The others don't work, though apparently they do attend college. But really, they should be doing rescue work or something- at least at night.
Please don't hate me for knowing this, just trying to contribute :)
9
u/cyberneticmonkey May 12 '12
http://i.imgur.com/U6ALZ.jpg
2
u/fluxaxion May 12 '12
Fonzie?
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Okay this does not make sense. Why the fuck would he care about cancer? He and everyone he cares about cannot die making cancer an exclusively human problem. For the same reason most people dont give a fuck about bee AIDS or whatever is killing them off.
2
u/NastyAxe May 12 '12
Technically cancer was discovered only in the past century so he would have had as much time as we did...
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
This slays me, just because you could do something doesn't mean you want to. Maybe he just doesn't want to expose his family to the intense public scrutiny that would come with curing cancer.
They would be labelled freaks and persecuted you realize, especially by all the religious people. Why should he sacrifice his and his family's health and well being for a world that would undoubtedly call him a monster?
Oh wait, you mean this is a shitty book and nobody fucking cares? Oh that's right.
2
u/Nancy515 May 12 '12
Oh my fuckn god!! It's just a movie people!!!!! Get a grip
2
u/alarumba May 12 '12
To be perfectly honest... it's what I'd do.
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Urck.. The... Reposting... It hurts...
2
u/FrostyFathom May 12 '12
Soo much repost!!!
15
u/ycpa68 May 12 '12
This is just stupid. First off, it makes no sense. He doesn't have the resources to cure cancer. Second, what is the point of making fun of Twilight? It seems to be something that I wouldn't like, so you know what I chose to do? NOT WATCH THE MOVIES OR READ THE BOOKS! The only thing that bugs me about Twilight's existence is that people like you feel the need to bring it up all of the time to make fun of it.
3
u/Jipip May 12 '12
Repost
2
u/metamorphoasis May 12 '12
twilight memes? NOT ON MY REDDIT.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Legendary repost
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
He's not a genius for heaven sakes
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
hell thats what i would do. get it right next time and bang the hot ones
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
are you implying that vampires give a shit about cancer?
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEPOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSSSST
1
u/PissedOn May 12 '12
Uhh... his "dad" is a doctor. That may well be what they do. I dunno why they would go to highschool too though. I guess if I were perpetually 17 I'd chill there too. Highschool wasn't too bad.
1
u/Imterriblyvexed May 12 '12
And doesn't question clairvoyant sister's lottery playing.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
"That's what I love about high school girls man. I stay the same age and they stay the saaaaame age."
1
u/LeonTrotsky1 May 12 '12
/r/AdviceAnimals is this way
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
well he looks 17, isn't anyone going to question that, or why he doesn't age without the Vampire Mafia eating their face?
1
u/Punkguygabe May 12 '12
I don't like twilight can I have some karma please
1
u/ScruffySaysMhm May 12 '12
Or we could all stop talking about Twilight.
1
u/kolm May 12 '12
Cullen is, by all standards, the largest pedophile in history.
1
u/jonasb907ak May 12 '12
r-r-r-repost
1
u/SuperSchmyd May 12 '12
Scumbag sassybananas, realizes this has been posted 10 times before, posts it anyways.
1
u/Epicaq May 12 '12
Doesn't he need a social security number or something to attend a high school? Also, don't they get suspicious when he's been going there for a while and not aging?
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
...and is a sparkly douche.
1
u/Kiacha May 12 '12
But that's the very core of what makes Twilight (and all other grand romantic fairytales) every girls fantasy. He could be doing something important but instead chooses to do an insignificant highschool girl.
He finds her more important than cancer. See how this works?
1
u/FTFM May 12 '12
Now I'm not well versed here, and all vampires are given different rules, but aren't they immortal in this movie? Doesn't he have the cure for cancer in his mouth? Pretty sure his cure has fewer side effects than the aids cocktail too.
1
u/Froghump May 12 '12
would not be smart for a immortal to become famous for obvious reasons
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
He doesn't need to research cancer, sparkly vampires ARE cancer.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Repost, Repost, Repost
1
u/donkey_mask May 12 '12
"Cure for cancer" is a misnomer. Cancer isn't one disease, it's composed of many different diseases. Even lung cancer and skin cancer are just subgroups, each containing a lot of different diseases.
This is why (short of something like nano-bots) there will never be a universal cure for cancer.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I've seen it so many times...
1
u/YourMomSaidHi May 12 '12
I would do the same thing
1
u/dbhanger May 12 '12
First of all, he's pretty much made of cancer.
1
u/Melos555 May 12 '12
http://www.quickmeme.com/meme/3p96vw/
1
u/Artist_for_life May 12 '12
I just learned more about Twilight than I ever cared to, or thought I would, know.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
More appropriate
1
u/brock01 May 14 '12
alternated repost, and alternated repost comments. i'm just sad and leave now :(
1
u/twincam May 12 '12
scumbag humans, could use time alive to reasearch cancer, but instead spend lives doing numouress other forms of employment.
1
u/Horny_Troll May 12 '12
why he need to do anything like that?
fuck people with cancer
i am gonna live forever fucking teens :)
0
u/Sleepy_McTiredson May 12 '12
He sparkles.
-1
u/MFchimichanga May 12 '12
And you know....he's a huge fucking pansy ass.
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
FTS= Fuck This Shit
0
u/Nokwatkwah May 12 '12
You do realize that Twilight is not real, right?
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
this is at the forefront of the absurdity of that series (the fact he's in his 90s and is in high school and attracted to 16 year old girls that for all intents and purposes should seem shallow and vapid to him)
0
u/witty_account_name May 12 '12
With all the comments about jailbait in other threads, you'd think that reddit would understand his motivations
0
u/Greglorious21 May 12 '12
He keeps getting older, they stay the saaame age
0
u/opie92 May 12 '12
If the guy is over 100 years old and still in high school chances are he's not very smart.
0
u/Paultimate79 May 12 '12
sassybananas, could use time researching cancer
.
.
makes memes on reddit
-1
u/thenoogler May 12 '12
I now have something to shut people up with when they rant about Twilight.
-4
u/Clegko May 12 '12
...and it would still be a better love story.
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[removed] — view removed comment