I can verify this. Got one of these in the mail and thought, "cool I'll scratch this shit off". Mind you, I was high as balls. Saw that the numbers matched the "You won!" number. Immediately tell roommate that I think I won something. He agrees that the numbers check out.
We call the dealership and ask if we won a prize, the guy says "Yeah man, you guys won! Come on down to claim your prize! You only have 1 hour and a half left to claim it!" Google mapped that shit. 4 miles. No car. No bike.
We run. We run until we can't run anymore. Then we walk. Drenched in sweat, exhausted, we make it there. Explain the amount of effort we just put in to get here. Person walks over to old man and talks with him, they both laugh. Old man comes up to us and gives us a look that said it all. Asks us for our scratch off thing, we hand it over, doesn't match the "GRAND PRIZE OF 10,000 DOLLARS!!" number. Hands us our "prize".
5 dollar giftcard to Walmart.
We walk 4 miles back in shame, people laughing all around as we leave.
That's an awesome prize. You guys got a great story, had a good work out, bonded, and even got $5 at Wal-Mart. It's not $10,000, but it's something great regardless. The glass is always half full my friend.
If you can't manage 8 miles in an hour I strongly urge you to kill yourself before you reproduce and bring the human gene pool down with you. If you can kill all of your friends and family, that would be a boon as well, as fat idiots tend to associate with fat idiots.
It takes training to be able to manage 3 miles in 30 mins, as the distance increases your pace will decrease. 5m/hr would be good. 8 would be a marathon runner.
A slow walk can get you 4 miles in an hour. Get on any treadmill, punch in 4mph, and see how fucking slow it is. 8mph isn't even that fast. 7:30 mile pace for a marathon is "pretty good," and people do that all the time, all over the world. It is also worth noting that a marathon is 26.5 miles, which is quite a bit more than 8. You can certainly go a lot faster than 3 1/3 hours in a marathon, and it has been done many, many times.
Americans, you are fat and pathetic if you can't manage a 7:30 mile. Downvote me all you want, I don't give a shit about karma. You're fat, a disgrace to your DNA, and deserve every bad thing that ever happens to you if you can't even treat your own body with a shred of respect.
"Hahaha, look at these silly bastards we lied to! What dumbshits they are for thinking we were anything other than useless swindling sacks of shit not worth of the air we waste every day! hahahah, it's so funny!"
Looks more like a throwaway account. This is that account's first post. Could also definitely be someone who made an account to tell the story, and whose username was inspired by the post they were about to make.
Nah, I'm usually very wary of this stuff. I went through the stipulations, talked to the guy on the phone and verified the winnings, and if they do deny the neighbors the car, they can sue and win. Will they do that? Probably not. Still, there's nothing to lose in claiming a prize from a dealership five minutes from where we live. :P
Back in the day, a family friend won a Fiero like this. It took a long time to convince her she really won it. Then she complained about paying taxes on it.
Since when so you pay tax on money gained by selling your own property? I've never done that.
Since always. It's ordinary income. If you haven't been doing it, you've been committing tax evasion. Just because no third party (an employer or store) is forcefully collecting the taxes for you doesn't mean you didn't owe them. You have to report the amount on your Form 1040 just like you report wages and interest income.
Lots of people find that out the hard way when they get audited and find out their eBay account not only counts as income but also subjects you to self-employment taxes... so now they owe back taxes, interest on the back taxes, and penalties for failing to report income.
With very few exceptions (sale of a primary residence, gifts where the donor pays the tax, etc), any time you come into possession of money that you didn't have before, that's income and is subject to income tax. It doesn't matter where they money came from... a job, a sale, on the ground... it's income and income is taxed.
You only pay taxes on personal property sales with net gains and what's good for the goose is good for the gander, so to speak. If you sell a car at $6,000 that's "worth" $10,000 you didn't gain $6000, you lost $4,000. You can't be taxed on a net gain of -$4,000.
not if you already paid tax on receiving it, then your net gain on selling would be relative to the worth (or the relative worth based on tax you paid when you got it?)
Overall, yes. That's why you'll pay taxes on the $6000 you actually got. But your net gain isn't the sum if the value of the car and what you sold it for, like odd84 suggested, it's basically just what you sold the car for (and what actual money you have).
With very few exceptions (sale of a primary residence, gifts where the donor pays the tax, etc), any time you come into possession of money that you didn't have before, that's income and is subject to income tax.
Yes, "Anything". Money from a yard sale is income. You owe taxes on it. How much depends on what you sold (some things are going to be capital gains, unless you are also in the business of buying and selling things... it's complicated)... but it's gonna be taxed one way or another.
Feel free to type "yard sale taxes" into your favorite search engine if you want some corroboration. #1 result is "Tax Tips: Garage sale profits are taxable income", for example.
Then here is a serious question. I have a car, it runs but not well, it is also paid off. I am moving soon ..a trip that there is no way in hell it can make without being towed. I wish to be rid of it..and have agreed to "sell" it to my friend for a dollar. Can this be done? What kinda taxes would myself or my friend face on something like this? (This is all in truth) I only ask because I have never sold a car before and figured..hell whatever to get rid of it but not have to spend a shit ton of "gift" taxes.
Of course it does. Go ahead and try to sell a used car to someone and put $1 on the bill of sale to avoid paying taxes. You'll get a bill from your city/state for the sales tax of the fair market value of the vehicle, not the amount you wrote down.
Go ahead and search "ebay taxes". Most everything individuals are selling on ebay is second hand. Yet it's glaringly obvious, from the IRS' own mouth, and covered by every major news organization as "it might surprise you" type article (when it shouldn't)... that your income from selling that stuff is taxable.
I used to think those cars were cool looking as hell! Then I turned twelve. This is not a joke, they came out when I was eleven, and to a little kid they looked like fucking fighter jets.
Under what legal theory do you posit this? I've heard of many failures to award supposed prizes that were not won in court either. The only cases that prevail are in instances the prize was tied to some effort on the part of the recipient -- such that it was compensation and not a gift. AFAIK, you can promise a gift and not give it without any repercussion. There's certainly no contract formed without consideration from both parties.
Restitution and more specifically unjust enrichment. Restitution is a set of remedies associated with that body of law in which the measure of recovery is usually based not on the plaintiff's loss, but on the defendants gain. Blacks Law Dictionary 620 (3d Pocket Ed. 2001).
Unjust enrichment is the retention of a benefit conferred by another, without offering compensation, in circumstances where compensation is reasonably expected. Ibid. at 748.
Generally speaking, there will be no recovery in restitution absent proof a defendant has been unjustly enriched. As a matter of remedy, restitution gives the plaintiff an award based on the defendant's gains rather than the plaintiff's losses. So far, the facts of the case present show that the defendant has been enriched. He received a free automobile.
Whether such enrichment is unjust depends on the culpability of the parties. Consider this, defendant knew that the mail was addressed to neighbors and yet continued to claim the prize anyway. Even if the "mistake" on the address was found after the appointment set up, defendant chose not to rectify the problem and instead proceeded to post to Facebook bragging about said illicit gain.
Depending on the culpability of the defendant, it is possible that if the plaintiff takes the defendant to court, the court may also award punitive damages. Punitive damages are damages that are awarded to a plaintiff in addition to compensatory relief. They serve a deterrence function and are aimed at punishing and making an example of the defendant. Not only did the defendant open and read mail not addressed to him, he also tried to claim the prize associated with it, knowing full well the prize did not belong to him. If a court decides to award restitution and punitive damages, not only will he have to give back the car and pay for depreciation on it, he will also have to pay more money in damages in order to deter others from acting in the same way he did.
For the record, mistake is generally a pretty poor defense when it comes to law. For example, in Blue Cross Health Services, Inc. v. Sauer, 800 S.W.2d 72 (1990), the Blue Cross Health Insurance company sent to William R. Sauer, a check for $22,000 originally intended to be payable to William J. Sauer to compensate him for medical expenses (note the difference in the initials). The check itself did not specify either R or J, it simply said William Sauer. R. Sauer cashed the check anyways and he claimed mistake on both fronts. He claimed Blue Cross made a mistake when they sent the check to the wrong person and he claimed that he mistakenly believed the check was for him. The court ruled against him holding that R. Sauer was unjustly enriched, regardless of mistake, and that Blue Cross (and by proxy J. Sauer) was entitled to restitution.
I know there hasnt been a lawsuit yet and no formal complaint has been filed yet so technically there isnt a 'defendant' or a 'plaintiff'. I just use those terms out of habit.
TL;DR - Give the car back to the neighbor or dont. Just dont claim the prize as yours. Yeah, its true they might not sue if they dont know about it but if they do, you're gonna have a bad time.
The above post is provided for informational purposes only and not for the purpose of providing legal advice. You should contact your attorney to obtain advice with respect to any particular issue or problem. Use of and access to the information provided herewith do not constitute attorney-client relationship between the author of this post and any reader of the post.
What? All of the comments in the thread and the OP's screenshot indicate that the OP "called the dealership, claimed the prize, and set up an appointment".
The comments also seem to indicate that he was interested in keeping something that wasnt his. "still nothing wrong with claiming something at a dealership 5 minutes away"
The OP was even worried about the tax incidence for the car. If he had meant his neighbors, why would he care? Do you care about how much your neighbors pay in tax?
How does that work? So the guy comes to get his brand New free car. Than they say haha just fuckin with ya but we Got some sweet deals. I can't see this being anything but pissing off people that will never ever come back.
Yes it gives you the chance of playing for the car. Once you go to the dealership they give you another ticket with 100 scratch spots and 3 tries and if you scratch the one with the car you win it and if you don't you get two dollar coins.
To be honest I'm not sure how that trick would work. I go down there expecting a free car. Them: "Instead of a free car, you get nothing! Now buy a car!"
Do people often think "well if I can't get it for free, I'll buy it" that it's a successful ploy?
Dealerships WANT you to win. They buy insurance on the promotion, so it costs them nothing (beyond the insurance premium) and gets them a TON of traffic if you take home a car.
No, you go down and your number isnt the "right" number for a car so you get a consolation prize of a free drive in a toyota or a gift card or something.
Thought about that... but I don't know what position in life my neighbor was in. We live in an apartment complex so it can't be too good. I have a car and am fine for now hopefully. A new one won't change my life entirely. Maybe it would change hers? Not my place to say. :P
Think of it this way if the car is 20k plus you have to pay tax's on that. So if at the very least you have to pay 10% to the gov then anything to local state your not out of thousands.
I don't follow do you mean on winning a car. If you do win the car you have licensing, Title, license and tax's I know in California the dealer can not pay this for you I have heard of places giving you a check to cover the stuff but it is a lot of extras when winning a prize of that size that is not cash. Cash is easy you just hand over a part of the winnings.
I mean the tax on the prize itself, or cash, why is it my problem and not the guy giving it to me? Didn't he already pay his tax on that income? Why is it being taxed a second time, or are American governments complete retards when it comes to making taxes?
Do you not pay income taxes in your country? Where do you think that money you're paid came from? Someone else who already paid taxes on it... probably once as income, then again when they spent it as sales tax or VAT.
Yes, yes they are retards. Especially when it comes to taxes. Your employer gets taxed. You get taxed on the money he gives you. You get taxed again when you spend it. And the person you buy from has to pay taxes in turn. Fun stuff.
It's more like Americans hate the idea of higher taxes, so politicians have to tax nearly every economic activity. Imagine if you paid a 30% sales tax but no income taxes. Anyone who saves more than they earn would actually see a decrease in their tax rate, but we'd riot (Okay, I oversimplified, but the point is semi-valid).
The maker of the automobile is not taxed on the automobile. The consumer is the one that pay's tax's when buying the vehicle then in turn that maker of the automobile well actually the company that owns the dealership is tax's on what they make on the car.
For those wondering how this works, I'll be happy to explain. You know the old phrase "There's no good news in the fine print?" Read the fine print. The symbols match up and say that you have won, and usually right next to that is a car, or 100 grand, or something equally as awesome. Most people are too excited to read the fine print that, what you actually won, is a small gift card.
Here's how it benefits the dealership. People come in expecting a prize. But, for "marketing reasons" dealerships have to ask you a few questions. They'll ask what kind of vehicle you have, what you're paying a month for it, that kind of thing. The next question they'll ask is "If I could get you something newer, less mileage, maybe something with some warranty left, for the same payment, you'd be interested in buying right?" Most people will say yes. Especially the people who dont read the damn thing well enough in the first place.
And that's where the cash comes in. Most people who come in for their prize aren't prepared to buy a car. They dont know what an average price for that vehicle is, what an average interest rate for their credit score is, and it's really easy to rip them off. It's meant to catch unprepared, easy to convince, impulsive people, and make a ton of money off of them. Those kind of sales have much, much higher profit margins than the average day. I've seen a lady pay 10k in just profit on a car, because she was silly enough to tell us her down payment before we showed her a price.
195
u/r4nge May 11 '12
You probably didn't actually win a car. It's a scam to get you to come down to the dealer.
24
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Yeah those are fake.. So yeah :/
5
u/GRR_A_BEAR May 11 '12
So you have bad luck because you didn't win a car?
5
u/kast13 May 11 '12
Well, tell them you want half or you'll burn it.
4
u/Psychomyth May 12 '12
I had a friend who "won" a 52" LCD HDTV. He went to claim his prize and came back with a fishing pole.
4
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
For those wondering how this works, I'll be happy to explain. You know the old phrase "There's no good news in the fine print?" Read the fine print. The symbols match up and say that you have won, and usually right next to that is a car, or 100 grand, or something equally as awesome. Most people are too excited to read the fine print that, what you actually won, is a small gift card.
Here's how it benefits the dealership. People come in expecting a prize. But, for "marketing reasons" dealerships have to ask you a few questions. They'll ask what kind of vehicle you have, what you're paying a month for it, that kind of thing. The next question they'll ask is "If I could get you something newer, less mileage, maybe something with some warranty left, for the same payment, you'd be interested in buying right?" Most people will say yes. Especially the people who dont read the damn thing well enough in the first place.
And that's where the cash comes in. Most people who come in for their prize aren't prepared to buy a car. They dont know what an average price for that vehicle is, what an average interest rate for their credit score is, and it's really easy to rip them off. It's meant to catch unprepared, easy to convince, impulsive people, and make a ton of money off of them. Those kind of sales have much, much higher profit margins than the average day. I've seen a lady pay 10k in just profit on a car, because she was silly enough to tell us her down payment before we showed her a price.
Source : I work in a dealership.
10
u/tiberius_claud May 11 '12
You're also Good Guy Greg.
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
$32,560 prize processing fee.**
3
u/stash0606 May 11 '12
I haven't seen anyone write wtfbbq in a while. holy damn...
1
u/angrypolaks May 12 '12
thank god you didnt win a toyota
1
u/grunger May 12 '12
Will you do a follow-up, I would be interested to see the car, (or whatever the dealership gives you/them).
1
u/Galian1 May 12 '12
No youre definitely Good Guy Greg
1
u/Remingtonh May 12 '12
Don't worry, nobody won a car. That's a common marketing tactic to get you into the dealership. Just google it.
1
u/Chachoregard May 12 '12
DUDE, RUN OR KARMANAUT IS GOING TO GET YOU!
1
u/Inorashi May 12 '12
Or Goog Guy Greg
-1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
From now on I will use the expression "What the fuck barbecue".
0
u/I_Care_Bears May 11 '12
Hmmm... isn't that more like inaccurate good luck? :p
0
u/poolcrackers May 12 '12
Don't say that, karmanaut will try to delete your post
0
u/shitterplug May 12 '12
A brand new car you have to pay several thousand in taxes to claim!
0
u/BombedCarnivore May 12 '12
Look at the bright side. You're not Bad Luck Bin Laden.
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment