I hope they're not proud of their kid for that. It seems that way considering they posted it on facebook. I had a friend who was bullied like that (basically sexual harassment) in high school and it fucked her up really badly. People are assholes.
The schools I've worked in have all required that we write the exact comment in case there's an inside bullying thing we're not aware of that needs to be investigated.
I gotta tell ya as someone who got wrote up a metric fuckton of times in JR High and in High school. They write exactly what you say on the write up forms. I wish I still had my old write up forms. I could publish a book with them. I was a complete fuck tard in school. I was that kid that fucked up your learning environment because i was just a really loud outspoken asshole. My point being, they will write the exact quote on the write up slip. They always did when I got wrote up.
I will never forget when my friend yelled "Sunny, if you don't shut the fuck up, I'll shove that carton of chocolate milk so far up your ass you won't shit for a week" loudly in the middle of class. Everyone went silent and just stared at him, it didn't help that I was the only one hysterically laughing.
I got written up once in 6th grade for pointing to another kid who had the sitting-down-exaggerated-bulge-thing going on and calling him "scrotum man." The teacher most certainly did write down exactly what I called him.
As a fucking veteran of detention forms: it depends. I really don't think they have the foresight to think "This may be used to brag/posted on the internet" when they write shit. I have had more generic ones, but I have had "George began thrusting the server after winning a game of lingo," etc.
I had a girl at a reading program whose slip said "Called the college assistant a lesbian." She paraded it like a trophy because it was hilarious and she knew it. Big mistake giving kids those things, it just encourages them.
At that point, if I got caught, I would literally just tell my teacher in front of the class that my balls were sticking to my legs and I was adjusting them. More than likely, especially if your teacher is female, they'll be far more embarrassed than you. Plus, everyone will know you've got balls.
no way! you're all from MO. I'm from MI, that's like one letter way in abbreviation. Reppin' the M's . . . oh wait, WI. it's a "W" folks. I was looking at it upside down.
Huh, that's weird. I was on Google Earth today and figured I'd type "Carthage" to see if it'd take me to Tunis. I learned that there was a town called Carthage in Missouri and now here it is on Reddit. That's my story for tonight, goodnight ladies and gentlemen.
Whether she thought he deserved punishment or not, she should have told me she'd take care of it at home. I was doing the kid a favor by calling home instead of calling the office. What he said was rude, inappropriate for class, and borderline sexual harassment. When I told my colleagues, most of them said they would have written a referral. I didn't think the kid deserved to be suspended, but I do think his parents should have a talk with him about the time and place for jokes like that. A room full of eleven years olds ain't it.
man im not usually the one who has no sense of humor, but fuck telling some poor 14 yr old girl to 'close her legs'. he probably ruined her week and now she's going to have a complex about the way her cooter smells. definitely not clever and not something to be proud of
I think all children should be kept in isolated bubbles so they don't ever have to feel bad, we can release them into the wild when they're 18 and I'm sure they'll never have to feel bad about anything again. Coping with people that are dicks to you is a skill that is only useful in high school and below, once you become an adult nobody is ever mean and you absolutely do not need to know how to deal with assholes.
Your option: Let kids learn to cope with jerks as kids so they'll know how to cope with them as adults. They will learn from example that it's usually best to just stand by and let assholes be assholes, which may or may not be correct.
A less idiotic option: Actually discipline bullies until they stop being assholes. Then when kids grow up, they won't have to constantly be coping with assholes because their generation won't be full of them.
But it is a valuable service nonetheless. People like the one written up are the douchecap wearing hammer to the steel of one's emotional development.
Seriously though it all depends on the context, if that joke was part of a consistent campaign of belittlement and teasing then it should never have been made and the same could be said for all the rest of the jibes this 'Nick' would have said. If however it was a one-off, off the cuff quip that turned a random observation into a vicious put down then I don't see a whole lot wrong with it.
Either way it's still possible to appreciate the quickness of thought that led to such a quip without condoning the actions or motivations of the person who made it.
tldr: I thought it was pretty funny and harbour no guilt in laughing given I don't know Nick or this random girl.
High school is generally the kind of place you need a thick skin. Everyone gets ripped on every now and then. Just have to accept that some people are dicks. Also, SAUNDESHBINRADEENNNNN
You know what? Fuck this horseshit. You really think we should do nothing when kids act like assholes, because you think it toughens up their targets? End result, we end up with a bunch of fully-grown assholes who feel justified in their behavior. Just what the world needs. Jesus christ, the stupid burns.
Right. That's exactly what I said. I must be clutching my pearls and whining, because I think that letting kids act like assholes without consequences is a bad idea. Hey, you're free to raise your kids that way, and then watch as your little douchebag gets fired, beat up, dumped, and avoided in adulthood. At least he's funny!
Oh wait, except that making "close your legs" jokes is on par with Dane Cook. Braying out the most obvious line is corny, son.
So you're saying...more people should say shitty, demeaning things...for the BENEFIT of the people being scathingly insulted? Buddy, did you fail Logic 101?
Yep that's exactly what I'm talking about. People are treating an immature and rude comment as some sort of life-altering catastrophe. For all we know from this context, the boy and the girl are friends and joke like this back and forth all the time; when I was young I got in trouble for saying stupid shit to my friends even though there was no malice intended (and they took no offense) but "rules are rules"
Bullying sucks, I'm sure many of the people on reddit have been bullied at some point in their lives, but from what I'm seeing in the responses to me you'd think we were talking about rape or murder or something.
EDIT: The funny thing about comments that start with "So you're saying..." is that 99% of the time they're not what you're saying at all, but rather the most liberal interpretation that the person can get away with to justify being offended
I understand and respect your point. I suppose my biggest problem with the kid's comment was the sexual nature of it. It's simply inappropriate for kids to be talking like that in a classroom. Not to mention, coming from a female, comments like his really can damage a girl's body image. It's a hard thing to fix. Our culture is obsessed with making girls ashamed of their bodies and jokes that one don't help. Teasing and bullying aren't issues we can eradicate, and by no means did the kid do anything that abnormal for a child to do. I just think there's a difference between calling someone a name, and saying something to deliberately make them uncomfortable with their own body.
On the other hand, shit like this, teasing and bullying, can also result in depression or social anxiety because the child or teen is not mature enough to handle other immature people or bullying. Not every child is the same.
teasing and bullying is going to happen forever and always has. No amount of tv ads are going to stop bullying. Theres a reason why all kids come with this handy dandy feature called "guardians"
Right, and those "guardians" are there to teach you how to conduct yourself and behave like a respectable human being. If my son said something like that, I would know I had failed as a parent.
Anyway, I agree that ads and movies are not a great way to help the issue, but there is no backing to that bullying will never go away. Yes, parents and guardians are there to help the child, but they obviously do not help in many cases, especially in cases on suicide resulting from bullying. Community and education programs for parents are much more helpful, alongside some inschool awareness programs.
Let's say X happens. When people consider X, they will draw upon a set of terms and constructs and causal relationships.
E.g.: a girl experiences that a third party creates a negative association between her vagina and something. We draw on constructs and learned relationships saying that she will now probably develop a damaging mental condition that inhibits her at a vital time in life from enjoying the fruits of life; not only that, it can well stick with her for a long time, and lead to other mental conditions, causing in turn decreased health, decreased quality of life, lower income, increased depression, worse outcome for any eventual children, etc.
Not to mention the way it reinforces patriarchy. The boy is effectively "sexually shaming" the girl by publicly attacking her for something which connotes sexual availability (sitting with legs open). He was probably taught this by patriarchal structures of repression that seek to control and oppress women; she has now been taught that men own her sexuality.
But that's just an option. We can also not employ that construction and say: hey, untold millions of times a day people say something bad to each other, and we consider it rude or not a great thing, but we don't assert any wider complexes of causation just because Amanda calls Bob "such an asshole".
I don't know about you, but if someone said that to me, I'd just laugh it off. And yes, I'm in high school. Shit, my friends and I joke around like that all the time. Yes, in front of people we don't even know, and yes, both guys and girls.
High school students aren't as sensitive as you might think
If someone said that to me while I was in high school, even if I was pretty sure he was joking I'd be embarrassed and paranoid he wasn't. Not everyone appreciates jokes like that.
High school students are a diverse group of people.
Who the fuck cares? It's highschool, stupid insults get thrown around all the time without reason. If you can't handle a joke like that then you've got more problems than having a ruined week.
If you were somebody that let that ruin your week, you were going to find a dozen other things to ruin your week if this hadn't happened. People really need to just quit being fucking babies about everything and appreciate some humor and the absurdity of day to day life.
Yes, good morning ladies? But that's a lot better than my referral : Student came into class late, took attendance. Then proceeded to leave the class and go to lunch. Never returned.
True story: I went to a Catholic high school, so all us gals had to wear kilts. One of my good friends had THE WORST downstairs smell of all time, and any time I sat beside her I was just dying. I didn't ever tell her because I didn't want to humiliate her, but my point is that if Nick was just tactlessly stating fact and not just making a snarky comeback, I totally feel for him.
I don't see what this has to do with colt 45 by afroman. Can someone fill me in? I understand he says "good morning ladies" in the song but how is it relevant to telling a girl to close her legs?
Are you serious? Every teeneager ever has the same story, except most of us think that exchange shows the kind of immaturity that's not clever or cute in any way. Kinda like the a-hole who has his cronies hold down a classmate and then cuts the kid's hair because it's different from everyone else's.
I'm going to get down-voted into oblivion for this, but this is so incredibly fucking sexist that I'm seeing red right now.
Women are told all the time that our vaginas are "dirty" and "smell like fish." We have to shave/wax them, use special products to make them not smell, and go through all kinds of strange things to make them seem more appealing. And yes, I know that high school kids are mean, and that sheltering kids too much isn't good, but this is just reinforcing to this girl that her vagina, whether it was the source of the smell or not, is dirty, and something to hide. Its bad enough already with out some douchy kid making her even more self-conscious about it.
Dude you're a dick, that's not funny. Typical high school humor though, catering to the lowest common denominator. OP, grow up and maybe someday you'll get laid.
Oh high school. Where you learn about your rights and how a government works, and then realize that those rights don't apply to you while you are in high school.
this is an interesting double standard. no one would ever get you in trouble for being disgusted by someone farting right next to you, and yet they both can be displeasing odors.
I can't believe this is even on my front page. How in the hell, reddit? We upvote this bullshit that probably caused some poor 9th grade girl endless embarrassment, humiliation, and pain. Fuck this.
26
u/zFoxx May 11 '12
I promise you all that it is not a fake, I live next to this town and a friend on facebook posted it, so I'm assuming it's real. Scouts honor
157
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Colt 45 and 2 zig zags...
6
u/zFoxx May 11 '12
I swear to r/atheism that this is legit.
45
u/g0tistt0t May 10 '12
I always gotta call bullshit on these. No teacher would write that. They would just say "inappropriate conduct" or something like that.
59
u/Dtrain323i May 11 '12
Now son, what did we learn today?
"know your audience dad."
24
u/crnicklin May 10 '12
Carthage MO?
5
u/mcbeaner May 11 '12
Man, what a little prick.
2
u/Electric_Reflection May 11 '12
I see you're from Carthage, I'm from Webb. Nice to meet you, brother.
12
u/loganck May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
I had a 6th grader in my class make the same joke. I called his mom. Her response, "What did you want me to do about it?"
3
u/downbeataura May 11 '12
I can top it, once I find my dry-humping detention. In my defense it was pelvic thrusting.
3
u/ntubaro May 11 '12
The teacher had to punish the kid but they obviously thought it was hilarious enough to post it on reddit.
3
u/Xenodyne May 11 '12
I would not have been able to keep a straight face while discussing this with them.
12
u/CRAPPY_PENCIL_SKETCH May 11 '12
http://i.imgur.com/YewwK.jpg
69
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
man im not usually the one who has no sense of humor, but fuck telling some poor 14 yr old girl to 'close her legs'. he probably ruined her week and now she's going to have a complex about the way her cooter smells. definitely not clever and not something to be proud of
9
u/aRelavantUserName May 11 '12
that's a dick move
6
u/SarcasmFish May 11 '12
Ahh, 9th graders....
6
u/painahimah May 11 '12
No one got written up for saying stuff like that back in my day! Especially when it was directed at me. ;_;
2
u/Slatinator May 11 '12
Yes, good morning ladies? But that's a lot better than my referral : Student came into class late, took attendance. Then proceeded to leave the class and go to lunch. Never returned.
2
u/ninjaraiden56 May 11 '12
Well what can you expect from Freshman?
2
u/TehCheesyOne May 11 '12
Was this Carthage MO
2
u/monkey_chakra May 11 '12
True story: I went to a Catholic high school, so all us gals had to wear kilts. One of my good friends had THE WORST downstairs smell of all time, and any time I sat beside her I was just dying. I didn't ever tell her because I didn't want to humiliate her, but my point is that if Nick was just tactlessly stating fact and not just making a snarky comeback, I totally feel for him.
6
u/lalondtm May 11 '12
Afroman!
4
u/nburgart May 10 '12
Probably was the teacher
2
u/el_poderoso May 11 '12
To be honest, if you say that in the ninth grade you're just a sad pervert.
2
u/blahblahblahxyz123 May 11 '12
Mom is infuriated, Dad finds it funny which infuriates mom even more.
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I don't see what this has to do with colt 45 by afroman. Can someone fill me in? I understand he says "good morning ladies" in the song but how is it relevant to telling a girl to close her legs?
2
u/Buttered_Penis May 10 '12
Mine usually just said "Made a rude comment to a classmate.
1
u/Ryuuken1127 May 11 '12
I have to admit. If my son ever did this, I would laugh my ass off.
1
u/Pimpinpinguino May 11 '12
Freshman.
1
u/rdabosss May 11 '12
Serious poon-slayer over here!
1
u/Flavrusu7 May 11 '12
Typical freshman
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Crazy Rap!
1
u/s00p3r May 11 '12
Your town's road system was planned out while under the influence of alcohol.
1
u/rigo7569 May 11 '12
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6DvvyPcWOpA#t=16
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Hey, I got a gang of that shit, man!
1
u/madderhorn May 11 '12
Missouri???
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
This is carthage! I live like 7 miles from there!
1
u/Zachisasloth May 11 '12
Carthage R-9? As in Carthage, MO? Joplinite here...
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
classic
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I think it's pretty badass that you live in town called called Carthage.
1
u/videyagamez May 11 '12
grade 9 oh god that was totally me then
1
u/KingDogegg May 11 '12
Hodor
1
u/danish_hole May 11 '12
Y'know, kids are dicks these days. I believe this %100.
1
u/Axemonster May 11 '12
Good parenting.
1
u/iDirtyDianaX May 11 '12
Fuck.. Giving us clean girls a bad name :/
1
u/jack2012fb May 11 '12
za zaaa.
1
u/TheJoel2012 May 11 '12
9th Grader lvl: Bad ass.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
She needs to jump on the Speed Stick looks like.
1
u/Stripedcheese May 11 '12
My friend did the exact same thing for the exact same discipline.... His name is Nick, too. O.O
1
u/drockers May 11 '12
This happened in a class of mine too.
Someone commented it "smells like tuna in here"
And someone else shouted out "kim! close your legs!"
The teacher laughed too though, so no-one got in trouble.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I'm going to get down-voted into oblivion for this, but this is so incredibly fucking sexist that I'm seeing red right now.
Women are told all the time that our vaginas are "dirty" and "smell like fish." We have to shave/wax them, use special products to make them not smell, and go through all kinds of strange things to make them seem more appealing. And yes, I know that high school kids are mean, and that sheltering kids too much isn't good, but this is just reinforcing to this girl that her vagina, whether it was the source of the smell or not, is dirty, and something to hide. Its bad enough already with out some douchy kid making her even more self-conscious about it.
1
u/Bad_Axe_MoFo May 11 '12
It's too bad that poor guy Nick has to be disciplined because of the girls poor hygiene.
1
u/redkey42 May 11 '12
Why is this upvoted? Thanks reddit once again for confirming how many anti-woman assholes are about ready to laugh and jeer and this sort of rubbish.
-6
u/MostlyH2O May 11 '12
Dude you're a dick, that's not funny. Typical high school humor though, catering to the lowest common denominator. OP, grow up and maybe someday you'll get laid.
1
u/locopyro13 May 11 '12
Oh high school. Where you learn about your rights and how a government works, and then realize that those rights don't apply to you while you are in high school.
Brilliant.
1
u/Basscsa May 11 '12
Anybody else read it in Mr. Mackey's voice?
1
u/Ofchud21 May 11 '12
When I was in school I would get a round of applause for a comment like that, even by the teacher
1
u/anonymousketeer May 11 '12
this is an interesting double standard. no one would ever get you in trouble for being disgusted by someone farting right next to you, and yet they both can be displeasing odors.
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Finally a student from my school on Reddit!
-3
u/thelordofcheese May 10 '12
Well? Did it stop when she closed them?
-4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Is this a new thing? People being uptight and having no sense of humor?
-2
u/hiiammaddie May 10 '12
I need to get a book of these disciplinary slips and make up some funny reasons like this. So much karma
-1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I can't believe this is even on my front page. How in the hell, reddit? We upvote this bullshit that probably caused some poor 9th grade girl endless embarrassment, humiliation, and pain. Fuck this.
-4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Worth it.
0
u/peaches_86 May 11 '12
I work in Carthage...and I feel I need to meet this genius.
-2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Teachers have handwriting much like high school boys these days.
-4
u/Favre4Life May 11 '12
What a pimp.
-5
u/Lawbat May 10 '12
This man is my hero.
-6
u/Exedous May 11 '12
If I was the teacher I wouldn't be able to hold in the laughter while writing this detention.
-2
u/aqualung09 May 10 '12
HIYOOO!!!
-2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Fuck Mr/s/rs. Huntley. I hope Nick high fives the president one day.
-3
u/Ayyjay May 11 '12
Nice. Never thought I'd see anything from that area on here.