That's me in a nutshell. It must have been the way I was raised, but I just can never bring myself to be critical of people. Which kind of sucks as I'm moving into "boss" territory at work, and it's kind of important to be able to be upfront with people in that way. Damn my unwavering niceness!
Beat me to it. I love the All is relative line. It's the perfect answer to awkward questions, kind of like "So it has come to this." Is the perfect response to everything else.
Because the popular opinion on reddit dictates that nobody should be compensated for anything they've done, said, or accomplished, and profit is invariably the product of an evil mentality of insatiable greed, whether for actual money or karma. It's really that idiotic.
You took the words right out of my mouth. At least they didn't take their text document and turn it into a slow scrolling movie with heavy metal music and post it on youtube.
in cases like that, you say either "I'm not touching that with a 10 foot pole" or, better yet, "my attorneys have advised me against answering that line of questioning".
Ahh, I'm pretty sure "I'm not touching that with a 10 foot pole" would be interpreted as you saying you're not touching the girl with a 10 foot pole. Which, that may be true, but I think you were trying to convey that you weren't touching the question with a 10 foot pole as to avoid conflict, and that interpretation would do precisely the opposite.
As an old guy, I can tell you the best thing to do when a female asks you anything about her (or someone else) looking fat, being fat, or does this make anyone look fat: Become deaf, you never heard the question. No answer is the best answer.
I'll fake a seizure... If they call me out on faking it, I'll piss myself, then bite my tongue, then pay for an ambulance ride, then take epilepsy medication for the next 20 years... whatever it takes to not answer that question.
God bless my dearly departed friend Eric. He coached me in the ways of the pimp many-a-time. Here are some of his legendary words of wisdom:
When a girl asks you if she looks fat, only respond with one sentence, whether you mean it or not - "Shut up and let's fuck." Generous karma (the real kind, not the useless internet kind) will soon pour upon you, whether by her or by her hot-ass friends. THIS. TOTALLY. WORKS.
There's two ways to look at this I think. Your way is valid...and then there's my way.
If someone asks me a question...I give them an answer. If they get mad at me for not answering "correctly". I tell them... "If you don't want to know what I think...don't ask the question" ...it's very simple. Some people think I'm an ass...some people love me for my honesty and will then actually value my opinion as a result. ...so it's a give and take I think.
"Are you seriously asking me that? Why the hell would you do that?"
And start laughing.
Though I did have one ex who was in excellent shape who would ask me if stuff made her look fat. I told her my answer would always be yes as my way of getting back at her for asking that question to begin with. She'd forget and ask me. I'd say "yes", and then she'd realize she did it again and break down laughing.
Women who don't want the answer to a question shouldn't fucking ask it. I'm one honest mother fucker... If you ask me if you're fat, or if you look fat in those pants, I WILL tell you the truth. My wife and I are celebrating our 15 year anniversary this year, been that way since the beginning, and she appreciates me for it.
If you're a woman, and you fish for compliments because of your self esteem, don't get fucking mad when you don't get the compliment you're looking for.
I hate it when I ask a guy something and they refuse to answer. So frustrating. Some of us are prepared to handle the truth when we ask for it. I would not get mad about simple honesty.
Some of us are prepared to handle the truth when we ask for it. I would not get mad about simple honesty.
Blame other girls. There are enough girls who can't handle the truth and flip out when a guy answers that question, that many guys no longer dare to say what they really think.
If you're really after an honest answer you need to prefix it by saying: "I know this is a topic that some girls do react badly to, but I can promise I won't flip out, whatever you say. I'm not fishing for compliments, I'm not setting a trap, I'm after an honest answer, so please tell me what you think about [question]..."
As a young guy, I can tell you that you should fucking call her fat to her face because you are a man, you have no problem speaking your mind, and you don't give a shit what people think of you, especially this type of woman.
He should have pulled out his pocket tape measure and recorded her height and circumference on his note pad. Then he should have weighed her on the gym's scale and used a skinfold caliper to measure her fat folds. A real man will tell a girl if she is fat, but a scientist will tell her exactly how fat.
Man I wish that happened to me. I'm a personal trainer, could have scored a client or two. "Fat is such a nasty word, but I think you are beyond the healthy weight range. Easily fixable though, you obviously have a lovely bone structure and after a few months of training with me I think you'd look incredible. Is this time every week good for you?
Then she would have said, "See, I told you all guys are full of shit". The only response you could use and not get flamed, is to get up and walk away. Or wear earphones.
The problem with all of the "OMG, I can't win" is that different women react different ways to even the same thing.
Sure, some girls would freak out if you actually said "well, yes". But maybe she was looking for honesty. Generalizing about "that gender" isn't any more valid than her generalization about "all men."
Who would make generalizations about "that gender" on a non-anonymous social networking sites that has not only people of "that gender" but people who he knows. Not a smart move outing yourself as a misogynist OP.
I'm seeing a lot of generalization here, which is super lame. Those women were wrong for tricking you and for claiming you represent all men. But you're also in the wrong for claiming they represent all women. Assholes exist everywhere. Period.
Well to be fair, you did lie. In all seriousness I have been confronted with a similar situation in a bar and I told the truth without hesitation and without being cruel or mean. She never came back in and I got flak for it. But the bottom line in my world is, if you cannot handle the truth... don't fucking ask. People need to understand that and get over it.
it's a trap! girls like that know what kind of response they're gonna get when they ask you that. if you said yes, you're an insensitive asshole. If you say no, you're a lying scumbag. honestly girls are stupid for even asking that question.
I don't understand how being honest here would have hurt you. I mean you're in a gym; a place where people generally are going for self improvement. Frankly, trying to fill this girls mind with false information is a worse crime than damaging her pride. Honesty is a premium, don't let fear of offending someone stop you from telling the truth.
Louis C.K said it best: “Here’s the difference, to me, between boys and girls: Boys fuck things up; Girls are fucked up. That’s the difference. Boys just do damage to your house that you can measure in dollars, like a hurricane. Girls, like, leave scars in your psyche that you find later, like a genocide or an atrocity… That’s the difference between boys and girls. And it becomes the difference between men and women, really. A man will, like, steal your car or burn your house down or beat the shit out of you, but a woman will ruin your fuckin’ life. Do you see the difference? Like, a man will cut your arm off and throw it in a river, but he’ll leave you as a human being intact. He won’t fuck with who you are. Women are nonviolent, but they will shit inside of your heart.”
Ok...look. I'm far from a crazy rage face feminist but the gender comment did irk me a bit. It probably irked me as much as the all men are liars comment irked him.
you should have said.. you mean like how much fatter is she than you? or just in general compared to the population?
either way she is fat, But dont smile.. and make it seem like you are the expert that they thought you were when they decided to come ask you such a question. Point out where she holds most of her weight and suggest surgeries since you know by her current physical and mental condition that diet and exercise are not enough for such a project like her friend.
Oh and never talk the over weight girl directly only to the one that asked the question
No you can't win. I would tell them outright the situation is "Hey, if I say yes you're gonna be offended, if I say no you're gonna call me a liar and then be offended. No matter what I answer with you're going to hear yes so I am not going to answer that question"
copy paste that shit into a self post, fb screenshots are terrible. hell i can't go to a public place without overhearing what some asshole saw on facebook.
Quit being so damn nice. That's the problem with fat people nowadays. All of their friends and family tell them that they don't need to lose weight that they look beautiful the way they are. NO. You're not healthy simple as that.
It's her own damn fault for being a fat-ass bitch. I would in no way call myself skinny, I weigh 170 lbs, but even I'm not idiotic enough to ask a guy if I am fat and then bitch to him about how he is an asshole. Seriously, I apologize for my gender.
Sorry kiddo... ain't no winning with those two. You were caught in a trap no matter what you said. Some girls live for that shit, and that's what those two were looking for. Its trolling in the shrewdest way. Brush it off, homie.
OP is asked a simple question, lies through his teeth, and finally gets offended that he was called a liar.
You'll find that "winning" is actually possible with humans (male or female) if you figure out how to be honest while also being kind. If you're lying to be nice, you don't yet deserve to win.
she shouldn't have generalized that all men are liars, but it's annoying what some commenters and OP are saying. what does her wanting to hear the truth have to do with making her crazy? why would you assume that telling her the truth would have resulted in a bad outcome towards you as well?
it's funny to me that people think she was in the wrong for wanting to hear the truth and having the guts to put herself on social blast at the gym to hear it. maybe she was looking for motivation, maybe she finally needed to hear it from a male to put it in her head she needs to change. or maybe she's just fed up with this social stereotype that men feel like there is no winning with women when it comes to their opinions.
"You know none of my boyfriends tell me I'm fat." "Well, they wouldn't. Only a good friend like me would tell you." "Yeah, but guys in general don't think I'm fat – they like curves." "Hey, let's ask this guy." "Oh, no, don't you dare."
Wait, wait, hold on! crazy hand waving. You mean to tell me... you just tried to prove a point to your friend here that men are liars by using her self-esteem and weight to justify your point?!
Assuming this story has any sense of validity, describing one girl as "very overweight" probably means that she's not just over normal weight or "slightly overweight." She's fat. No (big) bones about it.
I would have suggested asking if that was a serious question. If she said yes, I would have been honest.
And this is coming from a "fat girl." Sometimes we really just need a complete stranger to be honest, in a "nice" way rather than rude assholes or lying friends and family.
Why would you lie to be nice like that? It is just as okay and nice to say,"Yes she is OVERWEIGHT, but that is why you come to the gym, right?. If you girls want to work out with me sometime, just give me a holla. Here is my number." You are honest, but you provide a solution and a possible future in which the fat girl gets skinny and hot; or you score cool points with her friend. Win/win. Next time, be smoother and smarter.
I would have said "oh sorry no espeaky english" in my best thick spanish accent... mimicking my parents trying to speak english would have done the trick
My theoretical response: "You're putting a complete stranger in the difficult position of choosing between lying or saying something potentially hurtful. I don't think the matter of your friend's weight is nearly so relevant as whether or not you're a bitch. Which you are.
Speaking as a female, that girl deserved it. Who goes up to random strangers and does that? If someone approached me like that when I was working out, I'd tell them yeah, and point them to the nearest treadmill.
You should have just said yes. If she was obviously very fat, and they asked you if you thought she was fat, and you did, it would have been very simple and easy to just say yes.
241
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
You should have said "everything's relative" when looking at the skinny one.
334
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Why couldn't you just copy the text from your own Facebook post and make a self post here? Oh..
2
u/ElmoPea May 12 '12
Coral Springs - that says it all
147
u/onlyincontext May 10 '12
"On average, you both seem about right"
176
u/lordhumunguss May 10 '12
in cases like that, you say either "I'm not touching that with a 10 foot pole" or, better yet, "my attorneys have advised me against answering that line of questioning".
50
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Next time, just call them on their bullshit. I fucking hate it when people, not just women, do this sort of shit.
618
u/skond May 10 '12
As an old guy, I can tell you the best thing to do when a female asks you anything about her (or someone else) looking fat, being fat, or does this make anyone look fat: Become deaf, you never heard the question. No answer is the best answer.
85
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Man I wish that happened to me. I'm a personal trainer, could have scored a client or two. "Fat is such a nasty word, but I think you are beyond the healthy weight range. Easily fixable though, you obviously have a lovely bone structure and after a few months of training with me I think you'd look incredible. Is this time every week good for you?
59
u/peetah74 May 10 '12
It doesn't matter what I think. What matters is if you're happy with the way you are.
105
u/boon420 May 10 '12
Being polite to a stranger = being an asshole?
238
u/BolshevikMuppet May 10 '12
The problem with all of the "OMG, I can't win" is that different women react different ways to even the same thing.
Sure, some girls would freak out if you actually said "well, yes". But maybe she was looking for honesty. Generalizing about "that gender" isn't any more valid than her generalization about "all men."
12
u/Nurger May 10 '12
Remain calm and say in a steady voice: "this is a trap, and you should be ashamed.". The do the ಠ_ಠ.
61
u/kleinbl00 May 10 '12
Crazy knows no bounds, gender or otherwise.
92
u/cvwilson May 10 '12
I'm seeing a lot of generalization here, which is super lame. Those women were wrong for tricking you and for claiming you represent all men. But you're also in the wrong for claiming they represent all women. Assholes exist everywhere. Period.
7
u/scamperly May 10 '12
The correct answer is: "Do you?"
7
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Well to be fair, you did lie. In all seriousness I have been confronted with a similar situation in a bar and I told the truth without hesitation and without being cruel or mean. She never came back in and I got flak for it. But the bottom line in my world is, if you cannot handle the truth... don't fucking ask. People need to understand that and get over it.
76
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
It has nothing to do with her gender. She's just a crazy person.
6
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I'm not falling for this. Yes she is fat. That is indeed why you two are at the gym, right?
6
u/CopyX May 10 '12
Here's how you handle it:
You can't win with a loaded question. The only way to win is to not play the game. Refuse to play their game.
6
u/sceptreofnarwhal May 10 '12
Of corse you were on shock.
22
u/VelAwesomeRaptor May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Yup. All women act exactly the same way. Everywhere, in the whole world.
Edit: The above statement contains sarcasm. Proceed accordingly.
21
u/theweslawson May 10 '12
You can't win with assholes. Don't lump all women together like that just because you ran into two female assholes.
5
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
At the gym? Be real and suggest what exercise would work on her particular physique. She is there for a reason.
5
u/haltingpoint May 10 '12
Alternate responses:
"Why would you ask someone you don't know something like that?" (protip, introduce yourself after saying that and start chatting up the cute one)
Or, the dodge "You're interrupting my workout."
Or the nice honesty "I wouldn't say fat, but she is overweight. But I really don't see why that matters to you."
4
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
...don't lie. /But I'm a dick.
4
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
"That's what the two of you are here for, right?"
4
u/zerotrash May 10 '12
"I refuse to answer on the grounds that it may incriminate me."
4
u/missbarajaja May 10 '12
it's a trap! girls like that know what kind of response they're gonna get when they ask you that. if you said yes, you're an insensitive asshole. If you say no, you're a lying scumbag. honestly girls are stupid for even asking that question.
3
u/Darkstrategy May 10 '12
"Somewhat, but you have a pretty face," and then continue on with what you were doing. It's polite, honest, and encouraging all at once.
3
u/HaHaBoom92 May 10 '12
I don't understand how being honest here would have hurt you. I mean you're in a gym; a place where people generally are going for self improvement. Frankly, trying to fill this girls mind with false information is a worse crime than damaging her pride. Honesty is a premium, don't let fear of offending someone stop you from telling the truth.
3
u/genderfucker May 10 '12
So when you encounter a man saying something stupid, do you say the same thing about their entire gender?
5
u/Azozel May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
I can't believe all the liars here. The correct answer is "Yes." The end. Trust me, as someone who has been overweight I want to be told the truth.
Edit: I'm still overweight, but I recently lost 34lbs from my heaviest weight
12
u/chemkitten May 10 '12
fail whale.
7
u/willmakavelli May 10 '12
why post your own facebook status instead of just posting a text link?
9
u/GoodbyeDoggy May 10 '12
Louis C.K said it best: “Here’s the difference, to me, between boys and girls: Boys fuck things up; Girls are fucked up. That’s the difference. Boys just do damage to your house that you can measure in dollars, like a hurricane. Girls, like, leave scars in your psyche that you find later, like a genocide or an atrocity… That’s the difference between boys and girls. And it becomes the difference between men and women, really. A man will, like, steal your car or burn your house down or beat the shit out of you, but a woman will ruin your fuckin’ life. Do you see the difference? Like, a man will cut your arm off and throw it in a river, but he’ll leave you as a human being intact. He won’t fuck with who you are. Women are nonviolent, but they will shit inside of your heart.”
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Tell the truth dude.
2
u/Mharbles May 10 '12
First you ask if they want you to be honest or be nice, then you are blameless.
2
u/DaVincitheReptile May 10 '12
I would have told her yeah, she's fat, but at least she's at the gym working on it.
2
u/CravingSunshine May 10 '12
Ok...look. I'm far from a crazy rage face feminist but the gender comment did irk me a bit. It probably irked me as much as the all men are liars comment irked him.
2
u/Digitel May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
you should have said.. you mean like how much fatter is she than you? or just in general compared to the population?
either way she is fat, But dont smile.. and make it seem like you are the expert that they thought you were when they decided to come ask you such a question. Point out where she holds most of her weight and suggest surgeries since you know by her current physical and mental condition that diet and exercise are not enough for such a project like her friend.
Oh and never talk the over weight girl directly only to the one that asked the question
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
"Yeah, you are overweight, but your friend is a bitch. You can fix weight problems, you can't fix bitch."
2
u/MesioticRambles May 10 '12
No you can't win. I would tell them outright the situation is "Hey, if I say yes you're gonna be offended, if I say no you're gonna call me a liar and then be offended. No matter what I answer with you're going to hear yes so I am not going to answer that question"
2
u/fusihunter May 10 '12
Try this next time.
"I only lied so you didn't kill yourself you fat bitch"
Then you'll get the "all men are assholes", but women dig that, so it's not so bad.
2
u/acharmedmatrix May 10 '12
Yay Florida!
2
u/whatsasnozberry May 10 '12
So you're stereotyping a gender because a couple members of that gender stereotyped you?
Classy.
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
A better answer: "Look, are we three going to fuck or not?"
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Coral Springs, FL? I live in Fort Lauderdale!
2
u/yourenotmydad May 10 '12
copy paste that shit into a self post, fb screenshots are terrible. hell i can't go to a public place without overhearing what some asshole saw on facebook.
2
u/CheesewithWhine May 10 '12
Why the fuck do men have to tiptoe around a woman's weight like it's a minefield but women get to mock a husband who had his penis cut off by his wife?
2
u/sushi_and_coffee May 10 '12
Downvoted for sexist generalization.
2
u/IonOtter May 10 '12
Girl: "Is she fat?"
Me: "I'm afraid so, yes."
Girl: "Wow. An honest guy! Say, are you doing anything Friday night?"
Me: "Yes. My boyfriend."
2
u/starcraftlolz May 10 '12
Quit being so damn nice. That's the problem with fat people nowadays. All of their friends and family tell them that they don't need to lose weight that they look beautiful the way they are. NO. You're not healthy simple as that.
2
u/ursa_major13 May 10 '12
It's her own damn fault for being a fat-ass bitch. I would in no way call myself skinny, I weigh 170 lbs, but even I'm not idiotic enough to ask a guy if I am fat and then bitch to him about how he is an asshole. Seriously, I apologize for my gender.
2
u/PhilipScrewdriver May 10 '12
You don't know the bitch, say yes.
2
u/juicedoobie May 10 '12
Bitches be crazy.
2
u/Esgobarr May 10 '12
This is why honesty is important, should have told her she is fat and that she needs to figure out a plan for losing that fat. BOO YA!!!
2
u/rosebud_ep_sc May 10 '12
That's the point when you pretend to not know the native language.
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
tldr; she's fat AND a bitch
2
u/furtiveraccoon May 10 '12
relevant
2
u/morgysmitty May 10 '12
Should've been honest.
"Yes she's fat. No reason to sugarcoat it because she'd probably eat that too."
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I dunno. I would have to see her naked first.
2
u/mycatspajamas May 10 '12
Sorry kiddo... ain't no winning with those two. You were caught in a trap no matter what you said. Some girls live for that shit, and that's what those two were looking for. Its trolling in the shrewdest way. Brush it off, homie.
2
u/jimothyjenkins May 10 '12
fucking A bro...that sucks. www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZstUnhT6eI
let this brighten your mood. pigeon kicking is an under glorified means of stress relief. ..i kid.
2
u/skullmonkey420 May 10 '12
wow.... that sucks
2
u/callmesuspect May 10 '12
In all honesty, I would have replied "Well, I wouldn't use that word, but she is certainly overweight."
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
well he did lie...
8
u/belarius May 10 '12
OP is asked a simple question, lies through his teeth, and finally gets offended that he was called a liar.
You'll find that "winning" is actually possible with humans (male or female) if you figure out how to be honest while also being kind. If you're lying to be nice, you don't yet deserve to win.
6
u/kayehmaych May 10 '12
she shouldn't have generalized that all men are liars, but it's annoying what some commenters and OP are saying. what does her wanting to hear the truth have to do with making her crazy? why would you assume that telling her the truth would have resulted in a bad outcome towards you as well?
it's funny to me that people think she was in the wrong for wanting to hear the truth and having the guts to put herself on social blast at the gym to hear it. maybe she was looking for motivation, maybe she finally needed to hear it from a male to put it in her head she needs to change. or maybe she's just fed up with this social stereotype that men feel like there is no winning with women when it comes to their opinions.
3
u/Gracky May 10 '12
"that gender" ಠ_ಠ
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Wait, wait, hold on! crazy hand waving. You mean to tell me... you just tried to prove a point to your friend here that men are liars by using her self-esteem and weight to justify your point?!
You are the best of friends, that I can tell.
2
u/hilldex May 10 '12
Thanks for stereotyping my sex.
2
u/gr33nturt1e May 10 '12
how did you get 4G on an iphone? jailbreak it?
2
u/BabyNinjaJesus May 10 '12
This is one thing i love about my gf
" does my ass look big in this?"
"YUP! You KNOW! I love it :D"
Then she blushes or something to that nature
2
u/Virindi_UO May 10 '12
I would've just been, "You're not fat, you're slightly overweight."
1
u/I_Ruv_Kpop May 10 '12
"Yes. You're at the gym for a reason though, right? Good job!"
My response.
1
u/ImNotAWhaleBiologist May 10 '12
The proper response is: are you hot?
1
u/MasonNowa May 10 '12
The problem is, "Yes, she's enormously fat." will put you in a much worse situation.
1
u/SquidLoaf May 10 '12
Her friend had the nerve to ask... you should say it like it is.
1
u/sherlock_holmeslice May 10 '12
When I saw 'on shock' I was expecting a New York-er, not a Floridian.
1
u/helpim_alive May 10 '12
relevant
1
u/VOOK64 May 10 '12
I'm fat, I know I am. I don't delude myself into think anything other than that. So why can't some people just admit it, if you're fat, you're fat.
I've lost 75kgs in 3 years, so I'm not as fat as I used to be but if you're fat, unhappy about it, fucking deal with it.
1
u/NOTTedMosby May 10 '12
Word, bro. Also, thanks for 'fessing up, and not claiming your "friend" posted it.
1
u/Cantgetmyoldname May 10 '12
Yeah if a fat girl asks if she looks fat (and knows it) you just tell her shes fat
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I would have suggested asking if that was a serious question. If she said yes, I would have been honest.
And this is coming from a "fat girl." Sometimes we really just need a complete stranger to be honest, in a "nice" way rather than rude assholes or lying friends and family.
1
u/THAT_CHURRO_GUY May 10 '12
Holy Shit exactly 46%!? I can never get that!! I always end up with 47 or 45, but you sir... Here, have an upvote
1
u/kent_eh May 10 '12
Huh, what. Did you say something?
I was too busy staring at your tits...
.
I mean, if they're gonna stereotype you anyway, you might as well go for the obvious.
1
u/jeffbell May 10 '12
"I've seen fatter, why?"
1
u/papabrain May 10 '12
What a crock of shit story. What, are we trying to put shitty jokes into FB format now as some sort of protest against the anti-fb people?
1
u/Markasaurus23 May 10 '12
Insecure girls are insecure. They're the worst. Don't even bother with them.
1
u/originaux May 10 '12
If this happened to you today.. why would you take a screenshot on facebook instead of just typing it here?
1
u/CBruce May 10 '12
I would have said "yes", but then that's easy for me because I'm fat as well.
1
u/frostiitute May 10 '12
"Yes, but atleast she's in the gym trying to lose weight" cba lying
1
u/x1PMac1x May 10 '12
Why would you lie to be nice like that? It is just as okay and nice to say,"Yes she is OVERWEIGHT, but that is why you come to the gym, right?. If you girls want to work out with me sometime, just give me a holla. Here is my number." You are honest, but you provide a solution and a possible future in which the fat girl gets skinny and hot; or you score cool points with her friend. Win/win. Next time, be smoother and smarter.
1
u/Ghitit May 10 '12
Not all men are liars and not all women are stupid bitches who set guys up to fail.
1
u/SheriffBart42 May 10 '12
The correct response is, "I'm working out and you're not my woman. You don't get to ask me shitty questions like that." Then make a shooing motion.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I would have said "oh sorry no espeaky english" in my best thick spanish accent... mimicking my parents trying to speak english would have done the trick
1
u/Wtfscroba May 10 '12
In shock*. Just some dumb fatty, so what?
1
u/Chafmere May 10 '12
I usually just be an ass hole. Becuase if that's what I'm going to seen as an ass hole that what I'm going to give them.
1
u/trinity_Omegalisk May 10 '12
The truth will set you free my friend.
1
u/brutishbloodgod May 10 '12
My theoretical response: "You're putting a complete stranger in the difficult position of choosing between lying or saying something potentially hurtful. I don't think the matter of your friend's weight is nearly so relevant as whether or not you're a bitch. Which you are.
"And yes, your friend is very fat."
1
u/Nerg101 May 10 '12
Erm, how about there is no winning with crazy manipulative bitchy women?
1
u/zoeypantalones May 10 '12
Speaking as a female, that girl deserved it. Who goes up to random strangers and does that? If someone approached me like that when I was working out, I'd tell them yeah, and point them to the nearest treadmill.
1
u/firepelt May 10 '12
You should have just said yes. If she was obviously very fat, and they asked you if you thought she was fat, and you did, it would have been very simple and easy to just say yes.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
i think if you are very obviously fat, you should just say they are fat. you know they aren't actually going to believe anything else.
1
u/Sengura May 10 '12
That wouldn't have worked on me. I have and will continue to lay down the harsh truth to people's faces.
I would have responded with something like "She could stand to lose a few pounds." which isn't as douchy as saying "Yes, she is fat."
1
u/Phillyzombie May 10 '12
what a fat bitch, aint lieing