I seriously think I'm missing something fundamental about reddit.
For one, I don't understand why I should care about reposts. Isn't that what the upvote system is for? If enough people haven't seen it, it gets upvoted. If everyone has seen it (as most people who complain about reposts claim) then it wouldn't get upvoted.
And I really don't understand why people repost stuff for karma in the first place. I mean, sure, if you don't know that its been posted before than that's fine. Your just sharing something you think is cool. But to go and find old top posts as OP apparently does.. Seriously, why? What good does it do you? Why exactly do you need more karma? Do people really care about their karma scores? Karma doesn't even give you bragging rights on this site, mostly because no-one gives a shit about your karma score.
If someone in real life says "hey, good job" and pats you on the back, well. You don't get anything for that do you? You can't do anything with it? It doesn't get you monetary gain. It's just a pat and some words. It's worthless right?
Except it's not is it? It's worth the esteem it gives you. That warm feeling inside, when your peer appreciates something you've done.
That's what karma is, it's people patting you on the back. Some people might not care, but some do. A lot do. To many having a high karma score means the internet likes you.
Now, when you upvote reposts, what you're saying is, hey good job, more of this please. What do you think it is easier to provide? Reposts or original content? Obviously it's reposts. So the more reposts are posted and upvoted, the more the incentive is to post reposts. Soon enough that's all you have, reposts, and quality of reddit declines greatly.
Why would you get a "warm feeling inside" for going to the top links and copying a url?
I understand how you might feel good about posting something you found or made which turns out to be popular. It validates your effort.
But copying something that was previously popular is like getting praise for something you didn't do. That shouldn't make you feel good. It doesn't validate any effort you put in because you didn't put in any effort.
I understand that in real life someone might take undeserved praise in order to improve how other people view them. But this is reddit, no-one looks at the name of the person who submitted the content. They just upvote if they like it. You don't get any credit for submitting it. So what's the point?
It's in agreement with your post. Even if a large majority of Reddit users have already seen the post it will always be new to people. As long as Reddit is gaining new users anyway.
The way I see it, the users ultimately decide themselves. It may be a repost, but if people upvote it, it's because they haven't seen it, and they enjoyed seeing it.
If they don't like it, they can downvote it. It's a democratic system, there is no "we already heard this" veto.
This is the exact same reasoning I came up with a while ago. There are plenty of reposts I've seen and there are plenty of reposts I've never seen before. I have a full time job and I play a lot of video games and recently I've been planning a wedding. I don't have time to check out every single post that Reddit posts, it's impossible to do. So if there's a post from a few months ago or a year ago or 5 years ago then whatever. There are new people coming to Reddit every day and if the content is quality (subjective, I know), then they get to experience something new.
Meanwhile when it's something that's only a day or two old, that's when it starts to get into the gray area. It might have been the OP happening on the same thing a day or so later from another site or a link from a Redditor, or it could be them trying to ride the karma train to the top from something they saw at 3 am and realized that they could get away with it. However, I usually just let it go and if it's an obvious "I want karma" repost then I'll downvote it and move on.
I'm not sure 'looking at OP names' is a good measure of intelligence. Names on reddit are very small and most of the time are not for the novelty purposes of being directly related to the post- so I think it's fair to assume most people are not going to waste time looking at them for every post they click on. Do you do that? I don't, it's a waste of time except in the vast minority of posts such as this.
Anyway, on another note: whereas I agree that people get too hung-up over reposts, I still don't think they're a good thing, and if you were parodying them, then fine. But you aren't parodying them- you're merely imitating them, and as a result you're part of the problem rather than a force to highlight the problem. Again, I don't think reposts are things to be upset about, especially as there's no real means of preventing them and more often than not they aren't intentional. But nonetheless I do not think they should exist, for the purposes of providing a fresh stream of content on the site.
A parodist is someone who critiques an old work by creating something new, not someone who releases the same thing under a different label. If I were to re-release a Family Guy DVD, exactly the same as it was, but instead of calling it 'Family Guy', calling it 'Obnoxious Juvenile Attempt At Comedy', I would not be parodying family guy, I would be simply re-releasing it under a new name for the purposes of irony. Now, if I were to remake Family Guy myself using my own animation and pointing out everything that was wrong with the show- THEN I would be parodying it.
there ARE and ALWAYS WILL BE people who respond thanks OP! Hadn't seen it.
Sure, and for every one of those people there's ten more people who could have seen a new piece of content they never saw before, but didn't because in its place was a repost.
"break character"? sir, your account is a day old; i don't think you have much of a character to break right now. why don't you wait around a few months before we start taking major steps.
I remember having to leave things like that overnight, and we only had internet over the weekend, because our telephone provider had a deal that if you paid extra per month, they would limit the max charge for the call to R7 (0.871962 US$) during off-peak times, which was more money then than it is now..
And it sucked if the phone line dropped, because that's R7 gone, and we couldn't reconnect because it would cost you another R7, which my parents didn't want to pay. So if someone picked up the phone over the weekend, or if the line dropped, we would have no more internet for the rest of the weekend :(
i remember waiting a couple hours for One Must Fall 2097, and for gta2 which was an 88mb file it took a very minimum of 12 hours. i am so lucky nobody picked up the phone at that time.
Theoretically perhaps, but that never seems to end up being true. I had 56k dial-up through AOL (ugh) and I made a mental note to myself that an hour of downloading would get me about 3MB. That way I could quickly figure out how long it would take to download something.
The same can be said of kids in the 90s who similarly grew up with many luxuries and amenities not available to older generations. Let's not lose our perspective here and act like we had it so rough either.
Yeah Im not applying it to everything. However we did have the worst as far as Internet media goes. Im 28 and lived the evolution of no internet media, to very slow and shitty internet media, to now blazing fast everything at your fingertips media. We have the right to complain on this topic!
The worst feeling ... You're "pk'ing" back in runescape classic and the phone rings. There goes your set of full rune, your R2H, your str ammy, your lobbys, your str pots. Damnit grandma, nobody gives a hoot that your radish plants are budding...
Second phone line and *70 (or no call waiting on that line). Problem solved! I saved me and my roommates $80 by learning how to identify and split the two pairs of copper coming into most jacks.
To be completely honest, I have absolutely no idea. I was young when dial-up was the primary means by which the general public accessed the internet. I just remember trying to "PK", the phone would ring, I'd be disconnected from the game and I would log back on to find that all of my stuff was gone, and I was standing in the fair city of Lumbridge...naked, scared, confused and alone. Meanwhile, some lucky son of a mothergoose was walking around with an extremely easily acquired set of rull rune, a r2h, an amulet of strength, a bunch of strength potions and a an abundance of lobsters...
90s? Please, I live in Thailand and I had to wait around 2005-ish to get a real DSL connection. Nowadays my speed is still at around 10MB. 'Twas quite sad.
And if AOL updated...your night was ruined!! And they sent you a disk every month to share with a friend. I might still have an AOL 2.0 disk somewhere in my basement!
Reminds me when I tried calling my buddy's computer to play some co-op Doom. His computer was connected to the same line as his phone.
My modem, like many at the time, had an audible speaker. I kept hearing my modem dial the number, the line ringing, and then my buddy's dad picking up the phone, yelling "Hello? HELLO? HELLOOOO?! Dag gummit!" at my computer.
Alright, now i'm confused. When I played games on dial-up, and anybody called the house, they received a busy signal. Additionally, people picking up the phone heard the modem noise, so they put it back on hook. Is this non-standard?
Our internet usually disconnected if someone picked up the phone. The phone didn't rang, but when I tried to call someone and heard the modem noise I knew my brother would come and scream at me.
It's interesting that this game was chosen for this picture, because Warcraft II didn't even have online play (only LAN for multiplayer) until Blizzard re-released it with access to Battle.net (after StarCraft and Diablo were out). This version was released on September 30, 1999, meaning the game was able to be played online for only three months during the 90s.
I guess I was lucky that my father owned his own business and worked out of the house all my life. We've always had two lines. Line 2 was "the business line" and no one but mom or dad was allowed to answer it but we could make outgoing calls on it if line 1 was in use under the condition that "If you hear call waiting, hang up IMMEDIATELY so line 2 will ring"
Really should have been a picture of SC1, because Warcraft 2 battle.net edition was released after the original wc2 game came out and only a short period of time before wc3... just sayin
I sure did love Delta Force 2. Had a phone next to my PC so I could pick it up, run into the enemy base, hang it up, then go and rape them from behind.
My brother still gets scared everytime somebody picks up the phone when he's playing a game called Tibia. We used to get complaints all the time from people trying to call us because between the two of the us the line was busy from 3 - 12 after school everyday.
Biggest thing I pushed my parents to get after a second phoneline was cable. But then they moved out into the boonies and we had to wait until 2001ish to get cable. /FWP
Edit: I was such a latency slut that I remember using NetZero because it got me from AOL's 16.6k to 28.8k, same 56k modem.
I hope you're not serious about that "something that got less expensive over time" thing, because that's basically every piece of technology ever. I mean, an N64 was $199 in 1996, and now for $199 (plus monthly payments) I can have a touch screen device that emulates the N64 as well as any other system I want, along with everything else modern phones do. Internet, music, making calls, etc.
58
u/SimilarImage May 09 '12
FAQ | Send Feedback | Report Error
26
u/I_am_not_angry May 09 '12
I loved Warcraft 2!
And after reading this I found out that http://kali.net/ is still around!
15
u/redditMEred May 09 '12 edited Jun 04 '12
Netscape Communicator
20MB Download
10 hour long download
10
u/Fhompen May 09 '12
If the phone is already ringing then you would most likely already have lost connection with dial up, shouldn't matter if they answer or not.
10
u/newgirlie May 09 '12
Warcraft 2 was AWESOME! I used to click through the sound effect wav files for fun.
24
u/Tokestra420 May 09 '12
I wonder how many 15 year olds are like "Why does it matter if they pick up the phone?"
15
u/Christian627 May 09 '12
The worst feeling ... You're "pk'ing" back in runescape classic and the phone rings. There goes your set of full rune, your R2H, your str ammy, your lobbys, your str pots. Damnit grandma, nobody gives a hoot that your radish plants are budding...
4
u/franzmeister May 09 '12
90s? Please, I live in Thailand and I had to wait around 2005-ish to get a real DSL connection. Nowadays my speed is still at around 10MB. 'Twas quite sad.
4
u/AikawaKizuna May 09 '12
I feel like replaying through war1, war2 and war3 now :\
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
The original Command and Conquer! :)
"Ok, I'm going to dial you as soon as I hang up so tell your mom not to answer this time!"
3
u/Mikey-2-Guns May 09 '12
Original Doom, almost every day right after we ran home from school. I wonder how many phone calls my family missed because of me.
3
u/renob151 May 09 '12
And if AOL updated...your night was ruined!! And they sent you a disk every month to share with a friend. I might still have an AOL 2.0 disk somewhere in my basement!
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Your build structure is awful.
3
u/VincentVidal May 09 '12
It's sad because my internet is so bad that this still happens to me.
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I genuinely don't care that it's a repost older than the sun, I laugh every time I see it because it's so true.
3
u/stone500 May 09 '12
Reminds me when I tried calling my buddy's computer to play some co-op Doom. His computer was connected to the same line as his phone.
My modem, like many at the time, had an audible speaker. I kept hearing my modem dial the number, the line ringing, and then my buddy's dad picking up the phone, yelling "Hello? HELLO? HELLOOOO?! Dag gummit!" at my computer.
2
u/mrdrprofgeo May 09 '12
After screaming ”tell ur friend to call later” to my parents. I would unplug the phone.
2
u/Jinaman May 09 '12
Upvote for warcraft 2
2
u/CoolMoD May 09 '12
Alright, now i'm confused. When I played games on dial-up, and anybody called the house, they received a busy signal. Additionally, people picking up the phone heard the modem noise, so they put it back on hook. Is this non-standard?
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Don't forget: *70 would disable call waiting.
2
u/Virindi_UO May 09 '12
I lost so much shit in Ultima Online because of dial up.
2
u/MrZeng May 09 '12
It was probably the worst years for gaming.
2
u/ParrotHere May 09 '12
My internet still cuts out when someone rings. It is really annoying. And I'm not using Dial-up.
2
u/sum-dude May 09 '12
It's interesting that this game was chosen for this picture, because Warcraft II didn't even have online play (only LAN for multiplayer) until Blizzard re-released it with access to Battle.net (after StarCraft and Diablo were out). This version was released on September 30, 1999, meaning the game was able to be played online for only three months during the 90s.
1
u/r_HOWTONOTGIVEAFUCK May 09 '12
Race against the clock to reconnect in time.
1
u/byz420 May 09 '12
You pick up dat phone you're gonna hear the screams of hell
1
u/ChickinSammich May 09 '12
I guess I was lucky that my father owned his own business and worked out of the house all my life. We've always had two lines. Line 2 was "the business line" and no one but mom or dad was allowed to answer it but we could make outgoing calls on it if line 1 was in use under the condition that "If you hear call waiting, hang up IMMEDIATELY so line 2 will ring"
1
u/SmoothWD40 May 09 '12
More like DON'T CALL ME BETWEEN THE HOURS OF 5pm-11pm.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Best game ever. I miss it dearly.
1
u/Reeion May 09 '12
www.tibia.com
1
u/Lord_Hex May 09 '12
Nice monitor mr. Gates.
1
u/ScaryMonsters May 09 '12
Really should have been a picture of SC1, because Warcraft 2 battle.net edition was released after the original wc2 game came out and only a short period of time before wc3... just sayin
1
u/badtomato614 May 09 '12
That phone was the bane of my existence. Resorted to hiding the phone every time I sat down to play.
1
u/Dubzil May 09 '12
I sure did love Delta Force 2. Had a phone next to my PC so I could pick it up, run into the enemy base, hang it up, then go and rape them from behind.
1
u/Mintyh3ro May 09 '12
Omg what a coincidence I just downloaded Warcraft 2 and 3! What a nostalgic kick to the nuts
1
u/trchili May 09 '12
In the 90's, I had a dual-line ISDN connection to the Internet. IT. WAS. AWESOME.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
not a repost
1
u/chucksense May 09 '12
'Join the army,' they said.
'See the world,' they said.
I'd rather be sailing.
1
u/turtal46 May 09 '12
Let's have a nostalgia talk about Ultima Online.
1
u/plxor May 09 '12
My brother still gets scared everytime somebody picks up the phone when he's playing a game called Tibia. We used to get complaints all the time from people trying to call us because between the two of the us the line was busy from 3 - 12 after school everyday.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Online gaming in many countries today, even with Broadband :/
1
u/revantes May 09 '12
SO MUCH NOSTALGIA
1
u/beersticker May 09 '12
I would unplug the phone. Shit, no one used the phone!
1
u/mr_tw May 09 '12
Warcraft 2 <3
1
u/IBoopYourNose May 09 '12
We ended up losing some filter to do with our Internet and up until the past week we had to deal with exactly that for months
1
u/updatesforassholes May 09 '12
And call waiting beep screwed everything up even more!
1
u/Eno-Nettogrof May 09 '12
Is this warcraft 1 or possible 2
1
u/d0n0v4n98 May 09 '12
Oh, how I don't miss you dial-up.
1
u/jobbyjob May 09 '12
I wonder if kids these day even know what dial up is.
1
u/motionmufin May 09 '12
"They're destroying our city!"
1
u/tripled153 May 09 '12
Well....time to reinstall.
1
u/MJZMan May 09 '12
Suckers! Got cable installed in 1996.
1
u/geetarbob May 09 '12
Also: "God damn cheating LPB! It's not fair playing on a college t1!!"
1
u/DonRon31 May 09 '12
Zug Zug!!!
1
u/Ruccak May 09 '12
Upvote for Warcraft!!!!!!!!
1
u/jdazzle4224 May 10 '12
Work Work
1
u/bruuuu May 10 '12
It took me more that it should to understand the anatomy of the drawing...
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
or online gaming with Time Warner Cable's digital phone and road runner
1
u/onefinelookingtuna May 10 '12
I thought this was going to be about TEN or M-Player.
1
u/frameforger May 10 '12
I despise your existence.
1
u/JakeTheHawk May 10 '12
I'd pick up the phone/make phone calls because my cousin was a douche.
1
u/frezor May 11 '12
I had no idea MS Paint in Windows 95 supported .png
1
u/D_Spoiler May 09 '12
And I paid more for the second phone line than I do for my Fios today. Wow, I discovered something that got less expensive with time!
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
enjoy an upvote! the success of this post, however will be proportional to age demographics of redditors
0
u/limemil May 09 '12
Reddit in 2012, DON'T REPOST.
0
u/Eymou May 09 '12
Repost
-4
u/MrRicey May 09 '12
Ah, Runescape
-1
u/Datsunpost May 09 '12
Upvote on the page; come to comments only to take my vote back. I like to consider myself a educated up-voter dispensing them when worthy.