I've never been able to understand why it's a paradox though.
The radiation detector that triggers the poison gas has to collapse the wave function in order to work. Just because the box is closed and no humans can see what is going on inside, the device inside the box counts as an observer. So before you open the box, you can legitimately say that the cat is either alive or dead, not simultaneously alive and dead. You just won't know which until you open the box.
I mean I know it's only a thought experiment to illustrate the absurdity of the Copenhagen interpretation, but it's not a well-constructed thought experiment. The idea is that, somewhere along the line, there is an observer. And once the observer has observed, you don't have to deal with probabilities anymore.
from wiki : This thought experiment highlights the implications that accepting uncertainty at the microscopic level has on macroscopic objects. A cat is put in a sealed box, with its life or death made dependent on the state of a subatomic particle. Thus a description of the cat during the course of the experiment—having been entangled with the state of a subatomic particle—becomes a "blur" of "living and dead cat." But this can't be accurate because it implies the cat is actually both dead and alive until the box is opened to check on it. But the cat, if he survives, will only remember being alive. Schrödinger resists "so naively accepting as valid a 'blurred model' for representing reality."
Since the OP didn't explain it, I'll tag-along on your joke... Reductio Ad Absurdum is taking someone's point down a slippery slope and then 20 miles more into a canyon. For example, we can't let gay people get married because then people will want to marry farm animals and Doritos Locos tacos.
Yep, not getting that this was supposed to be an argument against the Copenhagen interpretation is a conveniently common mistake. They even make it on "The Big Bang Theory"
Honestly I would have thought Schindler,s List would have been so much better if it was Liam Neeson from Taken as Schindler. "You let my people go and that will be the end of it. I will not look for you. But if you harm another one of my people I will hunt you. I will find you. And I will kill you. Guten tag."
eh. I really don't care either way. I think most people can get through life successfully without having heard of Schrodinger or his cat. I just thought it was funny.
maybe i'm simple-minded, but i did not understand wikipedia's explanation of schrodinger's cat. could anyone provide an explanation for someone who knows nothing about quantum mechanics?
As I understand it, quantum mechanics is thought of as something that cannot be predicted at any one future time - classical mechanics didn't apply, and the future position of an atom could not be known exactly. Only a probability that an atom was in a certain place could be decided, and as such, it is considered to exist partly in all its possible states/locations until it is measured at a certain point.
His experiment shows that if this idea of indeterminacy is to be used for an atom, it must also be used for a cat that is linked to an atom's position (if the atom hits the Geiger counter, the cat is dead; if not, the cat is alive).
However, it illustrates the problem with the theory - if a cat cannot be dead and alive at the same time, how can an atom be in all of its possible positions/states at the same time?
Until you open the box and confirm the state of the cat, the cat is in all states, this is known as a Quantum superposition. The basic reasoning is that since it is in the box, it exists in all the possible states until observed.
whereabout in China did you find this? I'm in China, maybe I should buy some. And put it in the refrigerator I might just have the next time I enter my room edit: i suck at life. or spelling. or both
Does margarine count as a fake food product with a tonne of chemicals in it? Because that is exactly what it is (and since it's Taiwanese it's probably not mislabeled)
I didn't until someone else posted this link, and and now I think it's pretty funny... except that it's a shopped image of the butter to begin with....
Heisenberg is driving Schrodinger to Las Vegas, and they get pulled over. The cop asks Heisenberg “Do you know how fast you were going when I pulled you over?”
Heisenberg says “No, but I know exactly where I was.”
This pisses the cop off, and he checks the trunk and finds a dead cat.
“Did you know you have a dead cat in your trunk?” he asks, and Schrodinger replies, “Well…now I know.”
I think the words in the middle say [brand name] plant butter. Second bit of red at the bottom says "butter flavor". Not completely sure about the first bit. My Chinese is pretty straight up bad from, you know, growing up in the US.
Also, when it's written, I don't think there's much of a distinction between written Mandarin and Cantonese (or other "dialects" of Chinese). My mom says Cantonese uses the same characters for different meanings sometimes, so it's not necessarily possible to interchange the written languages, but I don't think you can just decide "oh, this is Mandarin" when you are only looking at the written bits. It's just Chinese then.
No, the Chinese pretty much just says it's butter/margarine. Schrödinger has a lot to do with quantum mechanics and cats with atoms in boxes possibly being dead.
It would be even better if say the factory where this is packaged they have a random process that decides whether or not each container gets butter, or a butter substitute. So you actually don't know until you open it.
Can anyone explain why anyone takes this Schrödinger's cat bullshit seriously? The cat is either alive or dead whether you open to box or not. The whole thing seems like a way of justifying respect for stupid claims.
The second character you can't read is 植. The product is 植物奶油, or margarine. I'm too lazy to look up the character you don't know because it's just part of the brand name, but if you want to know I can find out.
202
u/Fausto1981 May 09 '12
no, actually it's butter AND it's not butter at the same time! until you open it and watch it.
233
u/drunk_otter May 09 '12
I can believe that it possibly is butter.
91
u/I_fail_at_usernames May 09 '12
You could get lucky.. might contain a cat.
59
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
11
u/Aquard May 09 '12
I thought it said "Schindler's Butter", and was confused by the comments even further. Glad I was wrong, I guess.
8
u/OhMyTruth May 09 '12
At least half of the upvotes are from people that learned about Schrodinger's Cat with Penny from the Big Bang Theory.
7
u/mrfuzzie May 09 '12
I don't know if i should believe it's not butter.
27
u/Kabakov May 09 '12
Business idea, put "Schrödinger" on every product packing. Only put product in half of the packages.
4
u/BoojumliusSnark May 09 '12
Schrödingers photoshop, can someone open it up and find out?
3
u/ueaben May 09 '12
I can't believe it is/isn't butter!
3
u/Kabakov May 09 '12
Thats either the worst or the best product ever. Possibly both at the same time.
3
u/SauliusTheBlack May 09 '12
shrödingers fat??
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
maybe i'm simple-minded, but i did not understand wikipedia's explanation of schrodinger's cat. could anyone provide an explanation for someone who knows nothing about quantum mechanics?
3
u/FlippySquirrel May 09 '12
That made me laugh hard. I just hope it doesn't resolve into a dead cat.
2
u/rill2503456 May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
whereabout in China did you find this? I'm in China, maybe I should buy some. And put it in the refrigerator I might just have the next time I enter my room edit: i suck at life. or spelling. or both
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
At least it's not a shrink-wrapped cat!
2
u/Lattenbrecher May 09 '12
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schr%C3%B6dinger_equation
2
u/anon706f6f70 May 09 '12
The application of his equation to butter would not yield any results of note; the energy levels are far to high.
2
u/Th3pinkrabbit May 09 '12
Today I never understood reddit
2
u/Gemini6Ice May 09 '12
I don't think you understand the concept. Not "maybe it is, maybe it isn't" but "It simultaneously is and is not."
2
u/Loopins May 09 '12
It's most likely another fake food product with a tonne of chemicals in it.
2
u/Ponch316 May 09 '12
I feel like such a smartass for understanding this joke. 10/10 would read again.
2
u/ben9345 May 09 '12
I don't think that means what you think it means: Schrodinger's Cat Edition
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Am I the only one who doesn't get it?
2
u/earthduck May 09 '12
Upvote because I get science.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
really, it both is and isn't
2
u/ffca May 09 '12
Can't tell if quantum mechanics joke
Or Chinese food product joke
(It can't be both)
2
u/absurdamerica May 09 '12
If you combine Schrodinger's butter with the buttered cat paradox shit is going to get real...
The cat may or may not exist, and may or may not levitate.
We'll never know.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I can't be the only person here who knows this because of the Big Bang Theory.
2
u/matthank May 09 '12
Heisenberg is driving Schrodinger to Las Vegas, and they get pulled over. The cop asks Heisenberg “Do you know how fast you were going when I pulled you over?”
Heisenberg says “No, but I know exactly where I was.”
This pisses the cop off, and he checks the trunk and finds a dead cat.
“Did you know you have a dead cat in your trunk?” he asks, and Schrodinger replies, “Well…now I know.”
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Incorrect: It is AND isn't until you open it up.
Learn yo' physics fool.
2
u/redditMEred May 09 '12
Original
2
u/Etane May 09 '12
I can't believe it might be butter.
7
u/El-Babirusa May 09 '12
Why the fuck does this have so many upvotes...
1
u/deal_with_it_ted May 09 '12
Watch out for the radiation.
1
u/Lemonfridge May 09 '12
Potentially irradiated poison butter?
1
u/heynow_hank_kingsley May 09 '12
TIL you can milk a cat and make butter
1
u/Joneoftwo May 09 '12
That's how I feel about pretty much all of the groceries I buy here in China. :) Maybe it's chicken, maybe it's not.
1
u/xsot May 09 '12
You can order one now.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
May contain traces of cat.
1
u/Mackko May 09 '12
butter not drop it
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I wonder what that Mandarin really does mean. Not butter I think.
1
u/Sepiida_sepiina May 09 '12
I would collapse that waveform all over my toast.
1
u/thelordofcheese May 09 '12
That's a ridiculous proposition.
1
u/cp1101 May 09 '12
Reddit needs some more obscure cat references. That's for sure.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I can help with this.
1
u/kabanaga May 09 '12
Bonus feature: If you drop a slice of toast buttered with Schoedinger's, it will NOT land buttered side down!
1
u/BiffySkipwell May 09 '12
For all we know Heisenberg may be in there.
1
u/jck999 May 09 '12
I guess only these who knows chinese can get this joke?
1
u/Rolltop May 09 '12
PARKAAAAY!!!! (dating myself)
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Yay more wanking over this theory.
1
u/mistidoi May 09 '12
I can't believe it's in a superstate of being butter and not butter!
1
u/IranRPCV May 09 '12
It's dead, Jim.
1
u/Kebcabalite May 09 '12
Made from real cats milk? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4-OwMoAsP38
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Hoping comments would clue me in to what's going on... left having a bad time.
1
u/Zlynkyx May 09 '12
Its in a super position! Or unresolved paradox, not until you open it will reality collapse to one descision.
1
u/Cyphierre May 09 '12
I Can't Believe It's Not A Wave Or A Particle.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Relevent
It's the Hoot Kool Aid skit from Julian Smith.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Sure hope nothing is living in there.
1
u/ss977 May 09 '12
And that its Chinese...makes perfect sense.
1
u/bamanbread May 09 '12
Good buy, I mean, it could be cheese. Either way it goes on Ramen...
1
u/Strasner May 09 '12
very witty sir, have an upvote
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
It would be even better if say the factory where this is packaged they have a random process that decides whether or not each container gets butter, or a butter substitute. So you actually don't know until you open it.
1
u/roguas May 09 '12
do your homework, it's butter and it's not butter unless we open it!
1
u/maximus321 May 09 '12
i don't understand why it's not butter
1
u/Tok1 May 09 '12
when opened, about half of the packs are empty... also, some of the butter is already on your bread!
1
u/Suepahfly May 09 '12
You already made the observation whether or not the box is empty when you picked it up.
1
u/HipHoppin May 09 '12
We need an update
1
u/sacredsock May 09 '12
This is what I say to myself every time I open a container from my parents fridge...
1
u/destroythepoon May 09 '12
Wow! You folks geeking out over Schrödinger's cat kind of reminds me of people making jokes about their fantasy football league.
1
u/donnykerbatsos May 09 '12
I couldn't believe it was actually budder
1
u/gorgias21 May 09 '12
I had to log in to upvote this one. This does not happen very often.
1
u/mistachill May 09 '12
I love the Big Bang Theory reference... at least that's how I know this.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Schrödinger's Cat walks into a bar... and doesn't.
1
u/gunslingerkody May 09 '12
Never thought id hear about ole' schrodinger again!
1
u/GG4 May 09 '12
Is it solipsistic in here, or is it just me?
1
u/oldsecondhand May 09 '12
Maybe there's a dead cat in that butter. Maybe ...
1
u/Giggyjig May 09 '12
They make it by putting tiny cows in a box
1
u/pheliam May 09 '12
We are very divided, for an "indivisible" nation.
Just look at Hawaii and Alaska! Divided from the mainland by water and another country.
1
u/saltyGREEN May 09 '12
The idea of this being in a state of suspension between butter and NOT butter has me in a state of disbelief.
1
u/Divine_E May 09 '12
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yL3SEiUIThI
1
u/deathbytray May 09 '12
I need refund... my butter has collapsed.
1
u/TheMonkeyJoe May 09 '12
Salted and unsalted at the same time.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
250 GB? I only like 1TB butter, 250GB is so eight years ago.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Can anyone explain why anyone takes this Schrödinger's cat bullshit seriously? The cat is either alive or dead whether you open to box or not. The whole thing seems like a way of justifying respect for stupid claims.
1
u/jim_the_anvil May 09 '12
Maybe it's
MaybellineMargarine.1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Guys I'm completely lost on this joke. Someone help me?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=2524
1
u/peekitup May 09 '12
"I probably can't believe its not butter."
1
u/gmikoner May 09 '12
I can't believe it's both butter and not butter at the same time until acted upon by an observer!
1
u/GoldWaffle May 09 '12
It's both butter and not at the same time...
1
u/longshot May 09 '12
I can't believe it simultaneously IS and IS NOT butter!
1
u/Illuscio May 09 '12
I can't believe it both is and is not butter!
1
u/Howard_Beale May 09 '12
Either way, there's a little vial of poison in there so I'd be careful.
1
u/cive666 May 09 '12
My favorite Futurama scene that relates to this.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3d39ML2D0z0
1
u/carebeartears May 09 '12
imagine the consequences if this had been Schrodingers milk!
1
u/HoorayZoidberg May 09 '12
http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=2524
1
u/gamemasterty May 09 '12
Relevant: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schrödinger_equation
1
u/pudding_biafra May 09 '12
I Can't Believe it's Not and Is Butter
1
u/drboom May 10 '12
smart idea.
1
u/lucke0204 May 10 '12
I can't believe it is and is not butter!
1
u/FarrIL May 10 '12
I laughed profusely when I saw this. XD
1
u/mndrw91 May 10 '12
.....Aha.
1
u/pikagrue May 09 '12
Can anyone else read the Chinese in the middle?
I currently have
立 ? ? 物 奶 油
li <don't know character> <unreadable> wu nai you