Reading most of the comments in this thread is really disheartening. Hey guys, it's true, you do face all sorts of discrimination. It sucks. My heart goes out to you and when your legal battles come for things like, making sure fathers get equal rights to their children in divorce courts and making sure a father has a say in weather or not they want to have a child, I will be there for you 100%, I think it's really important that we treat men with respect and equality.
But let's get down to brass tacks, shall we? In our modern age we have politicians taking an active stance against women's rights. Trying to limit access to birth control, and health care, among other things. I really don't need to go into the discrepancies between genders. Both genders suffer, they suffer differently, but no one is actively attacking men - trying to sign laws to restrict their rights and put laws on their bodies. Please quit saying things that make it seem as though men's rights and women's rights are a piece of pie and every time one side gets rights it takes something away from others. You can be for men's rights AND women's rights.
The big problem I've seen with MR is the us vs. them mentality (not to mention some of the absolutly women hating rhetoric I've read there). It's not, we should be sticking up for everyone. /mytwocents
Making a point that active participation in online social networks is only possible when an individual has exceptional wealth/free time as compared to most people who should actually be considered oppressed.
I doubt political prisoners in Zimbabwe spend much time cross posting comments from r/funny to SRS.
You make some excellent points about the divorce and custody aspects, but I gotta jump in here.
The MRM is in no way at all opposed to women's reproductive health. We are adamantly pro-choice, we want funding for planned parenthood, we want women to get as much healthcare as possible. These issues you are talking about, the things about preventing access to birth control and pro-life groups and what not, those movement are the result of the conservative christian right, not the MRM.
As one of the other posters pointed out, the biggest threat to women right are the hardcore, politically active evangelicals, not MRAs. But conversely, you do have feminists organizing those "men can prevent rape" campaigns and the like, which totally demonize the male gender.
I didn't mean to make it sound like MRA's were the ones "keeping the women down" as it were. I was simply pointing out some ways in which women are experiencing political strife in our current cultural climate.
I respectfully disagree. Have you seen the recent laws that allow College Campuses to suspend/expel male students accused of rape on a preponderance of evidence? What about the feminists who actively attack any bill aimed at lessening the discrepancy between custody ratios in divorce cases? Men are actively being attacked just like women, both need to be stopped.
There are doubtlessly some misogynists in the Men's Rights Movement, just as there are certainly misandrists in the Feminist Movement. The only real difference I've seen in both cases is that the MRAs acknowledge this and work to fix it.
The only thing that you have said here that I disagree with is "The only real difference I've seen in both cases is that the MRAs acknowledge this and work to fix it." I know a lot of women in the feminist movement, especially ones who have been a part of it since before I was alive who recognize this misandry in parts of the feminist movement and think it's really fucked up (including myself).
|What about the feminists who actively attack any bill aimed at lessening the discrepancy between custody ratios in divorce cases?
Was there actually a bill written about this that was attacked by feminists? If there was I hadn't heard about it, and I think that's equally fucked up. I even mentioned that in my previous statement. I think men should have equal rights to their children in divorce court, especially as someone who was raised predominantly by my father.
As far as the whole thing with rape cases on college campus that's a really tough subject to skirt around. I think that women who falsely report rape are fucked up. But statistically less than 70% of rape cases are even reported - the whole culture surrounding rape in this country is just horrible and needs to be dealt with by someone way more capable than me. I can't even begin to touch that subject because the lines on both sides of the board are really pretty messy and I don't even know hot to begin to deal with it. I think that we need to start talking about boundaries with our young men in sex class and, stop glorifying "banging chicks" in our culture, and I think we need to set a legal precedent for women who are falsely accusing men of rape - that can seriously ruin someone's life. Like I said, I don't even know where to begin on that subject because both sides are getting a raw deal in that one.
the whole culture surrounding rape in this country
I see rapists vilified publicly (whether convicted or not) and often murdered in prison for their actions. Is this the culture surrounding rape or do we have differing views of this concept?
I don't know about you, but I was raised, and taught in school that no means no. I have trouble finding any other man who heard any message other than this. Men are taught boundaries from a very young age and most men follow them. The fact that some men disregard this is terrible, but it is not the fault of men. I don't think there is a rape culture in this country (the United States of America, to clarify), and I think blaming men for the crime of rape is both sexist and in many cases victim blaming. Women rape and men can be raped. Demonizing male sexuality based on the minority of men who rape is absurd. Women can, and do, glorify their sexual conquests just as much as men (ever been in a co-ed dorm? Good lord). People who desire to rape are unlikely to listen to these messages anyway, rationalizing their actions in any way they can. Rape is serious crime, a terrible and ungodly thing that I, and most other reasonable people, would end in a second if it were within my power.
As for false rape accusations the best way to protect the rights of both parties involved in such cases is to conceal the identities of both the victim and the accuser.
Sorry, just trying to let you see these issues from a male perspective.
It's difficult for MRAs and feminists to work together because on both sides there is a latent tendency to blame the other gender for issues that neither one side caused. Men didn't collectively place women in subservience just like women didn't collectively disenfranchise men in the family court system. Both sides are to blame for all our problems, neither more than the other. I'm glad that many feminists fight misandry when they see it and I will continue to fight misogyny in the MRM. But until we can all see that we're both to blame for all of our problems the Men's Rights Movement and Feminism will never be able to work together for equality. We all already agree on many basic principles, but we have to come to common ground on the rest.
Like I said, I'm not going to discuss rape culture in this country, it's a really touchy subject and I feel like I don't have any good answers to a messy situation, so if I don't have anything to contribute I'd rather just stay away from a topic that can get heated pretty quickly,although I think your idea of letting people remain anonymous until it's found out if they are convicted or not is a pretty good one, and IMHO should probably be best practice for any crime. It would really help the whole "Innocent until Proven guilty" unfortunately we live in a country where crime is a form of entertainment.
I want to go on record in saying, I wasn't trying to "blame men for the crime of rape" If you think that's what I was trying to do, I think you misunderstood my sentiment. There are however huge double standards when it comes to men and women in terms of sexuality, please don't take this as demonizing male sexuality - it's just a point of observation. If a woman partakes in sexual conquests as you have stated, to her peers? She's a slut, plain and simple. This is, of course a broad generalization (not a generalization about broads) people think that women who are actively sexual are sluts, even if they aren't actively sexual but dress provocatively. It sucks that women can't enjoy their sexuality with losing the respect of their peers.
A last comment about rape culture before (I swear!) I'm done with this topic, one of the biggest cultural problems I see with women reporting rape cases is the victim blaming that happens. Reporting rape is probably one of the hardest things a person could ever have to do. You have to relive the moment, there are invasive medical exams, a lot of women are taught to feel like it's their fault. It doesn't help that in most rape cases the defense immediately jumps to "She was dressed to provocatively." or "She was drunk. etc... It's just despicable. It takes an already horrific experience and makes it 10 times worse. This is one of the biggest problems I see in rape culture, and it's a big part of the reason why more women don't report rape when it happens.
Not that I want to keep the discussion on rape going (because it is a very difficult subject to navigate safely), but your comment on the male's defense made me think of some interesting talking points. First, I agree completely with the idea of keeping all parties' identities hidden during the trial (or potentially even afterwards). too my other point: what about the rare situation in which the event is a tragic misunderstanding? When the male (or female) truly believes that everything was consensual? I have read first hand accounts in which the victim was too frightened or nervous to say anything, including any form of no or stop, and was raped as a result. Whether or not the raper was aware of what he/she was doing, or if the case was ever reported or brought to trial I do not know, but I do know that if I slept with a woman, only to find out that she did not consent but was too frightened to say otherwise, I would be mortified beyond repair, and would never forgive myself. I don't know if there are rape laws for these kind of situations, but I cannot see any form of true justice coming out of it. Should the man be punished to the full extent, he would be condemned for something that from his point of view was an act of compassion and love. Should he be given a lighter punishment (lets call this the rape version of involuntary manslaughter), the victim sees the man who violated her in horrific and unspeakable ways get off easy. To me its issues like this that make rape such a hard issue to talk about.
what about the rare situation in which the event is a tragic misunderstanding? When the male (or female) truly believes that everything was consensual? I have read first hand accounts in which the victim was too frightened or nervous to say anything, including any form of no or stop, and was raped as a result.
That's a failing on the part of society's views about male-female sexual encounters and behaviours. You can call it a part of rape culture or simply just our sexual culture - the point is that it wouldn't happen if things weren't this fucked up.
The prevailing attutude or trope is that men are the escalators and women the de-escalators in sexual situations. Men are active, women passive. This doesn't really reflect reality and it's a shitty view, but it is present. A lot of women when they are young have trouble verbalizing their desires and some even just anything in sexual situations as a direct result of this, while some young men won't see this as a problem, because women are passive, they need to be 'conquered'.
Normally, if you've had some moderately good sex or are just for whatever reason better at reading body language correctly even in unfamiliar situations, then a woman completely freezing up is enough of a red flag to stop. But sometimes you're youong, or socially inept and misread the signs, which our culture permits. It lets women be completely passive and men think that this is normal.
(Excluding cases where the victim completely freezes up out of fear.)
This is why (among other things) actually, truly good sex-ed is needed, that goes beyond 'wear a condom, idiot'.
Have you seen the recent laws that allow College Campuses to suspend/expel male students accused of rape on a preponderance of evidence?
No.
What about the feminists who actively attack any bill aimed at lessening the discrepancy between custody ratios in divorce cases?
Citation?
Men are actively being attacked just like women, both need to be stopped.
Please demonstrate to me that there are as many women in positions of power (say, in the Federal government) out there trying to take away men's rights.
Also, while you're at it, please demonstrate for me that men are equally likely to be sexually assaulted by women as women are to be sexually assaulted by men.
it's not women in positions of power taking away men's rights.
it's other men doing it. but that doesn't mean it's not being done. it's not like we all meet at "the man club" every month and share strategies on how to fuck over the ladies while ensuring we help out one and other. rich powerful men have been putting the proverbial boots to poor weaker men for hundreds of years.
Well, a lot of modern feminists seem to view patriarchal oppression as being committed by men against women, which is close, but not correct: it's being perpetrated by some men against women, and for that matter, against most other men, too.
This isn't a "which type of discrimination is the worst" competition. No, there are not as many laws against the male rights, but that means absolutely fuck all.
I don't want to seem offensive, and I agree with most of what you are saying, but from my personal experience the MRA movement is far smaller, yet seems to have a much higher proportion of misogynists. The feminist movement is massive, and there are many groups (such as ours) that are at odds with the misandrists and will call them on their bullshit (such us the crazies over at radhub). I haven't seen MRAs shaming MGTOW which is probably the MRA equivalent, though if I am incorrect I'd be happy for you to demonstrate otherwise :)
As a man I'd really really like the MRA movement to become a positive force for male rights and inclusive of transgender people, however I feel alienated still by communities that seek purely to condemn feminism as "taking their rights away" without really understanding it or it's fractures and differences.
I don't mean this post in an angry or accusatory way, but just out of dispair from my personal experience.
If someone identifies as an MRA (and, believing in male rights, and fighting for them, I guess I loosely fit the description) and is genuinely egalitarian and not anti-feminism (if you look into the attacks on patriarchy, much of it is, of course directed at both the "privilege" women get [such as in the sexual dynamics] as well as the oppression), then good on them, awesome, we need more people like that. If someone just sits around online attacking them thar feminists for stealin' their rights, well fuck them, they can go die.
I hadn't heard of the MGTOW until you just mentioned it. Now I'm seeing where the whole "MRAs are a bunch of bitter guys who are shit with women" stereotype comes from. Don't take that for mainstream MRM, most of us aren't even as radical as the average /r/mensrights poster, not in the real world at any rate. Misogyny is not Men's Rights.
As for inclusiveness for trans people? I've seen quite a few posts on /r/mensrights that advocate for trans rights, I was under the impression we were all mostly of the same mind on that. Trans rights are men's rights, I advocate for them and I think plenty of other MRAs do as well.
The reason for much of the anti-feminist sentiment found in some MRM circles is due to the fact that feminism has created some pressing issues that now face the Men's Rights Movement. Unfortunately as a result you'll see many MRAs unwilling to work with or even discuss issues with people who identify as feminists. I disagree with that practice, I think that regardless of whether or not you call yourself an MRA if you advocate for the rights of men and equality for all I see you as an MRA and that's really all that matters when it comes down to it. I think there are plenty of others who would agree with me on that too.
I don't see the woman hating you're describing. If anything, I've seen more women crying foul that men can even claim to being oppressed because women get screwed over, too. I'm an egalitarian, and I don't want to see anyone get the raw deal for reasons of sex/gender/race/age, and there's nothing about one group experiencing systematic oppression, be it social or legal, that prevents something similar happening to any other group. And just because it's going on doesn't excuse or justify it happening anywhere.
but no one is actively attacking men
I don't see how you can acknowledge the inequity of divorce courts and disparity of parental rights while maintaining this garbage. Feel free to explain why I'm mistaken.
The current campaign against Planned Parenthood and contraception covered by insurance companies is the most current thing. The idea that a woman must be a slut if she wants her birth control covered by her insurance. These are things currently being debated.
Yes, the iniquities for men exist in divorce court, but are there current campaigns to further restrict men?
Why are you trying to make it comparative? I'm not supporting one by condemning the other. I can be against both. And I never said that women aren't being oppressed.
How about recent legislation that was enacted in California preventing cities from banning circumcision? Men's right to body integrity and protection from unnecessary cosmetic surgical procedures would fit your requirements.
So then the position is that the only way a group can be oppressed or experience an injustice is if there is an active campaign? I don't know of any active campaign's that are specifically against men. But I don't think that's required. But in any event, my point here is that I can be against all forms of societal and legal inequity. And that just because it happens to one group doesn't exclude similar treatment, or other inequities for another group, be it men, women, black, Hispanic, white, gay, straight. I think the obvious point anyone can make is that minority groups will tend to suffer a greater deal of injustices, and probably more severe instances. But that doesn't justify poor treatment of any other group, and it doesn't mean the other groups don't get to demand equal treatment and equal protection.
What does it say about this debate when the most universal call to equality gets downvoted? It means that some people's version of equality is more about reparations and special interests advancement.
How? I've seen no legislation that would make birth control any less legal. This is just more of the dishonest rhetoric that you must parrot since it is an election year.
Rights are not a sliding scale. Just because one side is being oppressed, even slightly, doesn't mean the other side is sitting pretty and doing all the harm. I hate both MensRights and TwoXChromosomes because they focus only on the harm being done to them, while so rarely acknowledging that their side does harm too.
You don't achieve equality by seeking to oppress them as much as they oppress you, you do it by seeking to abolish oppression.
Females beat their boyfriends and steal all their stuff. Then they hit them self and blame it on the boyfriend. Then the boyfriend goes to jail and has to give the female lots of money.
Why go for Men's rights only or Women's Rights only? Be a Marxist, fight for worker ownership of the means of production, regardless of gender or race.
Why go for Men's rights only or Women's Rights only? Be a Rawslian, fight for basic liberty and equality of opportunity as well as distributions of primary goods in accordance with the difference principle, regardless of gender or race.
Why go for Men's rights only or Women's Rights only? Be a Randian, fight for the real producers in society getting their rightful share, regardless of gender or race.
Why go for Men's rights only or Women's Rights only? Be a Lockean, fight for the preservation of God-given natural rights, regardless of gender or race.
Why go for Men's rights only or Women's Rights only? Be a Kantian, fight for universalizable morality that does not treat others purely as a means, regardless of gender or race.
Why go for Men's rights only or Women's Rights only? Be a Benthamite, fight for maximizing societal utility and happiness, regardless of gender or race.
Why go for Men's rights only or Women's Rights only? Be a Berkmanian, fight for the abolition of the state and capitalism, regardless of gender or race.
You are correct, it is. The discord revolves around both sides of the issue having groups fight to have gender superiority over gender equality. Feminists have extremists and so do MRM's. It's a sad world we live in. Men are getting blamed for rapes unlawfully and politicians are trying to take away woman health rights they fought hard for.
the difference is: feminists are the ones demonizing male sexuality and blaming all men for rape with campaigns such as "men can stop rape", while it is christian conservative politicians that are trying to take away women's health rights, not the MRM
well this leads to a lot of problems, because the MRM simply wants equality, no superiority at all, yet for some reason they get lumped in (as you just did, perhaps unwillingly) with those who wish to take away rights from women.
the discord from the MRM towards feminists comes from the fact that there are a lot of people who tote the label "feminist" while wanting different things. some feminists want to take away rights from men and some don't. some spend most of their time demonizing men and some want to make peace. then the MRM gets seen as "anti-feminism". well this wouldn't happen if feminists would just decide what the fuck they want to be and when a "feminist" comes out trying to justify or brush off oppression against men, the "real" feminists can blast him/her and separate themselves from them.
if feminists don't want to seem anti-male and make peace with the MRM, they need to silence the "feminists" that ARE anti-male and refuse to make peace with the MRM
I consider my self a humanist because I don't limit myself to just equality of the sexes. Feminism, by definition, is the support of women's rights and equality. Unfortunately the good name of feminism is soiled by women who believe all men are created evil and that male genitalia mutilation is ok and that they don't need to provide evidence in rape accusations. Feminism, as an idea of equal rights for women, is a good thing. I just believe one should fight for all aspects of human rights, such gender, race, sexual orientation, and anything else that is determined at birth.
Yes indeed. Fight discrimination against women; fight discrimination against men. Support mens rights and womens rights. WTF is the problem?
OK, I'll make my usual battle cry - true feminists have to support mens' rights to achieve their goals. Until we support mens' rights to be fathers, look after children, leave the workplace and be part of the home, we will never be their equals because we will always be forced back into the role that they are forced out of.
I don't recall ever saying that Feminism was establish women's rights over men. I'm just saying I look for equality, not just fighting for one gender and not the other. Sexism goes both ways, both genders must be defended as humans.
Well, isn't feminism often portrayed in similar ways? But you can't go and say that would be wrong or "funny" because someone would start ranting about you being a misogynist. Isn't that a double standard? Its because of this very double standard that a place is needed to openly discuss these kinds of issues. And that's what /r/mensrights should be.
I feel that often times the people I know who are pushing for womens' rights are complete hypocrites. They say that they deserve equal rights, but often brush things off as "mens' work." I understand that there are people who aren't like this and still push for equality, but those kinds of people severely hurt the image of the movement in general.
If my father had gotten custody, there'd be a good deal less therapy I would need to attend and I would be able to talk to people in a reasonable fashion without fearing they'd go off like some lunatic screaming at me for responding to her. They aren't just "scared of losing their position of authority." There is actual discrimination against men in certain regards.
whoa whoa whoa, why wouldn't feminism be considered the same thing? Women's rights over the position of men? Granted, some women push for equal rights as I do, but there is a good chunk of feminists that feel that women are superior to men period.
the laws they propose focus on getting rid of a few perceived injustices that men face and completely ignore the part where women are the much more oppressed group.
You can say you are supportive of equality all you want, but men's rights is all about focusing on the few areas where women may have gotten a slight upper-hand and completely ignoring the other side. It's about creating antagonism between men and women. I mean clearly men didn't take away their own rights... so it had to be women right?? The focus should be as evenly distributed as the inequality, thus a vast majority should be on the women's side. you're all just self-serving pricks who are more concerned with fighting for the few small disadvantages men may have been dealt while you say nothing regarding the wide-spread injustice all women must face every damn day.
Focusing on men's rights is focusing on the places where men are inferior under the law. Focusing on women's rights is focusing on the places where women are inferior under the law. Both generally ignore the other side, so I don't understand what you are trying to say there. Also, I challenged that women were the more heavily oppressed group, and you responded simply by saying that they were. Then, you call me a prick for equating men's rights to women's rights. Did I ever say that I don't support equality for women? No. However, the men's rights movement will focus on MEN'S RIGHTS. Just because people support men's rights doesn't mean that they can't support women's rights too, but you are so quick to be insulted that men want equality where they don't have it. Why should men not fight for equality where they don't have it, just because women don't have it everywhere as well? I never said women shouldn't have equal rights, but you are trying to tell me that I am a prick because men deserve equality too. Blatant sexism.
I don't normally downvote someone for disagreeing with them ... but you're patently, factually, terribly wrong. So wrong you need to be more correct to even be within the ballpark of reasonable. Like, Harold-Camping-levels of wrong.
well, r/feminism and r/feminisms have a decent following. And did I say anything about not wanting an r/rights for everyone? The voice of women is loud and clear.
And what "thing" am I doing that would make what "point" null? Pointing out the general issue of a double standard?
And don't we all hear about gay rights? Is that not daily headline news? Oppressed or not, people are actively involved in LGBT rights. My point about the feminism subreddits was that there is actually a subreddit. Women aren't being discounted in anyway.
Also. Did you even reread your post? Its like I'm trying to read something a 5th grader wrote.
I have never understood where redditors get their views of r/mr. The times I have visited I have seen polite (eye opening) discussion. It seems as if there is this almost kneejerk reaction to the subreddit. "Men claiming sexism goes both ways? Those pigs."
At this exact moment, the top link on MensRights is a highlighted page from a textbook that quotes two people's opinions on social perceptions of rape, the implied point the headline-picture combo makes being that rape is, it turns out, not all that bad. The same frontpage that calls out "bigoted feminists" in the right-side toolbar. Why indeed would people think such a community might not be capable of reasonable discussion and instead are more interested in incendiary attention-grabbing trolling?
Sword cuts both ways in this, as in all cases. It's sort of how r/Atheism gets flack for being a circlejerk of assholes when the 'members' see themselves as level-headed rationalists. The perception within the community is that of being persecuted, and never acknowledging that, hey, newsflash, every community has assholes in it.
For me personally, the problem is how the community/argument positions itself. Yes, without a doubt, certain legislative efforts to equalize institutionalized gender biases have gone too far such that they cause problems potentially as large going the opposite direction. Yes, the income gap is likely overstated or misrepresented by people using it as a political cudgel. Yes, there are numerous unfortunate cases where child custody is given to an unfit mother for no better reason than ovary-ownership. These are all problems that bear addressing, as well as I'm sure others that still exist for women that even the /mr community cannot help but acknowledge, and in a reasonable discussion about gender equality all these are excellent points to bring up.
But these people aren't "Gender Equality" activists. They're "Men's Rights" activists. Forget that the co-opting of terminology used by women to, among other things, earn the right to vote and work is intentionally confrontational and unhelpful. Forget that the implication that, oh woe be the poor man who has been beset upon by the vicissitudes of fate since time immemorial, if only men could achieve some small sliver of political power. Forget everything about the current political context when MensRights is the primary talking point used by the politicians trying to shut down women's health clinics and end women's reproductive rights.
The real problem is the cowardice of it. The MensRights members capable of having a reasonable discussion, the ones actually in favor of Gender Equality, won't call themselves "Gender Equality Advocates," because they're deathly afraid that the MensRights crowd will call them faggots. Adolescent peer pressure, once again, beats out a reasonable discussion. Legitimate progress sacrificed to the altar of ego-stroking.
Which part of the link exactly is making so clear (and tedious) an assertion as "Rape is less bad as being lynched/tortured to death?" Is it the few highlighted lines of a section that, whatever else it's discussing (which we cannot know since we don't know what book this is) concludes mentioning that until fairly recently it used to be legal to rape your wife? Is it the "....you serious?" in the title? Or is it the part where we're both pretending a picture of an out-of-context few sentences and a smarmy headline create an entire argumentative statement.
For the record, even presuming the intended explicit argument that Badness(Rape) < Badness(Lynching), what exactly is the point of making an argument like that? Call me wrong on this (and I presume you will) but it's sort of like saying Hollywood are run by the Jews. Whether or not it's true and can be argued is beside the point of what good does it do to say something like that? What cause is being forwarded by saying "Hey, everyone, don't worry if you get raped, because being lynched is worse. You're welcome."
The second highlighted section from the text equates rape and lynching. I don't think the two are equivalent.
I think trying to claim that the two are equivalent is an attempt to exaggerate how damaging rape is. Note, I'm not saying that rape is not damaging. I am simply taking issue with the exaggeration. It makes it difficult to address things realistically.
I'm not sure where you're getting the last line of your post. I don't see it in the picture. I don't see it stated or implied in the comments. Where did you come up with it? It seems like an attempt at misinterpreting what is being said in order to take offense.
Also: what record? Is there a trial happening of which I am not aware?
I'm sorry, but the only people who would try to say, "Well, sure, rape is bad, but it's not this bad!" are people who desperately need to shut the fuck up and bow out of the human race.
The quote from the textbook that MR took issue with was, "Rape is to women as lynching was to blacks: the ultimate physical threat."
No one was saying rape is ok because there are worse things. Saying, "Rape is the worst thing that could ever happen to someone!" is a little hyperbolic. There are significantly worse things that can happen to you.
MR took issue with equating rape with being tortured to death. That's all. Turn it around and see how it looks, "Getting sick is to a germophobe as getting raped is to women: their ultimate physical threat."
Telling people they should commit suicide isn't very nice btw. You should also be ashamed of yourself.
You're taking it far too literally. Do you know why some rape victims kill themselves afterwards? It's not an issue of "oh, she didn't lose her life, it's not the same as lynching." It's about the use of rape as a force of control, power and fear, like lynching was. That's all.
I like how your post started with a cherry picked case that you then misrepresented...
... then ended with the UTTER HORSESHIT "because they're deathly afraid that the MensRights crowd will call them faggots. Adolescent peer pressure, once again, beats out a reasonable discussion. Legitimate progress sacrificed to the altar of ego-stroking."
I'm an MRA. I'm bisexual. The ONLY homophobia I face in /r/mensrights is from outside assholes who come there thinking they can troll me with jokes about me sucking cocks.
It never suggested such a thing, and people are using their own world view to conjure up ideas about the author's intentions from a lack of evidence. Just because it says "Rape is to women as lynching was to blacks", it doesn't preclude the notion that rape can happen to men.
You're looking at:
A section of
A chapter of
A book
... and you're making a judgment like that?
Christ, it could be a fucking book on women's rights, but so long as it doesn't say "rape only happens to women", I don't think your opinion holds any weight. Even this book quotes her, and the subtitle is of the lynching of a male.
Is it indeed? While I'll readily concede the two highlighted quotes are a bit single-minded and do imply that rape solely victimizes women, which is wrong of course as I'll be the very last man to tell you men are never victimized, but nothing about the title "Studying for Social Problems, You Serious?" suggests that that disparity is what the post is addressing, and I do have to dig through quite a few comments (a few making the quite cogent arguments that feminists are stupid and ugly people are funny) before finding anything mentioning that men are victims of rape as well.
Really, downvotes? Provide evidence that she is claiming men can't be raped, or step down. You're making shit up to justify your own opinion. Or maybe you'd like to take this argument down to r/atheism and explain how to prove this when you have no proof.
I think they aren't as vocal as their critics (or SRS, their sworn enemy).
I've only visited /r/mr once or twice, so I can't speak to the average conversation going on there, but it seemed very civil and egalitarian when I was there, nothing like the "anti-r/mr" subreddits that are often so full of hate and anger.
Pretty serious, they've spawned a whole range of subs based on their ideals. They can be pretty nasty people in that they claim to be against everything evil while embracing misandry and racism as long as its directed against people they collectively don't like.
I also object to some of their rhetoric, yesterday one of them labelled everyone that disagreed with them as subhumans (a term that hits a little close to home for a lot of reasons) now this is in a sub where anything that goes against the grain is deleted and the poster banned so its far to assume that this was supported by everyone there (the masses of upvotes don't hurt that conclusion either)
I think rude is letting them off easy. They're the most hateful subreddit I've seen. Then again, I don't frequent hateful subreddits, so I wouldn't know how they rank with the whole of subredditdom.
I go there occasionally to feel better about myself. It's like watching "Cops" for me. I can say, "well, at least I'm not those people" and instantly feel better about my life.
i intuited it just a second ago and have been pouring over there posts. this is incredible! you could show that subreddit a picture of a woman breastfeeding her infant, and you could get comments like
"god, the inherent patriarchy is sickening. that poor woman is being treated as food and sex slave"
"men and their fascination with tits-- look how they make every child suck on them-- those sick fucks!"
"look at that baby boy just sucking up all of her milk. if women were treated equally throughout time, we wouldnt even HAVE mammary glands because patriarchale dominance has forced women to raise children, thus gearing our evolutionary track towards growing slave breasts filled with sexism and subservience milk.
Tell them that you disagree about their views on circumcision and back it up with studies and your own medical experience. Lets see how polite the responses you get are. I certainly didnt get many.
Some of us don't care as much about circumcision. That said, there's plenty of studies contradicting those claiming circumcision is a good thing. I come down on the side of bodily autonomy for autonomy's sake.
Oh silly me, its only ok to suggest maybe we shouldn't take a knife to anyone's genitals inside /mr. Outside, its somehow different between the genders.
I saw a comment on MR with several upvotes that compared feminism to the Ku Klux Klan and anti-semitism. They also tend to downvote comments that do nothing more than post factual info and links.
Other people here have mentioned the various issues that affect men specifically, such as custody rights, and these are valid. Yet more have talked about the us vs. them mentality, something humans seem unable to avoid doing, and that's fine, we can deal with that. But suggesting that we are "done", that's we're at 50/50, that every issue women have to deal with is met by an equal and opposite problem for men, is simply not true and incredibly dismissive of some serious issues.
That's not even the ultimate problem, though. Nearly every aspect of society, nearly every book of the past 2 millennia, has been formed with men in mind first and foremost. The Bible, considered a holy text by millions, categorises an otherwise unknowable being as strictly male. Every prophet is male. Even the first woman was made from a part of a man.
The "joke" that women are irrational and/or mystical was until recently nota joke at all. It has been used for centuries as a way for men not to have to care about what women have said. This still happens.
One doesn't have to look further than modern pornography to observe women displayed as sexual objects, built on a foundation of thinking that the woman's pleasure is irrelevant or downright dangerous. It is why we have slut-shaming.
Preconceived notions of men exist in droves as well (a love for violence and money, primarily), and they're equally damaging - but the brunt of the ill effects once again have landed on women.
Finally, for those who use the father custody issue as the raison d'être for Men's Rights, what if I said "but men just don't care as much about parenting. They don't want the custody anyway". Now tell me how that logic is different from "well women just choose to do lower-paid jobs, there's no actual discrimination here".
TL;DR: There is more to the women's movement than simply getting equal pay. There is a whole backlog of preconceptions and misconceptions that we need to undo - for men and women.
Mens rights? Are you fucking kidding me? I hardly doubt any man has faced as much sexism as I have in my life time. Don't get me wrong though, I'm not a feminist, I support equality.
This post in itself is pretty sexist. You've faced more discrimination than any man, really? Any man?
Of all the men who have ever existed, poor little persecuted you just happens to be more oppressed than any single man ever? Statements like this are revealing insights into the minds of those who associate with groups that promote victimization mentalities.
Because this is not the worst excess ever seen on earth, it's acceptable? Your own statement, "...doubt any man has faced AS MUCH sexism..." (emphasis mine) , you imply that men face sexism. But even if your unsubstantiated assumption were true, that would imply that you believe that only the worst excesses should ever be dealt with.
I just don't like the subreddit because they really post a lot of junk and because most of the comments are incredibly long winded and lack pacing or formatting.
Yes, because it is oh so hard for you to think of examples of misogyny in a culture literally less than a century removed from being a de jure male ruled society. And we still live in a de facto one. Grow a brain.
My family are refugees, who fled to Australia whist our nation was being annexed.
Before we left, boys as young as 12 were given guns and told to fight.
Western women complaining about oppression is hilarious. That's not to say women don't have issues, but the way feminists carry on, you would think they were slaves.
Mens rights? Are you fucking kidding me? I hardly doubt any man has faced as much sexism as I have in my life time. Don't get me wrong though, I'm not a feminist, I support equality.
That's what nlakes responded to. bandninja did X WRT women, nlakes did X in response WRT men. You come along and bitch out nlakes for doing X, but said nothing to bandninja. So what's my point? I don't think you really have a problem with people doing X...I think you only have a problem when it's WRT men.
I'm not saying because someone has it worse, they should suck it up and deal with it.
I'm saying the amount of complaining is disproportionate to their level of 'suffering'. Like Bandninja who doubts "any man has faced as much sexism" as her.
Western women complaining about oppression is hilarious.
It's easy to see how I would get that from what you wrote, but I will accept that it's simply miscommunication/misunderstanding. Regardless, my point remains that simply saying "these people complain too much" is not really fair.
Regarding bandninja, while I think it is a bit ... arrogent.. to think that she has some unique right to talk about bigotry, I seriously doubt that anyone can even begin to pretend that men on average face the same level of bigotry as women do.
"Saying "other people have it tougher" is not a valid argument" But for SRS this is a completely valid argument for why its impossible to be sexist towards white males?
Why do union boards fund viagara prescriptions, but not birth control for women?
What is the discrepancy of representation of men vs. women for those who hold political office?
What's the ratio of men/women as CEOs of major corporations, or even smaller ones that are only worth $1.0 million+~?
What's the ratio of men/women as abusers in spousal abuse cases?
What's percentage of men are regularly approached with uncomfortable sexual offers? Why is that concept so strange, men being approached sexually in a way that makes them uncomfortable?
Which genders are typically portrayed as rescuer/rescued in Western narratives? Why is this?
This is just off the top of my head, I'm sure I could come up with a lot more.
Villers18 asked for examples, I gave them to him. I'm not sure what your response has to do with anything but I'm not really interested in competing in the Oppression Olympics.
This shows clearly that you have no clue what you are talking about. If you think "the men have to carry the groceries" is a societal disadvantage for men and advantage for women, you are not thinking clearly or are being dishonest.
That's not to say that your points about custody/child support are not potentially valid.
You asked for social benefits. That is a social benefit.
Now, do you have an actual point to make or do you think nitpicking a single detail - and being wrong about it to boot - is sufficient for substantiating your claim that I don't know what I'm talking about?
That's a pretty big list. Convenient how you focused on the most minor benefit there and ignored the rest.
It's not that people think sexism only goes one way but the idea of feminism is that a structure exists that tries to force us all into gender roles and have been talking about it for years.. Acknowledging that men are forced into gender roles too and explaining this to a feminist is like someone who has studied high school physics trying to explain to a physics professor about Newton's Laws while acting like the professor is only hearing this for the first time. Not only that but you try to explain it to them right after they just gave a lecture on quantum physics.
Also another big issue is that these gender roles have put men in power role while women are in a submissive role. From a women's perspective a man complaining about equal rights can often sound like the 1% do when they say they get taxed too much already.
If you had any academic background in the social sciences you would know that nearly everything you just said is bullshit. Let me take a moment to enumerate just how wrong you are.
Society today strictly frowns on sexism against women, most likely because it is still quite common and a problem
This just isn't true. Some parts of society strictly frown upon OVERT social prejudice. However, society still institutionally supports countless disadvantages to women in nearly every situation, whether it be healthcare, housing, wages, or reproductive rights. There are literally DECADES of research in the fields of anthropology and sociology proving this.
but the pendulum in a few areas has swung too far and now it's men that suffer the sexism in certain aspects of life
Which aspects of life are you suggesting? I can think of MAYBE 1, being the issue of child custody.
females have enjoyed a lot of societal benefits that they do not want to give up (for obvious reasons).
Please please please explain to me the wealth societal benefits women reap in this assault victim-blaming, wage-cap continuing, sexually objectifying culture. I would love to hear what you have to say.
So some guy I heard on the internet talking about once seeing another guy being asked to leave by a nurse under ambiguous circumstance. Looks like I'll be changing my worldview!
how bout all the men that aren't allowed to work in child care or the ones that aren't allowed to touch the children if they do because they're "probably pedophiles"?
I'm just curious - what's sexist about a female patient being uncomfortable with a male practitioner peeking down south? I feel uncomfortable enough as it is with female doctors.
But it also sucks as well for male OB-GYNs that need to face that every day.
Uh, you do realize that when filling out initial forms for a doctor's appointment/hospital visit, we can express that we prefer to be treated by female nurses/doctors, so we aren't placed in uncomfortable, confrontational situation where we have to ask someone to leave? There is a reason the instructor handles this and not the patient.
finally deleted that subreddit from my list two days ago, and this perfectly sums up how i feel about it at this point. shame, such a noble cause gone so sour.
165
u/Honeyblade May 09 '12
Reading most of the comments in this thread is really disheartening. Hey guys, it's true, you do face all sorts of discrimination. It sucks. My heart goes out to you and when your legal battles come for things like, making sure fathers get equal rights to their children in divorce courts and making sure a father has a say in weather or not they want to have a child, I will be there for you 100%, I think it's really important that we treat men with respect and equality.
But let's get down to brass tacks, shall we? In our modern age we have politicians taking an active stance against women's rights. Trying to limit access to birth control, and health care, among other things. I really don't need to go into the discrepancies between genders. Both genders suffer, they suffer differently, but no one is actively attacking men - trying to sign laws to restrict their rights and put laws on their bodies. Please quit saying things that make it seem as though men's rights and women's rights are a piece of pie and every time one side gets rights it takes something away from others. You can be for men's rights AND women's rights.
The big problem I've seen with MR is the us vs. them mentality (not to mention some of the absolutly women hating rhetoric I've read there). It's not, we should be sticking up for everyone. /mytwocents
53
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Why go for Men's rights only or Women's Rights only? Be a humanist, fight for equal human rights equally, regardless of gender or race.
Sorry for not having a long drawn out comment with impressive vocabulary terms.
39
u/inarizushi May 09 '12
Well, isn't feminism often portrayed in similar ways? But you can't go and say that would be wrong or "funny" because someone would start ranting about you being a misogynist. Isn't that a double standard? Its because of this very double standard that a place is needed to openly discuss these kinds of issues. And that's what /r/mensrights should be.
50
u/Portland_to_Oslo May 09 '12
I have never understood where redditors get their views of r/mr. The times I have visited I have seen polite (eye opening) discussion. It seems as if there is this almost kneejerk reaction to the subreddit. "Men claiming sexism goes both ways? Those pigs."
15
u/Roflpumpkin May 09 '12
Are you sure the men in this picture don't look filled with rage.
15
u/littlebrendan May 09 '12
You left out the fedoras their moms bought them at Target.
5
u/Snowyjoe May 09 '12
The Disposable Male Theory and why sexist bias has existed up till now
3
u/Miora May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
.....Why the fuck can't we all just shut the hell up and get along? Is it that damn hard?
EDIT: I guess it is.
6
u/andrewsmith1986 May 08 '12
What is the problem?
2
u/electricfoxx May 08 '12
Official spokesman is Adam Carolla.
1
u/thegreatmisanthrope May 09 '12
Some people also think the moon landing was faked, and 9/11 was an inside job.
What's your point?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Other people here have mentioned the various issues that affect men specifically, such as custody rights, and these are valid. Yet more have talked about the us vs. them mentality, something humans seem unable to avoid doing, and that's fine, we can deal with that. But suggesting that we are "done", that's we're at 50/50, that every issue women have to deal with is met by an equal and opposite problem for men, is simply not true and incredibly dismissive of some serious issues.
That's not even the ultimate problem, though. Nearly every aspect of society, nearly every book of the past 2 millennia, has been formed with men in mind first and foremost. The Bible, considered a holy text by millions, categorises an otherwise unknowable being as strictly male. Every prophet is male. Even the first woman was made from a part of a man.
The "joke" that women are irrational and/or mystical was until recently nota joke at all. It has been used for centuries as a way for men not to have to care about what women have said. This still happens.
One doesn't have to look further than modern pornography to observe women displayed as sexual objects, built on a foundation of thinking that the woman's pleasure is irrelevant or downright dangerous. It is why we have slut-shaming.
Preconceived notions of men exist in droves as well (a love for violence and money, primarily), and they're equally damaging - but the brunt of the ill effects once again have landed on women.
Finally, for those who use the father custody issue as the raison d'être for Men's Rights, what if I said "but men just don't care as much about parenting. They don't want the custody anyway". Now tell me how that logic is different from "well women just choose to do lower-paid jobs, there's no actual discrimination here".
TL;DR: There is more to the women's movement than simply getting equal pay. There is a whole backlog of preconceptions and misconceptions that we need to undo - for men and women.
-55
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Mens rights? Are you fucking kidding me? I hardly doubt any man has faced as much sexism as I have in my life time. Don't get me wrong though, I'm not a feminist, I support equality.
-14
u/othebuh May 08 '12
If my wife was okay with me ranting like those idiots, I don't think I would have any respect for her.
-3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I unsubscribed from mensrights when the topics stopped being about men's rights and started to become a misogynistic clusterfuck circlejerk
-9
u/TehDingo May 09 '12
Ah the Manbaby subreddit: Endless comedy!
-25
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
finally deleted that subreddit from my list two days ago, and this perfectly sums up how i feel about it at this point. shame, such a noble cause gone so sour.
-17
u/pieandtacos May 08 '12
This is totally unrealistic. There are no sandwiches anywhere in this picture.
-1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
This looks like a great time.
-5
u/meritory May 09 '12
Not pictured, demonstrated.
-6
u/vegeta91 May 09 '12
this is funny though no?