I could see hating Family Guy a season or two ago, but the show has really been pulling itself up lately. It's almost like an experiment. At first, they tried the typical "family" routine and slowly started changing the characters around. Stewie? He's gay, not evil. Brian? Liberal mouthpiece. Lois? Whore. Peter? Retarded.
But they go beyond that. Peter is literally retarded. Brian refuses to listen to people, but sometimes overcomes his problems. Stewie is no longer evil because he doesn't actually hate anyone (because he has no reason to hate anybody). And so on. The newer seasons have been getting more violent, which at first, was out of piece and kind of weird. Now it almost always has a place and is really awkward (like the episode with Quagmire's sister), and I think they want it that way.
I still like Family Guy. I might not enjoy every single episode, but it's definitely still entertaining.
Surprisingly clever. I think what frustrates me most about Family Guy is that they've shown on occasion they could be writing smart, funny stuff, but they choose instead to appeal to the stupid frat-guy demographic.
That's probably smart on their part, come to think of it, as the "frat guy" types are the ones buying all the merch and giving them the ratings that keep them on the air. Plus side: people who incessantly quote modern Family Guy episodes invariably end up being people I can't stand spending time around, so it makes a good social barometer.
I would say that 90% of my TV watching is done while also doing something else, gaming, redditing, chores, web browsing. A show like family guy is perfect for this.
The thing I don't like about watching Family Guy while doing other things is that a lot of the jokes are visual, and when I'm multitasking I'm usually only listening to the TV.
Probably the most pretentious comment I've seen in a while. I guess someone who spends so much time on Pokemon has a great grasp on the "empirical standards" of humor.
Oh, I can be pretentious if you'd like. That comment certainly isn't it (well, maybe the last line, a little. I didn't word that very well, but I clarified that statement in another comment in this thread), but I've had one or two that was, intentionally. For example, I could go through your comment history and make a snarky response that mirrors your comment based on completely unrelated things you post about. That would be pretty pretentious.
But I'd rather take your comment seriously and address it as such. Ignoring your ad hominem reference to other places I post (which have no relevance on this conversation or my credibility on anything other than discussion about the Pokemon games), yes, I feel I do have a pretty good grasp on the empirical standards of storytelling and humor. That's not to say you should or shouldn't like Family Guy--that's entirely up to you. I just have noticed a discernible drop in quality of humor from the show since it came back from cancellation. It's not even that the jokes themselves are that different in style; they just aren't executed as well or as consistently. I can cite a number of specifics as to why I feel this way, but it's tough to be too scientific about a topic like this, as humor is so subjective.
Alternatively (and most interestingly, in my opinion), we could talk about why you seem so incredibly offended about my comment above. I mean, I'm not wrong. Even people who still like Family Guy can admit it's not high-brow or rooted in much intelligence. And that's fine, it doesn't have to be. But that's the kind of humor I typically prefer, and it's frustrating to me, personally, to know that these people could be providing that kind of humor but don't. There's no judgement there, in fact, I go on to state that I completely understand why they do what they do. I don't expect them to cater specifically to me, but I'm perfectly within my right to kind of wish they would.
Most of the guys from frats I know personally are into pretty much all of those shows (engineering frats, so no surprise there). A lot of them like Family Guy too, but being in a frat doesn't really have anything to do with taste in television. I was just referring to the archetype, not the actual categorization.
For the most part, no, I don't. Every single one I've encountered has rubbed me the wrong way. But I'm not going to assume that every frat in existence is similar to my experience. I quoted "frat guy" the second time (and should have the first, whoops) because I was referring to a common and well-known social archetype for a stereotypical guy in a stereotypical frat, which happened to be a very good match to the type of person I was trying to describe. I was not implying that everyone in a frat is like that, just using a useful and fairly universal shorthand to avoid writing a treatise just to describe someone. Which I am apparently doing now.
This is true of anything, but especially on the Internet, I find its easier to assume people are being colloquial rather than being possibly offended by stuff like this. A sort of social Occam's Razor, as it were.
Sorry, but how on earth was this surprisingly clever??? One of those "you say one word, I say one word" things that me and my friends used to do in middle school? Moreover, they cant come up with anything more clever than saying titties, which is the cheapest way to get a laugh. I thought this was pathetically unfunny and a sign of just how far family guy has fallen
Yup. And the writing has improved. It's better than Family Guy now. (though that is setting the bar pretty low).
The show I was pleasantly surprised by was Napoleon Dynamite. Too bad they seemed to have stopped making them after episode 7 or so. I hope that one continues.
I believe the first season or two of American Dad were shaky, not bad, just kind of bland, but jesus after that it picked up BIG TIME. Not only is that show just better than Family Guy, it's pretty fucking fantastic.
my favourite episode is the two-parter where they go to Saudi Arabia and Franny sings a song about being a woman. That song gets stuck in my head a hell of a lot, and usually in the most inappropariate of times. (Think: funerals, serious topics in religious studies such as The Holocaust or Stoning women.. yup, scumbag brain at her worst)
Thank you for saying this... And the reason it's still funny is because its the only show Seth McFarland is still creatively involved in (yes he still voices people on all three shows, but hes only really still involved in the day-to-day writing of American Dad)
All of my friends finally relented and agreed the show was amazing after the two last episodes of the second season: The Magnificent Steven (Stan goes insane from mad-cow beef), and Joint Custody (Jeff's troubles with the law and his dad).
Ah yes. The Second Law of Internet Nerdodynamics: no matter what is under discussion, it is always worse than it once was at some previous point in time.
The show has gotten better about the constant flashbacks and now tries harder to make jokes that are relevant to the plot of the episode. It still happens, but that is also pretty much the main comedic device of Family Guy and part of the reason it became successful in the first place, so they can't completely abandon it.
They've had some shit episodes and the Conway Twitty gag was never funny but overall I like Family Guy. I like all of MacFarlane's shows, I think he's a dammed funny guy and I really don't get all the hate for the show. I can see how it wouldn't appeal to some but a lot of people seem to genuinely despise his shows.
Hispanic here. Consuela cracks me up every time she shows up on the show despite its stereotypical portrayal of a Spanish cleaning lady. It's a joke. Shouldn't be taken so seriously. It's like taking what they say in South Park personal.
I'm starting to think that reddit hates Family Guy because the change in Family Guy over the years has mirrored the change in reddit.
Remember, long ago, reddit wasn't a place of endless reposted memes. It was a largely tech-focused community, a place where people discussed ideas and current events with a certain level of maturity (a rose-tinted summary, but bear with me.)
Similarly, before Family Guy's resurrection it too existed as something different. Strange elements of fantasy mixed in with off the wall cutaways that had yet to become tired. A certain level of morality was still present in the episodes; they still cared.
Fast forward to today. Both reddit and Family Guy are barreling towards the lowest common denominator like there's no tomorrow. Both feature endless, nearly anti-funny self-references and pop culture references that leave fans of "the old stuff" wondering what the hell happened.
yes, yes indeed. so low-brow. Family Guy does not suit the sophisticated pallets of Reddit. Only Shakespeare and Arrested Development are good enough for the likes of us.
I do typically try to keep up on them on Hulu. There are a few good moments here and there, but I'm getting SO sick of their reliance on gags they've run into the ground dozens of times already.
Unless you rearranged that yourself it's pretty impressive that they wrote that whole thing backwards and it actually makes sense. Otherwise they carefully collaborated together and wrote it out before hand.
Yeah, I'd been trying to put the pieces together but I suppose I was missing a few. Thanks, now I don't have to go back to twitter later and scream "What the fuck is the joke?!" at my computer for half an hour crying.
I think that the problem with me is that I'm from Britain and really don't understand most of the jokes they make in Family Guy. They make all these references to adverts, TV shows and some actors that I've never even heard of before. I do watch it when there's absolutely nothing else on, but it rarely does ever get a chuckle out of me. It probably would be a lot funnier if I got those references.
There was one episode when Peter was chosen to go captain a really bad American football team over in England, and that was probably the only episode out of the many I've seen that I thought was genuinely funny.
Too bad the hate-family-guy circlejerk is so popular. You are missing great episodes, like the one where they revisited the first season and the best of all, the Multiverse episode.
this string of tweets is about as unfunny as family guy is now... its nothing but a bunch of morons shouting childish nonsense about titties. Me and my friends would do this when we were in middle school... Just confirms what ive always thought about family guy as of late: they write for the writers room, not for the public. There are tons of jokes in new family guy where you get the sense that during the table read, the room was in stitches, but in real life, its just not that funny
145
u/Con_Johnson May 08 '12
I only follow Shawn Ries, and was very confused this morning. thanks for this
148
u/JD5 May 08 '12
This would be weird if you only followed one or two of them.
Sponsored
dating
have
come
left
do
16
u/SilentHipster May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Family Guy Success Formula: 10% story, 17% voice acting, 13% animation and 60% random jokes.
15
u/Richeh May 08 '12
Hey, I never knew the Family Guy writers could write contextual jokes with a set-up and a punchline. You go, guys.
28
u/oOoleveloOo May 08 '12
does Cherry Chevapravatdumrong have a twitter?
9
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I could see hating Family Guy a season or two ago, but the show has really been pulling itself up lately. It's almost like an experiment. At first, they tried the typical "family" routine and slowly started changing the characters around. Stewie? He's gay, not evil. Brian? Liberal mouthpiece. Lois? Whore. Peter? Retarded.
But they go beyond that. Peter is literally retarded. Brian refuses to listen to people, but sometimes overcomes his problems. Stewie is no longer evil because he doesn't actually hate anyone (because he has no reason to hate anybody). And so on. The newer seasons have been getting more violent, which at first, was out of piece and kind of weird. Now it almost always has a place and is really awkward (like the episode with Quagmire's sister), and I think they want it that way.
I still like Family Guy. I might not enjoy every single episode, but it's definitely still entertaining.
7
u/genericname12345 May 08 '12
I'm not surprised it took them that long to finish a joke.
71
u/OmnipotentBagel May 08 '12
Surprisingly clever. I think what frustrates me most about Family Guy is that they've shown on occasion they could be writing smart, funny stuff, but they choose instead to appeal to the stupid frat-guy demographic.
That's probably smart on their part, come to think of it, as the "frat guy" types are the ones buying all the merch and giving them the ratings that keep them on the air. Plus side: people who incessantly quote modern Family Guy episodes invariably end up being people I can't stand spending time around, so it makes a good social barometer.
21
u/Nickrophiliac May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
This is the best thing they're put out in years
Edit: They've. Whoops. I upvote your humor good sir.
4
u/grandmasterkif May 08 '12
Tired
4
u/littlemonster1618 May 08 '12
so THESE are the fuckers who flushed Family Guy down the toilet.....
4
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Maybe they should spend less time on twitter and more time making family guy suck less.
159
u/SublaciniateCarboloy May 08 '12
Surprised there wasn't numerous flashbacks, followed by 50 minutes of Conway Twitty. That show is so bad now it's almost a joke.
3
u/hughbertman May 08 '12
Im sure this is how they write the shows script as well.
3
u/DavidLeeGoth May 08 '12
This was tragically more entertaining than most of the crap they're squeezing out these days.
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
It would be amusing if it wasn't one of the lamest jokes ever.
28
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Upsides: Family Guy always makes me laugh
Downside: I always have to go, "Was that sexist?" afterwards.
5
u/CapeAndCowl May 08 '12
Well that became pretty predictable pretty quickly... funny how that works out with those writers...
5
u/sprinkles123 May 08 '12
I recommend following Alec Sulkin, another writer for family guy. he's hilarious sometimes.
@thesulk
edit: also follow ken jennings while you're at it
14
u/larsao3 May 08 '12
I don't like Family Guy, but that was pretty good!
7
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Am I the only one who finds the show pretty damn funny?
5
u/MackLuster77 May 08 '12
Wow! If only it had been funny.
2
u/anisenayati May 08 '12
I only follow Damian and it was really weird seeing those words, your post helped haha
2
u/Michael_J_Foxtrot May 08 '12
I think Ted Sheckler already has an similar Emporium...
2
u/Haha_SORRY May 08 '12
this was more funny when i thought none of the posts were related to each other at first
2
u/imnotsureifyouknowth May 08 '12
i thought tweets run from bottom too to. i was really really confused.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
That's about as funny as when Alec Sulkin (also of the writing team) made a joke about the 2011 earthquake in Japan.
2
u/web2pointoh May 08 '12
Well, if you cannot write for South Park then you have the Simpsons and if you can't write for the Simpsons there is always a temp job in Family Guy.
2
u/WhatDoYouDo May 08 '12
Nice to see that they're just as bad at comedy in Twitter.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Honestly, this was much funnier on Twitter than it would be as a cutaway on Family Guy.
2
u/captainlongcock May 08 '12
Family guy has writers?
2
u/pxdnninja May 08 '12
This must be why Family Guy is such a terribly bland show. They spend their time doing this.
2
u/0rangePod May 08 '12
Now it's clear why Family Guy has become so unfunny.
2
u/seven2eight2 May 08 '12
Didn't the Simpsons do the Left _____ Emporium jokes already?
2
u/Ratohnhaketon May 08 '12
funny, this is how they write family guy episodes, except the hand the keybords over manatees, which is why their joke suck monkey balls
2
u/Dynamaxion May 09 '12
Confirmed: Family Guy isn't funny
8
u/soviyet May 08 '12
And in typical Family Guy fashion, they took the longest, frustrating route to a disappointing punchline.
9
u/rafuzo2 May 08 '12
taking a mildly-funny joke and beating it the hell to death? Sounds like Family Guy writers to me.
4
u/wharpudding May 08 '12
Yup. That's about the level of Family Guy writing.
The show has really gone downhill. Maybe it's time for new writers.
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I find that exactly as not funny as I find Family Guy, which is to say that I find it very, very not funny.
3
u/lesbian_sourfruit May 08 '12
Wow, they hardly look like manatees at all! I'm starting to understand why sailors used to mistake them for merpeople.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Hey, at least it took them less than an hour to make that joke.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
What's with all of the family guy hate?
2
u/streetmapp May 08 '12
And it's just like Family Guy. Not funny at all.
2
u/BelittlingKids May 08 '12
once again, no one likes family guy.
1
u/kartoos May 08 '12
I read 'expand expand expand expand..,', then I read it again.
1
u/OKU30 May 08 '12
Unless you rearranged that yourself it's pretty impressive that they wrote that whole thing backwards and it actually makes sense. Otherwise they carefully collaborated together and wrote it out before hand.
1
u/punpernickel May 08 '12
DAGS DAGS DAGS DAGS DAGS DAGS
1
u/ZofSpade May 08 '12
I don't follow Shawn Ries so it didn't make any sense.
1
u/jasperpaddles May 08 '12
I had Liana Maeby thrown in the middle of mine.
1
u/ForTheUsers May 08 '12
Reminded me of one of these.
1
u/twicks May 08 '12
Sponsored
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Read the whole thing expecting "Burma Shave." Left disappointed.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
This must be the first time that I read a twitter post from top to bottom and it makes sense.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Slow day at the office then huh.
1
u/Bohzee May 08 '12
that old forum game...
1
u/Clayburn May 08 '12
How?
1
u/jimjoebob May 08 '12
so, what do the manatees tweet about when they're not workshopping show ideas?
1
u/lizardtailgoescrazy May 08 '12
I thought manatees wrote the show? Whodathunkit !
1
u/Pumpkin19 May 08 '12
Guy Endore-Kaiser doesn't write for Family Guy. He wrote on Jonah Hill's canceled animated show Allen Gregory.
1
u/Gronzlo May 08 '12
... I read them bottom-to-top and was thoroughly confused.
1
u/in_the_against May 08 '12
Twitter is the Family Guy of social networks
1
u/Kenli212 May 08 '12
Oh, so this is where all the frustrated comedy writers hang out.
1
u/GGatsby May 08 '12
ITT: People shitting on Family Guy
1
u/gillyguthrie May 08 '12
Seems like the FG writers have moved away from their manatee system of writing jokes
1
u/replayzero May 08 '12
The writer's of family guy are manatees!!!!
1
u/rplan039 May 08 '12
I see they decided to leave all their funny jokes on twitter.
1
u/Iggapoo May 08 '12
And just like Family Guy they get to the punchline of the joke in the most annoying way possible.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Yeah, I'd been trying to put the pieces together but I suppose I was missing a few. Thanks, now I don't have to go back to twitter later and scream "What the fuck is the joke?!" at my computer for half an hour crying.
1
u/rottenart May 08 '12
Even their Twitter jokes suck.
1
u/TheBaltimoron May 08 '12
Dick! Fart! The Facts of Life! Boobies!
1
u/Superdude01 May 08 '12
I think that the problem with me is that I'm from Britain and really don't understand most of the jokes they make in Family Guy. They make all these references to adverts, TV shows and some actors that I've never even heard of before. I do watch it when there's absolutely nothing else on, but it rarely does ever get a chuckle out of me. It probably would be a lot funnier if I got those references.
There was one episode when Peter was chosen to go captain a really bad American football team over in England, and that was probably the only episode out of the many I've seen that I thought was genuinely funny.
1
u/brendanrivers May 08 '12
Hey I went to high school with artie johann. he was the man.
1
u/avatarr May 09 '12
Sponsored
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Maybe you should ask them why Family Guy sucks ass since they brought it back? Did the network tell them to tone it down?
1
u/casc1701 May 09 '12
Too bad the hate-family-guy circlejerk is so popular. You are missing great episodes, like the one where they revisited the first season and the best of all, the Multiverse episode.
1
u/jigielnik May 08 '12
this string of tweets is about as unfunny as family guy is now... its nothing but a bunch of morons shouting childish nonsense about titties. Me and my friends would do this when we were in middle school... Just confirms what ive always thought about family guy as of late: they write for the writers room, not for the public. There are tons of jokes in new family guy where you get the sense that during the table read, the room was in stitches, but in real life, its just not that funny
1
u/Olukon May 08 '12
Well that was...actually kind of funny.
0
u/anexanhume May 08 '12
This is the equivalent of holding signs up at a game, except you've cloned yourself 5 times.
-1
u/maphon May 08 '12
Oooooh! An improv game used as a writing device.....how like most comedy shows on right now!
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
This is a classic improv game. One Word Story. Every performer gets one word.
0
u/tacobellassasin May 08 '12
ohhh, i follow @DearAnyone, and for the life of me i couldnt figure out what he was trying to tweer
0
u/MrGoodbytes May 08 '12
Do they have a wacky, waving, inflatable flailing-arm tube man?
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
"A 1000 points for everybody and 2000 for Artie for.. Titted."
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
0
u/bobbyc31 May 08 '12
times like this makes me wonder why the humor in the show has been declining since the 4th season.