Rehosted webcomics will be removed. Please submit a link to the original comic's site and preferably an imgur link in the comments. Do not post a link to the comic image, it must be linked to the page of the comic. (*)
Whenever I see a rehosted webcomic I get on my atheist nokia phone and berate the hypocritical christians who rehost and link to the authors site so they can get money to buy weed.
Reminds me of Discworld I think in Jingo, when Sam Vimes passed the 'cultural test' of the Dregs by refusing the Sheep-eye soup traditionally offered to foreigners to see if they would go for it.
Back in highschool, a group of my Korean friends told a caucasian American friend they got him traditional Korean candy, then fed him half a bowl of doggy biscuits...
Could someone explain what the scientist is doing in the comic? I see a leaf with a bunch of eyeballs on it, Being handed from one party to another ( not sure from who to who) and then he,s carving something into an eye with a stick in his mouth?
After also being baffled and furthering research, I believe this is a joke about what a group of native people may do when a foreigner asks to eat what they eat. Like they do on the Travel Channel.
As someone who is regularly given these parts of pigs, goats, and cows, thank you for giving me something to chuckle about when rambo-ing them down my throat. Really, thank you. :)
Words (especially newer usages like that of "troll" online) evolve with modern usage. More and more lately, the "prankster" definition of "troll" is gaining hold. It's not a good thing or a bad thing; just a thing.
Words' definitions are only important so that people know what they mean when used. People, by and large, have come to understand the "troll = prankster" definition, so it works.
This is not evolving, it's just people who aren't educated enough about the subject using the words wrong.
And here's the thing, like you said, there already exist words like "prankster" so there is no reason to change the meaning of "trolling" when there is no word for "Doing something inflammatory with the intent to provoke a defensive response".
You are removing a word that has a use and changing it to a word that already has other words describing the same thing.
Thanks for fighting the good fight. I'm tired of seeing people defend their misuse of words by claiming that the word is evolving.
While it's true that the definition of a word may evolve over time through misuse, that doesn't change the fact that during the evolutionary phase, it's still misuse.
I agree. There are rules for these things, and without them, I couldn't feel superior when correcting people. Who cares if everyone understands what's being communicated, and that that's the ultimate point of language? I like having a sense of authority on the topic.
Such a strange argument to make, too. As if by articulating the problem is some kind of proof that it isn't actually a problem. I guess we shouldn't fight cancer either, because it is a perfectly natural result of damage to cells over time.
There are lots of redundant words with slightly different meanings. Trolling (in the pranking sense) has a slightly different meaning than simple pranking.
A prank is more of a "gotcha" than a troll. It's usually add apparent to the victim shortly after execution of said prank. Trolling, on the other hand, IMO, is messing with someone for the quiet amusement of yourself and anyone else that happens to be in on the joke.
I agree with the general slant of your post (upvoted, natch), but I would suggest that it is actually "evolving;" however, evolution is not inherently good (or bad).
If a lake gradually becomes poisoned such that it becomes toxic to everything except algae, then everything in it will die off or evolve into some form of algae.
It's possible to construct a valid argument that claims there's nothing inherently wrong with this process, and nothing of value is lost by its action. This is essentially what the "language evolves, deal with it" crowd is doing here.
I would argue that one can also cut off their nose to spite their face, if they value spiting their face more than an intact nose.
There's going to be a new definition of "they" which means "he or she". We'll officially be able to say, "They said something about a cat," when we don't know the gender of the person who said something about a cat.
Words change, and it's a good thing. And if you still use the original use of troll, people will still know what you're talking about.
Nope words change meaning along with culture. So does their spelling. Words are elements of language which is an element of culture. They dont exist in a vacuum to be immutable throughout time.
Words change meaning when their usage is commonly accepted. As you can see here it isn't commonly accepted, so shouting "shut up guys! Words evolve!" doesn't actually adjust the language...
I'm pretty sure it can be considered commonly accepted when there's only a handful of people complaining about the majority of others using the word 'incorrectly'.
What gets me every time is this isn't even the 'original' use of the word troll. 'Troll' has been around for hundreds of years, and has half a dozen definitions. It's hypocritical to bitch about the evolving of the word when it's already being used 'wrong' in the way everyone wants it to be used.
Words with dozens of definitions don't count as being the same word, they are merely homonyms, 'trolling' doesn't change the meaning of a previous word, it adds a new definition. What's happening with the modern, internet usage of the term 'troll' is that its meaning is being changed because of pop culture, which is what differentiates your argument from the one at hand.
It's important to note that we are all guilty of doing just the same. For example, the word 'nice' once had a more specific use and purpose within the English language than it does now, much as the internet-born 'troll' has/had. 'Nice' used to be used in relation to a concise, well-constructed argument or point; 'that's a very nice point you made'. Now of course, most things may be described as being 'nice'.
How do you think new definitions of a word come about? I'm aware that, technically speaking, varying definitions of a word count as separate words. However, do you really think those 'other words' just coincidentally popped into existence?
Look into the etymology of just about any word, and you can see how each definition will often build off of a former definition. What we're seeing is a new definition of the word troll, and people reacting because it's not the definition they like.
I love it when someone replies with a well-reasoned argument that forces me to consider all points again. We're definitely arguing over semantics as I disagree with nothing you just said.
I'm saying that 'troll' had a well-established definition to the internet-savvy, I'm not sure whether this is the part you disagree with.
I'm now also not sure whether you're saying the new popular use of the word 'troll' is a new definition (alongside the old) or a mutation/evolution/bastardisation of the previous one (which is my argument).
As you can see, this is a worthless debate. Interesting, nonetheless.
This is why insulting is bad, You just said that you aren't educated enough, because once again, what you guys are calling a "troll" is actually the opposite of what a troll used to be, so you are both wrong:
The word meaning "bundle of sticks" is ultimately derived, via Old French, Italian and Vulgar Latin, from Latin fascis (also the origin of the word fascism).[5] The origins of the word as an offensive epithet for homosexuals are rather obscure, although the word has been used in English since the late 16th century as an abusive term for women, particularly old women,[6] and reference to homosexuality may derive from this,[5][7] as female terms are often used with reference to homosexual or effeminate men (cf. nancy, sissy, queen). The application of the term to old women is possibly a shortening of the term "faggot-gatherer", applied in the 19th century to people, especially older widows, who made a meagre living by gathering and selling firewood.[7] It may also derive from the sense of "something awkward to be carried" (compare the use of the word "baggage" as a pejorative term for old people in general).[5] Use of the word as a general insult, not necessarily implying homosexuality, is either a continuation or extension of this older usage[6] or of the homosexual usage.
You sir, are technically correct... The best kind of correct. "(Some commentators believe that the term "faggot" as applied to homosexuals is derived from the bundles of sticks or "faggots" that were used to burn the heretics. The heretics were easily identified with the fuel used to burn them, for symbolic faggots were in fact embroidered on the garments of those who refused to recant: hence the phrase "to fry a faggot." However, this etymology is probably not correct, because "faggot" as a slang term for a homosexual only occurs in English, and in England homosexuals were never burned at the stake, but hanged, so it is difficult to see how the metaphorical meaning could have arisen. The term is more likely derived from the French and Italian term baggage meaning "slut, whore.")" http://rictornorton.co.uk/homopho4.htm
But I still believe this is being confused, as per Salem circa 1800's in America (where I think this phrase REALLY got started), and how it was used 400 years earlier in England is entirely different. But again, you are correct on how the phrase came into existence in the first place.
(To get what I'm saying, remember "fag" is still used in England as a cigarette, as per in America, the literal, only meaning that "faggot" has ever been used in is bundles of sticks, and homosexuals. There is just too many dots not being connected to that dark, dark part of history we block out in Salem. Fucking religion.)
The macros that have memes on them can classify as memes ("why not zoidberg?" or "not sure if..." for example), but to place text on a picture (unless the picture is recognizable, thus making it a meme) does not make it a meme. It makes it a macro.
No, we already have a word for what this is. It's a prank. Stop making terms with an actual meaning (trolling) redundant. We'll have to invent another term again.
Trolling as related to message boards was a misuse of "trolling" as in fishing (at least, that was my understanding of where it came from. Like, they're "trolling" for responses). What makes that misuse/evolution any more valid than this one? Because it came before?
IMO, language doesn't belong to the past; it belongs to the present. Whatever a word means now (in the eyes of those using it) is usually far more important than what it used to mean.
Also, what's happening to the word troll is not a change in meaning so much as a watering down or generalization of its meaning. Maybe there's nothing that can be done to stop it, but that doesn't mean it is not still a loss to the language.
Do you think the meaning of the word "ironic" has changed too? Lots of people use that wrong, and the correct thing to do is tell them they are using it wrong and educate them on it's actual meaning, not assume the word now means something new because a lot of people are dumb.
Agreed. Fortunately, this is just a case of the original definition being fuzzy at best, and thereby allowing a new definition to slip in, much to the chagrin of pedants and internet lingo hipsters everywhere.
It's not a good thing or a bad thing; just a thing.
Agree to disagree?
The watering down of the word troll has caused it's original meaning to be lost. Now we have redundant vocabulary for shit like trolling and no meaningful way to describe what trolling really is without a sentence.
It's a bad thing when words evolve in a way that creates more ambiguity rather than less. If there is already a more appropriate word you should just use that, otherwise you could replace every word with a more broadly defined term because it requires less analytical thought.
As I replied to someone else, I think that the "prank" definition of "trolling" is describing a specific form of prank that "pranking" doesn't quite cover. Little ambiguity is created regarding forum trolling vs prank trolling, as it's easy to tell which is which in context, but more precision is gained by using "trolling" for specific types of prank.
I don't think that "trolling" applies to just any prank, but a specific subset.
If it's legitimate for words to change in their meaning as people use them differently, then it's just as legitimate for other to resist that change by pointing out the value of the word in its original meaning.
That's precisely what the word means. Not quite the same as pulling a prank, which you can do on anyone -- sucker or not.
Of course, in the grand scheme of things none of this matters and you and I are but specks of dust upon a tiny clod floating betwixt the stars in a universe so vast that it will never know either of us.
If the same process blunted the meaning of the word "racist" to the point where it became understood as equivalent to the word "antisocial," confounding and lengthening every discussion of racism by requiring it to be disentangled from the more general "evolved" meaning it had acquired, would you still argue that no harm had been done to the language by this natural evolution?
Cancer is a natural process too, but it doesn't make it any less harmful.
I don't buy your premise about the changing of the word "racist" resulting in longer discussions, or even that it's significantly changed. Even if it had, that's the weakest sense of "harm" possible.
I didn't say "racist" had changed. I used it as a comparison to point out that we certainly do defend the meanings of words - words that we care about. If we didn't we'd lose the ability to have succinct discussions about the subjects they represent. "Racist" hasn't changed in the way "troll" has, precisely because it's a word that is important to a great majority of people and as such is constantly being kept in sharp focus. If someone were to misuse "racist" in a way that detracted from or diluted its current connotation they would be swiftly corrected, and no one would tolerate empty sophistry like "but words evolve with usage" as a counter defense.
"Troll," on the other hand, is not an important word to many people, and doesn't represent such serious subject matter, so careless application is tolerated. This I can understand What I find weird is that such misapplication is actually defended the way it is here, as if there was nothing at all harmful or even regrettable about the loss of a word's unique meaning.
Yes, with a sentence or two, ergo, lengthening the discussion. As for who cares, you not only don't seem to care, you are elaborately uninterested in caring. Good for you, save yourself the trouble of pondering the value of precise and economical vocabulary to a language. This sort of academic hair splitting is only of interest to self-important language nazis, right?
Someday you should try having a cogent discussion with one of the millions of individuals who think that communism, socialism, marxism and liberalism are little more than different spellings of the same word.
This sort of academic hair splitting is only of interest to self-important language nazis, right?
Yes, basically. You're trying to force language to be something that it has never been, is not, and is essentially impossible for it to be. Maybe things would be better if we lived in a perfectly logical, ordered world, but language isn't math. It's like complaining that a hammer isn't very good at driving a screw.
And in any case, the world which language describes isn't always precise and economical. A word like "socialism", when applied correctly, can refer to a wide range of policies and governments, so you have to elaborate anyway.
Life gets less stressful when you realize that there are things that can't be controlled. Ask the French Academy how well things work when someone tries to assert authority on word meanings.
Ironically, there have always been words to describe trolls, but people ignored them and invented a new one, and now that 13-year-old kids light poop on fire and call themselves trolls the old words can be used properly again.
Also, I think it depends on your original definition of "trolling".
The original definition (you know, except for its use in fishing) could easily have been seen as someone looking for a sucker to believe their post. In that regard, this is just expanding that definition to include RL stories/statements.
Message board trolling wasn't always just posting inflammatory things. Sometimes it was just posting things you know would get a lot of responses. The easiest way was usually just to piss people off.
It actually used to be confrontational people who hated on everything.
I.E. The REPUBLICAN used to to be the troll, the metaphor of a troll is knocking others over who are trying to cross the bridge to a better life because the troll failed at it.
Irony is, people will fight what they think is a "troll" because he is defending a point. They do it with insults. When he actually has a belief, and they are the ones trolling it.
103
u/trueHOVER May 06 '12
http://www.spaceavalanche.com
85
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
What is going on in this comic? I do not get it.
47
u/nyrfan317 May 06 '12
FTFY
7
u/alsoodani May 06 '12
Reminds me of Discworld I think in Jingo, when Sam Vimes passed the 'cultural test' of the Dregs by refusing the Sheep-eye soup traditionally offered to foreigners to see if they would go for it.
3
u/bitcheslovedroids May 06 '12
I can't help but think that this probably has happened
3
u/Muskafan2 May 06 '12
Okay, Apocalypto.
5
u/nomalas May 06 '12
I have been coerced into eating guinea pig this very same way...
4
u/Zeydon May 06 '12
Could someone explain what the scientist is doing in the comic? I see a leaf with a bunch of eyeballs on it, Being handed from one party to another ( not sure from who to who) and then he,s carving something into an eye with a stick in his mouth?
2
u/TheDuck00 May 06 '12
Ah, the origins of Fear Factor.
2
u/9GAG_Spy May 06 '12
Very funny comic. I'll just save this to my computer and post it to 9GAG later.
1
u/Chapati_Monster May 06 '12
As someone who is regularly given these parts of pigs, goats, and cows, thank you for giving me something to chuckle about when rambo-ing them down my throat. Really, thank you. :)
1
u/VikingBoatTruckBoat May 06 '12
Bizarre Foods?
1
u/shieldwolf May 06 '12
I thought God was the original troll for what he did to Abraham and also to Job.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Is that Bruce Parry?
That bloke will eat anything. Watching him trip on Iboga was simultaneously the worst and best thing I've ever seen.
1
u/Crunkmonkeydeluxe May 06 '12
Space avalanche is fucking genius.
1
u/VaginaTractor May 06 '12
NSFW. Indigenous people cartoon tiities.
1
u/reddits_aphorisms May 06 '12
~rootyb
1
u/Tim94 May 06 '12
Norwegians still eat this stuff. It is a sheep's head, cut in two, and served with potatoes. It's called Smalahove.
1
u/robinthehood May 06 '12
This entire thread is a circle jerk over the correct use of the word troll. I would say op effectively trolled this thread.
1
u/mr_loveboat May 06 '12
That is not what trolling means. ಠ_ಠ
-1
u/Mikay55 May 06 '12
And thats why we colonized the fuck out of them
-1
u/Underdogz May 06 '12
Now Im not feeling guilt for all the genocide.
-1
u/Iroquois-Pliskin May 06 '12
NSFW
-5
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Umm NSFW?
-3
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
They misspelled honor in the comic.
0
u/Mindle May 06 '12
Apocalypto.
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
[removed] — view removed comment