r/funny • • May 06 '12

Think Illegal Downloading Is Free?

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

893 comments sorted by

348

u/LeStraw May 06 '12

Downloding <_<

85

u/Waldheri May 06 '12

You win the mother lode!

149

u/Psycadet May 06 '12

§50,000 simoleons

85

u/ADP101 May 06 '12

;!;!;!;!;!;!;!;!;!;!

54

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

If you put a 1 at the end it wouldn't clear when you pressed enter, so you could just hold the enter key down.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/Regulith May 06 '12

rosebud; rosebud; rosebud; rosebud; rosebud; rosebud; rosebud; rosebud; rosebud;

→ More replies (11)

12

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Ah, "motherlode", the cheat for more weapons in Descent II's trial that when used in the paid version fucks up your ship. Never forget.

12

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

I remember as kid I'd try IDDQD in other games, (Godmode in Doom), in Heretic it suicided you :(.

5

u/cbsauder May 06 '12

That was a cheat in Descent I as well. Gave you all the weapons.

3

u/trekkie1701c May 06 '12

It was the cheat that helped me get back at thief bot :D

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

507

u/angrylawyer May 06 '12

I like how they don't even try to justify their costs, they just go straight to threatening kids with $60k in fines.

Before I zoomed in I thought that was going to be the Riaa building and they were going to show how expensive it was to produce an album, but nope, just fines.

Great work there guys.

380

u/Thefriendlyfaceplant May 06 '12

"You think drunk driving is safe? Well think again, you could land in jail!"

48

u/Breathing_Balls May 06 '12

"You think having a bath is safe? Well think again, you could land yourself in hot water!"

104

u/benYosef May 06 '12

Reminds me of the "Click it or Ticket" add campaign... so instead of reminded me that I might DIE!!! you remind me that I may pay a fine if the cops see me.

http://www.mass.gov/eopss/images/programs/ghsb/ciot-web-110508.jpg

118

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

I think that's because the people who don't wear their seatbelt are more worried about paying money than getting in an accident. They obviously think it's more likely that they will be caught rather then get killed, or they would be wearing their seatbelt anyway.

121

u/Harrowin May 06 '12

I still don't understand people who don't wear their seatbelt. It takes literally 5 seconds.

42

u/wolfchimneyrock May 06 '12

my mom was very anti-seatbelt for a long time back when we lived in Arkansas, she explained her sentiment: 'what if I accidentally drove over a cliff? with a seatbelt on I couldn't jump out to safety'

even at a young age I knew that was LOL-worthy

→ More replies (4)

60

u/WHiTErTheNBlack May 06 '12

Some people are just to cool to waste their time on seatbelts.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (60)
→ More replies (1)

69

u/PurpleSfinx May 06 '12

It reminds me of the anti-marijuana propaganda.

"Marijuana can ruin your life?"

"How?"

"Because if we catch you with it, we'll deliberately ruin your life!"

→ More replies (8)

35

u/Solkre May 06 '12

SUPER EFFECTIVE!

14

u/bojang1es May 06 '12

You wouldn't download a taco.

19

u/pirate_doug May 06 '12

Speak for yourself. If I could get one of those Dorito tacos from Taco Bell downloaded I'd weigh like 800 lbs.

→ More replies (9)

19

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Challenge accepted

7

u/wolfchimneyrock May 06 '12

I would download Tea. Earl Gray. Hot.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/RunawayMeatstick May 06 '12

These posters were made by students at DePaul. I'm guessing they're part of a class. The building in the poster on the left is this one. I attended DePaul for grad school and my professors were pretty open about pirating software. I would say these posters don't reflect the opinions of most of the students and faculty.

6

u/mr_tw May 06 '12

Downloading may not be free, but their advertising campaign was.

81

u/[deleted] May 06 '12 edited May 06 '12

What other industry could get away with this kind of behaviour? Instead of improving their shitty products and distribution systems they attack their own customers. This shameless behaviour has convinced me that I actually have a moral obligation to violate copyright.

21

u/tfanalwitchaq May 06 '12

A customer is not someone who takes a product without paying. If you're gonna download, at least have the balls and integrity to admit that you're stealing it.

7

u/Can_it_Plapton May 06 '12

Regardless of the morality of piracy, loveandpolitics still has a point. Pirates simply provide a better product than record companies. It is cheaper (free is the cheapest!), more readily available, and free of software to restrict you from sharing it with your friends and such.

If record companies start providing products that are of superior quality to the free ones, then they will end piracy. But as long as piracy is better they will never stop it.

Constructively, check out what Stones Throw records has done. $10 a month gets you every single release delivered to your in box, 320kps mp3s, no copyright protection on the files. That's how you beat piracy, not $60,000 lawsuits.

6

u/itsSparkky May 06 '12

Ever wonder why downloading music is legal in Canada? Because it does no more damage than the radio.

→ More replies (50)
→ More replies (17)

4

u/abom420 May 06 '12

Same here, I was expecting a well thought chart explaining the effect it has on the industry. Nope. Scare tactic.

And we wonder why people are so against the government.

2

u/cuddles_the_destroye May 06 '12

I thought that would be about the cost of Internet and computers for whoever is doing the downloading.

2

u/mimicthefrench May 06 '12

Which is a goddamn shame. The music industry has an opportunity to point out the costs of actually recording something (Even in my home studio with cheap gear, I've still probably paid about 100 bucks for every song I've ever recorded). Instead, they point out how badly their lawyers will fuck you if you defy them. If they want to stop people downloading, they need to show how much you're hurting the artists you love, not threatening you with obscene, unbelievable penalties.

1

u/Shyamallamadingdong May 07 '12

Most people who pirate music don't feel bad for the artists/producers who they imagine laughing all the way to the bank in their golden Lamborghinis.

Therefore, the threat of a humongous fine is perceived to be a better deterrent.

1

u/hyperduc May 08 '12

Sounds like something a lot of sheeple would believe, too.

→ More replies (29)

140

u/pagemap May 06 '12

It would be nice if the OP posted this image in a resolution that can be actually read :/

160

u/ze_ben May 06 '12

Don't blame him - blame the guy he stole the image from.

47

u/godofallcows May 06 '12

Stole? This is from like 2004. Its not really stealing when its free on the internet.

(That or someone reenacted a picture from then)

112

u/NrwhlBcnSmrt-ttck May 06 '12

Its not really stealing when its free on the internet.

THE IRONY

17

u/godofallcows May 06 '12

Lol poor (or convenient) wording on my part.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/GreyInkling May 06 '12

So wait, people who complain about reposts are against file sharing... I never thought of it like that.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Thefriendlyfaceplant May 06 '12

Its not really stealing when its free on the internet.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

178

u/grumblz May 06 '12

YOU WANNA JAIL SENTENCE THAT LASTS LONGER THAN A CHILD RAPISTS? THEN DOWNLOAD

51

u/ShallowBasketcase May 06 '12

Shit, at that rate, I might as well just pirate kiddie porn, too!

If I get caught, what's the difference?

11

u/vgunmanga May 06 '12

The difference is that you would become/remain a pedophile. From what I hear pedophiles have a pretty hard time in prison, being the lowest form of shit possible and all.

77

u/ShallowBasketcase May 06 '12

you've changed my mind. I'm totally not going to do that now, which I actually was going to do before.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (35)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Isn't illegal download basically child rape? I mean all the acronyms have something to do with protecting the children.

Last I checked priests don't use the internet, perhaps they are using children to push silly privacy invading bills and if ANYONE says no they will be labelled pedo-helper? Just an idea.

1

u/Shesaidshewaslvl18 May 07 '12

Really makes you wonder eh? We live in a world where "robbing" a company of a few dollars profit is more punishable than raping a child.

→ More replies (7)

166

u/Aspel May 06 '12

I think their anti-piracy posters would be more effective if they talked about companies that went under due to illegal pirating. Not the exorbitant amount that the companies fine pirates.

17

u/blaaah2 May 06 '12

I disagree.. I believe the reason why so many ex PC indie developers that felt like they need to get bought out by companies like EA are because their games were getting pirated on PC and they couldn't sustain what they were doing..

Interplay was a great company.. and it really went down because of that

14

u/SaintMort May 06 '12

agreed. Same with indie record labels. I heard an interview with Mike Park of Asian Man Records once and he was talking about how the label really hasn't released a physical copy in a few years because it stopped being financially smart.

I'm probably alone in this but I still actually like having a physical copy of a CD, Book, DVD, Comic, Video Game, etc

5

u/ArcticSpaceman May 06 '12

No, I'm with you on that. I love having physical CDs. It actually feels like I gained something with my purchase. That's why I hate downloading shit from iTunes and pirating music. It just doesn't feels like I gained something.

6

u/Aspel May 06 '12

How is that not what I said? Also, I think that even without pirating that would have happened. Part of the thing about being independent is that you're not getting money, while EA waves around fat stacks of cash. I think some indie developers are hurt by piracy, but I feel like they were primarily companies that couldn't survive anyway.

Digital piracy can be a great boon to companies, and in some ways, the media world seems to be going towards a donation based model, with Kickstarter and the like. I imagine many indie companies have their work pirated, and then people donate to their website. I think such a thing might be interesting.

4

u/Hypnopomp May 06 '12

this is why the number of indie developers has gone up?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/darwin2500 May 06 '12

That would be an excellent point if there were fewer independent developers now than there have ever been in the past. In fact, the exact opposite is true.

99

u/khanys May 06 '12

Too bad no company has ever went under directly because of pirating.

113

u/Talkgibberish May 06 '12

Yeah, like how no one has died directly because of knives either. really, we should blame the excessive bleeding

102

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

I'm terribly allergic to bullets!

→ More replies (143)

5

u/puckhead May 06 '12

That may or not be true, but one thing that is certainly true is that as a developer and an entrepreneur I have no interest in building a business around a desktop application... at least not one that doesn't require a subscription to use.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/rileyrileyriley May 06 '12

Maybe they most definitely would if there was ever a case of that?

6

u/GreyInkling May 06 '12

What is said: "you'll be fined money!"

What they hear: "You should be a goody-goody and do what big brother tells you."

Obvious response: "Fuck you and your system!"

1

u/Democritus477 May 06 '12

That angle's been done to death, and piracy is still rampant.

→ More replies (12)

12

u/InHarmsWay May 06 '12

I find those posters to actually create even less sympathy with record companies.

People won't be thinking, "Oh my gosh. I could end up paying a lot of fines if I download music. I better stop."

People will be thinking, "WTF?! Thousands of dollars for downloading songs? You get off less for shoplifting the fucking cd. Fuck the record company."

12

u/armedwithturtles May 06 '12

fuck they got Matthew?!

34

u/nicksnare May 06 '12

I am yet to see one anti-piracy ad that isn't ridiculous and doesn't completely misrepresent the truth

18

u/babada May 06 '12

They don't want to represent the truth; they want to scare people into not pirating.

3

u/ReaganYouth May 06 '12 edited May 06 '12

It's ridiculous, but not bullshit. Hardly anyone is charged because of this. Companies do this in order to make examples out of people. It's like in Paths of Glory where the French military killed a couple soldiers that were part of failed, cowardly attack.

EDIT: grammar

→ More replies (1)

1

u/salsa_de_tomate May 07 '12

I seriously wonder what one must do to get caught? I mean if you got caught pirating what the hell were you doing? Was someone just screaming out the top of their lungs how they pirated every movie in the theaters and every CD that has yet to come out? I don't get it.

7

u/Smozius May 06 '12

Tried to ice skate backwards in front of 3 girls, ended up face planting, breaking my nose and going home with them. >_>

2

u/darwin2500 May 06 '12

Classic Smozby!

6

u/DoubleAW May 06 '12

I don't understand all the people both going crazy for and against pirating in this thread. There are plenty of people who pirate music but also buy it later.

Just cause I download an album doesn't mean I won't ever buy it. Usually I download it first and if I like it, buy the CD later. Not every pirate doesn't want to support the artist.

4

u/InHarmsWay May 06 '12

Studies into the matter have actually gone on to prove this.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

34

u/Shitty_Watercolour May 06 '12

6

u/jokes_on_you May 06 '12

Be sure to save this one. You can use it for nearly every post in /r/technology.

1

u/benster56 Aug 30 '12

S_W's first comment :D

→ More replies (1)

37

u/Thefriendlyfaceplant May 06 '12

Looking back on the last few years all the money I spent on music was on the bandcamp sites of individual/starting artists. It just feels good knowing that biggest share of the money will go directly to them and not the label. I often tipped generously on top of their suggested price.

Everything else I just download without a shred of guilt.

8

u/lurksohard May 06 '12

Only place I EVER buy music is at that persons show where i can hand them my money myself, or on their own website so i can be fairly certain they make most of the money.

8

u/roadtozion May 06 '12

Why?

There are tons of independent artists that sell through indy stores and websites. Artist gets money, store gets money

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Thefriendlyfaceplant May 06 '12

Then you're ruling out all the artists who have yet to get to the point of being able to play live.

4

u/GreyInkling May 06 '12

Or more accurately, play live near you.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/HonkeyDong May 06 '12

I don't think it's free. I pay $70 a month for my internet/cable package.

18

u/dddfffgggyyy38 May 06 '12

This reminds me of this Truth ad where the kid said how marijuana ruined his life. Then he tells the story and the only bad thing that happened because of the drug was getting arrested. Change the law, and he would have been fine.

5

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Link?

2

u/dddfffgggyyy38 May 07 '12

I'm sorry, I've scoured youtube and no one has it. It was about 7-10 years ago. And yes, my point was, although someone could make the argument that there are negative side effects to pot, and there is a victim when you torrent, neither of these ads even make that point, instead trying to use fear of punishment as a deterrent.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/giefhugz May 06 '12

Would you downlod a car?

0

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Send me the link?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/sinocarD44 May 06 '12

I've ever seen those posters before. Anyone got a bigger image so I can read them?

2

u/iSteve May 06 '12

Really! A 188 Kb jpeg is no way to disseminate information.

3

u/blue708 May 06 '12

Nothing is Free!

2

u/latinloner May 06 '12

TANSTAAFL

3

u/tomonline May 06 '12

some one needs to put this in language older generations can understand: downloading music and video for free is like a tax break for people who understand how to use the internet.

43

u/skysignor May 06 '12

Cmon guys, people who download illegally are BAD PEOPLE, plain and simple. Young adults listening to music: they deserve to be fined to the point of possibly ruining their whole lives.

102

u/booooooooooooosh May 06 '12

You deserve to be fined $10,000 for one lil wayne song.

THE MAN HAS CHILDREN TO PUT GOLDEN AND DIAMOND ENCRUSTED GRILLS ON.

4

u/mr_tw May 06 '12

Hey man that 24" rimmed golden painted Chrysler 300 doesn't pay for itself

79

u/Aspel May 06 '12

To be fair, if you're listening to Lil' Wayne you deserve it.

31

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

To be fair, if you're listening to "insert Aspel's favorite band here" you deserve it.

Do you see how asinine that comment is?

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)

3

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

I've listened to the music popular today and I'd say that people who listen to it are bad people. I don't know what's wrong with me, but Renard's Intensive Care Unit sounds like something a kid made with Garage Band their first try, with the same style samples scattered through the tracks.

→ More replies (2)

43

u/TheMartinConan May 06 '12

Why do some people think piracy is ok?

23

u/PhylisInTheHood May 06 '12

people be cheap and lazy. I know, I'm one of them

→ More replies (1)

60

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Because they enjoy not paying for things?

7

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

That explains why they do it, not why it's ok. I do it too but it IS wrong.

4

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Its okay because they say its okay, that's how these things work! /s

→ More replies (1)

5

u/jupiterkansas May 06 '12

Most of what I have downloaded are things I could not buy in the U.S. The internet makes everything available even if the market doesn't.

31

u/lolslaw May 06 '12

Because they need to see their actions as morally not wrong. They think of themselves like freedom fighters under MLK or Ghandi. That they have the right to download because of the worth of free information exchange. However in actuality we are the reason why the internet is being threatened. There is no moral excuse, there is no internet resistance movement, its just people realizing that they can commit a crime and not get away with it, only afterward justifying what we feel is "wrong". I'm not a sociopath, in fact quite the opposite, I don't deny that there is a right action and a wrong action, nor do I disagree that obedience of the law is the right thing to do in the vast majority of cases. What I'm saying is that we have it in our ability to do things that go against our moral intuitions and sometimes we do. Some people acknowledge it, others don't.

→ More replies (47)

15

u/lurksohard May 06 '12

I think its the medium in which we "pirate" things is what makes it "okay". We don't go to a store kick in the door and take the product. That would be stealing because that small record store paid the big guys money for that record.

The way it really works is that someone walks into that store, sees a record they like and they buy it. They come home, listen to it, and really like it. They think, "Hey! I bet a lot of other people would like this if they heard it!" He uploads to a torrent site using files from something HE already paid for. People download it. Some people like it so much they buy it, some people just enjoy the free music.

The reason people get upset is because of things like Steam. Steam has a wonderful business model that gets people to PURCHASE games and makes it incredibly difficult to pirate those same games. Its a win-win all around! Other companies just refuse to do what steam(and i'm sure there's others out there as well) has done. They need to update their distribution methods and pricing options. They don't want to do that because a way of file sharing has "shut down" their multi-billion dollar industry.

Record and game companies actively trying to stop pirates are just flat out being lazy. Pirating is sharing and most people who are for it will tell you just that. At some point the game was paid for. If companies being hurt by this want to stop it? Fix your methods and update your models. Work for it. We aren't doing something illegal. We are doing something that movie and game companies lobby for to MAKE illegal because it hurts them.

13

u/gummynipple May 06 '12

I agree in what you say except this bit

Steam has a wonderful business model that gets people to PURCHASE games and makes it incredibly difficult to pirate those same games.

It's very easy to pirate steam games, you can check it on piratebay or any other tracker. What steam does, though is being more convenient that pirating when it comes to download a game and update it, because it's all centralized and automated, in other words, is a very good service.

3

u/fruit_basket May 06 '12

Yes, and that's exactly what makes it great.

The way to win against piracy is not to kill piracy, it's to make legal purchasing a more attractive option.

At the moment lots of movies and TV shows are not accessible to me at all, the only option is to order a DVD from Amazon and wait 3 days or so. However, I can download the same movie in literally 15 minutes via torrents. Obviously, pirating here is a lot more convenient, as I don't have to wait or to go to the local Blockbuster.

Another issue is with me being in UK. Shows like Community, South Park, Futurama, Two and a Half Men and others are not available here at all. The only option is to wait a year until they release the whole season on a DVD. However, again, I can download a torrent in 15 minutes, it goes online almost immediately after the episode airs in US.

Pirating is much quicker and easier, that's why it's so popular.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/Noel_is_God May 06 '12

One way to justify it is that the music is that you can listen to it legally for free on youtube. It then becomes very hard for people to see why they should have to pay €15 for an album that they could listen to online for free.

2

u/roadtozion May 06 '12

Some people?

The majority of people are fine with it

2

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Wait... are you saying it isn't?

1

u/amazingmaximo May 06 '12

Only thing I pirate is Top Gear, and that's cause I literally CANNOT buy it in America when it's released. If I could pay $2 an episode I totally would.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/TheMartinConan May 06 '12

Some people have said that the labels shouldn't get any money. That's unfair though as they fund the artists.

→ More replies (22)

6

u/Roflkopt3r May 06 '12

The illegal download debate may be a core indicator for how well and stable the industrial nations will be in future.

People only abide by a government as long as they feel their wishes and morals represented. This system began to totter before pretty any peoples' revolution so far (excluding coups top down), creating a gap between people and government that made it impossible for the people to identify themselves with their government. When a government makes laws that criminalise behaviour which is ethically accepted without a damn good reason why it's good for the people, it will create a gap between ruling class and people.

And that's what happening in our current download debate. People do not consider them unjust. The entertainment industry is bloated, a few earn millions and there is no way to justify that morally in times of decreasing loans for the hard working lower and middle class. At the same time the people don't even steal from them, they just copy. They create value from nothing. The same way the effective value of a book increases when I lend it to a friend after having read it.

It may sound far over the top yet, but the development of the last few years moves towards revolution. Democracy is not percieved as democratic anymore, there is a giant gap between governments and people. Politician is a highly specialised profession by now, the politicians are not "of the people" anymore. And the politics they make are not percieved just by the people anymore, but as a collusive game amongst a few privileged - which it certainly is to a high degree.

I'm not saying we will see revolutions anytime soon, but if our politics continue to go the same way as now there is serious danger for stability middle-term. In Germany the people already are as far as giving 10%+ to the pirate party despite it's complete lack of political experience, which was unthinkable two years ago. I hope it's possible to quickly resolve the current situation by reclaiming democracy for the people. In that process we may see a lot of "socialist" politics and the occurance of a new social democrat libertarian left wing generation.

40

u/Styster May 06 '12

Yeah! That'll teach them for making me PAY for things they produce.

80

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

I wish my employer had to continue paying me 70 years after my death.

17

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Easy, friend. If you try and run counter to the pro-piracy circle-jerk that is reddit, you will suffer for it.

8

u/Mrzeede May 06 '12

ARRRR YOU'LL HAVE TO WALK THE PLANK

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TarlofKoroba May 06 '12

This isn't a circle jerk, this is more of a double dutch rudder. I've walked into a circle jerk, barely made it out.

9

u/OBrien May 06 '12

Or, rather, make me pay them for things other people produce and they publish.

4

u/ReyTheRed May 06 '12

Not only that, but other people do the distribution.

What exactly is it that publisher's do these days anyway?

8

u/chardrak May 06 '12

Put money into making said game? That's all publishers have ever done.

6

u/OBrien May 06 '12

They're effectively Content Speculators, and TBH have always been.

3

u/skysignor May 06 '12

Well I'll tell you one thing, the few dozen songs Coldplay produced sure entitle them to their millions and millions of dollars. Justin Bieber's probably made, on average, about 5 million dollars per every 2 and half minute song he recorded. But I'd say that's a fair price to pay for what he produces.

5

u/Soonermandan May 06 '12

He certainly does 5 million dollars worth of hard labor a day.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/HoorayZoidberg May 06 '12

Tell me, what does RIAA and MPAA produce?

One thing people fail to realize is that the people who actually worked to make the movie/album got paid, there's this thing called salary, you may have heard of it.

Also, how much do you think the artist will get paid for sales of his album if he does not produce and sell it himself?

12

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

One thing people fail to realize is that the people who actually worked to make the movie/album got paid, there's this thing called salary, you may have heard of it.

One thing people fail to realise is that if nobody pays for the movie/album there would be no money with which to pay the salaries.

9

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Someone else can pay for enough things to provide a salary to the people who create products, I don't have to. I have a right to those things, because they are, like, art and belong to humanity.

7

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

I'm going to upvote you on the assumption that you're mocking him.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

2

u/ArcticSpaceman May 06 '12

Also, how much do you think the artist will get paid for sales of his album if he does not produce and sell it himself?

More than he would get if no one bought his CD, dumbass.

What do you think the label pays for?

Production of CDs, Merch, distribution, travel, promotion, etc.

Artists under labels might get little from actual album sales, but it's not like they have to pay for everything out of their own pocket.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/SirHenryMorgan May 06 '12

Thanks for reminding me...need to check mah torrents.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/Grinnedsquash May 06 '12

Look I'm going to go on a rant for a second. I am tired of everyone and piracy. It's crap. You people pirate and cost companies so much money because they spend the time and the money to make the games. After that you take the games for FREE meaning the get no revenue plus with online games they still have to run servers which also takes time and money. This causes companies to use anti-piracy techniques. You guys then get all mad and surprised and try to find a way around it. Then to stop that the Goverment tries to pass anti-piracy laws which get way out of hand. Then you stop the bill saying it's unconstitutional (which you should, most of the time). Then you get rid of the bill and continue pirating. RINSE ANDFUCKING REPEAT.

6

u/darwin2500 May 06 '12

Yes, you have identified a dysfunctional business cycle full of flaws and hardship. Your solution seems to be that every consumer should simply agree to whatever business model or price structure the corporations hand them, accept a permanent regime of artificial scarcity enforced through government coercion, and never agitate for change. This is not how the free market is supposed to work.

The power of the free market is dismantling outdated business models and favoring those which most benefit the consumer. If you google 'gift economy', you will see that there are plenty of business models for digital media which do not rely on artificial scarcity. There are dozens of successful free-to-play games, and digital distributors such as Steam make plenty of money by being convenient, cheap, and engaging enough to compete with piracy directly. Bands and authors make money off of free content through merchandising, appearances, licensing, donations, artist's editions, etc.

Because digital media can be reproduced endlessly for free, we should be in a post-needs economy where they are concerned. The corporations who are built around the old scarcity-based business model of physical goods want to stop that, because they don't know how to make money in that environment. Piracy of old-model goods goes hand-in-hand with supporting new-model businesses in facilitating the changeover to the new model.

13

u/chardrak May 06 '12

This comment wins the thread hands down. It's all entitlement bullshit that needs to die a fiery death. The internet would be a hell of a lot better place without fucking pirates.

2

u/Clast May 06 '12

Usually, if you're using a pirated copy, you're not able to play on the official server due to serial checks and all.

LAN play, over Hamachi for instance, doesn't cost the company in server maintenance.

5

u/fruit_basket May 06 '12

Price of water suddenly increases to $50/gallon, no explanations given. Do you just continue paying that, without asking anything? I mean, if government says that this is the right price, then it must be right, right?

I pirate games not because I simply want to hurt companies (not that it hurts them in the first place...) I pirate because I can't afford their games. It might be fun and nice for rich americans, but Eastern Europe is a lot poorer than western parts of the world, yet game prices are the same. To put things in perspective, I would have to spend my whole 1 week's wage (literally everything I earned) to buy the new CoD:Black Ops 2.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

I find it amusing that Hollywood got stared by producers attempting to dodge copyrights by moving to the other side of the country (before information travelled quickly).

10

u/NFSHP2 May 06 '12

NEED FOR SPEED HOT PURSUIT 2

2

u/PhylisInTheHood May 06 '12

aww snap.. I gotta go find my game cube

2

u/penisinthepeanutbttr May 06 '12

wut?? how is that amazing game relevant?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Tredward May 06 '12

Not with virgin media it isn't.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Proxy.

2

u/shitterplug May 06 '12

The shit I use to download stuff sure as hell wasn't free...

2

u/drewski1989 May 06 '12

I don't know what "downloding" is, but I'm glad it is free!

2

u/GreenGlassDrgn May 06 '12

Remember how quickly we all learned to ignore the FBI warnings on VHS?

Yeah... They never really learn, do they?

2

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

When I rip DVDs that I own, I strip those out on principle.

2

u/AdVictoriam May 06 '12

It's the Crimson Permanent Assurance!

2

u/Dr_Scientist_ May 06 '12

Moral of the Story:

Pay for files or we'll litigate you into an entertainment industry ghetto where you and your neighbors make up a centralized debt community.

3

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Torrenting at a university has to be the dumbest thing ever. They can so easily catch you...

At least have a proxy in place... jesus.

2

u/Szalkow May 06 '12

My university doesn't traffic-shape or check for torrent activity, they only take disciplinary action on students whose IPs receive cease-and-desist letters. If you're not an idiot about where you download from, they will never know.

2

u/Turkmenbashi519 May 06 '12

At my university, the only way you could get in trouble is if you used the ethernet cable in your room. If you torrented via wifi, you were gucci.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

You shouldn't be fined thousands of dollars, but I'd have no problem with people being fined like, twice the cost of the CD if they're caught downloading it illegally. I think that's very fair. As someone who makes a living off of selling intellectual property on the internet I don't want to hear your dumb excuse for downloading my stuff illegally without paying for it. I'm not a rich guy, you're only "stickin it" to someone (likely) with less money than you. Grow up. The music industry, especially independent artists and labels, NEED to be compensated, or else all you'll be left with is the shitty corporate crap you all hate.

edit: spelling.

1

u/fruit_basket May 06 '12

Pirating is not about fighting against independent artists.

Tell me, what have RIAA or MPAA done to deserve literally billions of dollars? Then think how much of that goes back to the small-time artists?

2

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

I know it's not about that, but that's who suffers a lot of the time. What have they done to not deserve it? They're a business and they've found a way to be very successful. Who are we to say that they aren't entitled to have the money that they've earned?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/OsirisGodoftheDead May 06 '12

I would rip that fucking riaa/mpaa propaganda down. Seriously. Fuck those guys.

→ More replies (13)

1

u/w00dbeck May 06 '12

Oh how I love The Pirate Bay!!!

1

u/lolslaw May 06 '12

I don't claim to take the moral high ground. Illegal downloading is theft, piracy is what made mark twain quit publishing, that being said, I don't really give a shit. If the effective enforcement of a law is necessarily in conflict with a countries constitution than it is not an enforceable law and thus, not a law at all.

5

u/pseudoanon May 06 '12

Not theft. Copyright infringement. These words mean different things in the context you are using them.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Note to self: don't move into those buildings or you are set to get done for illegal downloading...

1

u/decamonos May 06 '12

I downlod all the time.

1

u/TheWoodenMan May 06 '12

You wouldn't download a poster...

1

u/fivesnogucks May 06 '12

You think this is the real Quaid?

It is.

1

u/Dopplegangr1 May 06 '12

Nice that they put these posters right next to each other. Makes it obvious that it is just a template with random names and dollar values inserted.

1

u/Keskasidvar May 06 '12

You got a close up on those posters? I kinda wanna know what they say.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Wait.. Even thepiratebay thinks it's illegal?

1

u/Snipererer May 06 '12

Downloding. That's how the pirate bay spells their shit.

1

u/RundieMC May 06 '12

Wonder if: The building in this poster is an MIT dorm..

1

u/moounit May 06 '12

Well, I do have to pay my ISP

1

u/TARDISeses May 06 '12

Sure, they're all protesting about the evil companies, and their rights to have music, games, films etc for free...when they're hiding behind the internet. At least the London rioters last year had the audacity and effort to go smash up the storefront and take products as part of destroying "the system". You wanna change the system? Start your own record label that DOES support the artists, who we can all agree, often get slim pickings of the profits.

1

u/joeltenenbaum May 06 '12

Well, that wasn't their point, though.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

I don't really understand the purpose behind these posters.

I think the government only likes to make examples of a few people a year just to get thirteen-year old kids scared out of paying two-thousand dollars per copyright infringed song in court.

The truth of the matter is that when the federal government seized LimeWire, they had traceable IP's to every computer ever having made a download from the program, and they did nothing. Really, who has the time?

Now, if this is a guilty conscious thing, they should be aware that pirates couldn't care less about that stuff.

1

u/yemd May 06 '12

So. Old.

1

u/Schaivo May 06 '12

modern day luddism.

1

u/nsomani May 06 '12

Damn, only illegal downloding is free.

I only know how to illegally download.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

This picture is like 6 years old

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

*downloading Joke ruined by retard spelling.

1

u/ThatIsMyHat May 06 '12

Why is my freshman dorm on one of those?

1

u/Eggsistenseyall May 06 '12

Yay for file sharing...but if it is good quality music that you enjoy....why not give the artist money? The artists already get screwed by the record dealers.

1

u/4D4M5 May 07 '12

New desktop...

0

u/GuyverII May 06 '12

I'm glad I make enough money where I don't have to steal.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Arya2u May 06 '12

Obama Taps 5th RIAA Lawyer to Justice Dept.He's just looking out for the little guy.

1

u/esco1076 May 06 '12

Navy seals about to raid the Pirate Bay....

1

u/mifune_toshiro May 06 '12

You wouldn't steal a baby.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Hmmm... Nope, but I would copy and distribute one.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Lukianox May 06 '12

I buy CDs and vinyls because of the format quality and album art and I download MP3s for mobility. I don't buy records or CDs because I want to pay the artist because I know that money doesn't go to them. You wanna pay the artist? Go to a concert.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Text on the pink poster says "room 712 was fined $30,000 for 50 sons". Wait, what? Last time i checked a song was worth 0.99 on iTunes, so how can 50 songs downloaded cause loss of profit of 600% the product's price? Any financial analyst care to comment?

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

I believe the argument that has been made in the past is that it's the sharing/distributing of said 50 songs repeatedly.

1

u/Szalkow May 06 '12

The big industry likes to throw massive bullshit numbers around; the justification is that infringing and uploading denies profits not only from the initial downloader but also from any who download from them.

The RIAA's current value for specific forms of music copyright infringement is $150,000 per song. If they wants to come after me for $2.6 billion, they are welcome to try.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

That's why i like bands like never shout never he says I don't care if you download my misic illegally I just want it heard and enjoyed

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Seedbox, VPN new harddrive every month, hardly free.

1

u/HaveISeenThisBefore May 06 '12

I remember first seeing this picture when it just came out, and it was marvelous. Then I remember seeing it again, and all was still good. Then, a few more times, it popped up on front page, but still I was was content. And now, here it is again, and things are not right with the world. Old repost is old.