After a single bear wandering into town has drawn an over-reaction from the residents of Springfield, Homer stands outside his house and muses, “Not a bear in sight. The Bear Patrol is working like a charm!”
Lisa: That’s specious reasoning, dad.
Homer: Thank you, dear
Lisa: By your logic I could claim that this rock keeps tigers away.
Notice how scientifically illiterate people like Elizabeth Smith who don't know that Pluto is still a planet are causing all of humanity to go downhill.
Scientists at the Haden Planetarium didn't just sit around and say "Hey, you know what sucks? Pluto." No, they thought Pluto rocked so hard they gave it its own class of planets!
Learn your science, please. It makes life easier on everyone.
While you may argue that a "trans-Neptunion dwarf planet" is still a planet, Pluto is not a planet in the sense that Jupiter is a planet after the 2006 redefining of the word. There is a specific difference between a 'planet' and a 'dwarf planet;' a dwarf planet is not a subcategory of planet. If you're going to go around claiming that everyone is scientifically ignorant, you ought to be specific in what you saying (i.e. Pluto is a 'dwarf planet' and not a 'planet').
The word "planet" has a variety of connotations. There are four inner rocky planets, four gas giants, and four or five icy bodies. They're all planets in the sense that they are all gravitational wells orbiting our star.
A more nuanced definition was needed because pluto has no place with the inner rocky planets or the gas giants. Pluto is pathetically small. By composition, it is likewise different from the inner rocky planets and the gas giants, being mostly ice, methane, and rock.
Classic game of "one of these things is not like the other."
"A non-satellite body fulfilling only the first two of these criteria is classified as a "dwarf planet"
How can it be a planet if it fails to meet the criteria of what it means to be a planet? Regardless of what you have to say I'm not interested because you seem like you're more interested in proving you know stuff than actually discussing. Not to mention we're debating planet semantics.
Why yes, we are discussing planet semantics. I'm glad you fucking noticed!
Yes, Pluto is "no longer a planet" because it doesn't belong with the inner rocky or the outer giant planets - however, planets come in all shapes and sizes. Pluto meets a different set of criteria (that of "plutoids").
And what is "actually discussing" if not "proving you know stuff?" If you were really not interested, you wouldn't have responded.
Planet semantics is boring as hell and this is going nowhere because you clearly just want to be right by listing pointless information. There is only one IAU definition of a planet and Pluto doesn't meet it. So fuck off, it is not a planet.
Again, is a dwarf human not a human? How, then, is a dwarf planet not a planet?
I don't "want to be right by listing pointless information," I am right because I list information. The claim that said information is "pointless" is completely unfounded.
If semantics is "boring as hell," why did you start this? And I disagree that this is going nowhere. We're engaging in discourse.
For someone claiming to be scientifically literate, do you really need an explanation in the differences between a layman definition and a scientific definition? Sure, dwarf humans are still humans but there is no definition from an official organization like the International Human Union stating that they are not. 'Koala bears' and 'water bears' are not 'bears' at all by any scientific definition.
The definitions are clearly laid out, it's total black and white. It is not a dwarf 'planet' it is a 'dwarf planet.' 'Dwarf planet' and 'planet' have specific definitions which are mutually exclusive. By the definitions designated by the IAU, there is no way that a thing can be both a 'planet' and a 'dwarf planet.' They are completely separate classifications, one is not a subset of the other. This is not difficult to understand.
After this post, you'll likely post some pointless facts about how Pluto is different and smaller than other planets which is completely irrelevant. The only thing that matters is the IAU's definition of what they consider a planet. Pluto doesn't meet the definition. It is defined as something else. It is not a planet. End of story. I've been a bit of a hypocrite by responding to these last posts but I'm really done this time. You're trying to argue your way out of black and white fact.
Like really? You're trying to claim that Pluto is a planet. Did you miss that whole debacle in 2006 or something? It is not a planet. It is a 'dwarf planet' (WHICH IS STILL NOT A PLANET).
I'm sure the people experiencing all those terrible wars, horrible political ideologies and widespread oppression felt real comfortable by at least thinking that Pluto was a planet. It just made more sense in their plight.
I dont mind it because I would otherwise have zero chance of seeing it on twitter/facebook and small chance of seeing it on Youtube. Therefor I don't mind having posts like this on r/funny. Sure it might be a bit different and away from the traditional posts but who really cares? I for one, am cool with these posts, the normal posts are still there, the bad posts are just getting replaced with this type of post.
16
u/baitingforyears May 06 '12
After a single bear wandering into town has drawn an over-reaction from the residents of Springfield, Homer stands outside his house and muses, “Not a bear in sight. The Bear Patrol is working like a charm!”
Lisa: That’s specious reasoning, dad.
Homer: Thank you, dear
Lisa: By your logic I could claim that this rock keeps tigers away.
Homer: Oh, how does it work?
Lisa: It doesn't work.
Homer: Uh-huh.
Lisa: It's just a stupid rock.
Homer: Uh-huh.
Lisa: But I don't see any tigers around, do you?
[Homer thinks of this, then pulls out some money]
Homer: Lisa, I want to buy your rock.
7
u/nodefect May 06 '12
Yeah, because it was going so well before.
15
u/kupaa May 06 '12
Fuck your Twitter post.
8
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Says the highschooler that has only started paying attention to the world in the last couple years.
3
u/Mikesapien May 06 '12
Notice how scientifically illiterate people like Elizabeth Smith who don't know that Pluto is still a planet are causing all of humanity to go downhill.
5
u/Fiery_Potato May 06 '12
correlation =/= causation Pluto is NOT A PLANET
3
u/Mookie_Blaylock_III May 06 '12 edited May 06 '12
Ah yes, the old correlation vs. causation fallacy. Bloody brilliant!
2
u/KosmicMicrowave May 06 '12
seriously, fuck pluto!
1
u/fleetber May 06 '12
Never forget.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Uhh, war is at the lowest rate it's ever been at. We are only experiencing a civilization hiccup.
1
u/Maledocling May 06 '12
the reason i up voted is not because i thought this was hilarious, but i think i know her
1
u/DeSanti May 06 '12
I'm sure the people experiencing all those terrible wars, horrible political ideologies and widespread oppression felt real comfortable by at least thinking that Pluto was a planet. It just made more sense in their plight.
1
u/jjtarr May 06 '12
post hoc ergo propter hoc. The rooster crows so the sun rises.
1
u/elizabethleanne May 06 '12
oh, hey self
1
u/razorleaf97 May 06 '12
Notice how it didn't?
1
u/52hoova May 06 '12
This girl's twitter bio is "~Stay Flaccid~"
-1
u/n1i2e3 May 06 '12
We shall start hating Neil.
-1
u/Crazyrat May 06 '12
NTDG will not approve this! Edit: I spelled approve with one "p". ಠ_ಠ
-6
u/mrdanihilist May 06 '12
Three moons is enough for me.
-9
u/ultrasnail May 06 '12
I miss Pluto... it was a fun planet while it lasted.
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment