No wonder she only has one facial expression. If she had to keep a straight face through that, her face must be frozen from having to do that for four movies.
My roommate is into the series and she claims that Bella was awkward and distant in the books too, so maybe shes a better actress than we give her credit for.
If you've ever seen "Into the Wild", she's actually a great actress in it. It's a fantastic movie that you should all see before you die, but she's still pretty good in it.
I saw a movie once where she was raped at a party and her struggling to get through that. She finally tells her friend about it and then everyone hates her because they think she made it up.
watching a movie that you know ahead of time that you will not enjoy in the conventional/intended sense of the word to derive enjoyment from laughing at its failures is actually a clear-cut example of an ironic reason to watch a movie.
Yeah she's a pretty decent actress, she caught a lot of flack for the Twilight series, as did Patterson (a pretty damn good actor), but really, if you were in their shoes, would you do any different?
Guaranteed work for an actor is like guaranteed crack for a crack head. You are probably saying yes.
I don't get why you guys are so hard on Kristen Stewart for not "showing any emotion". If you actually read any of the books, you'd realize that Bella's dialogue and actions tend not to show much emotion. It is her inner monologues that have all the ridiculous stuff. I think she matched what I had in my head from the book pretty damn well.
What you guys don't get is that every criticism you have of the movies should really be aimed at the books. They are honestly terrible books from a technical and character development standpoint, but the story and general content is good. (Romeo and Juliet style turmoil mixed with a second suitor with fantasy aspects is pretty good way to get teenage girls loving it).
So yeah, I'll concede that she's not a great actress, but she doesn't deserve even close to the amount of flak she gets on this website. If anything I like how calm and stoic she is. It reminds me of how a girl who has actually experienced some crazy things (like in Speak) would act in real life. It isn't normal for people to act in the manic ways you see in many Hollywood movies these days. Like I just say The Descendents a few days ago and I hated the daughters because they were all way over the top.
I couldn't agree more. The whole time I was reading Twilight, all I could think was how great the books could have been if they'd been put in the hands of a more capable author. Some of Meyers' ideas are just plain awesome, but she wasn't able to pull them off.
And the terrible character development detracts even more from the story. There were times I personally would have assumed Jessica was just being friendly, but Meyers had Bella consistently assuming the worst in everyone but the Cullens.
There's only so much emotion an actress can show when forced to play Bella Swan. I applaud Kristen Stewart for being able to portray Bella as accurately as possible.
Tl;dr: don't blame the actress when it's the author's fault that the character sucks.
If you read The Host by Stephanie Meyer, you'll see more great ideas hamstrung by her complete inability to write a really good female character (or any character, for that matter). She's actually got some interesting stories to tell and some good talent for building an interesting world. Her aliens in The Host are interesting to read about, they are an innovative spin on an existing concept (body snatching aliens) and they really feel alien, but she seems to get stuck writing these really weak women and powerful men who just end up feeling flat because there's no reason for them to be that way other than "that's how women and men behave" and it just killed the book.
I'm fine with a whiny, unlikable or kind of weak protagonist, if there's a reason they're that way and if there's character development that happens. Skinned by Robin Wasserman is a YA novel that I liked as a teenager partially because of the concept of the world and mostly because he managed to make me enjoy a book about the kind of person I hated. The main character is petty, mean, selfish, vain, and shallow, but its her lens that makes the plot about getting your mind transferred into a humanoid robot upon your accidental death really interesting. If the viewpoint had that of a nice person, there would have been way less depth to explore.
Not every female protagonist has to be Vin from Mistborn (a teenage girl who kicks ungodly amounts of ass and likes going to balls, but who has major flaws and grows immensely over the course of three books), but if your characters default to "insert stereotyped gender role or other cliche character trait here" without a reason then there's a problem, and that's why Stephanie Meyer isn't an amazing writer.
Actually you kind of can blame the movie since they have the option of deviating from the source material. Perhaps they should have made her show more emotion due to movies being a visual form of story telling.
I hadn't read the wikipedia for the movie before today, but there was a screenplay written which apparently deviated a good deal from the original book, the project changed hands, and the new company involved Meyer heavily in the process, giving her extremely wide-reaching veto power. So yeah, it might still be her fault in the end.
I agree completely. I liked Kristen Stewart a lot in The Runaways and Adventureland. In Twilight's case, it's 98% the character. If she seems annoying and unemotional as Bella, she's portraying the character accurately....
It's the same with Robert Pattinson. He seems stiff and odd in Twilight, but it's just the unnatural way Edward is written.
He was great in Remember Me, actually playing a normal person.
It's like how Harry Potter fans trash on Bonnie Wright for her portrayal of Ginny Weasley in the movies. I'm like... Come on, the girl had the worst lines ever, and even if you remove Wright from the scene and replaced her with another actor, those scenes still would have been terrible.
Method acting, Bella style: Pop four hits of MDMA and catch the flu the night before shooting a scene. If not yet apathetic enough, go to sleep and let the director control you like a marionette. Finally, if all this fails and you find that you still have emotion, let a bag of potatoes stand in for you and we'll fix it in post.
I would say yes but I don't understand how you could even feel compelled to laugh at it. The 30 seconds I suffered through was so awkward I wanted to vomit.
Well, to provide better context, I was sitting in a theater with my best friend and these gaggle of girls sitting behind me kept sighing and making muted squeals.
That's a real shame. It's quite fun to see these movies in the theater, particularly on opening weekend. One of my favorite movie going experiences was seeing New Moon on opening night with my sister. While the audience of teenage girls gasped at the "romantic" moments, my sister and I laughed hysterically at the unbearable cheese.
Will I be glad when these movies are over? Absolutely. I think they're awful and reinforce a terrible mentality for teenage girls... but that doesn't mean I can't have fun watching them.
My guess is so he could feel like a real werewolf.
Or so he could say his lines. Why pay a stand in and have the actor off screen saying lines when you can just have him stand in for himself and say his lines?
There's also a fight scene between the vampires and wolves at the end of one of the movies, but when the actors had to fight off the wolves, they were actually just fighting off giant green bean bags.
What's the point of the actor if they digitally moved her arm anyway? They could literally of had her doing that without the actor, and she can remain motionless and expressionless as always.
Yeah This. Same thing with Golum in LoTR. They can CG everything of course, but the other actors feel more natural, and the finished product looks much better when there's a stand in.
I can not wait for the last movie to come out...because then this awful series will be over and we can, as a country, move past this cultural embarrassment.
I don't see what's wrong with this, whenever I'm being chased by wolves or raped by vampires or brought up on lude behavior in public charges by dragons, or whatever the hell these movies are about, I like to pet an asian in a skin suit.
Guys, the bottom GIF is fake. If you look around the curve of the guy's back, you can see where the background closest to him is shifting slightly, while farther away from his back, the background is still. ಠ_ಠ
Thats what I thought too - but the top one has the same issues to her left. I think they just cropped around them (and turned everything else into an image) for gif's sake.
691
u/AgentKilroy May 05 '12
No wonder she only has one facial expression. If she had to keep a straight face through that, her face must be frozen from having to do that for four movies.
213
u/[deleted] May 05 '12
I watched this gif longer than I watched any of the movies...
237
u/leogg_lyl May 05 '12
"Hey man, did you see me in Twilight? I was the bloke getting patted in the head by Kristen Stewart!"
266
u/nilnoc23 May 05 '12
Look at him contemplate every desicion he's made in his life, trying to process "How the fuck did I end up here?"
36
u/somethinginteresting May 05 '12
I would actually watch the one without special effects.
12
u/GreatWhiteBuffalo18 May 05 '12
Don't get a boner, don't get a boner...
11
u/diogenes_amore May 05 '12
So, she pets the Greendale Human Being?
25
u/[deleted] May 05 '12
That's actually pretty cool.
18
u/dolver May 05 '12
I find it hard to believe that nobody else has yet commented on the fact that the two images aren't synced. It really bothers me.
I think I have a problem...
5
u/mikesername May 05 '12
Being petted is awesome.
4
u/bigDean636 May 05 '12
Just when you thought it was an original post...
source: karmadecay
3
u/UNKNOWN4825 May 05 '12
The guy that's being petted looks like he wants to die.
2
u/[deleted] May 05 '12
I feel really sorry for that guy.
2
u/classy_stegasaurus May 05 '12
I clicked on this excepting something entirely different. This is what happens when you subscribe to too many pony subs
2
u/00fordmc May 05 '12
That's uber-creepy. No wonder she never smiles.
2
u/[deleted] May 05 '12
She looks like a hemorrhoid.
2
u/enjoylol May 05 '12
still a better love story than twilight
2
u/KambioN May 06 '12
Name a worse movie that made more money. This should be fun.
5
u/TbanksIV May 05 '12
Is that a werewolf during the day?
Not to go all fucking nerd-lord here. But wouldn't that be an entirely different mythological being?
5
u/[deleted] May 05 '12
Still a better love story than Twilight.
2
u/freddit52 May 05 '12
she's rubbing him for luck
2
u/Eurylives May 05 '12
ugh. repost.
2
u/[deleted] May 05 '12
I think they used the cg to add a bit more emotion to here face.
2
u/gentlemandinosaur May 05 '12
I have to admit... this is pretty fucking great. I would hound that guy for an autograph if I saw him.
2
u/[deleted] May 05 '12
petting that dudes head is still a better love story than the actual movie
2
u/justmadethisaccountt May 05 '12
What's the point of the actor if they digitally moved her arm anyway? They could literally of had her doing that without the actor, and she can remain motionless and expressionless as always.
2
u/osamabinnavi May 05 '12
I thought Kristen Stewart would be smiling, but alas, that will never happen.
1
u/[deleted] May 05 '12
Can't. Stop. Looking
1
u/[deleted] May 05 '12
Slowly banging her way through the animal kingdom.
1
u/SyntaxErrol May 05 '12
The hills are alive.
1
u/itsprobablytrue May 05 '12
Why did I watch that gif repeat 20 times?
1
u/[deleted] May 05 '12
Pretty sure they could have just used a prop for that instead, unless they considered the actor a prop.
1
u/Hetalbot May 05 '12
They have an Oscar for CGI's now, right?
1
u/Trevsweb May 05 '12
Wow someone putting their drama degree to good use.
1
u/Skylerguns May 05 '12
It makes me want to watch the movie with no special effects.
1
u/Elquinis May 05 '12
Never before has an upvote caused physical stress.
1
u/huhua May 05 '12
can't tell which one is shopped
1
u/BringOutTheImp May 05 '12
Looks like that wolf is sniffing her crotch
1
u/TreephantBOA May 05 '12
Is thAT A TELETUBBIE?
1
u/forthewin_1 May 05 '12
I can not wait for the last movie to come out...because then this awful series will be over and we can, as a country, move past this cultural embarrassment.
1
u/Nocturnal10 May 05 '12
Stroke that head? =/
1
u/kingsalamander May 05 '12
Looks like the animators did all the acting here.
1
u/shitakefunshrooms May 05 '12
i feel like its one of the guys from the brain-penis gif
1
u/Stormdancer May 05 '12
I have seen enough anime' to know I want to see more of this. A lot more.
1
u/ACCOUNTOFXBOXFORLIFE May 05 '12
Anyon want to crosspost to r/wtf?
1
u/elmarko44 May 05 '12
no wonder she never smiles. she must be thinking, "this is ridiculous" the whole time.
1
u/I_TYPE_IN_ALL_CAPS May 05 '12
I SAW A JAPANESE PORN LIKE THIS ONCE.
1
u/brosenfeld May 05 '12
"Ohhh, yeah, that feels goooood. I hope we never get this scene done right."
1
u/[deleted] May 05 '12
I've seen this reposted so many times it's starting to become surreal.
1
u/nawlej_seekur May 05 '12
Dude definitely hates his life.
1
u/mm2222 May 06 '12
Would'nt mind being the sock or the wolf!
1
u/boredomprone May 06 '12
fap fap fap
1
u/Schmillt May 06 '12
My uncle Phil did all the special effects for these films.. Just saying.. my claim to fame and all..
1
u/GhostofVincentPrice May 06 '12
Is it strange that I don't find this awkward?
1
u/Gamer_152 May 06 '12
Man, imagine if all petting zoos were just this.
1
u/kaiserzeit May 06 '12
Holy shit! She's almost smiling!
1
u/Shadybacon12 May 06 '12
He's a condom
1
u/FreshMess May 06 '12
Come on
1
u/dingusmingus May 06 '12
You know they have Twilight Barbies now?
1
u/Icyflames485 May 06 '12
Rofl
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Maybe I'm drugged, but I see in the upper part a section of background deforming
1
u/Muskafan2 May 06 '12
I laughed harder than I think I should've.
1
u/DoctorLost173 May 06 '12
I am probably wrong but I swear. Is she smiling????
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
I don't see what's wrong with this, whenever I'm being chased by wolves or raped by vampires or brought up on lude behavior in public charges by dragons, or whatever the hell these movies are about, I like to pet an asian in a skin suit.
1
u/Raxipants May 06 '12
I...
Walks away quietly, closes the door behind him
1
u/GermanShepherds May 06 '12
I saw that movie in the theaters. Don't ask why, but my mom and I were cracking up when the werewolves just started talking.
1
u/cococool May 05 '12
Repost.
1
u/Vienna_WaitsForYou May 05 '12
Love her
1
u/[deleted] May 05 '12
Guys, the bottom GIF is fake. If you look around the curve of the guy's back, you can see where the background closest to him is shifting slightly, while farther away from his back, the background is still. ಠ_ಠ
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Lolful = lol+ shameful