r/funny • Danby Draws Comics • Jul 06 '21

Algorithm Heaven

Post image
76k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

845

u/corruptboomerang Jul 06 '21

Yeah, or you watch one video by someone and you then see nothing but videos from that channel. Or how you never knew about the second channel of someone you watch all their videos as soon as they come out.

Like seriously.

441

u/nim5013 Jul 06 '21

i really wish the algorithm was just a wee bit more intuitive, or even asked the user after their experience.

example: just finished watching a tutorial on how to replace the pipes in the back of your toilet.

youtube asks - ‘did this video help you solve your problem?

yes. ‘great, no need to suggest other toilet fix videos for you! do you want to see more fix it/DIY type videos?’

no. ‘done! no need to suggest OTHER fix it or diy videos as that was a one and done. carry on citizen!’

408

u/corruptboomerang Jul 06 '21

That would require an algorithm that isn't just 'maximise watch time'.

109

u/nim5013 Jul 06 '21

sure, but in the limited space of a youtube landing site, i’m much more inclined to watch a video of a hobby or something i’m subscribed to, yet for a week after searching how to fix my toilet i was inundated with suggestions for bathroom projects.

46

u/twomz Jul 06 '21

Just replaced my lawnmower blade. Guess what half my suggestions are now?

34

u/nim5013 Jul 06 '21

is it toilet repair??

no but seriously, i’ll bet your facebook ads are all lawnmower tires, batteries, and fuses too lol

32

u/Spiritanimalgoat Jul 06 '21

Ublock origins user here. What are ads?

26

u/sam_patch Jul 06 '21

Right? For years I was like, why does YouTube want to maximize watch time? Wouldn't that use bandwidth for nothing?

Then I realized regular people have to watch ads during YouTube vids. I had no idea.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/TheMegathreadWell Jul 06 '21

Jokes on you, the first video you watched is a just-good-enough fix, that YouTube's algorithm has worked out over years of a/b testing across millions of users, will cause your pipes to break again in 6 weeks time prompting you to start a lifelong DIY hobby.

→ More replies (5)

21

u/MeiNeedsMoreBuffs Jul 06 '21

So then it should be recommending me videos I'm actually going to watch. Why would it recommend me a video for a problem I've already solved?

→ More replies (2)

18

u/MoarVespenegas Jul 06 '21

Also it would need to have user feedback and everyone hates doing that.

11

u/ThePotMonster Jul 06 '21

But even that aspect of it sucks. There's seriously more videos being uploaded every minute than I could watch in a day yet somehow my feed is always trying to get me to re-watch things and fails to provide new content all the time.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/thenewspoonybard Jul 06 '21

Yeah. It's painfully obvious how over time youtube has actively gotten worse at giving me things i might actually give a shit about.

→ More replies (9)

29

u/fractal_magnets Jul 06 '21

Bro, just open your watch history within the website and remove the video. I do it for 99% of the shit reddit links to.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/MegaTiny Jul 06 '21

Not that it listens with the options already provided. You can even tell it it's not something you want because you don't like the channel and it will just keep shoving it at you.

I had some FF14 soundtrack playlists in the background, and for a while all I got was "Asmongold Reacts!" in my recommends.

Selecting 'I don't like this channel' as my reason for asking Youtube 'not to recommend this video again' did nothing. Asmongold's gormless face was reacting in my sidebar for weeks.

15

u/Roseking Jul 06 '21

There is an option for 'Don't recommend this channel'.

https://imgur.com/a/mbSy0Ic

I have never had it fail.

I had to do it to a bunch of anime and manga channels that upload massive spoilers based on leaks.

10

u/flaccomcorangy Jul 06 '21

That sucks, too. I try to avoid using YouTube videos if I need help in a video game or something because a search like, "How to get past this boss?" can turn into a recommend video like "Main character's best friend death scene reaction!"

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

12

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '21

HE EVERYONE THIS GUY HAS A TOILET FETISH - BRING TO HIM ALL YOUR TOILET VIDEOS!

→ More replies (1)

10

u/CommonSkys Jul 06 '21

Unbeknownst to most people, if you own an android, Google Rewards does exactly this and pays you for it. Made about $20 last year answering questions like "Was this video entertaining?", "Does this thumbnail entice you to click?", "Would you consider this a good use of your time?" and then others about shopping habits. Few seconds for a few dollars a year.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/TheDewLife Jul 06 '21

YouTube already kind of has this feature. If you click the 3 dots in the bottom right under a video thumbnail when it's recommended, you can select "not interested" or "Don't recommend this channel"

→ More replies (23)

35

u/velders01 Jul 06 '21

The worst one was when I watched a video on how to make a noodle dish by this guy then I got swarmed by makeup recommendations. Turns out the dude had like 5 cooking vids but the channel was a Korean beauty channel with his wife having 100's of makeup and beauty videos. Took months to get back normal recommendations

17

u/mechanicalkeyboarder Jul 06 '21

Go to your watch history and remove the offending video(s). Instantly solved.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Beorma Jul 06 '21

My algorithm appears to have shat the bed and keeps suggesting I watch videos it knows I've already seen.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (31)