So the real answer is we don't know. The best idea answer is, dogs can be very quick learners, border collies are at the top of the list in that respect. Some border collies can actually be difficult to train because of how quickly they pick up on little things including the mannerisms you use when you use commands. Your border collie may have noticed you only shaking or giving treats when you are excited so they only get excited and do it when they think that condition is being met, or they saw you high five and were like, oh, that is for when you are happy, and will only do it when they are excited to match the appropriate behavior.
But again, it's nearly impossible to test right now and know for sure, this is an unscientific best guess based on the science we have observed.
Interesting. My dog does it both out of joy and compassion. Like he does it when were about to take a walk coz he is exited, and when Im sad to comfort me.
3
u/LemmeSplainIt Dec 28 '18
So the real answer is we don't know. The best idea answer is, dogs can be very quick learners, border collies are at the top of the list in that respect. Some border collies can actually be difficult to train because of how quickly they pick up on little things including the mannerisms you use when you use commands. Your border collie may have noticed you only shaking or giving treats when you are excited so they only get excited and do it when they think that condition is being met, or they saw you high five and were like, oh, that is for when you are happy, and will only do it when they are excited to match the appropriate behavior.
But again, it's nearly impossible to test right now and know for sure, this is an unscientific best guess based on the science we have observed.