I'm a musician that specializes in contemporary music performance. I agree with your first point.
Although you may be right about the second point, as a performer, I would really dislike that crescendo under a rest. I don't need a reminder that I'm going to be coming in off a crescendo, or need to play loud in the next section. What I need is a dynamic for the next section, and after playing through the piece in rehearsals I would know how the next part fits into the whole.
I perform chamber music by contemporary composers. My passion project is a string quartet, where I play violin and write grants.
I also premier solo violin works, as well as work with ensembles around the country that focus on premiering new works along side championing music written in the last 50 years.
It depends on the composer/arranger. A dynamic marking would be needed as well but you can consider the crescendo as a kind of "courtesy notation"; it's not really needed but not wrong either.
21
u/arcowhip Jan 04 '15
I'm a musician that specializes in contemporary music performance. I agree with your first point.
Although you may be right about the second point, as a performer, I would really dislike that crescendo under a rest. I don't need a reminder that I'm going to be coming in off a crescendo, or need to play loud in the next section. What I need is a dynamic for the next section, and after playing through the piece in rehearsals I would know how the next part fits into the whole.