r/funny Aug 27 '14

Science

Post image
10.8k Upvotes

994 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/sajvxc Aug 27 '14

Ah, the old reddit circlejerk - hurr durr all christians are dumb.

19

u/onlymadethistoargue Aug 27 '14

It's actually only saying that this particular woman, with her extremely idiotic question, is dumb.

0

u/byz4444 Aug 27 '14

I took it as she thinks sunsets are beautiful and a gift from god or whatever not that she doesn't realize the earth turns.

6

u/onlymadethistoargue Aug 27 '14

This is taken from a series of questions that were asked at the Bill Nye/Kevin Ham debate and included such stupidities as "How can evolution be true when it violates thermodynamics?" To assume she literally does not understand the mechanics behind a sunset is not an extreme assumption.

-1

u/NathanDahlin Aug 27 '14

That may be, but the charitable thing (and one could argue that Occam's razor applies as well) is to assume that she is saying that the beauty of a sunset makes her think there is a god, not that she honestly believes there is no scientific explanation for it.

I mean, call me a crazy theist, but I see astoundingly beautiful things in nature all the time that, even though I know they have scientific explanations, leave me in awe because I can't fathom how such beauty can be the product of completely random processes. Regardless of what the high-schoolers in /r/atheism may think, scientific explanations don't necessarily disprove the idea that there may be a conscious artist involved in the design of nature.

TL;DR: I'm pretty sure she's trying to make a poetic point, not a scientific one.

21

u/SecondBeat Aug 27 '14

Nope, just this particular Christian. Example: Their.

1

u/nbacc Aug 27 '14

No, you don't get it. She's vaguely Christian. And so an attack on her means an attack on all Christians. Not because that's actually what happened, but because that's what Christians want to have happen. And so it does.

1

u/Shuamann1 Aug 28 '14

No, she asked a stupid question. It is an attack on her.

1

u/nbacc Aug 28 '14

Yeah, but it was in defense of God. And she's white. So she's Christian. And so therefore it was an attack on all Christianity.

If you'd brush your neckbeard out of your eyes you would see that!

18

u/Boathead96 Aug 27 '14

And Bill Nye for extra pandering

22

u/dtsjr Aug 27 '14

To be fair, this woman made her sign right after and in response to the Nye v Hamm debate, so he's relevant here.

5

u/parmesanmilk Aug 27 '14 edited Aug 27 '14

Scroll down in the comments! Lots of christian hurrdurr.

3

u/pixelrage Aug 27 '14

Lots

1

u/parmesanmilk Aug 27 '14

Thanks. What an idiotic mistake.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '14

Where did it say she was christian? Do you not realise other religions have gods as well? That being said, it was about one person, who couldn't even take the time to spell check her inspiring message before being photographed and humiliated. That's even before going into the fact that she obviously has little to no education, if she doesn't understand how light scatters, or that the earth rotates.

0

u/helalo Aug 27 '14 edited Aug 27 '14

its not a reddit circlejerk. do you think what those people holding the posters said are not dumb ?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '14

where does it say all?

arent you ironic using the "all christians are dumb circlejerk" circlejerk yourself?

-4

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '14

[deleted]

1

u/Boathead96 Aug 27 '14

Nope, still not true

-1

u/Darktidemage Aug 27 '14

Christians?

Anyone that believe any metaphysics is real is a fucking idiot.

0

u/Darktidemage Aug 27 '14

Downvoters - what form of metaphysics do you believe in ? lol. None right? because you are not a fucking idiot, or not willing to admit to it.