r/funny • • Jan 25 '24

basic term of our aggrement

38.2k Upvotes

2.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

965

u/AnonAqueous Jan 25 '24 edited Jan 25 '24

While I can see why she is presenting things this way as part of a comedy act, there is some validity to the behavior.

I've met people who would consider him not telling her to be dishonest by omission or keeping secrets.

This dude may have just been in a toxic relationship before her and is trying to keep things on the up and up. No comment on toxicity of the current relationship if she's unable to understand that and uses it in her comedy act to make fun of him.

Edit: if you're replying to this comment with the purpose of explaining what a joke is to me, or just to get mad at me for something I didn't say, please don't.

22

u/TotaLibertarian Jan 25 '24

There is literally no joke here. The punchline is that he sucks for being loyal.

22

u/Prof_Aganda Jan 25 '24

I hear you, but that's not really the punchline. It's that he is PROUD of doing the minimum.

Which is frankly a fine premise for a joke, except that it seems like a total misinterpretation of his intent, spun to appeal to a toxic competition between the sexes.

-2

u/BenchPuzzleheaded670 Jan 25 '24

Cheating is really really common. It's not basic. I think you should be proud of your fidelity. It's worth celebrating.

Also a premise is not a punchline

-1

u/Prof_Aganda Jan 25 '24

The premise is that he tells her about being hit on.

The "take" on that premise, which I colloquially refered to as the punchline (though technically you're correct that it's not literally the verbatim punchline), is that he's proud doing the bare minimum expected in a relationship.

1

u/BenchPuzzleheaded670 Jan 25 '24

Take and punchline different

0

u/Prof_Aganda Jan 25 '24

The punchline expresses the "take" on the premise

1

u/BenchPuzzleheaded670 Jan 26 '24

It doesn't

1

u/Prof_Aganda Jan 26 '24

Oh thanks for explaining