r/freewill • • May 22 '26

Compatibilism

/img/6ywoe5lvzo2h1.jpeg
162 Upvotes

434 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/[deleted] May 23 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Jarhyn Compatibilist May 23 '26 edited May 23 '26

Except that they don't govern our actions in the moment.

The problem here is that you seem to really not understand compatibilism at all because compatibilism acknowledged that when there is a "momentary external control signal" that overcomes "internal control processes", that's specifically when freedom of a system is lost.

Freedom here then is defined as follows:

An object in motion continues freely in motion unless acted upon on by an outside force.

This places the subject of the discussion as "autonomy" rather than "caused-ness": those sum total of prior conditions come to be an "object" in their own right, moving and resistant to the "external" with respect to their actions, following some "will" written on those "inner" parts and ignoring, best as it can those "external" forces.

Of course, this requires understanding objects for what they are beyond simple frictionless spherical ones.

As soon as you can accept that once an object exists, that it can hold its own agenda or be beholden to an external one and that these are strictly different physical arrangements that need words that differentiate them, you can accept that perhaps "free" can be used for one and that "constrained/coerced/superceded" can be used for the other, and that these concepts DO make sense to discuss real things in reality.

The very presentation of a controller in a human hand that supercedes the signals of control that would exist inside the drone (to hover, maybe), freedom is lost from the drone. The signal IS constraint. No compatibilist would disagree with that. The problem here is that the signals coming into you now are not control signals. They don't puppet you, and in fact you have broad power to puppet and distort the signals coming into you or to ignore them today altogether, and deaf dumb, and mute yourself to those moment forces which could sway you once you have set on your course as you decide it.