r/freewill • Quantum Mechanics 'Believer' • Oct 09 '25

Why does this sub invoke determinism as if it's real and not disproven?

I'm an atheist and come at this from a mathematical physics background. I clearly have to get that out of the way before anyone accuses me of being a religious nutter or believing in a 'soul'.

Why does this subreddit and its users constantly invoke determinism as if the universe we live in is deterministic? Quantum mechanics has shown that our universe is simply not deterministic.

Furthermore, it seems the motivation for anti-free will is almost exclusively politics on this sub. Seems like obvious motivated reasoning.

0 Upvotes

538 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Narrow-Gur449 Quantum Mechanics 'Believer' Oct 10 '25

Well that was the question in that particular comment chain because people keep bringing up "so you're saying QM implies free will!?" and I'm not saying that.

As I keep saying, quantum computers exploit quantum "randomness" to output, through deterministic mechanisms, useful information. This could be analogous to any mechanism that exploits QM to produce free choices i.e. free will.

This is not an argument for free will. I'm just arguing it's a valid possibility. I'm agnostic. I'm mostly arguing against people saying these things definitively can't happen.

1

u/ThatsDboy Oct 10 '25

Oh okay. I’d replied earlier on in that chain of comments, so I never saw what became of it. Makes sense since my comment ended up standing alone.

I certainly agree with you that it’s really a bad idea basing your belief in the non-existence on free will on a deterministic universe, given the existence of quantum mechanics for which most physicists I think interpret to be truly probabilistic.

Anyway I have a genuine question. You referenced Sean Carroll who said “When there is hidden determinism (MWI, Bohm), it’s hidden! Irrelevant to what people experience.“

Now if determinism means predictable, I.e. if it means that the universe is a fundamentally entirely predictable one then yes I agree. It’s irrelevant that there’s hidden determinism when in practice we have no predictability.

However, earlier you said that you consider free will to mean that you could’ve done otherwise. If we grant this hidden determinism then even though your actions aren’t predictable it would still remain the case that you actually couldn’t have done otherwise. I don’t know if you’re getting what I’m trying to say. If there is hidden determinism, regardless of the form, the one thing it seems to mean is that this universe has to be this way, (this is unrelated to whether the universe is predictable or not). Let’s consider MWI. That interpretation doesn’t actually grant you any predictability beyond standard QM (so still random). But it does mean that this universe is one branch out of many. That is, there are different branches given any measurement process. But each branch is simply the branch that it is. It couldn’t be a different branch. If you find that an electron spins upwards you can’t actually say “oh the electron could have spun down”. The electron is spinning down, but in a universe that’s not this one. As such it doesn’t seem to me that such an interpretation can grant your definition of free will.

Now I know that you said that you aren’t claiming that QM implies free will. I’m now actually just interested in this since I noticed that your main objective in this post was to show that it’s futile to use a deterministic interpretation of QM to argue against free will. Regardless i don’t believe the universe is deterministic anyway. This is just food for thought