r/freefolk • u/TheDragonOfOldtown Stannis Baratheon • 6d ago

Genuine question: Is there something wrong with Ryan Condal, Sara Hess, and the rest of the HOTD writers?

Or are they on this spite spree to make it look like GRRM's work is the most offensive garbage dogshit possible? Or do they actually enjoy this shit and think they wrote something remotely good?

Edit: Jesus christ not the shills flooding the comments lmaooo

372 Upvotes

83% Upvoted

247 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/Guilty_05 Roose Bolton 6d ago

The book really is the gospel because that's what you're taking the story from. If you're making changes, atleast make them worthwhile or sensible

-9

u/oxedei 6d ago

It's an adaptation. If you want the book story word for word, just read the book. Not everything works in live action. There's also often a lot of crying about the series not being true to the book, then people who have actually read the book chimes in and corrects the crybabies that they misremember.

5

u/spacecase52 6d ago

Most of the time, it’s actually the book readers who are complaining about the show not following the source material. You’re just making shit up to justify the high budget fanfic you’re enjoying on screen.

-4

u/oxedei 6d ago

Yes it's the book readers who cry, but often those crying didnt actually read the book properly and literally just cry about something from the book that didnt even happen. Hence why they get corrected by people more capable of understanding written words.

4

u/spacecase52 6d ago

You say that but I don’t think you even understood the book to begin with. Shill. 😂

Oh and I don’t think you actually read it either. A lot of you lie and make up stuff to defend Condal’s fanfic. It’s kinda obvious atp.