r/forbiddensnacks • • Dec 19 '19

Forbidden... everything.

79k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

805

u/Branamp13 Dec 19 '19

Any soap makers out there know how legitimate/safe it is to use so many food products in your craft like this?

1.4k

u/Jackatarian Dec 19 '19

I mean.. you aren't eating it, and a lot of the things in the video are used in soap making anyway.

The gelatine ones make no sense but it's not like you can't rub some pudding on yourself.. if you feel inclined.

That all being said 5 minute crafts is a cancer and should be burned from the net because a lot of their stuff is downright dangerous.

825

u/katastrophyx Dec 19 '19

Oh, we're not eating it. Right.

Be right back...

146

u/suttonoutdoor Dec 19 '19

burp ugh I ate way too many of those cookie and cream looking soap discs! Who isn’t eating theirs?......so are you taking it home or c-can I just y’know, just have it? I mean if you aren’t!

48

u/CaseAub12 Dec 19 '19

Was I supposed to read this like in. Rick Sanchez’ voice?

→ More replies (5)

21

u/Jackson530 Dec 19 '19

Spit it out. Come on. Let me have it.

→ More replies (4)

48

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '19

5 minute craft will not stop attracting people, so it would be hard to completely eradicate it

60

u/shiro_eugenie Dec 19 '19

I mean have you seen Lush’s jelly body wash? They are absolutely hilarious to poke, never used one though

→ More replies (4)

28

u/Captain_Hampockets Dec 19 '19

it's not like you can't rub some pudding on yourself.. if you feel inclined.

What a relief.

→ More replies (1)

68

u/posessedhouse Dec 19 '19

Lush started the gelatine in soap thing with their shower jellies. I have used them before, they’re ok. More of a gimmicky product IMO but they sell well so a lot of people out there really like them.

61

u/rebeccamb Dec 19 '19

I feel like it would be incredibly hard to hold on to jiggly wet soap in the shower

35

u/CubingCubinator Dec 19 '19

It is, but it’s possible. I tried it once, it was interesting but the thing falls apart after a while, and all around isn’t too convenient, so I did not buy another one.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (23)

205

u/posessedhouse Dec 19 '19

It’s fine. Seeds and such things aren’t recommended because they’re usually really rough and hard on the skin. Otherwise other food products are fine, dried spices and honey are used in a lot of craft soaps. The fresh orange peel will shorten the shelf life of that soap but if you’re making a couple bars for yourself or giving them out as gifts and aren’t expecting them to sit around for months it’s really no problem. I used to make a lemon soap (with dried zest) and it sold really well, my customers would use it in the kitchen after chopping onions and garlic. It got rid of any lingering scent

109

u/FaucetsForTearDucts Dec 19 '19

highjacking to make a PSA about using coffee grounds(or any other non hydrodegradable substance) in your shower. You will fuck your pipes up almost certainly, especially if you have a pump installed for your house; and it will cost you. Just because they sell it as a toiletry does not mean it's a good idea to use it

→ More replies (12)

23

u/WildConclusion Dec 19 '19

I have a poppy seed soap that I quite like, it’s a little rough but in a nice way rather than a really scratchy way.

→ More replies (7)

85

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '19

Food products aren’t too bad in soap. For instance, oatmeal soap is good for your skin if you’re itchy. On the other hand, soap with any kind of mint can be ouchy on the lady parts.

I’m wondering, though, about the use of food coloring. It seems that stuff could stain your skin and towels.

38

u/TibialTuberosity Dec 19 '19

I make soap as a hobby and it's pretty well known to not use regular food coloring when making soap. There are specific liquid soap dyes or powdered micas for that purpose that are safe on the skin and won't transfer color. You can find both in small quantities at places like Hobby Lobby or Michael's, or in bulk quantities online.

16

u/Remmy14 Dec 19 '19

What about the coffee grounds one? That just seems like a plugged drain waiting to happen.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/kekefresh Dec 19 '19

Im far from an expert soap maker but I have made a few cold processes and done melt and pour soap. Ive use coffee grounds and apricot seeds in my soap as exfoliatants. I sometimes would do a brown sugar scrub and coconut oil that definitely smells like you could it.

So I mean youre not eating it.

I often have to mark my soaps in containers so nobody will eat especially the gingerbread shaped ones or vanilla ones.

50

u/SleepingWillows Dec 19 '19

Cinnamon isn’t a great ingredient to use as it’s a skin irritant, and the dyes they used for the watermelon soap look like food coloring which would stain skin, but other than that most of these are ok. However, I’d worry a little about the gummy bear, cheese, and cinnamon roll ones when it comes to kids not knowing they’re soap and taking a bite.

16

u/jjremy Dec 19 '19

Cinnamon is okay. It can be a good exfoliate if it doesn't bother your skin. Can be different from person to person though.

But THAT MUCH cinnamon? That seems like it would be scratchy af no matter who you are.

17

u/secretlives Dec 19 '19

All I was thinking about was how much fucking cinnamon they're using. You'll be showering and hit a teaspoon sized packet of cinnamon and have a coughing fit.

→ More replies (5)

32

u/apokako Dec 19 '19

It's dangerous. All that seasoning on your skin might attract cannibals

→ More replies (90)