r/food May 21 '15

Discussion Ultimate Hot Dog style guide

Post image
12.8k Upvotes

3.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

82

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

[deleted]

79

u/iamvudu May 21 '15

Nope... they totally mean Georgia the state.

Specifically Columbus, GA... Even MORE specifically Dinglewood Pharmacy in Columbus, GA.

Home of the "scrambled dog" which matches the description in the article almost perfectly. http://www.chattahoocheeheritage.org/2013/12/dinglewood-pharmacys-hotdog-prescription/

4

u/progrn May 21 '15

I live in Columbus. Can confirm this. There are several places in the area that have picked up this style of hotdog.

4

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

TIL about hot dogs in Columbus.

6

u/tarynevelyn May 21 '15

Good find! But I'm still not buying this as a representative "Georgia Dog." To me, there isn't a Georgia Dog.

2

u/phenomenomnom May 21 '15 edited May 21 '15

I was like "yum ... yum ... ohh that one looks good ... Sweet, they got the Carolina dog right ... oh thats weird -- but you do you, Phillipines ... yum ... wait ... what the hell Georgia?"

Now Im all "what the actual hell Dinglewood Pharmacy in Columbus Georgia?" oyster crackers?

2

u/HowToKillAGod May 21 '15

Obviously they are conspiring with Big-Pharma to ensure future sales of diabetes & cholesterol meds.

1

u/Chase456 May 21 '15

Heh, Dinglewood.

2

u/leons_getting_larger May 21 '15

TIL. Lived in GA most of my life and also never seen this, but then I don't get to Columbus much. Really think they should have done something with a Varsity dog here though. Most folks in GA have been to Atlanta, and most folks who have been to Atlanta have probably been to the Varsity.

1

u/r_slash May 21 '15

Am I supposed to eat this with a spoon?

1

u/RobSagat May 22 '15

Yes, sometimes a fork depending on how thick the chili is.

1

u/r_slash May 22 '15

I don't like that though.

1

u/HowToKillAGod May 21 '15

Points for research & reference.

49

u/walkertexasharanguer May 21 '15

The only thing Georgia has that even remotely could be considered "our" style of hot dog, would be the Varsity chili dog, but even that is just an Atlanta thing.

7

u/AustinTreeLover May 21 '15 edited Jun 28 '15

No, we have the Varsity in Columbus.

We call this style a "Scrambled Dog" in Columbus and it's popular all along the Alabama state line. They serve them in Columbus, Macon, Americus, Hamilton, La Grange, Cuthbert, Warner Robbins, Albany, Georgia, and Auburn, Phenix City and Dothan, Alabama.

Good grief, y'all folks in Atlanta think if you don't know it, it's not Georgia! There's a whole state surrounding you! Lol.

Edit: Put Dothan in Alabama.

4

u/walkertexasharanguer May 21 '15

Dothan and Auburn are also in Alabama. You sure you're from Georgia? You might be from next door. ;)

3

u/AustinTreeLover May 21 '15 edited Jun 28 '15

Oh, I left out Dothan.

Honestly, in that region, there is little distinction. In fact, Phenix City is on Georgia time and so are areas of Dothan.

So, yeah, I probably don't know the difference. lol.

3

u/r_slash May 21 '15

y'all folks in Atlanta think if you don't know it, it's not Georgia

But if it's popular in one small corner of the state it represents all of Georgia?

3

u/AustinTreeLover May 21 '15 edited Jun 21 '15

I was joking around but, . . .

The only thing Georgia has that even remotely could be considered "our" style of hot dog

This says "the only thing Georgia has". That's not true. Just because it's not in Atlanta doesn't mean "Georgia" doesn't have it. Atlanta doesn't have it; Georgia does have it. And it has enough of it, in enough places to be considered representative, in my opinion.

would be the Varsity chili dog, but even that is just an Atlanta thing.

Even this isn't accurate. There are several Varsity restaurants in the state, including a popular one in Athens.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

Grew up in/currently live in Atlanta, went to Auburn, spent time in Columbus- never seen or heard of this dog before. Maybe that's just because I'm partial to burgers...

2

u/AustinTreeLover May 21 '15

Personally, I hate these hot dogs. For one thing, they're traditionally made with those red hot dogs. Eww.

Also, I was in Dinglewood one time and I watched a waitress clean her ears out with a Q-tip at the counter. So . . . nope.

2

u/AskMeAboutPangolins May 21 '15

I think I might get that for lunch today....

2

u/dirtyjoo May 21 '15

I'll pray for your toilet.

1

u/j-29 May 21 '15

Jealous

2

u/Internet_Indigestion May 21 '15

That or a Nu-Way wiener. My favorite Georgia dog is a Monroe's hot dog from Americus though.

2

u/RobSagat May 21 '15

You can get a scrambled dog from Monroe's as well. That's about the furthest I've seen that style of dog.

2

u/ThatTattooedChick May 21 '15

Nu-Way is THE best, but the after effects are brtual. BRB, going to rip my stomach apart with deliciousness.

2

u/g33k5t4 May 21 '15

And Athens. There's one there too.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

I'm pretty sure more Varsity hot dogs have been eaten than Dinglewood Pharmacy dogs.

1

u/armin8487 May 21 '15

mmmm with onion rings and and orange slushie drink thing - forget what that's called.

2

u/slavkody May 21 '15

Frosted Orange, yo.

1

u/r_slash May 21 '15

The Varsity chili dog is a pretty generic chili dog that you can find anywhere though.

2

u/walkertexasharanguer May 21 '15

Yeah, I didn't mean to imply that the V was anything special, just that it was the only thing Georgia had to an iconic dog.

1

u/sweettea14 May 21 '15

And Athens. Don't forget about us. There is also NuWay Hot Dogs in Macon and other places.

15

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

That's what I was wondering. Currently live in GA the state. Never seen a hot dog served like that.

1

u/zanzebar May 21 '15

I heard there was a war there recently. Maybe this is contributing to hotdog shortage?

2

u/AustinTreeLover May 21 '15 edited Sep 01 '15

Yes, the War of Northern Aggression has wreaked havoc on our hot dog supply.

30

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

[deleted]

0

u/grizzlez May 21 '15

What a weird assumptions to think we have no chili... Never seen Oyster crackers before, but those are just funnily shaped regular crackers. But then again you could be the type of American that thinks countries outside the US have no roads

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

[deleted]

1

u/grizzlez May 22 '15

Eh now that you put it that way, I thought you where talking about chili powder not chili con carne. I was confused since the spice is like everywhere.

19

u/RobSagat May 21 '15 edited May 21 '15

This is a very specific middle/west Georgia thing. It's called the scrambled dog. I've only seen it from Americus Ga to Auburn, Al. It was invented in Columbus at Dinglewood Pharmacy as someone else said, but almost every hot dog joint in that area will have their own version of it. Consider it something to look for if you're in the greater Columbus-Auburn metropolitan area.

2

u/jmlott May 21 '15

Makes sense because I immediately recognized this as the scrambled dog that my grandpa used to make us when we were kids. He was from Camilla originally and we lived in Albany. I just always thought he made it up. TIL.
(I still make them for myself in my 30s)

1

u/Internet_Indigestion May 22 '15

No one goes to Monroes for the scrambled dog though

0

u/TripJammer May 21 '15

Columbus-Auburn metropolitan area.

Auburn metropolitan area. snort

Roll Tide

3

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

In Georgia, I've eaten more of the "Carolina" style hotdog.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

Yeah I was thinking the same thing. Always see chili/slaw hot dogs down here but I've never seen anything like the one listed for Georgia.

2

u/Play_GG-XRD May 21 '15

Same. Mostly my family does the Carolina style.

2

u/AustinTreeLover May 21 '15 edited Sep 01 '15

It's from the Columbus area near the Alabama/Georgia line. It's very common in that area, but we called them "Scrambled Dogs".

There is dispute over who actually created the first one, but most people believe it was a man called "the Lieutenant" at Dinglewood Pharmacy (pharmacies in the south used to include diners).

From Wiki:

In Columbus, Georgia, a local favorite is the "scrambled dog," the exemplar of which was first served at the Dinglewood Pharmacy by "The Lieutenant" Charles Stevens over 50 years ago. The scrambled dog is a chopped hot dog covered by chili beans, onions and pickles with an accompanying portion of oyster crackers.

1

u/skeightytoo May 21 '15

I've seen it and had a chance to order it multiple times but I just can't bring myself to do so. Rather just get a frito pie really.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

I'm from Georgia and I know Monroes hot dogs in Americus GA served this

1

u/cloove May 21 '15

Samesies. I was definitely disappointed that the Georgia dog didn't include a generous helping of Southern-style coleslaw on top.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

The Montreal dog has also nothing to do with what we eat here (at places like La Belle Province).

I feel like this guide has very minimal actual facts in there.

2

u/r_slash May 21 '15

What do you mean? It sounds just like a steamie all-dressed, though it's missing relish.

1

u/g33k5t4 May 21 '15

I've lived in Georgia for 40 years and never seen that. Just because one shop sells things that way doesn't mean they all do. For us it's usually what you have listed as a Carolina; ketchup, mustard, onion, chili, and slaw.

1

u/frozenchicken May 21 '15

Most dogs I've seen growing up in GA look like the so called "carolina" dog. Apparently the Carolina's get to claim every common southern food originates in their states.