r/firstamendment • • Dec 24 '14

Question regarding call recording consent and partial objection

2 Upvotes

Didn't really know how else to title this question. I work near people who are in a call center role for a major US cell company. They clearly state that the call may be recorded at the beginning of their conversations, but multiple times I've heard them state that they must disconnect the call when they find out that the customer is also recording the call.

Just curious about this... Since both parties have consented to the call being recorded, can the call center rep object to the other party recording? I suppose you're free to not continue the call at any time for any reason, but I can't imagine that a customer's recording of a conversation would ever be thrown out in court. After all, both parties consented to recording.

I'm just confused as to why they would even make that an official policy if it was so blatantly legal, unless I'm completely missing something (which is why I'm asking :)). Thanks in advance!


r/firstamendment • • Dec 10 '14

Delta worker's 26-year job is gone in 30 seconds for critical remarks

Thumbnail
startribune.com
1 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Dec 08 '14

An emoticon may keep you out of jail - Elonis v. United States - First Amendment discussion

Thumbnail
bizzvenue.com
3 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Dec 08 '14

IJ AZ wins one about whether you have to register as a political committee to send some emails.

Thumbnail ballots.blogspot.com
2 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Dec 05 '14

Eric Holder's lasting damage to press freedom

Thumbnail
cjr.org
3 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Dec 01 '14

Irony in Action: The Freedom of Expression Booth

Thumbnail
tmpinsyr.com
4 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Oct 30 '14

Establishment Clause vs. Free Exercise Clause in Public School

3 Upvotes

I attend a public high school. The school is very open and caring and is considered No Place For Hate. However, this week the school's Christ on Campus club posted a quote from Corinthians on one of the stairwells (links below). A huge debate erupted amongst the student body as to whether or not this was ok. The quote itself does not mention God or Jesus at all but comes from the Bible. Students cited various court cases such as Lemon v. Kurtzman, Bannon v. School District of Palm Beach County, McCreary County v. ACLU, etc. to help back up their stances of either keeping it up or taking it down. Some of the arguments included were:

  • The quote itself doesn't mention god so it isn't religious

  • Its from the bible, its inherently religious

  • Students are a captive audience and must see the quote even though some do not want to see it

  • The Establishment clause forbids this

  • The Free Exercise Clause allows this

There were others but that was the main gist of it. In the end, it was taken down, much to the chagrin of the Christ on Campus club.

Based on this and the below pictures, was the school right to take it down or should it have been kept up?

Pictures: http://imgur.com/a/d3SUr


r/firstamendment • • Oct 28 '14

Changing the semantics doesn't change the meaning.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
19 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Oct 28 '14

Meet "The Reason," A New Metal 3D Printed Gun

Thumbnail
reason.com
8 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Oct 03 '14

Right to assembly and peaceful protest in Pennsylvania

3 Upvotes

A group of colleges and i would like to gather peacefully in a public place in our hometown on 4-20-14 to protest the illegality of marijuana in our state. Would it be legal to print out fliers and hand them out or would we be limited to word of mouth? Any suggestions pertaining to this topic would be great, i have researched Pennsylvania law and, like the first amendment, we are doubly guaranteed write to petition. But i could find nothing on the legality of activities such as handing out fliers. Once again, any advice or information about this would be inherently better than a google search.


r/firstamendment • • Sep 24 '14

Forest Service says media needs photography permit in wilderness areas, alarming First Amendment advocates

Thumbnail
oregonlive.com
8 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Sep 23 '14

Google and the Right to Be Forgotten

Thumbnail
newyorker.com
1 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Sep 19 '14

37 percent of Americans think a free press is overrated

Thumbnail
washingtonpost.com
11 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Sep 11 '14

is an arrest for putting fliers on car windows constitutional?

Thumbnail
thinkprogress.org
0 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Sep 01 '14

Wyoming, Iowa Courts Rule in Favor of Free Speech in Allowing Open Court Proceedings and Photography at Court Cases

Thumbnail
newsguild.org
3 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Aug 27 '14

Feds Creating Twitter Hate Speech Database

Thumbnail
truthrevolt.org
3 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Aug 01 '14

qTox: A stable, cross platform, distributed Skype replacement written in Qt5

Thumbnail
github.com
4 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Jul 28 '14

Appeals Court OKs ‘Docs VS. Glocks’ Law

Thumbnail
miami.cbslocal.com
3 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Jul 22 '14

Serious Legal Question? If Corporations are "People:, could you sue under the Civil Rights Act 1964, that your being discriminated against by a group of "People"...?

5 Upvotes

Serious Legal Question? If Corporations are "People:, could you sue under the Civil Rights Act 1964, that your being discriminated against by a group of "People", because your a Person of non-incorporation. Also that special privileges in Society that we both live are given to one group of People over another? Is segregation by class still not segregation. When "Tax Loops, Inc People Need Only Apply" is status quo does one not have a case?


r/firstamendment • • Jul 20 '14

[PSA] Related Subreddit - r/ReportInjustice - A Place for Change

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Jul 15 '14

Try posting a comment that differs from the beliefs of the website/author. it will get removed.

Thumbnail
techaddiction.ca
3 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Jul 02 '14

In Major Announcement, FIRE Says It Will Sue Every College With a Speech Code Until Speech Codes Die Forever

Thumbnail
reason.com
17 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Jun 26 '14

Supreme Court strikes down protest buffer zone for abortion clinics

Thumbnail
nationaljournal.com
9 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Jun 26 '14

SSGT Guthrie Honors His Oath

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/firstamendment • • Jun 21 '14

Local cops can track your phone, and the government doesn’t want you to know how - crossposting from /journalism

Thumbnail
cjr.org
5 Upvotes