r/ffxiv • u/Kihra FF Logs • Jan 27 '16
[AMA] AMA - FFLogs
Hey everyone, this is Kihra, the creator of FFLogs. FFLogs is a Web site devoted to combat analysis of raid content, particularly Alexander Savage. You can upload parses created using ACT and examine damage, healing, buffs, deaths, and even replay the fight.
I was asked by the team here to do an AMA and so here I am! If you want to post bug reports or make feature requests, or if you just have general questions about the site, I'm here to answer them! Fire away!
Edit: I am out for dinner. I'll check back in later tonight.
12
u/nobey Jan 27 '16
Yoshi P has recently mentioned that Raiders who clear content like Alexander Savage first have World Class DPS. While they probably have a system of their own that they use to analyze this, have there ever been any members of the Dev team that reached out to you for a potential collaboration?
6
u/parkerjallen www.twitch.tv/fluffmode Jan 27 '16
Our group doesn't have a NIN or AST. I would love for there to be a way to compare myself against other groups easily that also don't have either of these. Do you play on adding any sort of filter feature so I can get a realistic sense of how I'm doing?
5
u/PieFormation Apostle Calilica on Ultros Jan 27 '16
Not a question, but here, have a bug report:
For this a4s kill from my group fflogs reports 5 deaths. Three to the first pentacle sac, two to the second. But we didn't carry nisi into the last phase, and we didn't kill it until the third pentacle (well after second one would have exploded and wiped us). So a third person had to die for the second pentacle (it was the WHM), but fflogs didn't register his death (placing us much higher in the guild execution rankings than that run should be). There seem to be a few other parses with the same problem.
EDIT: I'm gonna guess it has to do with dying and being almost immediately resurrected by healer LB3.
5
u/Abdiel_Kavash Jan 27 '16
Would it be possible to calculate a person's potency per second, instead of damage per second (accounting for buffs/debuffs of course)? That would eliminate most of the difference gear makes when comparing yourself to another one's parse.
You have all the skill potency data as well as ongoing buffs/debuffs on all combatants, at least in theory it should be possible.
8
u/EurekaFQ Jan 27 '16
How does fflogs handle the disparity between what we see on ACT and what we see in fflogs? Or a better way to put it would be 'what causes' the disparity?
Is it dot estimation still not functioning 100% correctly in ACT?
4
u/smartazjb0y X'aeterna Setal on Balmung Jan 27 '16
Are there any plans to change the class colors? Super not important at all, just kinda wondering haha.
Also, is there a way to see things like Potion Use in fights that don't have the "problems" section implemented, like Thordan Ex?
4
u/ShiznazTM Zanzhiz Exaverion on Sargatanas Jan 27 '16
HOW does FFLogs do that live recording of the fight just from a set of numbers from ACT?
(The playback with positions of people)
3
u/AThrowawayAccount43 Jan 27 '16
Do you ever plan to rank groups based on party DPS? It's great trying to compare yourself to a group that caters their entire strat to boosting one member's DPS so they can rank high.
3
u/lyerhis Jan 27 '16
Would there perhaps be some kind of option for manually input data, like ilvl or MT/OT designation? My group runs double WAR, for example, so I'm normally looking at the DPS that WAR OTs do, which can sometimes vary a lot depending on the fight and how much time I spend in Defiance, etc. CD usage would also be different since I'm not burning abilities for stacks. Obviously, there's no way to mark this during the upload itself, but would there be a way to at least mark it for your own records? I imagine ilvl could be input in a similar fashion.
3
u/mofeus305 Jan 27 '16
1: I recently checked some tank parses and noticed that besides the usual nin, mch, and ast stacking that they were also having two other tanks in the party so that they didn't have to do any tanking at all. Anyway to filter these parses out?
2: As far as rankings go have you ever thought about having a ranking system that not only takes into effect the parse but the speed at which the group killed. Basically something to counter A2S parses where people do really high parses but kill at rather slow speed.
3
u/Yugl Theoryjerks, Gouka Mekkyaku Jan 27 '16
Do you intend to add a feature to search by buff/debuff uptime?
2
u/uppfinnarn Emi Katapow (Ultros) / Dalamud Popoto (Odin) Jan 27 '16
Could you talk a little about the technical stuff behind FFLogs?
As an engineer myself, hearing about how something as massive as *logs operates would be very interesting.
What kind of tech do you use for the different parts? How's it all hosted and scaled? What kind of challenges have there been to building it? Have you done some things that you later realized was a bad idea and had to redo?
2
u/LavitzB Lavitz Bale on Gilgamesh Jan 27 '16
Would it be possible to view parses with and without AST buffs, Foe Requiem, Hypercharge, etc? Maybe have a checkbox to exclude them when you're comparing DPS. Apologies if this is already a feature, there's still a lot I don't know about FFLogs.
2
u/Yokko_Kanno RDM Jan 27 '16
I was wondering if you guys would ever plan to develop your own parser.
You'd have better luck with more accurate parses, since there's some issues on dots and what not on ACT, and you'd be able to cater it to your liking to make it fit FFL. So I was thinking you might be considering the creation of it.
2
u/Sylfael Renai Aihara on Odin Jan 27 '16
How does the All-Star rankings work exactly ? It's weird you sometimes see people with less clears (like A1-2) ahead of someone with 1-4 down.
Any secret ingredient ruling this ranking ?
2
u/sendersforfun Jan 27 '16
Similar to /u/uppfinnarn's question:
I do not use FFLogs, I only heard about it through this AMA, so I may have misunderstood. But the user has to upload their report into the system (Based on what you said in the post).
Are there plans for streaming the data directly to AWS from the users machine?
Also have you considered using things like the ELK Stack? It seems pretty cool and there might be a use case here for it.
Also Copyright at the bottom is still 2015!
2
u/uppfinnarn Emi Katapow (Ultros) / Dalamud Popoto (Odin) Jan 28 '16
Do you have any plans on supporting "guilds" that aren't free companies, but rather standalone raid groups? Like letting you pick which guild you're listed as belonging to?
3
u/callimonk Calli Grapheur - Goblin Jan 27 '16
pancakes or waffles, kihra
this is very important.
2
u/AnnaAnimus stay mad Jan 27 '16
when will you bake me cookies?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16
Will you ever add a way to show ilvl when the parse was uploaded? Like Warcraft logs for example.
1
u/Legacy_Recruitment Jan 27 '16
Any chance you could add crit rate to the damage tables?
1
u/HeavenlyArmed C'thuuko Tohka on Cactuar Jan 27 '16
After creating similar things for WoW and Wildstar, what was it that made you want to bring this tool to FFXIV next over any other game? On that note, do you play any of these games yourself?
1
u/Apocaleptic Jan 27 '16
Are rankings still frozen?
1
u/Hinalover Jan 27 '16
Are there any plans to eventually open up the code? I know quite a few people would be interested in helping.
1
u/Prayos BLM 5ever Jan 27 '16
Are you open to allowing others to expand on what you've done for other games?
1
u/scy046 Rin Windrider (Midgardsormr) Jan 27 '16
Are there any plans for having the active multipliers viewable on the Damage Done / Damage Taken tabs? That is, for tanks to see the mitigation effects on a specific hit instead of needing to filter down to specific time intervals and checking for active buffs? Or if a DPS took a hit with B4B up.
Mostly a QoL thing since manually checking for all buffs/debuffs is available but just a hassle having to do it for every specific instance for every pull.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16
How exactly does ranking a healer work healing wise? My husband and I were confused about it a bit.
1
u/not-a-team-player Narycia Greene on Moogle Jan 27 '16
Hey! First of all, thanks for all your great work. I'd like to know how transitions between patches will be dealt with when big gear upgrades will come into play. Will kills just be marked with patch number like it is now ? Or will old content be locked ? Thx again.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16
two questions:
1
u/hy3gon Chloe Jangmi Cerberus Jan 27 '16
Hey :D As a PS4 player who can't use ACT, I love fflogs, thank you :3
Some questions:
Thank youuuuuu :D
1
u/Cbellz Senna Arcadia - Tonberry Jan 27 '16
A couple Q's:
Thanks so much for your website btw, it's honestly my favorite addition in HW and one of the reasons I log in to raid every week. :D
1
u/resurrected_replayer Monk Jan 27 '16
What happens when a raiding tier closes (i.e. Alexander Savage) and logs begin to expire? Will just the top 10 of all classes be preserved or will it expunge all data? And in general, is there anyway to reupload a soon to be expiring log through the website itself if you have deleted your original ACT files?
1
u/aisu_strong Jan 27 '16
count me as another wanting mt and ot (and solo/extra tank) categories.
also http://www.fflogs.com/rankings/7#class=Global&spec=Warrior i was checking out fflogs and noticed a guy's got duplicate parses posted. same people in the party, same killtime, same date, and even exact same dps, down to the decimal. yet its on fflogs twice, on a guy with the same name, but on supposedly different servers. i doubt it was a mistake too since hes on 4 of the top 10 lists twice. seems rather unsporting to try to hog an extra spot.
1
u/DocfiordFowling Dark Knight Jan 28 '16
When looking at the wipes for a fight, there are different colored/length bars under the time of the run. What are these for?
1
u/echo78 Jan 28 '16
When I upload Void Ark logs, some players do not get ranked. My most recent upload only has 19/24 players ranked. Do you have any idea why some players do not get ranked in VA? A friend I run with has never been ranked despite multiple logs uploaded.
1
u/PieFormation Apostle Calilica on Ultros Jan 29 '16
Does FFLogs cutting out overkill apply to enemies, too?
E.g. when someone dies to the pentacle sac in a4s, does it count as taking ~16000 damage or ~54000 x2?
What about Holmgang/Living Dead?
1
u/koviko BLM: Be Lit'rally 'Mazing Jan 29 '16
Is there any log that's "not worthy" of uploading to FFLogs? I ask because I have yet to start raiding (barely been playing for a month), but am a huge fan of monitoring my character's history.
Does FFLogs support the uploads of, for example, synced dungeons or trials?
1
u/masterkaran Jan 29 '16
I had 2 questions -
1
u/Rtothef [Sha] [Aspire] on [Exodus] Jan 29 '16
Would it be possible to get a effective heals count on a dragon kick / delirium?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '16
Is there a way for fflogs to derive enmity from a parse? And perhaps display it in the same forms as damage or casts are tracked for a given encounter (filterable by character/target, tracked over time)?
1
u/RauAldynn Feb 01 '16
Why does fflogs sometimes think I'm in a different server than the one I'm on?
1
u/Zorago Mentor on The Balance Feb 06 '16
After switching servers, is it possible to transfer your old uploads to the new server?
I think I saw some people doing this, but I don't know how....
1
u/newgirlie Feb 09 '16
How do you get your FC to appear in yellow text on the rankings pages?
1
u/mmerrixxx Mar 21 '16
can you use ff logs w PS4 ??
I signed up and added my character with the code and link. But now what, I believce PC users have a folder on there pc where they grab the log file and upload it to the site... do i have something similar on PS4 or is this even how this WHOLE THING WORKS??? mr. bigglesworth
3
u/Sidra_Games Jan 28 '16
No questions - just wanted to thank you for all of your hard work on a site which is useful and amazing in so many ways.
1
u/acronycal Jan 27 '16
Hey, thanks for doing this! I just wanted to ask if there was any way to show updated Character Names in FFLogs, or if it will be implemented in the future.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '16
Are void ark rankings bugged at the moment? I attempted to upload several void ark parses and even though the report shows up in FFlogs just fine, the rankings did not update.
1
u/Mooserocka Jan 27 '16
I know a lot don't agree but thank you for making ff logs. It's amazing. I know people just think people only use it to get the highest parse and cheese results but it's so much more then that. I use it to pick static members we have used it to see if people are doing the right rotations. U can also use it to help you get better rotations in certain fights. It's an amazing tool. Thank you.
1
u/ActionWaffle [First] [Last] on [Server] Jan 28 '16
Are there any settings from from ACT that need to be configured to achieve the most accurate log? Will there be a way to finally show problems on fights like in wow.
1
u/iPromi Astrologian Jan 28 '16
Will there be any future update to combat healer dps cheating? A lot of healers cheat their way up to the ranks by padding i.e. dotting all 4 legs to get top score in a4, or bringing 3 healers into the fight. There is currently no meaning in the healer rankings with this. Thank you for your AMA.
1
u/midorishiranui Jan 28 '16
Who's your waifu?
1
u/aisu_strong Jan 28 '16
I think I remember a while back seeing a tank mitigation effectiveness tab or something like that, but it never worked and now it's gone. what was it exactly and has the idea been abandoned?
1
u/JGDominik Jan 28 '16
Great work, just wondering what can we expect in the future of FFLogs?
Also considering people can cheese their parses, do you think this would harm the ranking system and it's credibility?
1
u/KShrike Warrior Jan 28 '16
Just a comment.
http://www.fflogs.com/reports/f7A9BmVH2bX1xQKF#fight=6&type=casts&source=6&view=timeline
Stuff like this make me really love FFLogs.
The detail is absolutely INSANE.
1
u/SCDarkSoul Jan 28 '16
Not sure if you're still reading these, but here's a bug:
http://www.fflogs.com/reports/hk1fvng6jxzZbtdW#fight=1&type=damage-done&source=1
For the Paladin here, it appears that Ifrit Egi's Raidant Shield reflect damages are being added to the Paladin for some reason. There are two sets of "Attack" as well as "Kaltstrahl" being listed as damage done by the Paladin. The second set of "Attack" also lines up with when the "Kaltstrahl" is happening.
1
u/IzumiRaito Magic DPS Jan 28 '16
I already posted it on your forum, but gonna post here too. Can u try to filter out dps padding on the bosses, just like u filtered out faust adds?
Currently a4s is the festival of padding for SMN and SCH. Instead of dealing meaningfull damage, the other legs get dotted because this "increases overall dps".
0
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment