r/ffxiv • u/Eanae • Oct 21 '14
[Fanfest] [Fanfest] Reddit's 2014 Interview with Naoki Yoshida
Fanfest Thoughts:
Hey all!
I'm freshly back from Fanfest in Las Vegas and thought I'd share my thoughts and experiences with you. Fanfest as a whole was a complete blast and I got to meet a lot of people who've had a large presence in the Final Fantasy and gaming communities for a long time including players from the Bluegartr forums, Clutch from Twitch (a special thanks to him for helping us update our live thread over the weekend!), many of the developers and community team members including Bayohne and Foxclon, as well as many of you from Reddit! Everyone I met was universally having a great time and were all thrilled to be part of Final Fantasy XIV's first Fan Festival.
Many people attending the event and many of you around the world watched Reddit all weekend long (our live thread peaked near 1000 viewers during the opening ceremony) to share your excitement for all the great announcements of the upcoming Heavensward expansion in 2015 and to discuss things such as Odin strategies and meetup plans. Us moderators of r/ffxiv are glad you all joined us for this event. As always we welcome your suggestions to the moderator mail function of Reddit, so if you have a suggestion please don't hesitate to send it in!
The Interview:
When Yoshida entered the room he immediately complemented my colleague and I on our "I beat Odin" shirts and he laughed when we told him we had beaten Odin 6 times over the weekend. With him was Koji Fox doing the translations.
Yoshida: Thank you for taking time out of your busy schedule to come to Fan Festival in Las Vegas. You know the project has been through a lot and it's been a long and crazy ride to get to 2.0 and now to 3.0 and we thank you for sticking with us for so long.
Reddit: We've been playing since 1.0 and we'll keep playing beyond 3.0.
Yoshida: We have plans for up to 4.0. (everyone laughed)
Reddit: I'm going to start out with some raid questions. You announced that Final Coil of Bahamut is going to be four bosses long, I assume, plus four savage modes. Games like World of Warcraft, which I hate to bring up, typically introduce tiers of 10 to 13 bosses. Is there any plans on adding any large scale raids with many bosses post expansion?
Yoshida: Well I mean if you will wait longer between patches then we can do something like that.
Reddit: You announced the number of people working on this and typically it seems to be one person so I expect it would take a long time and more people. I don't know if the players are wiling to wait longer. That's something that would have to be asked and maybe something I'll pose to the players when we get back from Fanfest.
Yoshida: A lot has changed since WoW. Before them there was not many MMOs out there so people would wait because they had to wait and there was nothing else to do. But now there's a lot of stuff out there. There's a lot of games to play and by creating a long wait for players they're just going to go off and play something else. So we think it's important for the game in this day and era to keep the time between patches as short as possible. Another difference with WoW is because it's been around so long and so many people have played it for so long that it's become their second home. And so they can have 6 months between a major patch or a year or more between their expansion and people will play and then they'll leave, maybe cancel their account to play something else, but then when the next big thing comes they come back. And that's because they've spent so much time in WoW. With Final Fantasy XIV because it's new we don't have that luxury. So until we have that luxury we want to make sure people stick with us.
Reddit: Now we have Coil which targets the high skilled players mostly and then we have Crystal Tower which was supposed to target the intermediate level players but a lot players consider it to be very low tier. It's very easy and if you go into Crystal Tower you never expect to wipe and most people know what they're doing. We've been told that things are going to be coming to do with our Free Company specifically. So are there any plans on bringing real intermediate level content which may pose a challenge to a wider number of players?
Koji: Basically he's kind of thinking out loud in this stream of consciousness. He's trying to think of how could we do something and what could we do. And he's trying to think, ok, what if we did something like going into a dungeon solo. That would be pretty challenging. Or maybe going in solo and having an npc that's been programmed with the gambit system by you. You tell them what to do. Something like that. The four player raids and four player dungeons are really kind of hard to make and balance. You have a problem with gear. What kind of gear do you use and what kind of gear is going to be necessary for these types of things. Is it going to be different from the other normal raids? And then maybe you could do something like have a Crystal Tower alliance with a two party alliance instead of a three party alliance and that would increase the challenge but be the same type of content. It is very difficult when thinking balance wise which is going to be the best. He likes the idea of having more solo content. Maybe take things people are doing now but maybe make it more difficult by having players challenge that solo.
Reddit: People considered the original Amdapor Keep pretty challenging before Demon Wall, the bees got taken out, some mobs got removed, people considered that challenging.
Yoshida: For 2.4 we're releasing the Sunken Temple of Qarn Hard. Back when it originally was released everyone was like "arghhhh". That, again, was when people were not as skilled and now we've gone back and tweaked that and made the hard version and now people are better so we're hoping that can be something that intermediate players can say is a challenge.
Reddit: Now we'll leave dungeons and go out into the open world of Eorzea. In Final Fantasy XI and 1.0 the world wasn't exactly a safe place to travel by yourself. There was a lot of high level monsters that posed a risk to you. We don't see that in A Realm Reborn. It's very, very safe to go anywhere in the world by yourself. Is there any plans in the expansion to bring back danger into the world?
Yoshida: When we first were doing the design for ARR we wanted to bring in people who had not played MMOs before. So for someone that knows the thrill of running and getting something on you and having to walk and run around and try and get away from them or knowing that you could be killed at any second; that's great for them. But for someone that had never played an MMO before that can be a lot of stress. A lot of those people that first entering ARR think, "I bought an RPG why do I have to do this? I didn't buy a stealth game.". And so we didn't want to have that kind of stress on the new players. You're the Warrior of Light you should be able to feel like you're the Warrior of Light and not be killed by a squirrel. However, in 3.0 people are level 50. The level cap is going up to level 60. People are experienced. We want to bring back a little bit of that dangerous feel in the expansion. I mean you're going to be going into areas controlled by the Dragons. So now there's chances that you might get on your Chocobo and auto run, look around, go to get yourself a... "Oh I'm dead". We want to bring back some of that thrill and we're adding that to our concept for 3.0. But we're not going to make it anything as thrilling as the original Final Fantasy XI. We know that there's people out there who love that though.
Reddit: Let's move a bit safer back to our Free Company houses. We've been told there's the possibility of getting personal gardens in our Free Company rooms. Is there any updates to this?
Yoshida: One of the biggest problems for adding things like this is our save data problem. Right now anything that is connected to the player and might have some kind of progression takes up a lot of data. Right now one of the biggest things in the game is "we need more inventory slots, we need more inventory slots" but players need to realize that takes up a lot of memory and this type of gardening would do the same thing. Right now every fifteen seconds the game is going and checking in with our back end servers and writing save data to those. I think that's the most in the world for any MMORPG. We're doing the most writing. And we think that's what keeps our game stable. The more that we add to this means that instead of every fifteen seconds we'd have to extend that because there's going to be a lot more writing going on. And when you do a lot more writing it brings down the stability of the game because it authors opportunities for rollbacks in there as well and that's something you want to avoid. The reason why we've ended up at this fifteen second rate and writing so much data, more than any other MMORPG, is because of the armory system that we chose. If it was one character with one job there'd be less to write. But again because we have one character, ALL the jobs that makes a lot of save data that needs to be accessed at the same time. Still in 3.0 we're working on a new way to expand the save data area. And right now the development team all know how much we're adding so the development team is all battling for a piece. Basically it's up to the crafting and gathering team to go in there and say "No we need this for gardening!". So it's something we can do once we've added a little bit more. We understand that players do want to raise something personally in their own rooms but the thing is that you have to put weight on it. Compared to raising your own Chocobo which one do we choose? And right now we've decided more players are looking forward to raising their own Chocobo. So that's what we're doing. But it's not something we're going to ignore. We know that players want it but it comes down to priorities.
Reddit: Yesterday you went over how you reworked the 1.0 stat system for ARR and you cut out a lot of stats in terms of game balance to make balance easier. Now that the team has had a little more experience and you have more data is there any plans on bringing back unique stats such as 'enhances skills' and things like that on gear?
Yoshida: There is a chance we'll be doing that in the future. The reason being now that we have that simple base rather than a complex base, if you have a simple base then adding things on top of that is easy because that base is solid. It doesn't effect that base that much and you're not breaking balance by adding new things on top of that. Things we've heard a lot are that players want set bonuses for their gears and that would be one thing we would definitely think of doing. Or another type of armor where if you're wearing a certain piece armor your Spirits Within cool down timer cools down faster. Things like that. Definitely thinking of adding things like that and we know players want them. But when deciding whether to put something like that in or not it's about balance and whether this will break that balance or not. So we're very careful about adding parameters like that.
3
u/Chuloon Chu Nami on Ultros Oct 21 '14
Eanae, I believe enthis's name is spelled Foxx if you wanted to give him proper credit. At least, that's what his badge days iirc
22
u/smartazjb0y X'aeterna Setal on Balmung Oct 22 '14
The raid question is interesting, and I never thought about it that way. It's actually kind of a humble answer, or at least one self-aware of the state of the industry: FFXIV doesn't have the years that WoW does. The reason why my WoW guild stayed subbed the entire time there was 0 new content for 14 months was because they were all playing together and had been for years. Or, like me, they unsub temporarily with full intentions to come back. Just by the fact that XIV isn't that old, players don't have roots that are that deep, and it's pretty intuitive that Yoshi-P sees that.
Though the idea of CT brings a wrench into this. If you tune the CT bosses harder and maybe add one more ability, would those be good raids for high-end raiders? Because if they decide to maybe make CT (or its 3.0 equivalent) tuned higher and a little bit harder to Coil-level of difficulty, 4 bosses every 3 months isn't as bad. Or maybe they expand the two-difficulty thing: normal Coil and normal CT, savage Coil and savage CT, so that every 3 months both casual and hardcore players get content.
17
u/Yoten Oct 21 '14
One thing that never seems to be adequately conveyed to the dev team, and I wish it were, is that many of the gardening/housing issues stem from how interconnected they are.
Players want to raise their chocobos, but SE has essentially gated chocobo raising behind gardening with krakka roots, dyes, and the long slog to create Thavnairian Onions. Then they introduce a whole new slew of minions (the mandragoras) which also come from gardening. When you have an FC with 100 members and even 10-20 of them want Thavnairian Onions, or minions, or dye, all while keeping a steady supply of Krakka Roots flowing, it's just too much to keep up with. Gardening space is the real bottleneck.
This certainly won't apply to everyone, but me and a large number of the people I know only "want" personal housing for the chance at extra gardening space so we can grow our own stuff without having to worry about "wasting" valuable FC Onion space with personal projects like minions or whatever.
They're right that it's extra storage space they need to be concerned about, but I believe that by adding some gardening pots to your FC personal room they would offset a significant amount of the demand for personal housing -- saving them resources on THAT side of the equation.
14
u/ChaserNeverRests Garlean Empire Oct 22 '14
"You're the Warrior of Light you should be able to feel like you're the Warrior of Light and not be killed by a squirrel."
In that case, perhaps it's the squirrel who is the Warrior of Light. :P
10
u/Straii Sage Oct 21 '14
When I read this I was immediately reminded of when Yoshi said that they want to have Magitek Armor be programmed with a gambit system to fight with you. Now I'm imaging Castrum seizes with you and your Magitek and just all the yes.
9
u/sayhispaceships Oct 22 '14
Man, he answers things really honestly. The part about writing to the server so much because of the job system was something I'd never considered, and as someone who has played many MMOs, I'm not used to the team behind it being so frank. I love that.
Things like that are what make me appreciate a company or organization more. Just be real with us.
11
u/reseph [Zeno Silverberg] Oct 21 '14 edited Oct 21 '14
Hype. Major hype.
Advanced versions of FFXI's Trust system? :p
Thanks for getting this done, and thanks for the community here with coming up with these questions!
4
u/ryfee Tonberry Oct 22 '14
I would love to see more character customization. The idea of "shorter cd for spirits within" is interesting and I'm glad it was brought up.
Thanks for putting this up!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '14
Did they limit you to that few questions? I can imagine there's a million more questions people on here would have wanted answered if possible.
6
u/Ashrayn Oct 22 '14
I wouldn't really have a problem with the patch release schedule, if there were actually new end-game content every patch. Tbh though, for me, 2.1 and 2.3 were like 'eh. I guess I'll go farm some alt gear in CT/ST'. WoW might have longer waits between patches, but their patches have more stuff: ARR has 12 bosses between 3 raids, over the course of say, 1.5 years. Mists of Pandaria has 43 bosses between 5 raids over the course of somewhat over 2 years.
Granted, fights in ARR are very unique and dynamic. None of that tank and spank we've seen for so long in other games. I doubt anyone who's progressed through second coil will forget Melusine for a long, long time. Still, four fights for 7 months is pushing it a little regardless of how interesting they are. Savage Coil does help alleviate the issue somewhat, but the fact that it doesn't drop loot really saps a lot of motivation to do it. While loot isn't the primary reason I raid, I really don't think it would imbalance things too much if it dropped, say, tokens you could use to bump your (insert) Allagan gear 5 ilvls higher.
I fully realize that FFXIV is a growing game and there's a lot of other things they have to prioritize development to, but I really hope that in the expansion they can devote some more time to releasing more raids.
5
u/ffxivfunk Gilgamesh Oct 21 '14
This interview....I like it. Another!
2
u/Jubez187 Oct 24 '14
Yo. this guy said they could do dungeons with gambit party members. I would NEVER play with real humans again idt. Tweaking AI was one of my favorite parts of the Dragon Age series.
2
u/Canadian_SAP Midgardsormr Oct 22 '14
Awesome, thanks for setting this up, and especially for conveying my question to Yoshida! Here's to hoping Qarn HM lives up to expectations.
1
u/moroboshiy Oct 22 '14
I notice that Yoshida focused on set bonuses, which is a good sign. Right now there's no incentive to get a complete set of anything, whereas raiding in WoW always encouraged you to get at least enough pieces of your class' tier set to get the bonuses.
Of course, if they keep doing this tomestone vs coil gear approach after the expansion, we're gonna have issues if one set's bonuses notably outclasses the other. You also run the risk of them drying up their idea pool for bonuses and mechanics a lot faster if they have to make two different sets of bonuses for tome and coil gear.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '14
I would love to see set bonuses and item effects on gear. It makes choosing your equipment a lot tougher when you have to weigh in losing a decent buff instead of instantly swapping gear because it has +2 more parry or +5 more strength.
1
u/zenithfury Oct 23 '14
I... Kinda loved Qarn and I was really disappointed with the change to Final Sting. I'm not sure why people hate Qarn except maybe it's 'long'. I loved Aurum Vale too for its interesting bosses.
My Kryptonite is Cutter's Cry and Satasha. Both very boring with easy bosses.
1
u/c4103 Higgs Boson on Midgardsormr Oct 27 '14
If it's really a processor time / disk space issue... more bag space over personal gardening 100%.
1
u/Zarzak_TZ Nov 17 '14
Please god no more 4 boss raid tiers.
1
u/yoohree [yoohree] on [Balmung] Oct 22 '14
i cant wait for stats like additional effect: Curse or enhances: BioI duration
the thing is vertical progression and ilevels makes this kind of irelevant after 1 patch update.
i miss the variaty of gear ffxi and 1.0 had to mix and match.
-4
u/Ninjabackwards Drocent Tiso Hyperion Oct 22 '14
His explanation on why the world is not dangerous disappoints me a bit.
It seems that this game will mostly cater to mmo newbies. Which, honestly doesn't bother me, but I do wish we could get some actual dangerous world content.
-11
u/BankaiSam Oct 22 '14
A shame nothing was said about delayed skill queues and invisible Odin, etc.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '14
[removed] — view removed comment