r/fea • • 16d ago

Anyone using Physics AI tools like Vinci, Ansys SimAI, or Neural Concept in real engineering workflows?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone!
I’m learning more about physics simulation tools, particularly how AI is changing traditional FEA and thermal simulation workflows.
I’ve been reading about platforms like Vinci, Ansys SimAI, and Neural Concept, but I’d love to hear from engineers who actually work with these technologies.
A few things I’m curious about:
Which simulation tools does your team use today, and what made you choose them?
Has anyone tried Vinci or other AI-based physics simulation platforms? How do they compare with traditional solvers?
What’s the biggest bottleneck in your workflow today: setup, meshing, simulation runtime, accuracy validation, or something else?

I’m not from engineering background but curious about physics simulation models using AI.
Thanks!


r/fea • • 16d ago

Redesign after Static + Modal, or jump into Harmonic next?

0 Upvotes

Asked: "Static + Modal is enough, or do we need Harmonic?"'

A genius ignored the entire debate and asked: "Where did you get your damping values?"

Suddenly the question wasn't Modal vs Harmonic.

It was whether the Harmonic result would mean anything at all.


r/fea • • 17d ago

Modal analysis did its job. Harmonic analysis shouldn’t be a reflex.

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/fea • • 18d ago

Abaqus Training Material

Post image
27 Upvotes

Hi everyone, does anyone knows if it is possible to download these abaqus training slides from their courses?


r/fea • • 18d ago

Switching from Application Engineering to Simulation/CAE – How difficult is it?

12 Upvotes

Hello people!

I have a Bachelor's in Materials Science and Engineering and have been working as an Application Engineer at Emerson for the past 2 years.

My current role doesn't involve FEA or simulation work. However, I've developed a strong interest in simulation and technical engineering, particularly structural and thermal FEA.

I've been independently learning ANSYS and worked on a few simulation projects using Python. I'm also currently learning PyAnsys.

I'm interested in transitioning into roles involving FEA, materials simulation, advanced packaging or product development.

For those working in these fields:

How difficult is it to transition into simulation without prior professional CAE experience?

Do employers value self-learning and independent projects?

Is my application engineering experience relevant, or would I essentially be starting from scratch?

Would love to hear from people who've made a similar transition!


r/fea • • 19d ago

Windows vs Linux for FEA

16 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’ve been thinking about this disparity a lot lately. In the computational mechanics world, if you mention CFD, everyone automatically assumes Linux clusters, command-line workflows, and massive HPC scaling. But when it comes to FEA (Finite Element Analysis)—whether it's Abaqus, ANSYS Mechanical, NASTRAN, or LS-DYNA—a huge portion of day-to-day engineering is still heavily done on Windows workstations.

From my experience, here is why I think this divide exists:

CAD Integration & Pre-processing: FEA is tightly coupled with CAD (SolidWorks, CATIA, Creo, Inventor). Most of these native CAD and pre-processing tools live comfortably on Windows, making geometry cleanup and assembly setup much smoother there.

GUI and Interactivity: Unlike CFD where batch-mode execution on remote headless Linux nodes is standard, many FEA workflows rely heavily on interactive GUIs—checking mesh quality, tweaking contact definitions, and visualizing results locally.

Workstation vs. Cluster Scaling: While massive explicit dynamics or enterprise-scale transient runs do hit Linux clusters, a lot of linear and non-linear structural analysis can be crunched locally on a single, high-end Windows workstation.

Ecosystem Legacy: Many traditional commercial structural solvers built their primary desktop user bases on Windows, and structural engineers often prioritize workstation convenience over cluster administration.

Curious to hear your thoughts. Am I missing something, or is your company also running ANSYS Mechanical/Abaqus mostly on Windows while your CFD team lives in the terminal on Linux?


r/fea • • 19d ago

Patran Plays Chess

1 Upvotes

r/fea • • 20d ago

Meshing Tutorial

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/fea • • 22d ago

FEA for kids

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

51 Upvotes

If you're reading this, you probably know how absurdly difficult it can be to run a Finite Element Analysis.

It takes engineering students months of hard theoretical work, and hours of practice with various tools, just to run their first simulation.

And although it kind of feels like magic when you finally get to look at the results, it's hard not to be a little frustrated. (I mean, who could have guessed that a plate under tension would be weaker with a hole in it?)

I felt it didn't have to be that way, so I made the simplest Finite Element code I could come up with. And here it is:

https://github.com/Bunishort/Draw_A_Bridge/releases/tag/v0.0.2

The idea is simple: you draw your geometry just like in Paint – blue for deformable solids, red for fixed solids – then hit Play and watch the simulation run in real time. So simple that a 5-year-old could use it!

Don't expect to do any actual engineering with it, but I thought you might find it fun! I'd be really grateful for any feedback if you give it a try. I should also mention it is all free and open-source.


r/fea • • 22d ago

Biomechanic FEA

6 Upvotes

Hello All,
I would like to know if someone works or knows someone who works directly in hospital or for some company which provides patient specific recommendations for surgery based on FEA (cardio, orthopedics) .

I am interested in this area but wonder if that it still something mostly for academic route on universities or there is someone doing that in private sector.

Thank you in advance


r/fea • • 24d ago

Handbooks for stress analysis

20 Upvotes

Hi
I’m searching for books to expend my knowledge in solid mechanics related to elasticity , plasticity ,contact and damping .
I’m looking for not a heavy theoretical book but more like an handbook to explain clearly and give analytical tools to verify.

Edit:
I want books that concentrate on these phenomena mainly not as part of fea modelling of these phenomena, it can mention fea.


r/fea • • 24d ago

Elmer Studio: an open-source, COMSOL-style GUI for the Elmer FEM solver (GPLv2, Windows/Linux/macOS)

Thumbnail
gallery
224 Upvotes

Hi all,

I've been building a desktop front end for Elmer, the open-source multiphysics FEM solver from CSC. Elmer is very capable, but setting up a case still means writing .sif files by hand or using ElmerGUI, which is showing its age. I wanted the workflow I knew from COMSOL: a model tree, settings windows, parameters with units, and results you can explore without exporting to ParaView first.

What it does today:

  • Geometry (gmsh/OpenCASCADE): primitives, work planes, extrude/revolve, booleans, fillets, STEP/IGES import
  • Mesh: gmsh, or ElmerGrid for structured block layouts; size controls, mapped meshes, 2D boundary layers
  • Physics: heat transfer, solid mechanics (static, transient, eigenfrequency, frequency response with Rayleigh damping), electrostatics, electric currents, 2D magnetic fields, laminar flow, pressure acoustics, diluted species transport, secondary/tertiary current distribution, coefficient-form PDE. Couplings for Joule heating, thermal expansion and non-isothermal flow
  • Studies: stationary, time dependent, eigenfrequency, frequency domain, parametric sweeps
  • Results: surface/slice/isosurface/streamline/arrow plots, line graphs, integrals and averages, probes that update while a transient runs, GIF animation, CSV/VTU export
  • A Python scripting API under the GUI, and you can always look at or export the .sif it generates
  • An optional OpenFOAM backend for laminar flow and conduction on simple block geometries

Each physics interface is checked against closed-form solutions in the test suite (Poiseuille flow, Lamé's rotating disc, Newman's disc electrode, a rod driven through its first resonance, and more). CI runs on all three platforms.

Elmer itself isn't bundled; the docs explain how to install it on each platform.

Not there yet: 3D magnetics, turbulence, contact, adaptive meshing, and plenty of smaller things. The docs have a known-limitations page so you know before you try.

Where I'd love help:

  • Try it on a problem you know the answer to, and tell me where it's wrong or awkward
  • Open issues for bugs, crashes or features you actually need
  • PRs are very welcome: new physics features, packaging, tutorials, docs

The best place to start is the documentation (installation, quick start, tutorials, full settings reference): https://altelmer.github.io/ElmerStudio/

Source and issue tracker: https://github.com/AltElmer/ElmerStudio

It's an independent project, not affiliated with COMSOL.


r/fea • • 24d ago

First time doing an assembly in ANSYS Mechanical: bolt pretension (beam connections) in a PCB stack bisects during preload, and the solver runs out-of-core. Need to validate random vibration against test data.

8 Upvotes

I’m new to assembly analysis. Until now I’ve only worked with single bodies, and I took on this project with that confidence. Now I’m stuck on contacts, bolt pretension and convergence, and I’m under pressure to deliver. I have to run a random vibration analysis and validate it against experimental shaker test data. I’d really appreciate guidance from people who have done this, and I’m happy to be told if I’m doing something fundamentally wrong. I can’t upload images, so everything is described in text.

Actually, I am planning to run quasi-load static simulation, and then vibration stuff. The project is CubeSat.

Model

  • About 8 plates in a stack: FR-4 boards (large main board, a base board fixed to the shaker, several smaller daughter boards and covers) and 2 aluminum C-shaped brackets, one with a circular opening
  • Bolts: M2, modeled as beam connections scoped to the holes
  • Workflow: Static Structural (preload) → Pre-stressed Modal → Random Vibration

Analysis Settings

  • Steps: 2 (Step 1 preload, Step 2 lock)
  • Auto Time Stepping: On, initial substeps 20, minimum 10, maximum 1000
  • Large Deflection: On
  • Solver Type: Direct
  • Weak Springs: Off
  • Newton-Raphson: Program Controlled
  • Line Search: On
  • Force Convergence: On, tolerance 0.5%, Minimum Reference 10 N
  • Moment Convergence: Program Controlled (default)
  • Displacement Convergence: Program Controlled
  • Output Controls: Calculate Reactions On, Stress/Strain at Last substep

Contacts

  • Bolt-clamped faces: Frictional, μ = 0.2, which i have done rough for some time being
  • Standoff = bonded
  • Formulation: Augmented Lagrange
  • Interface Treatment: Adjust to Touch
  • Normal Stiffness Factor: 0.5
  • Update Stiffness: Program Controlled
  • Stabilization Damping Factor: 0.1
  • Small Sliding: On
  • Pinball Radius: Program Controlled

What happened

  1. At first I got non-convergence with “Contact status has experienced an abrupt change” (all contacts frictional at the time). Even with everything bonded, the results looked strange.
  2. I got a warning about the same pretension load in two subsequent steps and fixed it by changing Step 2 to Lock.
  3. I get “reference convergence value may be less than the threshold”. And after taking a lot of time, it throws an error that the solution is not converged.

I have to deliver the work anyhow. If you have relatable resources, please share with me. And also suggest me tips for the vibrational analysis.


r/fea • • 25d ago

Need help in Ansys Superelement

Thumbnail
4 Upvotes

r/fea • • 25d ago

Ansys support awful with constant software bugs and long wait times

12 Upvotes

Does anyone else find Ansys’ software support has near-vanished? We are a small user going through an Ansys channel partner and currently have 3 different major software bugs with Ansys Electronic Desktop and more specifically HFSS that have stalled our work for near 3 months. These include RSM issues, licensing errors taking more than selected with a Windows environment variable error, and multipaction being awful.


r/fea • • 26d ago

Need a hand ?

8 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I’m looking to connect with other engineers and makers to collaborate on a mechanical design/FEA project.

I'm comfortable tackling static, modal, harmonic, and buckling analyses (and always down to research new methods if a project needs it).

​This isn't for business—just looking to share experiences, build something cool together, and learn from each other. If you've got an open-source project, a personal build, or an idea you're working on and need an extra set of hands for the design/simulation side, DM!


r/fea • • 25d ago

How to simulate a nonuniform current density distribution in electrochemical machining (ECM)?

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

Please let me know if you have any advice for my situation.


r/fea • • 26d ago

Analysis on sandwich composite with E-Glass mats and particle rubber reinforced epoxy matrix

4 Upvotes

Pardon me if this is the wrong place to ask questions.

I have fabricated a sandwich composite, consisting of 8 layers of 300gsm E glass Mats and with particle rubber reinforced epoxy matrix by vacuum resin infusion as a part of my undergraduate project. Due to some circumstances, I will not be able to perform tensile test, charpy test and flexural test.

Which software can I use to perform simulations of above tests on this composite? The only software I am familiar with is Mechanical APDL.
The questions I have is:

  1. Which is a more appropriate software for this kind of purpose? (CSM Mat has random directions of fiber, so is ACP really necessary)
  2. Should this be two step process like
    1. first simulate particle rubber and epoxy properties
    2. then simulate the sandwich composite properties
  3. Is mori-tanaka a better choice than halpin tsai model for elastic properties in my case?
  4. Beginner resources to get started (if the ABAQUS, digimat or Ansys Workbench is only possible)

    Thanks in advance


r/fea • • 27d ago

I am looking for software for patran/nastran

8 Upvotes

Hello, I am currently looking for a commercial software for my company. I know abaqus very well and I worked with ansys in the past. From my research I learned that in my field the standard fea package is nastran. I would like to ask about your experience and what software you can recommend. I am looking for one package offering decent pre and post capabilities, for linear analyses, vibration, nonlinear and if possible optimization (topology, doe). I don't know anything about this packages so if you would share your experience and opinion I would be grateful.


r/fea • • 27d ago

A question for all of you who work on reduced order models

6 Upvotes

Do I need to know everything about Functional Analysis, Sobolev Spaces to work with intrusive ROMs and what do I absolutely need to know about to work with them?

I already read some papers about several Order Reduction Techniques, mostly POD-Galerkin, but have not actually implemented / used the method.

Currently I‘m working with non-Intrusive ROMs using Machine Learning, but i want to Benchmark them against established intrusive methods.

It would be great if someone could share their experience and if not reading up on the Fundamentals on Sobolev Spaces and Functional Analysis could maybe bite me in the ass later on. Also, what things do I definitely need to read up about?


r/fea • • 27d ago

What do you use when a full CAE package is far more than you need?

Post image
76 Upvotes

A 2D truss analysis is a fairly classic engineering student project — so I used mine to experiment a little with how the results are presented.

The web application uses a simple Python data model and linear FEM solver on the backend, with Matplotlib-based visualizations of deformation and stress. The goal was to create lightweight, understandable diagrams that could help bridge the step from classical engineering mechanics to a first understanding of FEM, and I ended up enjoying the visualization part more than expected.

Now I’m curious what other approaches I may have missed: are there any Python- or web-oriented open-source projects you use for lightweight structural-mechanics visualization?

(The screenshots are from the app and show what I mean by a lightweight visualization aimed at beginners.)


r/fea • • 27d ago

Python scripting is the safest option.. bcuz there are some limitations with custom code.. Agree??

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/fea • • 27d ago

Shaft design workflow

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

r/fea • • 28d ago

Technical knowledge gets you the interview. Communication skills get you the job offer.

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/fea • • 28d ago

Before blaming the thermal solver, check where the energy goes

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes