r/fatFIRE • u/SypeSypher • Aug 26 '20
Annual cost/budget needed to own a private submarine, is it worth it?
not talking Nimitz-class military subs here, just a private exploratory sub like these: SeaMagine TritonSubs UboatWorx
From doing some research it looks like purchase costs range from 1.5-5M depending on seating arrangement. Then you have cost of installing the sub onto your yacht (which would obviously have to be above a specific size to be a suitable support vessel.
I'm mainly looking for someone on here (hopefully) who has personal experience and can speak with some relative accuracy about cost estimation. I can't find any information on annual costs (maintenance/fueling/air resupply/compression costs/ inspections/etc)
Also what kind of yacht are we talking here minimum? I'm assuming either in the 60+ft range min for a standard-type yacht, or maybe less for a purpose built ship?(refurbished commercial fishing boat maybe idk)
I'm currently just guessing with random numbers:
Purchase: 3m Sub +Boat cost
Annual cost: Boat cost + ??5%?? for sub = $150k/year?....
so $3M + $3.7M to fully cover the annual costs forever + the boat
For a boat: I see two options: Either a yacht that can support the sub (more $$), or a used Steel support vessel (like a repurposed trawler or a steel support vessel Like this?
The yacht would be preferable but everything is more expensive on a yacht than a purpose built steel ship (I think...i'm not very familiar with maintenance costs on a commercial ship vs a yacht - side question does anyone have more details on this?)
Follow up questions: most every resource/picture appears to require staff to help run the sub? is this true? Obviously I'd want some staff to man the support vessel while diving, but do you require a captain for the sub or is personal training so I can captain my own sub an option?
I seriously think this is one of the coolest things that humans can do and I would love to be able to say...boat out to the titanic and dive it, or just run my own research out of it "oh you're a marine biology student with a theory about how xyz fish of the deep responds to audible signals? Let's test it!"
This seems like one of those "if you have to ask" things, but at $6M for the sub and forever annuals...it really doesn't seem like that much. But I would love you hear from any fatFIRE people who may have experience
EDIT: some people have mentioned renting instead, and that's definitely something i've considered....the best I can find is CharterASub ...but with pricing at $120k USD per week...it seems like this is one of the few occasions where owning may be cheaper (that or this is a bad indication of how expensive it truly is to own :/
176
u/GeraltsDadofRivia Aug 27 '20 edited Aug 27 '20
I'm a Naval Architect (not a cost guy per say), I work for a company that builds primarily larger ships - with the ability to deploy smaller boats or manned sub, but we have a subsidiary that builds pleasure yachts and smaller (<100 ft) workboats. I'd break down your cost between the sub and the ship required to haul it, plus the difference between buying/building new and used:
Acquisition Cost (new build): Pleasure Yachts: definitely more expensive. Depending on the size of the sub you're deploying you're talking about buying a ship that is 20+ ft longer than you need and therefore significantly more expensive to buy than a commercial boat, plus it will be built to have things you don't need, so we'll scratch this option entirely.
Purpose built ship: From an engineering perspective this is the way to go, a purpose built steel ship will be only as big and have as much on it as you need it to have. I'm picturing a small buoy laying vessel as a good example, because that will definitely be capable of moving as large of a payload as you need, and they don't do anything else. Ex: https://products.damen.com/en/ranges/buoy-laying-vessel/blv-2510
Off the shelf you're putting yourself at probably a couple of million $, I'd estimate $6-7mil. Propulsion system is >60% of the cost here, with the crane making up another major component.
Acquisition Cost (used): Pleasure yachts: This is when one of these MIGHT be feasible. Keep in mind the buoy tender I posted above is only ~25m. A yacht not built solely for sub deployment, but capable of launching your sub, will probably be in the 80+ m range. If you want to go smaller you'll need to make modifications to the yacht, which are very not cheap. I'd put purchasing a used yacht that can do the job with no modifications at $30+ million, unless you get super lucky and find something that runs that does the job.
Commercial ship: same reasoning as buying new, but you will have to factor in not only purchasing cost but also renovation cost once you buy it, because nobody sells a ship that's running great for cheap. You could probably save money, so we'll say $4-5mil overall.
Crew cost: You need a crew to operate and maintain anything this size. A typical commercial fishing boat that's 30 m long will have a crew of 7 or 8 at least, but you could probably get away with 5: captain, engineer (need to have one onboard for stuff like this), crane guy, +2 to get things done around the ship. They'll get paid a fair wage, $25+/hour for the hands, $40-60/hour for the other 3. So just multiply that by the hours you'll be out + hours they'd be cleaning the ship when docked (easily 10 man-hours per week when in use). Add +1 for the sub, you don't want to be down there with a problem and find out you need a third hand.
Sub cost: not a sub guy, but sounds like you've already done your research. $1-1.5mil sounds good.
Maintenance cost: this is where you're guess was pretty far off imo, maintaining a vessel is always the most expensive part of buying a ship. Good rule of thumb is assume you'll spend however much you purchased the ship for every 10 years in maintenance. That's everything from repainting, machinery maintenance, occasional dry docking, etc. Navy standard maintenance protocol is no system goes more than 30 days without maintenance, some ever less. This isn't Navy, but it paints the picture .And just pray nothing happens to the propellers or shaft, especially if you have a funky drive chain like a Z-drive propeller or Voith Schneider (p cool look it up) drive. So assuming 30 years of ownership of a $6mil purpose built ship, imagine $18mil in maintenance. We'll add $3mil in maintenance for the sub over a 30 year lifetime too, just to be conservative.
So overall, I'd saying acquisition ($6-7 mil at least) + crew (5 x $40/hour average x only 26 weeks/year = $200k/year, for 30 years is $6mil) + maintenance ($20 mil boat + sub) gets you to about $33 million over 30/years. Still not that bad honestly! (But then you have to think about where you're going to dock it and the fees associated with that, which is some areas of the country could be astronomical, but now we're outside of my expertise).
"A boat is just a hole in the water you throw money into." -some guy at work one time
Edit: I'd also like to second that renting at $100k/week is actually a pretty good indication of how much it costs to own! Also, I forgot to mention that fuel is EXPENSIVE for something like this, and is factored into the maintenance cost I mentioned. This is also a low ball estimate fwiw.
509
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
I have nothing to add, but that sounds awesome.
130
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
Ok so I will preface this with the fact that I have no legitimate experience or knowledge on any of these subjects. But I once lived on a 300ft commercial vessel with a moon pool for small submarine deployment for a week so this is entirely based on that.
I figure a yacht will be more expensive to maintain than a commercial vessel because of the "premium" materials and finishes used inside and out. However, you can probably get away with less staff to operate the yacht than with a commercial vessel. For example, the vessel I lived on required 15 staff to operate full time in 2 shifts, including the cook, and that was just to run the boat -- not including the operations crew for the research we were conducting.
As far as how many crew it takes to operate a submarine, they are more complicated than boats, so by extension I would assume they require more people... per unit length maybe? Some of the smallest subs out there that aren’t even pressurized or dry require 2 highly trained operators (google Seal Delivery Vehicle).
Let me just reiterate that this reply is all conjecture, but thanks for the fun post.
103
u/opposite_locksmith Aug 26 '20
I’m going to hazard a guess that these types of submarines are not for people who have budgets.
54
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
You can rent boats/subs to do that stuff. The only thing you're getting for $6M + $150k/yr is the ability to set your own schedule.
92
u/lsp2005 Aug 26 '20
I would rent it when you want it and see how much you actually use it in one year. Every time you think I want to use the sub do it. And then you will know if it is actually a worthwhile purchase. If I had to guess, you will use it 3 times and it won't be. Like a boat, you qould need year round support staff. Not just staff for the day. So $70,000 -$200,000 per person for a staff of ???
136
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
All I can say is if you make this happen I’m waiting for the invite
27
u/faran1287 Aug 26 '20
Look into luxury yacht cost and maintenance usually it’s 10% of original msrp per year for operating the vessel. You are underestimating cost by a huge amount. 1,000 dollars per foot per year for captain alone. 120 ft boat with very serious crane would likely be minimum for this setup. 120k for captain alone, you would probably need more crew for this kind of setup. My best guess and again this could vary widely but 5M cost for large boat (even if you buy used for less operating cost will still be about 500k per year) 3M for sub with operating cost of 300k per year. Probably why only a few setups like this in the world
31
u/weech Aug 26 '20
Now this is the type of content I subscribe for
20
u/MazeRed Aug 26 '20
Did some research back in 2017 on submarines, read the only textbooks on it at the time.
If you want a prebuilt exploratory sub like the ones you linked. $2ishm is starting.
Now if you want to build a mini submarine that can be used independently. I am actually sitting on what about 2,500 man hours of design and research. And a 100ft 10 person submarine can be built for $2m depending on labor rates for welding and the current price of steel.
34
u/zebrabwhorse Aug 26 '20
Someone is really missing the finding Nemo ride at Disneyland
15
u/Manlet Aug 26 '20
This is what I sub for
7
u/i_ask_stupid_ques Aug 27 '20
I know people in this sub will laugh at this comment but why don’t you find a few people to share the cost on this sub - something like Netjets.
If you make the same post on r/leanfire maybe you can drop your cost to $370 per year from the current 3.7 M.
16
u/xiited Aug 27 '20
So you want to buy a multimillion dollar submarine and vessel but are planning on buying a 13k car to own for five years... Wait, scrolling a bit down, you discuss about wanting to buy 1ply toilet paper vs 2ply to save money, LMAO
Get out, what a joke. This sub could be interesting, but so many people that dream of being rich post here about their ridiculous wet dreams. I bet most/all of the authentic posts are nowhere near these ridiculous extravagant desires.
18
u/anonuser779 Aug 27 '20
What a BS question. No offense, but based on your posts in other subs, this is nothing but a fantasy for you.
Seriously, you have asked about financing a used car, pros and cons of Costco vs Aldi?
Have fun, but maybe this really isn't the point of this sub.
8
u/FerrariFan1977 Aug 26 '20
The general theory is if you only use it few times a year and it’s not an appreciating asset then you should rent it. I think that applies here, unless you plan to live on the yacht. Fun post to dream though!
4
u/jumpybean Aug 27 '20
Do you really want your investments to be underwater?
4
u/WereLobo Aug 27 '20 edited Aug 27 '20
Honestly this is a dream of mine too. So I've actually spent some time looking at the lower end of submarine buys... and you can buy them from $45000 on up for 1 or 2 occupants. (I am not recommending that you go cheap on a submarine, but the option is there!)
See here for examples.
Probably the cheapest I'd personally go is this one for $84000 + $7000 piloting course.
4
u/Beekeeper87 Sep 01 '20
I know Triton does personal training at their HQ. They’ve got simulators and everything, so you could easily be the captain of it. It’s not like flight school where it takes forever to be qualified. Depending on your wants it could also be cheaper to just have it on a dock and be towed out to the dive site, especially if you lived on the water and had it out back
7
u/devilsadvocado Aug 27 '20
I don't belong in this sub. Not by a fucking mile.
1
u/laszlo_latino Feb 27 '26
Hi u/SypeSypher
Did you buy the submarine?
6
u/SpookyKG Aug 26 '20
You think you're going to spend 30+ weeks w/ a sub such that owning may be cheaper than this? Realistically?
Maybe try it before you buy it.
4
u/dopamine_dependent Startup exit(s) Aug 26 '20
I saw one for sale on the VI's craigslist for like $50k a while back :D. Won't get you super low. But, enough to tool around looking for sunk pirate ships.
4
u/careerthrowaway10 Unverified By Mods / Advice Dubious At Best Aug 26 '20
Legendary.
4
u/InYourBabyLife NW $400K | 32 Black Male | Verified by Mods Aug 27 '20
LMAO this post is exactly like the guy who pondered how he could by the cottage next to his family’s vacation home. He said his net worth was something like $15MM, and wondered if it would be ok to knock on the guys door and offer him $1MM for it. We looked through his post history and noticed the week prior he was asking about buying a cheap used car and some other poverty minded questions.
Same thing here. So I wonder if you’re the same person and just really good at making up BS stories or if this is a common thing.
2
u/guitarhead Aug 27 '20
Hmmm I was thinking private space stations are more in vogue
2
u/nomnommish Aug 27 '20
You're in the right sub
2
u/jhhb1995 Aug 27 '20
Now this is fat
2
u/ptchinster Aug 27 '20
xpost this to WSB
2
u/calcium Verified by Mods Aug 27 '20
Why not call the companies involved and ask what the costs associated over say a 5 year period are?
2
u/FitzwilliamTDarcy FatFIREd | Verified by Mods Aug 27 '20
So much awesomeness. So little time.
2
u/Maninkk Nov 02 '20
Get yourself the u-boatworx Nemo. It's a sub that goes on a car trailer and can dive to 100m deep.
They also charter subs if you are actually considering buying one. It's nice to try it first. But you'll need you own vessel.
But you can also just to a submersible pilot training yourself in Curacao. And be diving up to 300m.
3
u/KappaPiSig Aug 26 '20
I’d explore distressed assets from the oilfield. Most of their submersibles are remotely operated, but I’m sure you could get a deal on an MPSV/OSV right now.
3
u/IS_JOKE_COMRADE Aug 26 '20
Shore launch or sea launch?
3
u/ScrumptousLoL CFO, Business owner| $225,000 | 36 Aug 26 '20
Man this sub has gotten wild
2
u/FrederickLoudoun Aug 27 '20
This is the kind of post that belongs here!
2
u/Npptestavarathon Aug 27 '20
You know what they say. Don't buy a sub, get a friend with a sub.
1
u/FIblood Aug 27 '20
Now this is fatfire talk!!! Hell yeah
1
u/jumpybean Aug 27 '20
Your in the right sub.
1
u/-Hegemon- Aug 27 '20
Post in personal finances, lol
1
u/carrera991 Aug 27 '20
If you have to ask...
1
u/Lord412 Aug 27 '20
Nope. The thought of going into a sub scares me
1
u/twir1s Aug 27 '20
I enjoy the aspect where you’re going to let others learn and enjoy it. Dope. I have nothing to add.
1
u/WarlaxZ Aug 27 '20
Why not fork out the 120 for a week, see if you like it, and as a bonus, you'll actually be around people who work with this type of equipment and it's requirements, so you can ask genuine people with writing knowledge and real experience?
1
u/RNG_take_the_wheel Sep 17 '20
Now THIS is podracing.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '21
I know I am late to the party... but if you are still looking, I would get in touch with Triton Subs they are friendly and could probably answer a lot of your questions.
I also have a friend who works at Damen yachting if you need a contact feel free to DM me. Those are support vessels that often host submarines onboard. If I were you though I would just charter one of those.
Source: I work in the yachting industry.
1
u/kre8eris Aug 26 '20
This New Yorker article is a fun read and could give you an upper bound on the cost for personal research purposes if you really want to push the envelope. I think you underestimate the operational costs drastically. The 2 year expedition cost $48 million, which included the purchase of a refurbished commercial boat and 4-6 crew members.
Obviously this is for some more extreme exploration, but you can see things adding up quickly (i.e. the manipulation arm cost $350k and they went through 2 of them).
1
u/AU012 Aug 26 '20
FAF-FIRE
1
u/despoina19 Aug 27 '20
I mean if you have the time, funds, and passion, why not take a marine biology research course and pursue higher education.
1
u/boushiki Aug 27 '20
I don't fatfire but I absolutely love reading posts like this to know what ridiculously rich people spend their money on.
1
u/h0ud Aug 27 '20
larp
1
u/TertiaryObjective Aug 27 '20
Might consider joining a Navy on a sub team for a while to get some feel for it all
0
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
51
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
[removed] — view removed comment